Everything posted by DocBauer
-
Let May close; and where the heck is Polanco?
50 bucks?! You big spender you! Too rich for my blood...or wallet.
-
Article: Line Of Succession
I really like this. It's a frustrated, but really smart post. I suppose it's easy to say the smart plans are the ones that work. But there is truth as well as fiction involved. Having a plan and following it is great, and will hopefully pay off in the long run. Having no plan almost guarantees no success. But not every plan works for every team, to state the obvious. Some teams simply have more money to work with and can augment their rosters with big FA signings, extensions, taking on trade dollars, etc. Much like the Cubs example mentioned here, or the Yankees, who actually achieved success when they finally kept and promoted their own and supplemented with big paydays. (Sort of like the Cubs example) I am not defending Ryan, though at times I believe I see where he is going and what plan he has, but I feel that if he is guilty of anything, it's not making a strong enough commitment in any one direction. Given a chance to spend real money, he's made unprecedented moves in the FA pool to augment the team, try to keep them winning, to some degree, rather than embrace all out "rebuild", a word and option we know he dislikes. Part of me gets that, understands it, and even appreciates it as a fan. But even as you try to play the FA game, to keep your head above water, and put a better product on the field while waiting for the youngsters to come up, you also can't ignore short comings on the roster, and gamble that these players will leapfrog AAA and leap directly to the majors to provide a boost. CF for three years and the bullpen for two are prime examples. Nolasco didn't really work out. It happens. Santana and Hughes weren't bad signings, nor was Suzuki. But extending Hughes and Suzuki were big mistakes. Not adding an OF or two to bridge the gap, or adding to the bullpen with pieces that wouldn't break you, and could maybe later be traded, we're also big mistakes. I think he's allowed himself to be caught between trying to be competitive and the dreaded "R" word, and now the Twins are flailing and failing this season somewhere in between.
-
Article: Line Of Succession
I agree with the first part of the sentiment, but not the second portion. I absolutely agree that it is time, or will email time, to bring in new blood and new ideas. The Target corporation example is a great one. After a time, not necessarily through the fault of anyone, ideas and approachespecially become stale. Much like with the manager or head coach of any pro franchise, no matter how successful, eventually ideas become outmoded and voices become more difficult to listen to. Just as players themselves need to be replaced at times, so do coaches or FO personnel. Back in the day, the previously mentioned Andy McPhail was a tremendous example of this for the Twins. So I agree with new blood. I don't know, necessarily, if that is in the GM spot or president of operations. And I also agree with said new blood making various decisions as to who stays and who goes, who fits, and who doesnt. But, IMO, it's overreaction to call for a complete house cleaning just for the sake thereof. St Peter and Antony are prime examples. I've never seen the ad with the cancer patient, and I strongly disagreed with his comments in regard to the 25th man on the roster comment, as well as his "the Twins Way was a media creation" comments. Both were limited in thought and rather assanine, I thought. All roster spots are important, and the proverbial "Twins Way" was about smart and well-rounded baseball. But I can't look at past successes and Target Field and say he needs to automatically go. Same with Antony. He seems respected and knowledgeable in his daily functiomns, but that doesn't mean he should be a strong GM. He was acting GM previously for a few months. A poor performing team at that time shouldn't define whether or not he's a capable assistant. It seems our past few drafts have brought high quality. There has been a noticeable shift in the organization in a more power pitching approach. The last couple of seasons, most of the Twins milb clubs have ranked near the top of their respective divisions in quality starts, SO's, etc. Just because the vast majority of the Twins top 30-ish prospects haven't reached the majors yet shouldn't be an indictment to the scouting department or those running the milb show. We've all been impatient and extremely eager to see the kids reach the Show. Some of them have, some have had cups of coffee, some are getting really close to debuting or "sticking", some appear ready or close to AAA and AA advancement. We can argue about rate of promotion, or some sitting on the Twins bench, and with sound reasoning, but to just "wish" them al, to the ML at a super quick pace is not practical. In short, new blood is a definate, but cleaning house for the sake of doing so is baby out with the bathwater IMO.
