Everything posted by DocBauer
-
Article: Sano Won't See Outfield (Game) Action In Winter Ball
I really like this post. Now...hitting .260 with limited power and an OB of .330-.340 may not cut it either. But teams Re all constructed differently. The Twins don't have a bopper at 1B? Well, very few teMs have a 2B who hits like Dozier does. I watched Grace, Joyner and Hernandez win gold gloves, make all star games, and have long and productive careers despite being more contact, line drive hitters than boppers.
-
Article: Sano Won't See Outfield (Game) Action In Winter Ball
I hope...I hope...I hope we see a return of the old Mauer...(young Mauer? normal Mauer?). If not, the way the team seems to be constructed now, and with so many good young OF's, Mauer would be best as the veteran LH PH/DH/backup 1B. I don't know that the Twins would be bold enough to do that. Or if most anyone would, for that matter.
-
Hicks will be traded
Having seen Willingham, Arcia, Nunez, Escobar and Santana play the OF in years past, and knowing the overall atheltic ability of Plouffe, Mauer and Sano....I see no reason why Buxton couldn't start the season in AAA with Kepler...we could then trade both Hicks and Rosario for catching and pitching help much in the same way we traded Revere and Span. Santana could play CF until Buxton is ready. Sano or Plouffe or Mauer could play the OF corners, along with Arcia, and one of them could play 3B. Heck, why not just move Mauer back to catcher! Now we have Park at 1B, Plouffe at 3B, Arcia and Sano could play the OF corners! Doesn't matter if Sano has never played the OF professionally, he's young and a good athlete and he can hit so he'll be just fine. Oh my! Did I cover about all of it? Look, IF Sano plays any OF...which I doubt fully...it will be to increase lineup versatility and not due to any sort of permanent switch. He is a 3B, the Twins have tons of OF talent, and believe it or not, over the years, the Twins absolutely DO value good defense. Hicks may indeed have trade value at some point. Probably after another solid to good season to prove he really belongs as a ML hitter, and provide insurance for our OF situation since we are just so young out there right now and have a few questions in regard to when Kepler will be ready, or if Buxton is ready now or a month or so in to the season. Rosario is good...will get better...and provides a valuable LH bat in the lineup. I don't think he's going anywhere. I don't believe Hicks goes anywhere until mid-season at the earliest. Sano will be a 3B, maybe DH some. If anyone is gone now, it's going to be Plouffe.
- Article: The Trade Market For Trevor Plouffe
- Article: The Trade Market For Trevor Plouffe
-
Article: The Trade Market For Trevor Plouffe
I am a fan of Plouffe. Which I guess puts me in the "overvalued" camp, which I don't feel is either accurate or fair. If you like Plouffe and respect him and his contributions, I guess you overvalue him. If you feel solid fielding 3B who hit .250-ish with 30 Dbl and 20 HR power kind of grow on trees these days, then I guess you undervalue him. It's not being snarky, it's simply the reasonable split being discussed here in regard to Plouffe, his value, the number of quality 3B in the league, and teams in need. While Norris has yet to hit as he did in the minors, the potential is there. I wish he were LH, but oh well...can't have everything. I like the idea of trading with San Diego, though I could get behind a real quality RP arm or two. San Diego options include Plouffe, possibly another solid prospect, for a talented young catcher in Norris. The other option, crazy but impossible to dismiss, is a 4 or 5 for 3 with both clubs burning the midnight oil. Plouffe, Polano perhaps, Arcia maybe, Nolasco back to the NL, and a young pitcher not named Berrios. Stewart, Gonsalves or Burdi maybe? Twins get their young catcher, a top relief arm in Kimbrel, but also take on Shields. This deal doesn't really work for the Twins unless a 3rd team is involved for Shields, Santana or Hughes. (Hughes if the one I'd like to really keep) It may be too complicated...but it would be interesting.
