Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

savvyspy

Provisional Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by savvyspy

  1. Are they really?? This starting rotation was bottom 5 last season and they made no changes except for demoting their best pitcher Duffy. The bullpen might have been the worst in the majors but certainly bottom 3. They had a closer who broke down 2 years in a row and wasn't throwing 90 mph all spring yet did nothing about that. In addition to adding absolutely nothing to the overall bullpen after the GM came out and said that was his biggest need. Said GM then traded a plus defensive outfielder or a backup catcher that appears to be designated to the minors and puts a 270 lbs DH/3B with ZERO career innings in the outfielder even though that's never actually ever been done with success in the history of the game. Throw in that Sano and Rosario were probably due for some regression and the manager refuses to play one of your best prospects, Kepler, probably because he isn't playing "the Twins way" or some garbage like that, and here you are. This roster is an absolute mess and that was foreseeable for months. Basically this team was set up on hope not a full understanding of what wins games. They aren't 5-17 bad but this isn't a .500 team and any expectations that they were in their current configuration was counting on a lot of hope.
  2. In next season's edition of Neglecting Outfield Defense, GM Terry Ryan is going to try an actual traffic cone in left.
  3. You lost me at the Twins thought Sano was "athletic enough". There are exactly zero people EVER that have played outfield effectively at his weight LAST YEAR. He is 10-15lbs heavier (which you cannot blame the team for) this year but they certainly saw that the day he showed up for camp. I don't know where this fallacy originated from that Sano was "athletic enough" to play outfield but it doesn't represent an actual plan of any sort. Sano is no more suited to play outfield that Brian Robison is to play outfield. Moving people to positions that they have never played before at a size no one has ever effectively played that position in the history of the game isn't a plan. That is exactly what this post is illustrating. The Twins seem to think they can make things up as they go and the result are clear. This team hasn't just shown these weaknesses this season. They have won 43% of their games since Ryan returned to the role. That is not acceptable. Just go down the list: Scouting, poor drafting, developing young players, not using statistical analysis, not platooning players, roster construction, on field strategy, player regression. There isn't one area of running a professional baseball team that ANYONE in the league looks at the Twins as a leader. Everything the Twins do is either done years after the top teams started doing it or is so questionable that no other teams do it. And the results speak for themselves. In any organization there are best practices. There are no laws saying you can't do things differently but you better see results. The Twins shun best practice at every turn to do it the Twins Way. Unfortunately for everyone the Twins Way is an abject failure by any measure. So basically what you are left with is a team that is somehow figured out how to consistently have the worst plan in the league or has no direction. The evidence would definitely point to the latter. That is flat out irresponsible. This is a team that had no trouble threatening to leave the market and fleeced the taxpayers of the state for a public stadium and the can't even be bothered to take responsibility for the self inflicted mess they've created. You want proof they have no plan??? This team's front office watched the first 9 games of the season and decided what needed to be done was signing David Murphy to a minor league deal. DAVID MURPHY. A guy worse than the outfielders you just cut from camp 2 weeks ago. The Twins Way.
  4. Outside of Sano in RF I honestly think the most frustrating thing about this season is Joe Mauer looks like Batting Title Winning Joe Mauer again and it completely doesn't matter because this roster is a damn dumpster fire.
  5. There isn't anyone with an IQ above 30 that would suggest Sano at 245lbs was in the same zip code of reality. Cabrera is an awful comparison. He hasn't played an inning in the outfield since 2005 which not so coincidentally is when he went from 230lbs to 255-260lbs he is now. Sano has never been in the majors below 260 lbs and is probably 275lbs now. This is very simple. There are ZERO players to play outfield at Sano's size LAST YEAR let alone 15lbs heavier which he is this year. You can imagine a case where you can try to shift the blame away from Ryan but you need to use false comparisons and rely on Sano doing something that no one has ever effectively done before. You might see asking a player to do that as part of Terry Ryan's genius but I view it has a very predicable failure that a clueless front office is now trying to CYA by using the EXACT same criticism of the player that they did with David Ortiz.
  6. An actual GM would have noted his closer basically needed to be shut down in the 2nd half of the season 2 years in a row and noticed a pattern and planned for it in the off season. An actual GM would have seen said pitcher in camp throwing 88-90mph and gone to Plan B before the season started. Our GM instead did nothing but sit on his hands. Oh and give quotes to the local beat writer than the drastic drop in velocity was unconcerning because "outs are more important than MPH on the fastball" That is exhibit 8 billion on why this front office is basically St Paul Saints West. No offense to the Saints.
