Everything posted by Squirrel
-
Scalia is dead
yeah, this could just turn into one of the biggest 'get out the vote' campaigns of all times, no matter the 'side' or 'middle' from which you hail.
-
Scalia is dead
I really think the Republican Senators up for re-election are squirming a bit. What happens to the Court is always on my mind during elections, but it will now be on everyone's mind. I'm sort of in the 'Who cares who is nominated for president, but what of all those Senate elections' mode now.
-
Scalia is dead
Can we please move on and discuss the topic? If you can't do so without extreme emotion from either side, walk away from this thread.
-
Scalia is dead
I think they are in a tough spot ... letting a nomination come to vote, letting a nomination pass, or delaying the process until after the election. I read somewhere recently that this is not unprecedented to have a nomination process in an election year, I think I read there have been 14, so delaying by saying 'We can't possibly' isn't really a good reason. So ... what happens? Time will tell ... but I think no matter what, it puts the GOP Senate members in a very tough position ... and it could be impactful on any of their own campaigns, too. Edit: okay, so, this process hasn't happened that many times during a presidential election year, but it has happened.
-
Scalia is dead
Okay ... let's move on. Put this thread back on track: Scalia, nominations, impacts.
-
Scalia is dead
I just wrote this in a PM to someone, and I'll write it again, publicly, with some alterations: I was just completely shocked, not just in a death on the court, but his death. It was very unexpected and shocking news that will have major implications making not only the nomination process but this election possibly the most unique and interesting in history. It's historical! My post on FB was similar ... I think it was something like 'OMG ...news! Real news!' and a link to the CNN announcement. Yes, I'm a liberal, and I can't deny being hopeful, now that I've had some time to process some of this, of what this could mean for reversing decisions like Citizens United, but my initial reaction, the one you see above, is what was expressed and what I explained ... it's unexpected and shocking news. Never once was my feeling one of joy. I even commented on another FB post specifically that, that I don't celebrate death as it's not right. I don't even enter that death pool contest in this forum for the same reason. It's bad karma. But this news is what it is ... shocking. Some of your reactions are from perspectives of being conservatives and knowing I'm a liberal, and trying to to place emotions on me that you think I have because you may be dismayed. You are trying to characterize my post as something it wasn't. What I can do is compromise ... I'll take the exclamation point out of the title, but I'm not altering the original post as I think I've explained it. If none of you wants to accept that, that is your problem. If I had made a post that included the words 'Yippee!' or 'Hurray!' that would be concerning, and I'd have already altered it or removed it and given myself a warning ... which I've done with of post of mine in the past. What everyone needs to keep in mind while posting anywhere on this site ... you need to give the other poster the benefit of a doubt because we don't know one another, don't characterize other posters' posts and put your own spin on because you yourself are not objective, and keep it out of the realms of personal as that drives discussions down the wrong path. You don't know anyone's intent, so work to find that out, respectfully, instead of making accusations and guesses. Even now this discussion has become about me and my intent, even after I've already explained it, instead of what will happen next and how this news impacts the future.
-
Scalia is dead
This is why this whole situation is so flabbergasting for me ... never has this been so ... interesting and impactful. That's why my initial reaction was OMG!!! because this is so ... OMG!
-
Scalia is dead
This all goes back to what a few of us have been saying for a while how having a Dem in the White House is so vital for Court appointments.
-
Scalia is dead
Yeah, I think he has potential to be a really good Justice, I just don't see him wanting the job after his years as president.
-
Scalia is dead
Yeah, that's the idea I like and think would be effective. I wasn't understanding the suggestion of working a deal where you force Ginsberg to retire promising to replace each Justice with a like-minded justice. I don't think that does anything.
-
Scalia is dead
I think he has the potential to make a great judge. But I don't think he'd do it. And certainly not so soon after being president.
-
Scalia is dead
I'm not understanding why this would be a good thing. I think your original suggestion is the best. Make 5 moderate nominations, and let the Senate deal with it, or not. Their jobs would be on the line and I don't think them blocking nomination after nomination would reflect well on them.
-
Scalia is dead
Well, not sure how healthy he was, really, given his weight and stress of the job. But yeah, nice way to go.
-
Scalia is dead
Quit characterizing posts to suit your agenda. I've already made my statement about it and that's the end of it. It was also completely surprising, shocking even.
-
Scalia is dead
I agree. But I also think their delaying in a decision could impact the election in November, not in their favor. So there will be some interesting discussion and maneuvering in the near future.
-
2016 Election Thread
That's what I was thinking, too. This is why this is such huge news. The timing of this and how it will play out ... it isn't something we've ever had, seen, whatever ... and may not again.
-
2016 Election Thread
Why would she do that?
-
Chuck Klostermann's HYPERtheticals
Ahhh ... you think more intelligence will help you solve a Sisyphean dilemma?
-
Scalia is dead
How am I celebrating? Did I say 'Yippee!'? Your jumping to conclusions is what is disgusting and characterizing my post as such was just wrong. It's HUGE news, HUGE ... and that was my point. And the implications are HUGE. Get a grip.
-
2016 Election Thread
Most of the problems with guns coming into Illinois (specifically Chicago) are more issues with Indiana and Missouri than the other two.
-
2016 Election Thread
I just posted a separate thread topic on this. Does Obama get a nomination through the Senate before the elections? If not ... yeah ... MAJOR election issue, as I've always said.
-
Scalia is dead
Omg ... what a news day! http://www.cnn.com/2016/02/13/politics/supreme-court-justice-antonin-scalia-dies-at-79/index.html Wonder if Obama will get a nom through the Senate before the elections!
-
2016 Election Thread
Well, those without the proper visas and/or passports.
-
2016 Election Thread
Yes, Illinois needs to erect a wall between us and Indiana and Missouri; yes, indeed! Brilliant!
-
2016 Election Thread
There's also the loophole of different states having different regulations. That's a huge problem in Chicago when a majority of guns involved in criminal activity comes from out of state.