-
Souhan on Park
Effectively, Park replaces Plouffe in the lineup. (With Plouffe traded in some deal for catching or RP) Sano plays 3B, Mauer plays 1B, Park is the primary DH but also plays some 1B. My only problem is, where is the LH power still? A healthy and productive Mauer could provide 30+ doubles still, possibly 12 HR. Rosario is very exciting and can definitely provide some XB power. With Parks at DH, this limits Arcia and Vargas as LH DH power options. Arcia could still play a little OF (cringe) as long as someone like Hicks is available to replace him late innings. I'm not saying I dislike the move for Parks. But I am a little worried about AB's from the left side. This is where a catcher upgrade, FA or trade, young or old, who can swing solid/good from the LH side could help balance things.
-
Article: Twins With Winning Bid On Korean Slugger
Wow! Interesting to say the least! Am I thrilled? Meh...kind of excited, but not thrilled. Too many variables to say I'm thrilled. Could the Twins use another power bat? Absolutely. Just wish it was LH, but power is power. I'd be thrilled if I could know ahead of time what to really expect from him. Now, we all know he's not going to hit or produce like he did in Korea. However, it's probably not unreasonable to expect him to him in the .270's, right? Even cutting his power in half he'd be a 25-26 HR hitter, and that is also good, yes? Now...200 SO's wouldn't be fun, but mixe in at least a few walks with the Avg and power and I'd be pretty happy. It's not a move the usually conservative Twins make. And it's nice to see them being aggessive, as well as not being gun shy after what happened with Nishioka. And I agree it would seem Plouffe is probably gone now. Step 2 could be even more important than step 1 was.
-
Article: Do The Twins Need To Acquire An Ace?
While I agree with you, it's sooo hard to just say he will be that "ace" pitcher. The pressure (presumably) and expectations are such that I don't know if you can ever win that debate. (the is he or isn't he truly an "ace") What if it takes 2 years? 3? What if he he's an ace quality every other year? But yeah...I just have a really, really good feeling about Berrios, his stuff, his work ethic, and his determination and mental makeup. Interesting point, I have often compared him to Pedro Martinez, who also was not tall, though I'd speculate Berrios is bulkier. But also, Cueto, a proposed ace pitcher, while bulkier at a listed 220lbs, also stands only 5' 11". So just another couple examples of an ace pitcher not being over 6 foot.
- Article: Do The Twins Need To Acquire An Ace?
-
Article: Old Friends: Which Former Twins Could Return In 2016?
FWIW...I have no interest in "putting the band back together." I am, however, interested in FA players that may be available to help bolster the Twins. If those players happen to be Ex-Twins, well then, that's just a happenstance. I like AJ if the right deal for a long term catcher just isn't there this off season. It improves our catching situation, (debate all you want as to how much-there are varying opinions to be sure), doesn't cost us big money or prospects, and let's us re-visit the FA and trade market next off season, as well as allowing another full season to examine prospects in our own system; i.e. Turner and Garver. Span I hadn't considered. Now I am. IF Plouffe is traded, I feel the lineup is rather unsettled. It seemed to me a signing might be more along the lines of a power hitter. (still leaning that way) But the Span idea to help stabalize the top of the lineup with Dozier maybe moving down to a larger RBI position. So I could get behind this. Again, the fact that he's an Ex-Twin doesn't matter to me. It's just...interesting.
-
Article: Old Friends: Which Former Twins Could Return In 2016?
OMG! I still have night sweats over that trade!
-
Article: Why Not Wieters?
Question/statement...if I may. I have also tossed Stewart's name out on an occasion or two, as of late, as part of various trade bundles and options. To be perfectly honest, I'd rather trade him than Gonsalves. Perhaps I am misguided in this thought, but it is how I feel. However, pretty much every single prospect list related to the Twins has Stewart in the top 15 at worst, if not top 10. And I believe I have yet to see him listed behind Gonsalves on any list. Therefore, while we may complain and wonder on these boards about his SO's and potential, and whether or not he will ever turn a corner, just how good he can be...RIGHT NOW...everyone who ranks prospects seems to still see him as a quality prospect.
-
Surprise, Surprise!
Very astute! I couldn't think of a way to work in a 3rd surprise, but this is what I heard in my head when starting the thread. lol
-
Surprise, Surprise!
