Everything posted by USAFChief
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Detroit 5:10 PM PST (7:10 PM CDT) 8/23/2019
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Detroit 5:10 PM PST (7:10 PM CDT) 8/23/2019
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Detroit 5:10 PM PST (7:10 PM CDT) 8/23/2019
-
Is Cruz the best Twins FA signing ever?
Terrible.
-
Game Thread: Twins vs. Detroit 5:10 PM PST (7:10 PM CDT) 8/23/2019
Berrios shouldn't have been in to give up the double that drove in the first run, much LESS the line drive out, the walk, then the grand slam, then another line drive hit. He was struggling to put away hitters all night. Saved from an inning by an incredible play from Castro. How does that happen? What was the idea there? You haven't played a game since Wed afternoon. You can't let Berrios, clearly struggling, piss away a 3 run lead. I hope they come back and win, won't change a thing about Rocco's decision making. Terrible.
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Detroit 5:10 PM PST (7:10 PM CDT) 8/23/2019
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Detroit 5:10 PM PST (7:10 PM CDT) 8/23/2019
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Detroit 5:10 PM PST (7:10 PM CDT) 8/23/2019
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Detroit 5:10 PM PST (7:10 PM CDT) 8/23/2019
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Detroit 5:10 PM PST (7:10 PM CDT) 8/23/2019
-
The Rays got their man at the deadline. Arggggh!
False. I cared then, and I would still care now. There is no combination of events that could have occurred that would have made trading Pressly acceptable, IMO. And no outcomes from Alcala/Celistino will change that view. I don't know how many times or ways I can say this. The trade should be judged based on what's known at the time. And even if we accept this year-later hindsight view, or the "they should have followed up with these other moves" view, there is zero chance the Twins bullpen wouldn't have been been better in 2019 with Pressly than without. NO MATTER WHO they might have added, short of 8 Mariano Rivera clones.
-
Front Page: Ranking Minnesota Twins’ Players Weekend Nicknames
Not ONE ending in -zee?? No Cave-zee? Cron-zee? This is an invalid list.
-
Killebrew or Puckett?
Pull a fit?? Harmon finished his career in KC because the Twins didn't sign him. sheesh.
-
Is Cruz the best Twins FA signing ever?
No. Our own season prediction thread poll here at TD had the most people predicting 86-90 wins. I hesitate to call them all "homers." Some pretty smart posters were included in that. Almost nobody had them below .500. http://twinsdaily.com/topic/32597-poll-how-many-wins-this-year/?hl=poll Most national publications had them as solidly in 2nd in the ALC, with several predicting the Twins to win the ALC (7 of 32 Fangraphs preseason predictors picked the Twins.) Bleacher Report had them at 87 wins. Ceasars had them at 84 wins on their preseason over/under wager list. Off the top of my head, Harold Reynolds at MLB Network picked the Twins to win the ALC. USAToday picked the Indians to win the ALC, but put the Twins as a darkhorse most likely to surprise. And that's just looking up a few, I'm sure there were more. I don't think it was "idiotic" to predict the Twins had a very solid chance of contending in 2019. And further, IMO it's completely inaccurate to call the 2019 Twins "rebuilding." They're either "rebuilt," or it's time to tear down and start over. Virtually the entire farm system that they "rebuilt" with is up in the big leagues, and with at least a year or two of experience. Kepler, Sano, Buxton, Polanco, Berrios, Rosario, et al are not the players of a "rebuilding" team. They're the players you rebuilt with and now sink or swim with. Don't get me started on Pressly, but if the FO didn't think they'd contend, why Gonzalez? Cron? et al? Signing Cruz was not only a great idea, but almost zero risk. Taking ABs from nobody, and if not in contention, a great July trade candidate. Cheap. too. You didn't have to predict a career year to think he'd be extremely valuable.
-
The Rays got their man at the deadline. Arggggh!
I sit down a lot in the winter, so there's a good chance I will be. Prime nap time. But either way, point them out to me, because I don't pay much attention to them.
-
Is Cruz the best Twins FA signing ever?
I believe we got David Arias.
-
Killebrew or Puckett?
Killer career OPS+: 143 Pucket career OPS+: 124 And that's with the last three years of Killebrew's career included, all three of which were below 100. Puckett had only one season with a higher OPS+ than Killer's career average. I'll certainly grant Puckett played a great CF for a number of years. Killebrew was just fine as a first baseman...not as valuable, for sure, but the offensive difference is pretty overwhelming. None of which should be taken as a knock on Puckett. I'd probably rather watch Kirby. But Harmon was the better and more valuable player.
-
Killebrew or Puckett?
I loved Kirby Puckett as a player. What a joy to watch. But he's nowhere near Harmon Killebrew as a baseball player. Starting in 1959, when Killer became a regular, his OPS+ for the next 14 years, through 1972: 137 142 162 138 147 153 145 157 173 131 177 159 138 138 When Harmon retired he was 5th all time in HRs in MLB history. One MVP, Top 5 in MVP voting 6 times, named on MVP ballots 11 times. 11 time AS in an era when ASG rosters were smaller and meant something. Led the AL in HRs 6 times, RBIs 3 times, BBs four times. Full season OBPs over .400 four times, OPS over 1.000 twice, over .900 another seven. Harmon was an iconic MLB player. As much as I loved watching Kirby, and he's a deserving HOFer, he's not in Harmon's league.
-
Cleveland Discussion/ScoreWatching Thread
And...rain delay 2, bottom 8, Mets 1st and 3rd no out.
-
The Rays got their man at the deadline. Arggggh!
The pitcher with the 70-19 K/W ratio when traded. Looking at a reliever's ERA for a month is not a reasonable way to evaluate. He was clearly the Twins most talented reliever at the time of the trade. I think this is a case of people refusing to admit they were wrong, more than anything. I don't see a reasonable argument to be made that trading Pressly was anything but a colossal mistake, and looking at it a year later only confirms that fact.
-
The Rays got their man at the deadline. Arggggh!
You're right. My apologies. The rest...I disagree.
-
The Rays got their man at the deadline. Arggggh!
I think you judge a trade by what's known at the time. I dont care if Alcala wins a CYA. Still would call trading Pressly a clear mistake. "Wait five years, then ask me"? Weak.
-
Is Cruz the best Twins FA signing ever?
lots of people predicted this team would be in contention. But even if not, what was the potential mistake of adding Cruz?
-
Front Page: Twins Game Recap (8/21): Giolito Throws Complete Game as Sox Take Series
Carlos Santana sits on a change with 2 outs and 2 strikes in the top of the 10th, puts the Indians up 3-2. Really great AB. Brad Hand comes in, gives up a leadoff double, followed by a sac bunt, followed by a DP ball to Santana at first, but they only get one, as nobody covers first base to comple the DP, game tied . Walk, single, Mets Mets Emm EEE TTT ESSS METS!!!!
-
Is Cruz the best Twins FA signing ever?
He was pretty sad when he was signed, too.