  7. This isn't your beer league softball league. Playing a position at the professional level takes years of experience. There have been exactly ZERO cases of anyone in the history of the game playing outfield at 270 lbs or more with any level of competence. Sano NEVER played one inning in the outfield at any professional level. You can't just say, well he's athletic so what the heck. Players that have never played a position at a size and build that history tells you never should be attempted given its common sense track record does not fit any scenario where "players on the field have a part in the teams success" should be offered as a defense of it. Its like saying the Wild should move Dubnick to center because they have a need and "hey he's an athletic guy". That obvious and very predictable failure is on whomever suggested such a ridiculous idea not on the player forced to go along with it. In this case, this train wreck is 100% on Terry Ryan and no one else. He basically has too many DHs on the roster and since for whatever reason Plouffe and Mauer, who are 1000x more suited to play outfield, can't be asked to attempt it, they moved a guy with no experience and at least 30 lbs heavier than the largest outfielders generally are to move out there with VERY predictable results.
  8. Not sure this is a sound understanding of how calculating risk works. This is like saying a 2 pack a day chain smoker and a marathon runner both have a risk of getting lung cancer. While technically true it vastly underestimates the risk factors for the smoker. Sano playing outfield at his size with zero experience presents many more risk factors that could lead to injury (like diving for balls that land 10 feet in front of him) than a more experienced outfielder. This being said, injury is a secondary reason Sano shouldn't be playing outfield. The primary one being he is horrendous out there (through no fault of his own) and it does the rest of the team a disservice by having to cover for a complete liability because this front office can't manage a roster at a professional level.
  9. The bullpen and Sano in RF is Exhibit 12 million on why a change is needed in this front office. Because of this idiotic Sano nonsense, Ryan is forcing his manager to take his best hitter out of the game 2/3s of the way through and expose their horrendous bench. Instead of improving the worst bullpen in the majors, Ryan somehow managed to make it worse by making their best arm, May the long man while leaving below replacement level guys like Fien, Abad, and Jepsen to take high leverage roles. But hey at least our backup catcher is slightly better. Eye roll.....
  10. Actually not missing any point. On what planet does a team move their best hitter to a position he's never played and ask him to just drop 20 lbs? Honestly the list of players that have played outfield at 250 lbs isn't all that long either and do you really want your best power hitter to lose 20 lbs to conform to this massively ridiculous move? What you are saying is you are willing to risk a drop off in power so Sano MIGHT be the 35th best outfielder in the AL instead of the 40th?? This isn't a question of Sano's ability to lose weight. The question is why on earth would anyone ask him to lose weight to play a position he's never played?? This isn't wrestling.This is 100% Terry Ryan's inability to manage a roster. He couldn't do prior to Sano's arrival and this fiasco shows he isn't getting any better this season.
  11. I think making one of the worst front office decisions I've ever seen in my 40 years of watching baseball about Sano's fitness is one of the most asinine things I've seen written by the Minnesota sports media EVER. Its really this simple: NO ONE HAS EVER PLAYED OUTFIELD AT 270lbs WELL. EVER!!! And no front office has ever been as dumb as to attempt it with a guy that literally NEVER played the position before. Any GM, media member, or anyone trying to justify this move is banking solely on one thing, hope. Every piece of available data would tell you this is going to be a disaster. Anyone who believes otherwise is banking on hope. Nothing more. Reusse should be ashamed of himself. Not for writing the piece but for giving Terry Ryan a free pass in this fiasco.
  12. I think Quentin has a chance to make the team. Sano will have to be yanked out of the lineup almost every game for defensive reasons and Molitor is going to need a bat for the late innings after he's forced to pull his cleanup hitter. They will start the season with Sano, Rosario, and Buxton with Quentin and hopefully Arcia. Mastroianni has a decent minor league deal so he's probably the first guy called up even before Kepler in my opinion. Honestly they have a number of good options right now in the outfield. I wish they weren't trying to stash Sano but my guess is that sorts itself out in the first 2 months of the year. Ryan seems to have found a way to make the bullpen worse than last year which is kind of impressive considering how many options he had to make it better. They could have almost complete turnover over the season. I only trust Jepsen and May at this point. The closer is a question mark and the rest of them are replacement level on a good day. I would start with Pressly, Fien, and Tonkin (since he's out of options) and maybe Abad although he's looked pretty average. O'Rourke is useless. Hopefully we see a number of prospects by June or July.
  13. I think the Sano discussion should center around what other organization would put their best hitter in a position they have never played and has looked awful so far so that the manager has to take his best bat out of the lineup in the 7th inning so they don't hemorrhage more runs defensively. It should then transition to cover the wisdom of making the defense significantly worse on purpose when you already have one of the worst rotations in the majors. Nothing this team is doing with this roster this season even hints Terry Ryan knows anything about how baseball games are won.
  14. I expect major league teams to start finished products. Its embarrassing that people have lowered the bar to this point. Like another 5 or 6 games makes this any less of a predictable dumpster fire. This isn't D-league softball.
  15. Or unfortunately General Managers
  16. The team looks decent through 2 games. I'm not ready to cut Nolasco quite yet after one bad outing. A lot of pitchers are going to be victimized by having Sano trudging around taking horrible angles in the OF until they pull the plug on that fiasco. It was a hard hit ball but hey, its the major leagues, it won't be the first one he's going to see. A professional outfielder makes that catch and minimizes the damage. Terry Ryan's disdain for defense was really on parade last night.