To quote Python, Monty that is; "and now for something completely different." Wait...what's this? A post about something other than Ryan, Mauer or a catcher??!! (At least in theory) So simply: What was your biggest surprise in 2015? What do you speculate as being the biggest surprise in 2016? I guess the biggest surprises don't have to be positive in nature. Or perhaps you may feel there were significant surprises both positive and negative in 2015...possibly speculate on the same for 2016? I could, but will not, post a litany of possibilities as that is up to you. Were I to be negative, Arcia would be my top choice, in a very tight race over D Santana. Most positive surprise would be Duffey. For '16, my surprise is Berrios. I believe he will be OK, and after settling in, he will pitch like the ROY he will become. You?
-
Article: Twins With Winning Bid On Korean Slugger
In the scenarios presented, sounds like Nishioka, despite quality numbers, was the equivalent of all conference vs all American. If we could count on half the HR and a drop of 25-30 points in Avg, we'd still be talking quality production. But that is counting on, OR, having strong reason to believe. I know we are talking sometimes about millions of dollars as if they were pickel cards, but still, the investment may be worth it if we're talking $5-6M up front and $3-4M per. Otherwise, I'm really worried about tossing big $ after mega strikeouts.
-
Article: Why Not Wieters?
I may be naive or mistaken on trade ideas/value, but when trying to place myself in Milwaukee's spikes...granted without intimate knowledge of the Brewer's roster...I would think a trio of quality young prospects would be exactly what is needed to pry a player of Lucroy's ability, albeit, a bit on the outs due to injury and rebuild mode. While I love me some Trevor Plouffe, I think I might be more interested in Arcia, were I the Brewers on a rebuild. (Maybe both) I'd have to have a top pitching talent, maybe Stewart, as has been mentioned. For a third? Not sure. But no matter how much I respect Lucroy, I have a very hard time trading for a player with recent concussion issues, (especially considering the Twins history with such issues), and giving up Kepler and/or Berrios. I just think it may be asking too much. Giving up pretty much anything/anyone else for Lucroy...or anyone else who offers long term potential at the catcher spot, works for me.
-
Minnesota Twins Offseason (Part 1 of 50 most likely…)
BTW....welcome to TD!
-
Minnesota Twins Offseason (Part 1 of 50 most likely…)
Great post! Just about 100% exactly what I believe and the way I'd do it. 1* Even if he needs to hit lower in the lineup initially, I agree with playing Buxton in CF from day one...unless he just proves he needs more time. I believe the natural tools and work ethic will afford some on the job training. But I do note you do not have him listed on your roster from day one. 2* In addition to a high quality RHRP via trade or FA, I would target the best LHRP I can to give me something beyond a mere LOOGY for the 7th and 8th innings. 3* I am coming around on the Span idea. Previously, I didn't like it. (Though I have always LOVED Span) The reason? Simple...Hicks in RF/4th OF with Arcia available and Kepler in the near future, and Buxton as the eventual leadoff hitter. I have been more inclined to sign a power/RBI producer IF Plouffe were traded. But again, the Span idea is growing on me. No question our OF defense is excellent, and he solidifies the top of the order. Hmm........growing on me a lot. 4* Regardless of how the DH spot ends up...Arcia-Vargas-Pinto-Sano-Plouffe-Mauer in different combinations and possibilities...were he able to repeat his performance of last season, I would be in favor or trying Escobar in the 2 hole. This would allow Dozier, and his power and mid-lineup speed to drop down to a greater RBI production spot. (Buxton-Span in the top 2 spots could be outstanding...eventually, if not soon). Other than those couple tweaks of ideas, you and I are spot on. What's really encouraging to me is how this projected team, and these projected moves, don't require huge amounts of dollars to make happen, or overly complicated and involved trades.
-
Article: Why Not Wieters?
