Everything posted by Platoon
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Orioles, 7/28, make-up game from 5/9, @ 6:10pm CT
If you gave 10 competent managers this roster, you would get 10 different lineups. But not one would have Dozier hitting third!
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Orioles, 7/28, make-up game from 5/9, @ 6:10pm CT
Someone is kidding me, is this Brian's lineup? We have Mauer leading off, which is ok. But not if the trade off is Dozier in the 3 hole. As for Park? I will leave that to the nattering nabobs of negativism. I wish to refine yesterday's short form analysis of the Twins roster! If Plouffe is hitting fourth, you just cannot have a good team. Now I have to add, if Dozier is your 3 hitter, your lineup has serious flaws!
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Orioles, 7/28, make-up game from 5/9, @ 6:10pm CT
You promised 9 pence. This was only 5 pence! You shorted us 4 pence. (I did the math, I was afraid that like Chiefs jokes, it was too complex for TD) I was a farm boy, and if your short 4 pence, that's a lot of hogs running loose!
-
Article: Twins Being Overwhelmed By Underperformance
The good news is we probably could do a better job. The bad news is the trading deadline would expire while we argued about what to do!
-
Article: Twins Being Overwhelmed By Underperformance
While some of the Twins young RP with velocity have been slowed by injuries, opportunities to promote have still been bypassed. Most recently Chargois. And while I know and understand all the pros and cons of Meyer, why not Meyer. What the bleep is the difference. We are 13.5 out. Maybe with Meyer we would be 14 out and completely out of the running, but let's take a chance!
-
Article: Twins Being Overwhelmed By Underperformance
And if two way productive catchers are as rare as hens teeth, we could bring up someone like Turner who many say is a ML defense catcher already. We are giving up the AB's anyway! Ps at least half the reason Aaron Hicks was traded was about personality. IMHO He has been a thorn in managements side for three years!
-
Article: Twins Being Overwhelmed By Underperformance
One of the stated but under emphasized components of this collapse is the terrible basics! Base running, cutoff men, throwing to the correct base, et al. Those things can be done correctly while hitting .152 or .352. And the next media talking head who plays the "young players learning how to play the game" card should be publicly flogged at second base during the 7th inning stretch! . These things generally start getting taught at the middle school level. Who knows, maybe someone even mentioned them in the 5 years of MiLB most play.
-
Jim Pohlad's Can of Worms
By now I imagine Pohlad has instructed his secretary to hold all calls, especially from anyone named Scoggins. He likely wishes he had done this sooner, but at least we now know why he is seldom quoted on baseball topics. That said, if we are to assume his comments were forthright and reflect his opinions of the current team, he has opened a window into team philosophy. A baseball team has several levels of structure. Owner GM Manager Players A teams historical won lost record is most likely the result of ownership. I don't mean today's game, or this weeks, or this seasons. I mean over a span, in this case 20 years, or so. The players output is limited by their abilities. It can ebb and flow, but in general it is what it is. Meaning Eddie Rosario will never be Joe Mauer, nor vice versa. The players play and hit where the manager puts them. His single biggest task is to put each player in a position to succeed. That's really all he can do. In turn he can only position the players he is given, which brings us to the GM. One can argue over the ability and upside of each and every player, but the bottom line is good players cost more than bad players overall. And in certain eras, the value of positions changes, SP, RP, hitting, etc. That does not mean spending money guarantees winning, Pohlad is correct about that. But it seriously increases the odds.and while there are a lot of other areas to the GM job description, a lot of them are limited, or enhanced by ownership. The Pohlads. Based on the history of the last 20 years, not just this year, or the end of the Gardy era, it seems obvious to me that everything slides uphill. The players are actually the least culpable. They are only what they are. The manager is somewhat more responsible. It's his job to take what he is given, and make it as cohesive as health and the competion allow. The GM operates on several fronts. Talent, budget, evaluation, and instinct come to mind. But unless he operates within the confines of ownerships parameters, he will not be there for the 20 years this piece is using as a reference. And what are those confines? Comments by the ownership have been very few, and very far in between, and likely won't increase soon. So all one can do is surmise, from an outside perspective. Terry Ryan did not keep his position this long without being able to adhere to ownerships agenda, and without being able to read the tea leaves. And the ability to spin that agenda so as any focus on the Pohlad family is positive,i.e. they have never refused to pay whatever needed for a FA! But history negates that narrative. What history shows is that the owners want: A team that can be plausibly marketed as "competitive", but in reality ends up with no real possibility of "winning". Don't get me wrong, they will take winning if it falls to them but competitive, and winning are two different definitions, at least to me. Seats in the seats. How they get there can be a compilation of the aforementioned competitive team, a new ball park, selling the experience, bringing back an old fan favorite, or celebrating our last trips to the WS, with many of the players in a posthumous mode. Lots of teams do this, but it should not be the apparent major focus. A consistent budget, with contracts and players managed as assets. That's not unusual, but what is somewhat is the fact that the nature of the sport is that not all FA work out. So be it. But then it's time to suck it up, and move on. Trying to get your money's worth and burning a roster spot to amortize a contract over its full 4, or more year run is an accounting practice, not a good baseball philosophy. To me there can be only several conclusions. By the length of his tenure, and the lack of Bill Smiths, Ryan is obviously doing the bidding of ownership. That W/L record is not a metric considered in success, unless it starts to seriously impact the P&L. That ownership is loyal to a fault, see Smith and Gardenhire. That while stability and public image are important, they are likely overvalued. In closing, this not a defense of TR. I am not necessarily a fan of his. He is too reactive v proactive for my tastes. And other subjective issues I won't go into. What I am curious about is why he stays? He is a baseball lifer, like him or not. I would think that if he could, he would want to go to an organization that would let him be more than an asset shuffling manager. Maybe he hasn't had the opportunity? Maybe he is happy with the security? Or maybe he is the perfect fit for the Polhlads expectations. You can improve the record in a given year by changing some players, or the manager, or the GM. But to improve the long term results, will require new owners. They set the standards.
