Aaron Hicks was a liability offensively versus right handed pitchers. The Yankees will use him as a platoon player for a while before deciding to play him full time. And acquiring a young catcher under team control for a long time is no easy feat. Especially one that will likely play significant time and is an upgrade over Suzuki. Does Hicks have great upside? Sure. But so do Kepler, Rosario, and Buxton.