Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

John Bonnes

Administrator
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by John Bonnes

  1. It's a fair point, and on the one hand, I'd love to have a real bench bat that I was confident in. That, to me, would be what this team could use right now. A veteran DHish guy. But on the other hand, part of the issue is that the bench is already much better than it has been in the past. On most night, Gardy can turn to a decent choice or at least work things to have a matchup in his favor. Even now, I don't even mind the 13-man pitching staff. If anything, this team needs a lot more bullpen options than bench options. And that's because it doesn't look like a bad offensive team right now.
  2. Ramos was a fulltime guy, that's why he wasn't there. I'll take your word on Morales. I personally might have given Rivera more time, but it's worth noting that he hit .144 in the majors. So there might be an edge there, but it's a small edge. Plus, it only shows that a) the organization didn't choose the right, nearly worthless catcher, but that hardly shows a Gardenhire bias. And that Gardenhire is going to be anxious to give whoever comes up a lot of at-bats. I'm not saying Gardy doesn't like Butera. I just don't see a lot of evidence that he's going to give him a dangerously large role.
  3. But he doesn't have much time. I gotta think they'll at least try calling him up this year.
  4. I'm still puzzled by this perception. I asked for evidence that Gardenhire is somehow partial to Butera in another thread and don't think I got a reply. Like I said, in 2010, when Mauer was the only catcher, Butera got 155 plate appearances. Last year, Butera got a ton of at-bats, but Mauer was hurt and there just weren't much in the way of other options. And this year, he was presumably involved in the decision to send Butera down before Towles and was the primary decisionmaker to carry Burroughs over a 3rd catcher. I'm honestly asking - why are we so convinced that Gardenhire has a mancrush on Butera? I suppose the evidence could be Gardenhire quotes raving about Butera's defense, but what does that really prove? Only that Gardenhire feels the need to publicly reward a guy for playing defense (or publicly defend a guy he knows can't hit his way out of a paper bag.) If he didn't do that, wouldn't we criticize him for going after him like Valencia.
  5. By "knee-jerk", I meant that it is a reflex, and in our case, it's a learned reflex. It might be fun to get mad about, but I think the criticism melts a bit when faced by any real analysis. As for "useless" - that's my point. Yeah, Butera is relatively useless. So would be an extra middle infielder. Or a 5th outfielder. Or a 13th pitcher. To me, whatever move the Twins make is almost a freebie.
  6. Both of those names are intriguing. I don't think it's too crazy to think they could call up Guerra straight from AA. He's been on the 40 man roster for at least 2 years, right? So would next year be his last option year? 8K in 8IP with no walks and just three hits? That's awfully encouraging. Did anyone else see DeVries having this good of a start in AAA? I didn't. 15/4 in 15 IP.
  7. Again, this is the beauty of it. That's exactly what it does. If you add up all the positive WPA and negative WPA for the winning team, it equals .5. If you add them up for the losing team, it equals -.5. And if you add up all the cumulative WPA for all the members of a team, it's equal to "how many games the team is over .500" times .5.
  8. A little back of the napkin figuring.... In 2010, when he was on the roster the whole year and Mauer's primary backup, Butera got 155 AB in 170 plate appearances. Let's assume he gets about 150 plate appearances, though that seems high. Furthermore, let's ONLY take a look at offensive impact, not counting any defensive value. According to Baseball-reference.com, Butera has created 20 runs in 407 plate appearances or .048 runs per plate appearance. Meanwhile, Hughes has created 31 runs in 335 plate appearances, or .092 per plate appearances. The difference between those guys is .044 runs per plate appearance. Over 150 plate appearance thats....6.6 runs difference. That's 2/3 of a win or less than 1% of the runs the Twins will produce this year. It is also well within reach of what Butera could add just by gunning down a few baserunners. I spent most of the offseason on the podcast asking that the Twins get some reasonable alternatives to Butera. But from a practical standpoint, they have. This kvetching seems like a knee-jerk reaction, a bad habit that we've developed, a Pavlovian defense mechanism.
  9. Hey, I'm in. A good marching/drinking song, especially a cheesy one, is always welcome at a baseball game.
  10. I'm a little intrigued by the hand-wringing about this. What is the concern, exactly? 1. Are we worried about losing one of the bullpen pitchers to waivers? (I have a little trouble believing that.) 2. Is there a different player we want called up who would provide so much more value as the last guy on the bench? (It can't be Hughes, because it hasn't been 10 days, right?) I can understand being generally opposed to having a 3rd catcher, just like I can understand being generally opposed to a 13 man pitching staff. But this isn't a theoretical situation. From a practical standpoint, what is the downside here?
  11. I don't know if I want Parmelee bunting in that situation (or any situation), but it is REALLY disappointing that he didn't move the runner over there. Incidentally, the Twins chances of winning that game dropped 10% with that at bat. It was a huge at bat, obviously.