-
Article: Twins Being Overwhelmed By Underperformance
If your philosophy revolves around everyone having to have a good year to succeed, you will fail. To me there are only two surprises on the team that went north. Park who is a pleasant surprise. And Sano who is not. I will give Sano a partial pass for the RF fiasco, but he loses some of his points for his winter prep. I might also add Arcia, who seems to have worked his ass off since last summer. I am not surprised by Mauer, the third year after a concussion seems the charm. But while I love Mauers overall play, he is not and never has been a "carry the team" 3 stick, as Chief has alluded to. Molitor looks wiped out. I know losing will do that, but he looks completely lost. His pitching changes seem out of a hat, and for whatever reason the players don't make an effort to clean up their act. The mental mistakes have gotten to Bad New Bears level. A good manager cannot make bad players win, but a bad manager can make good players lose. The Twins are loaded with average players. They do not have an elite player at any one position. But the players are ML caliber and should be functional. As should their record. 14-17? That's only six games, but a world away.
-
Blake Swihart
If we send them 2- #4's, I think they would average 2 apiece.
-
Blake Swihart
I thought we already did that?
-
What Happened to "The Twins Way"
Not all of your post is to be disconsidered. In a way the team is still playing Twins Way baseball. Our pitchers are PTC, to a fault. That's half of TW. The defense half is missing. Once Buxton left, we were left without an elite defender on the team. This weekend you saw what good OF offense could do. Last weekend you saw what bad offense can do. Not ours, but Marlon Bird did a legitimate impression. Another part of the TW not mentioned was base running! It's horrid. Today when Nunez got doubled off second it was idiotic. It would have been the time for Molitor to jerk him, and make an example. Sooner or later the Twins will have to get their heads out of somewhere and realize that straightening out this roster, and teaching some lessons trumps a win. Then the wins would follow. May in the 8th 2 down? Really. There is no off day tomorrow. What if we actually need him. It's truly hard to define where the line between inept management, and desperation lie.
-
Game Thread: Twins @ White Sox, 5/8@11:10 AM PT (1:10 PM CT) Jet Lag Edition
And in 23 of them at the end!
-
Article: Minnesota's Misuse of Meyer?
Two general thoughts on the Twins pitching situation. If the FO has no issues with higher velocity pitchers, with both higher SO and walk rates than we are used to seeing, it has not shown itself in the last 20 years. In honor of Mother's Day, I quote her. "The proof is in the pudding" . Second, if Alex Meyer does not get an extended look as a SP on the ML level this year an oversight is being made. There is absolutely nothing to lose, and what's the worst that could happen? A three inning stint by a starter?
-
Who Really is the Twins Best Hitter?
I might add this, because it relates to the lineup construction. Or should I say the lineup flexibility. If your teams collective talent evaluation allows you to put Sano in the OF, there can never again be raised the argunent that another player cannot.
-
Who Really is the Twins Best Hitter?
I have had this running argument for years with another baseball blogger. It isn't that Mauer can't hit, or doesn't have good numbers with men on base. He's missing the power of a good 3 hitter. He truly should be leadoff. He isn't totally slow, is a good baserunner, and is on often. That said, any team that hits a Dozier leadoff for that long cannot be expected to make lineup adjustments easily.
-
Game Thread: Twins@White Sox - Traveling Edition 5/7@4:10PM PT (6:10PM CT)
I could see that!
-
Game Thread: Twins@White Sox - Traveling Edition 5/7@4:10PM PT (6:10PM CT)
Spoiler Alert to Chief. Caseys dead!
-
Game Thread: Twins@White Sox - Traveling Edition 5/7@4:10PM PT (6:10PM CT)
Is it my imagination, or do the Twins spend most of their games with the infield in?
-
Game Thread: Twins@White Sox - Traveling Edition 5/7@4:10PM PT (6:10PM CT)
I find the first part of that statement very hard to believe.
-
Game Thread: Twins@White Sox - Traveling Edition 5/7@4:10PM PT (6:10PM CT)
I am amazed how large your hands are!
-
Game Thread: Twins@White Sox - Traveling Edition 5/7@4:10PM PT (6:10PM CT)
It's also important to arrive fashionably late.
-
Game Thread: Twins@White Sox - Traveling Edition 5/7@4:10PM PT (6:10PM CT)
I just saw the slide play WTF
-
Game Thread: Twins@White Sox - Traveling Edition 5/7@4:10PM PT (6:10PM CT)
Or a crappie man.
-
Game Thread: Twins@White Sox - Traveling Edition 5/7@4:10PM PT (6:10PM CT)
I do think the Tains have finally gotten Sales attention, which was probably not a great idea. They should have tried to sneak up on him, played possum, then pounced!