- Article: Twins Minor League Report (5/10): Kepler, Buxton Rock Rochester
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (5/10): Kepler, Buxton Rock Rochester
No matter how terrible, disappointing or gut - wrenching this season has been, I still keep envisioning an Aug. 1st lineup with Buxton in CF, Kepler in RF, Sano at 3B, Arcia/Rosario in LF, Polanco in the middle infield, Murphy as the primary C after his AAA success and promotion, and Berrios starting the game.
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Orioles, 5/10/16 @ 7:10 PM CT
Now see, except for moving Plouffe down to the 7 hole, I actually like this lineup. Though, to be hinest, I'm not even sure why Plouffe is playing. Only 2 Gan Messenger to shake the rust off and they say he's still not 100% but is trying to play through it.
-
Article: Where Are The Prospects?
I agree 100%. And part of that process is to let guys like Buxton and Kepler every single game and AB they can at Rochester. It's also the reason I wasn't too upset by the Mastroianni promotion. It's not the option I'd like to have, and I don't think I'd be starting him, but, I'd rather him in the short term. But the other part of making this happen is opportunity. And that comes from doing things differently than before. We can lament all we want about past business, or this offseason...and with good reason in some instances. ..but whats important is how business is done going forward. Some of the recent options and waiver wire moved allow for said change. Will it be maintained? It has to for the team to move forward. That's going to mean a few tradex, the eating or partial eating of some contracts, and possibly the inclusion of some lower level prospects as well. But it's the only way you make room for Berrios and Duffey, or May, etc., plus maybe acquire another C or RP. BTW...I still want May in the rotation as well. But the way things are set up at the moment, Meyer off to a good start and minting it is probably the more likely option.
-
Blake Swihart
I am not willing to abandon Gibson after a poor start and injury. Considering what he's shown the past two seasons, and apparently still has upside, I'd really like to hold on to him. I think frustrations are boiling over to the point where fingers start getting pointed everywhere and anywhere. The Twins needed to make room in the rotation to keep Duffey and Berrios both. Half of that mission is acco,polished now with the removal of Milone. Nolasco needs to be next. The reason is simple, contractually, he should be easier to move than either Hughes or Santana. I disagree he doesn't have value. His contract is not grossly out of line, is good for only one more year, and his overall career numbers have been solid. I could see a team, NL, with aspirations and a hole or injury needing some help that would consider him a solid pickup. Especially, as I have long maintained, the Twins were to pick up a portion of his dollars, and possibly throw in a lower level prospect. I would love to see a 3rd opening eventually, trade or move to the pen, to make room for Meyer, or possibly May back to the rotation. But for now, clearing space in the rotation is a big issue.
-
Blake Swihart
I stuck to INF and OF in my previous post. (And they are somewhat tied together at the momemt) Catcher is a mess. And I would not dare so to not go get another one if you can...reasonably. While both Turner and Garver offer some hope, the best we can hope for now is that a month of Murphy at Rochester will get him looking more like the player we hoped we were getting all along. Then, he needs to be promotec, started, and let Suzuki be the backup. (Or gone) Did I read somewhere recently that the team ERA with Murphy starting was substantially better than when Suzuki started behind the plate?
-
Blake Swihart
I hate to say this as I love the guy, he's done a lot for the team, is not 30 yet, and sooner or later is going to come out of his current slump, but it may be time to seriously look at moving Dozier. Today? Probably not. But maybe come June and he's hitting like he has in the past? You can't have a young talent like Polanco, filled with potential, even if it is ultimately determined that he can't be an everyday SS, and just keep yo-yo-ing him in and out of lineups, up and down the Minnesota-Rochester shuttle. How about Sano at 3B, Escobar at SS, Polanco at 2B, Nunez and Santana at utility, Mauer and Park sharing 1B/DH. By the season's second half, the OF could include Buxton, Kepler, Arcia and Santana as a fill-in. Unfortunately, that still leaves us potentially an OF short, unless Rosario finds himself again. But still, doesn't that INF/OF situation just make a lot more sense that where we are at now?
