Everything posted by gil4
-
Report: Donaldson and Cole to be Road Roommates
That Mike Kekich and Fritz Peterson line was classic. Anyone want to put together a scouting report to see who would win the Cole - Donaldson swap? (100% not serious. Don't do it, please.)
-
Off-season, non-Twins, baseball news and signings 2021-2022
He got 7/183. Does that mean Story is asking for more, the Rockies preferred Bryant, or Story just wants out of Colorado? The Story/Twins rumors are interesting, but I'm not sure that interest reaches 7/183 for me.
-
Trevor Story Rumors
So he's expecting we will win it in 6 this time? (Or maybe he's expecting game 6 and 7 will be on the road.)
-
With the current roster, how many wins will the Twins have this season?
I'm hoping the number of games they play with the current roster is zero.
-
Grade the Garver for Kiner-Falefa Trade
That's not quite a fair comparison. IKF should be on both incoming and outgoing list (which just cancels out.) The net result is Twins trade Garver, Donaldson, Rortvedt, and a 1st round draft pick for Gary Sanchez, Sonny Gray and Gio Urshela (plus a minor-league pitcher whose name escapes me right now.) I don't know how much money moving Donaldson frees up because I don't know how much the incoming guys make. I also don't know if they are going to spend more. I'll call my grade an incomplete for now. If they stop now, it will convert to an F.
-
Twins “showing interest” in Trevor Story
That might seriously be the plan. We need someone to catch. We just traded 2 of our top 3 (plus was Donaldson an emergency option? I know he started as a catcher) The fact that Rortvedt was called up means there can't be too many feasible options in the minors.
-
Reevaluating Minnesota’s Draft Picks: 2005-2009
Especially when you consider draft order. The highest the Twins picked in that stretch was 14 (Hicks in 2008). 2010-2015 gave us Buxton, three guys with ,2 career WAR each (Gordon and Stewart could still add on, but probably not much.) In that time, they had pick 21, 30, 2, 4, 5, and 6. 2011 - Twins drafted Levi Michael #30 - there were 6 hits and 24 misses in the next 30. Jackie Bradley or Trevor Story would have been nice, but there were a lot of options on the table that would have been equal busts. 2012 - 60 matching player(s). 40 played in the majors (66%). Total of 264.3 WAR, or 6.6 per major leaguer. (Twins got Buxton at 2 plus Berrios in the supplemental (#32) - 27 WAR and counting between them. Two hits in a deep draft) 2013 - 39 matching player(s). 30 played in the majors (76%). Total of 141.0 WAR, or 4.7 per major leaguer. (39.7 WAR in picks 1-3) Twins left a lot of opportunity on the table. 2014 - 41 matching player(s). 28 played in the majors (68%). Total of 139.2 WAR, or 5.0 per major leaguer. (20.5 WAR in picks 1-4) Weird draft - #1 and #2 didn't make it past A ball, #6 has a career OPS+ of 27. Nola (7), Turner (13), and Chapman (25 ) were more than half the WAR for the class. This was the 2nd year in a row the Astros selected #1 and got nothing (Appel, Aiken). It doesn't matter where you hit, as long as you hit somewhere. 2015 - 42 matching player(s). 31 played in the majors (73%). Total of 100.8 WAR, or 3.3 per major leaguer. (46.1 WAR in picks 1-5) Weak draft overall, Benintendi was next, but there were a lot of busts. The 2011 (edit - I meant 2012) supplemental (31-60) was probably equal to the top 30 in this draft. I'm not sure there was to this other than the draft is a crapshoot and you need to get one or two of the 10+ WAR guys for it to be a success.
-
3 Players Gone Too Soon
Walt Bond/"Died of leukemia (diagnosed 1962) in September 1967." It seems like a lot of progress has made in the treatment of leukemia. Former Twin Danny Thompson died of Leukemia in 1976. I knew at least three people who died of it in the 1980s. Since then. I haven't heard of any. Is the impression mistaken? Is it just that I am no longer in the age bracket that's hardest hit? (My kids are in the bracket now that I was in then, and I haven't heard of any of their friends having it.)