  12. Lord, but do I want to take a series from the Yankees at Yankee stadium. I don't think I'm overstating things when I say that Twins fans need this. We judge our team way too much by how they compare to the Yankees. Taking three of four changes the vibe in this city a bunch.
  13. ??? I think we might be talking about something different. The Oriioles had a 92.6% chance of winning that game going into the 8th. http://www.fangraphs.com/plays.aspx?date=2012-04-08&team=Orioles&dh=0&season=2012
  14. Regarding the original topic, I'd say: 1) it may not happen anytime soon, unless there is an injury 2) The reliever who is sent down is whoever sucks the most at the time and 3) the guy called up will likely be dependent on who is fighting some nagging injury on the team. If it was right now, I'd say the need is for Hughes. I can't see it being Revere - what role would he play? I guess I can see it being a shortstop, probably Nishioka, if they're worried enough about Plouffe's D. But I don't see why they woudl be in any hurry to move someone right now.
  15. I dont' know where this perception comes from, but I assure you, it would be hard to type a more untrue statement. The tension between Smith and Gardy was palpable. I'll be honest - I don't know where the percetpion that Gardy loves Butera comes from. I see it mentioned here a lot. The Twins sent Butera down early, did not keep a 3rd catcher, and yet everyone is convinced Gardy loves Butera. Why? Because Butera played a lot? Butera played a lot because Gardy uses his bench guys a lot, because it's important Mauer rests a lot and because Butera was on the roster. Am I missing some smoking gun here?
  16. The glass half full guys would note that the Twins are now 4-5 versus 3 90+ win teams, and they could easily be 6-3 if they hadn't stranded the world in Game 2 or Perkins had fessed up about his arm prior to blowing that 3rd game versus the Angels. Of cours,e they could be 4-12 by this time next week. I wouldn't be shocked if they were.
  17. I'll give five counter reasons (and saying this, let me say, I like Luke Hughes): 1) He didn't hit well enough to be a corner fielder - Last year in 330+ PA, he hit .223 2) He didn't field well enough to be a middle infielder - He can't play SS and he can't pivot the DP at 2B. 3) Danny Valencia - Another RHed third baseman, which is Hughes best position, is in the organization. And Valencia has (unfortuately for Hughes) stayed very healthy, giving Hughes few opportunities. 4) He had trouble staying healthy - Which is how Valencia passed him in the organizational depth chart. Do I remember correctly that it made him lose some playing time in the majors, too? 5) He may fall into an organizational blind spot, which is a lot of what I think you're saying with a lot of the stuff above. I wrote passionately back in 2002 about calling up a guy who reminds me a lot of Hughes, but the Twins didn't, and Casey Blake ended up doing pretty well for himself. Perhaps this organization feels like middle infielders have to have very quick feet or something. BTW, I could add another reason that I think might surprise you: 6) Bill Smith is no longer GM - I think you and Smith actually have something in common here. I always got the sense that Smith thought highly of Hughes, especially in an interview I did with him a couple of years ago. He went out of his way to point to Hughes as an option at third base when I was talking about Valencia.
  18. My experience on the divide on Revere seems to be centered on this question: True or False: Ben Revere will be a productive starting outfielder in the majors for several years? I'd be interested in what people think to this. I'll go with "True." His batting skills further develop so he gets on base at an above average rate. From there his speed and defensive range overcome his lack of power.
  19. Thanks for the heads up. Fixed.
  20. You can view the page at http://twinsdaily.com/content.php?449-Twins-Daily-Features
  21. John Bonnes posted an article in Twins
    We can't promote all the great content the Twins Daily community is generating, but if you're not reading the blogs you're missing out on... Shanewahl provided a nice Big 10 baseball roundup that starts with the Gophers sweeping Northwestern. I loved catching up with ex-Twins with EXTC, because there have been some interesting turns. Like the one Delmon took on Friday. Twins Fan From Afar has been busy, especially because he's been watching a AA-New Britain team that's off to a fantastic start. James Richter thinks Francisco Liriano needs some tough love, because it worked for Joe Mays and Ricky Bobby. Finally, if you're looking to reference the results from the Twins minor league teams, bkucko has been tracking them for you.
  22. It will be interesting to see how the Twins handle the lack of starter this team faces, both this year and in the future.
  23. But you're right - what coulda been INDEED.
  24. I wouldn't have been shocked if those names came up in talks, but if I remember correctly, the real problem was Santana - he made it clear the only acceptable cities were Boston and New York. There were rumors of another team, too (was it Texas?) but once Santana told the Twins he would only bargain with those three teams, other talks were worthless.
  25. I was wondering the same thing. I'd love to see you start this as a topic in the forum.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.