-
Blake Swihart
Nolasco, healthy again and having moments and games of looking like a viable MLS again, he may have trade value. Particularly to a NL team where he has spent the majority of his career. Or, put another way, healthy again and only 1 more year left on his deal, the Twins have to find a way to move him to keep Duffey and Berrios both in the rotation. Plouffe has been mentioned yet again. Healthy, fieldimg, hitting as he has most of the past couple of seasons, I'm still surprised that "reportedly" he has little individual trade value. Maybe as part of a package, especially if someone has a significant injury any time soon. If the Yankees are ready to start tearing things apart, maybe there. Long shot, but maybe. Moving Plouffe and obtaining SOMETHING of value also helps set the INF with Sano at his natural and more comfortable 3B position. Which, in turn, helps, eventually, set up the OF. As to the original post, a healthy Santana, back in a groove and not throwing like his last start, and with his career track history, would be the one guy that would qualify, or come closest, to being a #2 SP. But, while he is not owed a fortune by any means, 2 remaining years on his deal would scare off a lot of teams IMO.
- My Twins
-
Twins DFA'd O'Rourke and Graham, Maestro up
Absolutely they bear responsibility. Both for last year and this year. And the FO has been terribly "hopeful" and short-sighted as to be depending on such rapid progress/preparedness of these youngsters. Burdi getting hurt, however, doesn't help. Chargois seems to be the real deal. But with so much time missed due to injury, I'm stil, OK giving him a little more time. But he should be at Rochester immediately, IMO. Not in regard to your post Mike, but in general, I find it interesting that the past couple of seasons there has been much consternation about Tonkin and Pressly actually getting a fair chance to show what they can do. And now, this year, they are finally getting that opportinity. While the results have certainly been mixed, there have been positives as well. And yet, in frustration for a losing team, and a bullpen who's two "mainstays" have been hurt, or ineffective, or both...along with the Fien situation...there seems to a relative ease to also point to Tonkin and Pressly. I'm not really sure thats fair at this point.
-
Breaking Down the Roster Construction
I'm a huge fan of Dozier. And I'd hate to see such a good and productive player lost to my team. (I say this in spite of his struggles this season) But if we look at roster construction the rest of this year, and going forward, it may simply be a better fit for Polanco to take his spot. Sano plays 3B. Escobar holds down SS. We have 1B and DH set, it seems, for the foreseeable future. Eventually, Buxton and Kepler should be 2/3 of the OF, with Arcia, Rosario and Walker strong factors. Palka? Maybe. Santana? Maybe? Maybe it's just me, but it seems there is a path here that seems kind of obvious.
-
Breaking Down the Roster Construction
Brandon, a really great article. Thoughtfull, direct, and I believe accurate. Well done! And thank you for an honest and "step back" perspective. While I hope I don't end up repeating you too much, I have some points I'd like to add. 1} It's simply way too late, and meaningress really, to play GM in a revisionist role. But since you brought up the points, I feel compelled to do so. I am NOT going to play the bash TR game. However, IMO, he has blown the CF situation for 3 years, and the bullpen for 2. I have stated before, and you pretty much said the same thing, that the otherwise conservative Ryan was gambling on prospects being ready. Hicks wasnt, and Buxton wasnt. The young, power armed RP weren't and still aren't quite. But instead of providing alternatives, we are stuck where we are now. It seemed OBVIOUS to me that what the Twins needed was a veteran RH OF to play both corners, a possible 4th OF/CF option to delay Buxton, and a couple of quality RP. And yet, none of these moves took place. There WERE options for these spots that would not have cost a fortune...some of them may have been along the lines of make good contracts...but they were out there. Cleveland has 2of them alone in Davis and Byrd. How much better are our options now if we have them, or someone like them, to platoon with Arcia and even allow Rosario to go down and find himself? And again, I simply can't believe...though I agree with avoiding 3 year contracts...that a couple quality, experienced RP couldn't be moved at some point to a team in need later this season when any youngsters proved ready. 2} Plouffe should have been moved. I like Plouffe. I still do. But Sano is the future, should be at 3B, and we are only delaying his overall value, and positive roster construction by forcing him to the OF. Even with questions about Park's ability to fit in right away, there were enough options available that moving Plouffe in some sort of deal should have taken place. 3} I absolutely agree about giving Buxton and Kepler time. (Reference point number 1) The hype, hope, talent and potential for both is tremendous. But as you pointed out, Buxton has so few games and AB above A ball to almost be scary. And despite all of Kepler's tools and potential, he was very raw, is just coming in to his own, and it is very short-sighted, perhaps irresponsible to just want to promote them and play "sink or swim. 4} As disappointing as this season has turned out to be, as much as we want all of these tremendous young talents to succeed, there is a learning curve attached. And promoting them too soon, or promoting them and sitting them on the bench, is not the answer. The problem is not having some sort of viable option at the ML level to better allow this. Polanco is another name you bring up. I think there are still question marks what to do with him, where he fits in best. And I'm not sure I have a proper resolution. But there has to be a plan in place here at some point. He is just way too young, way too talented, has way too much talent to just be yo-yo'ed around the way he has been.
