Judge should be MVP not bc it would be a coin flip  with Ohtani but because I want to see him demand 50 million a year from the Yankees and they will have to pay it to keep him.

I'd probably give Judge the MVP over Ohtani if the season ended today. Even though Ohtani has been a great hitter and starter, Judge's season is next level and he's likely to finish over 10.0 fWAR and maybe 10 bWAR.
Ohtani = 3.5 fWAR batting 4.6 fWAR pitching = 8.1 fWAR
Judge = 9.7 fWAR batting/fielding.

Ohtani = 3.3 bWAR batting 4.8 bWAR pitching = 8.1 bWAR
Judge = 9.1 bWAR batting/fielding

WAR is a funny thing though. Since it's a multiplier, a couple 0-5 days in a row drops the offensive value relative to peers (like wRC+) and that value gets multiplied by all the plate appearances a player has so it can have multiplied effect. Judge could lose or gain 0.5 WAR in a double header.

...and the season doesn't end today. Also, how Ohtani went about generating his value is more impressive.

AL MVP vote (if I had a ballot): 

1.) Aaron Judge
2.) Jose Ramirez 
3.) Shohei Ohtani 

I totally agree with you Seth on the MVP race.  Unfortunately Ramirez doesn't get the recognition he deserves.

Is reliever of the year an official award? It sounds made up for this discussion.