  17. It is really surprising to see people here completely discount the impact of defense on successful teams. All of the people suggested in this thread including Dave Parker, Puig, Pena, and Carlos Lee were all smaller than Sano some by a lot but more importantly all had experience playing the outfield prior to doing it in the majors. Sano is trying to do this for the first time at the major league level. People should also remember that the closest comp to Sano size wise (Carlos Lee) was an absolute DISASTER defensively by any metric but even he had experience playing the position prior to playing it in the majors. All the other justifications like RF in Target Field is small, someone else in CF can cover more ground, or my favorite "he's pretty athletic" are really nothing more than hope. Successful GMs don't construct rosters for successful teams banking on hope. This move of Sano to the outfield is going to be most likely a complete disaster and at best a really bad idea that will negatively impact the team's defense. A very predictable result given any reasonable analysis of it. The bigger question is going to be what Ryan and the Twins are going to do once it becomes obvious this was a really bad decision and you can't ignore the dumpster fire anymore?
  18. The fact that this team hasn't won a playoff game in over 10 years, a playoff series in almost 15, and a World Series in 25 but basically is run almost the exact same way by the same type (if not the exact same) people through that entire span tell you all you need to know about this front office. There isn't anything this team does that successful organizations are looking to from an innovation standpoint. Ryan and the entire front office seem like nice people but from a results standpoint they have been complete failures on almost every front. They are dinosaurs whose time has passed them by. From drafting, free agency, roster construction, giving ridiculous contracts to marginal players, lack of interest in analytics, that they won't even entertain platooning players, complete disregard for defense, and finally, their arrogance that this failed outdated approach will somehow work in the future if they just keep doing it. Any success this team has is done in spite of their front office not because of it. Frankly, Molitor should have been manager of the year last season. He took a 65 win roster and almost made it a playoff team when his top players (Perkins and Dozier) really struggled down the stretch. Any hope I have for this year lies SOLELY with my confidence in Molitor and the natural talent of Sano overcoming anything this team is trying to do to change his swing and foolishly putting him in the outfield where he's never played before.
  19. How do you figure we improved in RF? By moving a 275 lbs DH/3B who hasn't played one inning of outfield in his life out there? All I can say is WOW.......
  20. I just hope the team puts him in the best position to succeed. His stats clearly show he was much better in night games last year. Maybe they could give him significantly more off days for day games and mix in Sano or Plouffe at 1st. Mauer can be very frustrating but brain injuries are really serious and the best thing the team could do is try to get him in spots where he is the most comfortable. Hopefully some sort of sunglasses work if needed but that can be hit or miss.
  21. Our existing options are just as bad as these listed. The front office has masterfully left itself no options which they will turn around and tell everyone "there are no viable options" to improve the bullpen. There really isn't any point in getting upset or even discussing it at this point. Their bullpen is going to be horrendous. They might as well just go with their internal options and get on with it.
  22. I think it ends up being Rosario, Santana, Buxton, and Sano out of spring training. There will be enough warning signs that the Sano experiment is a horrible idea but the Twins are definitely elite in their stubborness and they will go with it. By mid-May the train will have left the tracks and they are going to be forced into moving Sano back to 3rd/DH and Plouffe will probably get some reps out in RF. This will force the next domino to fall as there aren't enough ABs for their top players and Plouffe gets dealt for a song at the deadline. Kepler is called up the next day. By the end of the season Sano will be the full time third baseman and the outfield will be Rosario, Santana, Kepler, and Buxton. It should be a fun year if all of the young guys are up and playing.
  23. The fact that a professional front office thinks putting a 275lbs DH/Corner infielder type in the outfield having never played there on any level speaks volumes to where the Twins stack up against the league. This isn't D-league softball. You put Sano in the outfield for an entire season and you better be prepared to score at least 30 more runs just to break even. I've seem comps like Dave Parker and Willie Stargell and neither player was nearly as big as Sano. Stargell may have been big for the era but he was 6'2 and MAYBE 220 lbs. Parker was about the same. Again, big for the era but not even close to Sano. He's 6'5 and conservatively 270lbs. Throw in that both Parker and Stargell actually played the outfield versus Sano who never has and hopefully people start to see what a horrible idea this is.
  24. What does the lineup look like when Sano in right predictably blows up in the teams face? Does he go back to 3rd? 1st? DH? I think this is the biggest issue facing the lineup. If Santana, Buxton, and Rosario are your OF, where do they play Sano? There is absolutely no evidence Sano, at his size and not having played the position, will be anything but a complete liability in the outfield. That isn't going to work for an entire season. The lineup should be pretty decent if they figure out where to put everyone. Pitching is a completely different story........
  25. Sano is 250lbs with one foot on the scale! There is no way Sano is less than 275lbs. Putting him in the outfield having never played the position and at that size borders on criminal negligence. Could be entertaining though.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.