Everything posted by cmoss84
-
Front Page: With Twins Likely Out on Donaldson, So What's the Plan Now?
yup. this.
-
Front Page: With Twins Likely Out on Donaldson, So What's the Plan Now?
Anyone ever play poker? You ever tell people what you are going for? The FO telling people we are going for an impact signing is the equivalent to telling people at the poker table, "I hope I get a really good hand." Of course you hope things work out. Sometimes they do, and sometimes they don't. Not sure why people on here expect the FO to lay out their entire blueprint.
-
Option C(astellanos)
Don't you think this statement is a bit unfair? Cruz's value is crazy high-considering production/leadership and salary. Also, paying someone more than Cruz to produce less is okay-it might mean they had an excellent year-just Cruz might have a bit better numbers. And yes, the notion was to have Castellanos take over at DH (at least part time) when Cruz is done. I'll take .285 25-30 bombs/90-100 RBI from a guy every year, especially if it is for the next 4 or 5 years It is more of a comparison of value between Donaldson and Castellanos, not Cruz.
-
Option C(astellanos)
I'm seeing a lot of people with this opinion or that he is an average hitter. I am not saying he has been one of the best hitters in the league, but he has been pretty damn good/consistent. Can someone point out what makes him "average" versus my thoughts of him being really good? Last time I checked, Detroit is not an easy place to hit (to put it mildly). Right? In 2017 and 2018, he played 157 games and basically averaged .285 with 25 HRs and 95 RBI (with 73 XBH/year). In Detroit. To me, those numbers trump his "deflated" numbers when he was with the Cubs for 2 months. He is going to be 28-do you expect him to have better numbers or worse numbers, especially getting out of Det? Is he not entering his prime? Again, I am not saying he is better than Donaldson or that his defense will be average. I am saying that he might be an option worth exploring a bit more...
-
Option C(astellanos)
If we really are "in" on Donaldson, I don't see a reason why they could not spend less to get Castellanos, even if it was a bit of a splurge (especially if it is for a player entering his age-28 season).
-
Front Page: With Twins Likely Out on Donaldson, So What's the Plan Now?
Because he would be signing with a team that won 101 games last year, in a weak division, that broke homerun records, that is returning mostly everyone and has young guys in the wings to help out as well? And there are still 2 months of off-season left?
-
Option C(astellanos)
https://www.mlb.com/news/nicholas-castellanos-texas-rangers-interest I must not be completely crazy-here is an article by Jon Paul Morosi about how Texas could move Castellanos to 1B and sign a cheap 3B like Frazier. The more I think about this, the more I think this option would be cheaper/less-risky (versus signing Donaldson) with a higher return. But hey, what do I know. SKOL VIKINGS!
- Front Page: Hayes: Twins To Sign Rich Hill & Homer Bailey
- Front Page: Hayes: Twins To Sign Rich Hill & Homer Bailey
- Front Page: Hayes: Twins To Sign Rich Hill & Homer Bailey
-
Front Page: Hayes: Twins To Sign Rich Hill & Homer Bailey
Let's take things at face value before giving up on our off-season. Nobody said these were huge, impact moves. Can Bailey be a good #5? Make an argument against it if you don't think so. Hill was signed to help make a late season/post-season run. If he reaches his incentives, it means we have done very well! Plain and simple! Again, if you have a good argument against signing a $3mill lottery ticket with experience, I'd love to hear it! These moves need to be looked at separately than impact moves we are all waiting for.
-
Front Page: Where Do Twins Stand in Pursuit of David Price?
Price and Jay Groome. We pay 3/60 of his contract.
-
Front Page: Where Do Twins Stand in Pursuit of David Price?
Graterol throws innings 1-2. Price 3-7. Nice.
-
Option C(astellanos)
If Donaldson signs: 3B: Donaldson - age 34-38 seasons, expensive (4/100?) 1B: Sano - not exactly a great 1B If Castellanos signs: 3B: Sano - below average to average 3B 1B: Castellanos - age 28-32 seasons, has never played 1B. Can also be 4th OF. 4/60? or more? I actually like both moves, but neither is foolproof...actually both come with a lot of risk. But both worth the risks IMO.
-
Option C(astellanos)
I guess my point is you have to pick your poison. I'd like an addition of Donaldson, but it is (A) not guaranteed and ( does not come without its own risks...
-
Option C(astellanos)
You might be right, but how much worse is it than last year's defense? Is his bat worth it? To me...yes.
-
Option C(astellanos)
You guys bring up some valid points. The question I have for you then, is why do you trust Sano at 1B, but not Castellanos?
-
Option C(astellanos)
Thanks for posting this-good stuff!I am definitely in at 4/60 or higher. Points taken though!
-
Option C(astellanos)
4/60? Man I was way off!! I didn't say I wanted him to play 3B, however. Mentioned him transitioning to 1B and playing OF in a pinch...
-
Option C(astellanos)
Thanks for your input-definitely appreciate all responses! I am getting the feeling I value his bat more than most. I also should have noted that since this team isn't built on defense, defensive flexibility and premium bats are the direction I would go at this point...save a defensive specialist to put in late (Iglesias/Echevarria).
-
Option C(astellanos)
We missed out on our big money aces. A big impact 3B will either cost age/money (Donaldson) or top prospects and money (Arenado/Bryant). So why not spend money and invest in a completely different direction? Nicolas Castellanos has played over 500 games in his career at 3B. He is one of the best hitters in all of MLB. He is also 28. Does anyone ever want him to step foot at the hot corner again? Doubtful! But in an era valuing flexibility, Castellanos might be undervalued. My question is, could he transition to 1B? With so much experience at 3B, I would guess yes (he has to have decent hands, right?). He is also 6'4". He could also play RF for us in a pinch. He could eventually transition to DH if Sano moves to 1B later on (or Kiriloff). I would love it if the Twins offered 5/100 or even 6/120 and made Castellanos a key part of our lineup during his prime years. Am I way off here? What do you think?
-
Front Page: Opening Thoughts: Brusdar Graterol (What Would You Do?)
Start him up with the Twins. Pitch any way needed. Wouldn't hurt getting a 5 inning start or two...especially when hitters timing is off...
-
Lineup Questions/Changes for 2020
LH pitcher Garver Polanco Cruz Sano Kepler Arraez Marwin Rosario Buxton RH pitcher Kepler Polanco Cruz Arraez Rosario Garver Sano Marwin Buxton
-
Why the Twins Need to Take the White Sox Seriously
White Sox making moves! They will be good. But EE scares me less than Castellanos, who they were rumored to get. Needless to say...we should probably key in on winning now...
-
Front Page: Ryu To Sign with Toronto. Now What?
Is there a sale on Price? What's the price of Sale? The sky is not falling to me...yet. Still time for Archer/Bell AND Ray!