-
Twins DFA'd O'Rourke and Graham, Maestro up
Also really surprised Fien was claimed and not Milone. Please, please, if Fien does well for the Dodgers, new team and new league that doesn't know him, lets not jump on some "the Twins should known better" bandwagon. I'm confused about the Dean promotion. I just don't get it. He is not a top prospect by any means, but I'm not a hater. The vitriol against him is very misplaced, IMO. And he may end up doing a great job, who knows. But if you are not going to keep and use O'Rourke as an effective LOOGY, then why bring up Boshers? I know he's just turning 28 and was in the independent leagues a year ago, but he was good there, seems to throw fairly hard, had a solid ST, has excellent numbers at Rochester through 10 appearances and 12 IP.
-
Twins DFA'd O'Rourke and Graham, Maestro up
The reason Mastro is back, in theory, is he can PR and be a defensive replacement, with a start here and there against LH pitching. I'm not saying he's an ideal option. And I could be accused of attempting to spin things in a positive manner. And I really wish we had Sweeney still around, or another veteran option. But I'd rather promote a 5th OF bench option...for NOW...than interrupt much needed playing time and AB for Buxton, Kepler and Walker. Yes, Buxton is playing better. I get that. And he is super, super talented with a potentially huge future in front of him. But having already been promoted twice when not ready, I feel it's a lot better to give him more prep time and experience, as wel, as continued confidence and good mojo, than to rush him right back. Come on waiver wire!
-
Berardino: Twins place Milone and Fien on waviers
Sorry, I generally likeep LEN3, and he's right about these moves being uncharacteristic. As long as the moves are not window dressing, they are needed. (Should have been during the offseason along with others but we've hit that topic adnauseum) But I think he's flat out wrong to target Arcia. And arguing with an umpire and getting tossed is not the way to go about your business. (But as bad as some of the umpiring has been at times this season, I'm surprised the whole team, coaches, broadcasters and fans haven't been tossed) And Sano can't play 3B? Has he even been watching Sano play in the infield? Nobody expects a Gold Glove from him there. But he's still young and developing defensively. He's been OK there last year and this year. Probably even better this season when you realize he's been forced to the OF, "for the whole season", before moving back. Was Gaetti a great 3B initially? Koskie? Plouffe? The rhetoric of Sano at 3B is getting annoying.
- Article: Twins Minor League Leaderboard (Through 5/6)
-
Twins DFA'd O'Rourke and Graham, Maestro up
As to the roster at this time? Unless we can actually find an OK ML OF somewhere, somehow, to help out, Mastro as a 5th OF, defensive replacement and PR may be, at least, prudent, and allow Buxton and Kepler more time. I'd do my best to keep both Berrios and Duffey in the rotation. Moving Nolasco, however it has to be done, insures this. I'd keep playing Sano at 3B, at least on a regular basis, and I'd be looking at Plouffe, Mauer and even Park as a possible RF temp/fill in. This would allow me to prepare for the future, Sano at 3B, while still attempting to get my best bats in the lineup. Why and how can Sano be moved to the OF but everyone else is immune to any such move? I don't really understand the O'Rourke move. I'm not a big fan of a pure LOOGY, but at least he seemed to be OK in that role. Maybe Boshers can and will do better. There ARE feel good stories out there where somebody gets another chancd, with another organization, something clicks, and they find a role. I seriously doubt Kinsler has a future with the Twins. But if it's him or Fien, I'd take Kinsler, at least in the short term. And I'd probably move Chargois up to Rochester with the idea that in a month, maybe the break, he's now ready to take Kinsler's job, or someone else's. (As good as Chargois looks, he's still lacking much pro experience of any kind) Until or unless he slumps, I'd still get Nunez in some games. I'd go with Centeno as second catcher for now, and try to get Murphy back on track in Rochester. If and when that happens, I'd bring him up to PLAY, and make Suzuki the backup catcher. (Or even DNA him, or hope someone out there could really use a veteran catcher for depth and offer up SOMETHING) Dozier has had some solid success in the past in the 1 spot, and has voiced he has enjoyed playing there. I know there are valid arguements to batting him lower in the order, but maybe swapping with Santana would spark him. And whether it costs us a contract or a lower level prospect, I'd keep watching the waiver wire and such for that veteran OF, or a catcher, that may be acquired as a stop gap option who could maybe help. This might even allow Rosario to go back down to AAA for a time to get right as well.