I don't know the exact odds of a team having ANY players from ANY draft play significantly in the majors, but I know they are large. I read once upon a time where a team hopes each draft produces 1 star (type) player, 1 solid starter and 1 solid contributor/role player. I don't have a problem with losing the #17 pick in the draft, (we'll have 2 seconds this year), as there is so little cause to feel we hurt ourselves. I also have no problem paying a 30yo catcher 4 years and $15-16M per. I honestly don't expect him to regress so quickly that he is a negative, (even if value per dollar is down for year 4) I'd rather sign him, and his potential bat, than trade away a couple top players. My concern remains, what if he just can't hold up for 120 games due to his arm? Players come back all the time these days from TJ and play the field. Sano did this year. So I ask again, why did Wieters play so little behind the plate this year? Why not on consecutive days? I need to know he is 100% before I make this investment. He's just not a good enough to hitter to slide him somewhere else, like DH, and chalk it up to an "oh well." I've stated before I like AJ for one year if things don't come together. Then re-examine the FA and trade market next season, as well as our own catching prospects a season from now. But I've been thinking about another candidate; Alex Avila. Since his big 2011 season his numbers have been on a 4 year downward slide. But, his career numbers against RHP are .251/ .358/ .423/ .781. He will only be 29 in '16 I believe. His career CS% is 29%, but over 32% if the one poor season of 2013 is removed.
-
Wolfson: Sano to get a look in OF
I just find this argument to be ridiculous. IF we had ANOTHER Sano that had arrived, or was arriving, then OK, got to make room for both of them somewhere, somehow. But other than MAYBE growing out of the position ONE DAY, all scouting reports say he can play 3B. What little I have seen of him at 3B, his size is not an issue, and he is actually quite fluid. Will he be a gold glover right off the bat? Of course not. But he will be OK, and get better and better, just like all the other 3B the Twins have had for the past 30 years starting with Gaetti. (in this reference) Rosario, Buxton, Hicks, Kepler, Arcia and Walker...with top young OF talent like that arrived and arriving and available, why on earth would you put Sano at a position that he hasn't even played before? Like Leviathan said, with his ability to play 3B and hit, he has all the versatility necessary.
-
Article: Do The Twins Need To Acquire An Ace?
I am on the "don't sign one" bandwagon. Note, I am NOT blasting Ryan for signing Hughes, Santana or Nolasco. (Haven't we been down this path before???) But the fact is, they ARE signed. Even if we can move Nolasco for SOMETHING and only have to pay half his salary, I feel we would absolutely have to then move either Hughes or Santana to not only afford our new FA "ace" pitcher, but to make room in the rotation. Then, how much better...IP, QS, etc...would this pitcher be over the displaced Hughes or Santana? Would it really be enough to offset improvements that really need to be made at catcher and the bullpen? I love having that true #1 guy to lead your staff. But he still pitches only once every 5th day. With Hughes, Santana, Berrios, May, Duffey, Gibson and even Milone available, I feel pretty good about what the Twins can march out to the mound EVERY day. I would rather go with what we have, let the kids develop, and focus on catcher and strengthening and deepening the bullpen.
-
Dozier to the Yankees for a Catcher?
Just can't get behind this move. As Stringer stated, there is enough unsettled in the lineup heading in to 2016 that unsettling another position, with the loss of Dozier, seems to weaken the lineup/team, not strengthen it. I do like Polanco. I do think he's going to be a very good ML infielder. I do think, under different circumstances, that he could replace Dozier now or in the near future. But while the team has a lot of young pieces, a lot of young offensive talent and potential, it hasn't had time to bloom yet. To remove Dozier, the second best power source on the team, just doesn't make sense to me at this time.
- Article: Why Not Wieters?
-
Article: Why Not Wieters?
Suzuki is only a must through 2016, so the $20M price tag for catcher would only be for a single season. For the right move, a move that really helps the club, I feel a whole lot better losing a 17th pick than a top 10. (which we can't really lose anyway) And while I hated not signing our 2nd round pick this past draft, we get a compensatory pick this year in place, so if we did lose our 1st rounder, we would have two 2nd's. So those aren't real issues for me. And despite being a catcher, there is nothing in particular to suggest Wieters will suddenly regress over the next 2 to 4 seasons to the point where he is a liability. Again, it's a defense first position, and you look for the best offense you can get. What does bother me is the arm. Did I hear correctly? Something about catching less than half his team's games the past 2 seasons and no games caught back to back last year? His agent, naturally, will spin it as precautionary, how he is now 110% and ready to roll every day with no issues. Could I get excited about this signing? Yes. But 4 years at $15-16M and reservations about his arm and longevity to stay behind the plate as a result...I just think I have to say no.