Everything posted by USAFChief
-
Offseason Status Update: 40-Man Shuffling, Missed Opportunities
Nick: "And guess what's going to be happening during those months? This comment seems entirely oblivious of the reality that is about to materialize. It would be nice to have any semblance of good news or encouragement before the baseball world shuts down completely." What would you speculate Nick is talking about here?
-
Debate No. 2: Who was the better player: Kirby Puckett or Joe Mauer? (Debate/poll concluded - thread open)
Kudos to both jharaldson and Brock for incredibly good and entertaining debate points. Really well done.
- Offseason Status Update: 40-Man Shuffling, Missed Opportunities
-
A case against signing the top free agents
Signing a top free agent, or more than one, prevents you from having your own home grown core? Your argument should really be FOR signing top free agent(s). If you want "a solid team across the board," which do you think is the better way to do it: - use only the players you've developed, ignoring any holes, or - use the players you've developed, supplemented with players others have developed, that you've acquired through trades and free agency? Which one do you suppose gives you a better chance of having a "solid team across the board?"
-
A case against signing the top free agents
The Twins should easily be spending hundreds of millions over the next five years plus, no? You have no point.
-
A case against signing the top free agents
Your point is they shouldn't sign free agents, because they may need money in the future to sign free agents? That seems rather circular to me...won't you be here in the future arguing against signing THOSE free agents, because doing so would tie up money for free agents even farther into the future? IOW, you'd NEVER sign free agents.
- Bring Niko Back to Target Field
-
Twins sign Jake Cave to 2022 contract for $800k
I'll take "indicators this was a bad signing for $1000, Alex." "What is "can be released before ST ends and you won't owe him the entire $800k is the best justification for the signing anyone can come up with."
- Twins Are Rebuilding, Not Retooling, if They Trade Buxton
-
Is this front office borderline hostile to "not their" guys?
There are flaws with the RBI stat but you are overstating the case. Someone has to drive in runs, you don't get to put a 1 in the runs column just because someone drew a walk. I don't understand how someone could watch the Twins with runners on 2nd/3rd, less than two outs not score, and come away not understanding how important it is to drive in runs. In fact, I'd say 2 out RBI are the single most important factor in Wins and Losses over time.
- Twins Are Rebuilding, Not Retooling, if They Trade Buxton
- Can Twins Level Up to Matt Chapman from Josh Donaldson?
- Three Creative Options to Plug the Hole at Shortstop
-
Debate No. 2: Who was the better player: Kirby Puckett or Joe Mauer? (Debate/poll concluded - thread open)
Fair points. I agree those things add to the debate.
-
Debate No. 2: Who was the better player: Kirby Puckett or Joe Mauer? (Debate/poll concluded - thread open)
Nice work.
-
Debate No. 2: Who was the better player: Kirby Puckett or Joe Mauer? (Debate/poll concluded - thread open)
The question was, is leadership up for debate as part of the equation? As to the two players, if we agree leadership can be part of the discussion, perhaps Puckett's leadership played some role in his getting so many more opportunities.
- Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
-
Debate No. 2: Who was the better player: Kirby Puckett or Joe Mauer? (Debate/poll concluded - thread open)
I disagree. Both with the conclusion that Mauer was the better player, and the opinion that accomplishments, including postseason, are not a part of "better." I disagree that leadership isn't part of "better player." And I strongly disagree that statistics can't be part of the evidence of better.
-
Am I wrong? I'd rather the Twins have Martin, Woods Richardson, and $20M per year to spend than Jose Berrios?
Bingo.
-
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
I expect him to believe what he says. St Louis has been above .500 every year for over a decade. Atlanta in 9 of the last 13 seasons. And they've managed to win a post season game.
-
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
So does Falvey.
-
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Not only do I expect them to be competitive every year, that's what Falvey claimed as his goal when hired: The goal here is straightforward and measurable,” Falvey said. “It’s to build a sustainable and championship-caliber team and organization https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2016/11/twins-introduce-derek-falvey-thad-levine.html This team is anything but "sustainably championship quality" today, and it's really difficult to imagine it will be any time soon. They have ZERO MLB starting pitchers as I type this. None. That, in and of itself, is enough to question whether they deserve another day in office.
-
Am I wrong? I'd rather the Twins have Martin, Woods Richardson, and $20M per year to spend than Jose Berrios?
None of which changes the fact that on November 19, 2021, one has a successful nearly full season of MLB play under his belt, one has advanced to AA. As of today, Baddoo is the better baseball player.
-
Debate No. 2: Who was the better player: Kirby Puckett or Joe Mauer? (Debate/poll concluded - thread open)
Great job by the debaters. I voted for Puckett. Puckett impacted games, WANTED to impact games. Mauer was warm milk. Look at the postseason ... Mauer never won a game. Never impacted a game. Puckett won two WS. And then there's this...which player would you rather spend your hard earned money on to watch play baseball? Would you rather watch Mauer, with the winning run on first, let 2 fastballs down the middle go by, and settle for a walk--leaving the job of driving in that run to a lesser player? Or watch Puckett go up there and do everything in his power to rope one in a gap somewhere?
- Finding MLB Draft Changes that Stop Tanking