-
Twins DFA'd O'Rourke and Graham, Maestro up
I also played amateur GM this off season, and thought I did a pretty good job of it. (Not that it matters or anyone asked. Lol) And I was befuddled by moves made and moves not made. But I tried to focus on the positives and hope. During ST, I really thought there was a shot that this team would be at least OK. Alas...that is not the case. I don't feel there is an issue in regard to actually giving TR or anyone else "credit" or an "at a boy" for these recent moves. I think the feeling is more one of...hope simply may be the best word here, though not totally accurate...that at least there is a willingness to begin to move on. The problem isn't the Twins past way of doing things, or a failed off season. Those things are what they are, being in the past. And the issue isn't really Centeno of Boshers or Mastroianni. No, the issue is what's next? I understand the frustration and disappointment we all feel. But, IMHO, the answer is not to just promote 4-6 prospects or so, throw them out there, and let them take their lumps and see if they sink or swim. And if they sink, toss them back down again and bring someone else up and play the sink or swim game with them. There is no form of continuity there, it could damage steady progress, and it's not really any different than recycling veterans round and round and seeing if something "sticks to the wall", as it were. So the issue is again, what's next? And not tomorrow, but maybe 2-4 weeks from now. Is this a real attempt keep Berrios and Duffey in the rotation? Is this a real effort to add a 5th OF just for speed and defense so Buxton and/or Kepler can get some more time before coming up? Is this a prelude to actually remove guys like Milone, Nolasco and maybe others, despite contacts in order to clear the 40 man and the 25 man rosters? If the answer is yes, I'm not willing to toss bobbles or bouquets to Twins management. Nor am I saying there shouldn't be some very warm butts. But at least it would signify...again, maybe hope...that there is actually a change in thinking and procedure. That maybe, there is at least the makings of an actual plan instead of a recycling job.
-
Berardino: Twins place Milone and Fien on waviers
Boshers?
-
Berardino: Twins place Milone and Fien on waviers
Yes...but...while the past few months have just felt awkward in regard to Twins moves, isn't what's taking place right now kind of what we've all been clamoring for? Keep the long term, remove the short term, promote players, even if it's AA to AAA and A to AA, etc.
-
Berardino: Twins place Milone and Fien on waviers
But at this point, who else would you bring up? You don't want Buxton, Kepler or Walker sitting on the bench, and if you're smart about it...poor choice of words these days perhaps...you don't want to disrupt their daily playing/development/progress at Rochester. So you keep the kids down playing every day and add a solid defensive OF with some speed to sit on the bench, PR and maybe be a late inning defensive replacement.
-
Fixing the Twins Isn't That Complicated
Agree it's a very well thought out point of view. But I also disagree on Murphy. He's talented enough and young enough that I don't think he should be so easily dismissed. I don't think he's been handled right. (Surprise!) How do you trade for a young catcher and then not play him? Suzuki is not part of the future, offers no potential, and is almost certainly gone after this year. Does he really offer so much for a struggling team that he has to play daily over Murphy? Despite no obvious option at AAA, thank you TR for that, I'd rather see Murphy play every day at Rochester for a time to find himself again. Play him or help him! Keep starting Berrios and Duffey. Move Nolasco for SOMETHING, even if you trade money and a low level prospect to do so. Make room! Fien and Milone is a good first start. If you can't find a market for Plouffe, or Plouffe and a prospect, then give him, and Mauer and Park, an OF glove and find someone who can play a less than horrible RF so Sano can concentrate on 3B primarily. Whether he ever turns in to a good/great 3B is irrelevant. He's solid there. Repeating myself, lose Nolasco to make room, and by mid season at the latest, prepare to run with Buxton, Kepler, Polanco, maybe Meyer, and a couple young RP like Chargois and maybe even Boshers. (?) There is a nucleus in place. Build on it!