I agree that Ryan should have been broomed along with Gardenhire. You hit all the right reasons but forgot the problem with the outfield. In order to atone for his many mistakes with the starting pitching (which you nailed) he traded away two competent CFer's, Span and Revere, for SP. Ryan put the team in a position to need to rely on Aaron Hicks to become a good player and he didn't.Then he put Mastroianni on waivers and when Hicks failed he had to trade for Sam Fuld. Then he put the SS of the future, Santana, in CF. Centerfield was a mess and has been for 2 years now. The rest of the outfield was manned by defensive tortoises--Willingham, Parmelee, Kubel, Arcia, or guys playing out of position--Santana, Escobar, and to a lesser extent, Herrmann. So Ryan has bungled the starting pitching and the outfield. Let's not forget the decision to put Jason Bartlett on the squad. The reason he's still got his job is because the Twins have some highly touted prospects, which Ryan was responsible for drafting and/or trading to get. If they don't pan out, the Twins could be the next Kansas City or Chicago Cubs, constantly rebuilding and missing the playoffs for decades.