-
Bring on the computer, knock off the framing
My info may have been a bit out of date. Apparently the system has been tweaked and is much better than in its first season. From 2019: https://www.baseballamerica.com/stories/imperfections-and-all-robo-umps-make-significant-impact-on-atlantic-league/ The ABS system is not ready for the major leagues. You can find players who say it's not ready for the Atlantic League. But if Major League Baseball is ever going to switch to a computerized strike zone, it is going to want to have gotten rid of all the bugs ahead of time. It will want to make sure that the mechanics of getting the pitches called quickly and accurately are cleared up as well. The Atlantic League's players are dealing with issues so big leaguers won't see those problems. From 2021: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2021/08/30/invasion-of-the-robot-umpires [Wally Backman]: “It’s gonna be in the major leagues in a lot shorter time than people think.” M.L.B. has already concluded that the device is near-perfect, precise to within fractions of an inch. “It’s going to be more accurate, it’ll reduce controversy in the game, and be good for the game,” the M.L.B. commissioner, Rob Manfred, has said.
-
Bring on the computer, knock off the framing
Do you think flopping in soccer makes the game more entertaining?
-
Bring on the computer, knock off the framing
That is probably true, but I would prefer to get the opinion of an umpire at the MLB level for this. Calling balls and strikes in high school games is easier than your average 10u game. (A 10u game with good pitchers is easier, but those are few and far between. Most of the time, I tell them 12u and above if they call me for travel ball tournaments. 10u is just brutal.)
-
Bring on the computer, knock off the framing
Did you take a wrong turn on the way to the Dodgers forum?
-
Bring on the computer, knock off the framing
Fort something that doesn't exits, we sure find a lot of it around here. I'm just adding to the pile
-
Bring on the computer, knock off the framing
That is the biggest issue with the technology right now. The answer is "not very well." The calculated balls/strikes are not used for the umpire evals until after the upper and lower limits of the zone are recalculated for each batter. I think it's a hurdle that can be overcome, but I don't think we are there yet.
-
Bring on the computer, knock off the framing
So do we make pitchers throw between the shins and the waist to Judge or from mid-thigh to the nose for Altuve?
-
Bring on the computer, knock off the framing
Chief is a master of multitasking and manages to do both at the same time.
-
2021 Vikings Season Thread
His two INTs that set up TDs helped contribute to the dirty feeling part.
-
Oliva and Kaat elected to National Baseball Hall Of Fame
Except now there are multiple committees doing it. But if the writers did a better job, there wouldn't be a need for them.
-
Oliva and Kaat elected to National Baseball Hall Of Fame
I was always a small-medium Hall guy, but as this settles in, I'm a lot happier about Tony O and Kaat getting in than I thought I would be. Beforehand, I was 50/50 on Oliva and mostly against Kaat. I've had a major change of heart. I still don't like the Hodges selection or Baines from a couple of years back, but putting two of my borderline guys in can help me overlook that.
-
Oliva and Kaat elected to National Baseball Hall Of Fame
I like the selection of Oliva, Kaat, and Minoso (although Kaat should be listed as player/broadcaster, because I don't think he's in as just a player.) O'Neil must have more to his candidacy than the available Negro League stats, because those aren't terribly impressive. (I have an autographed b&w photo signed by him that I bought off Ebay about 15 years ago - 99% chance the signature is forged - but I think it's cool he got in, even if I don't know exactly why. ) All I know about Fowler is on his Wikipedia page, and that didn't do much to convince me. I don't like the Hodges selection at all. I think Schilling, Bonds, Clemens, Rolen, Helton, Sheffield, Jones, and maybe Wagner should be in.
-
Rob Manfred's Public Arguments Framing the MLBPA's Desires As Harmful to Fans Make Little Sense
I agree and think it is realistic (although the numbers may vary.) Just to expand on what the players would want, the minimum would have to be a hard minimum with stiff penalties, and the maximum would have to be a soft cap, with penalties scaled based on the amount over the cap and the number of years over the cap (like they are now.)
- Dog in Christmas Sweater Urges Twins to Sign Byron Buxton
- One Fan’s Opinion: Byron Buxton Contract: Bust or Boom
- My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
-
So, the Yankees tried to acquire Simmons at the deadline
I guess the Yankees didn't have a bucket of baseballs handy to complete the trade.