Everything posted by DocBauer
-
Article: To Tank Or Not To Tank?
Nothing wrong with removing players who don't fit and/or blocking youngsters who are ready to audition. Play them and try to win. Winning helps breed winning and a winning culture. Still thinking of keeping both Santana and the younger Dozier for 2017.
-
Speculation: E. Santana to the Red Sox and Ricky Nolasco to the Orioles...
After another horrible start from Nolasco yesterday, I'm just not sure there is a market for him. I'd love to eat some contract and move him to a NL team willing to give up SOMETHING for a flyer because they need help, his career has been spent in the NL, and a change of scenery may turn him around. But at this point, whatever it takes, the Twins just need to move on, and so does Nolasco.
-
Who Fits Where at the Deadline
I've always liked Plouffe. He's a solid ballplayer. His poor 2016 is a result of injuries. But Sano should never have been thrust to the OF. As stated by others, it messed with the entire makeup of the team. I don't think keeping him was necessarily the problem, however. Assuming there was or wasn't a real market for him, the Twins should have been able to move he and Mauer and Sano in and out between 1B, 3B and DH as they did the last half of 2015. The problem was a jumbled mess after acquiring Park. If you didn't have a plan, then don't go after Park. Especially when you still had Arcia, possibly Vargas, as other DH/role player options. But they went for Park, got him, and then created a jumbled mess. Sano at 3B should be fine. You can examine the careers of former Twins 3B, including Plouffd, and see that it takes time to fully develop defensively. He only has to be solid, and he has the potential for better than that. Very few 3B, or SS for that matter, arrive at the ML level a polished defensive product. Years of observation and a tiny bit of research shows this.
-
Trevor May...what would you do?
Going back a page or two, I'm going to disagree with Stringer on being OK with May's move to the pen last year. It should have been Pelfrey. May was far younger, was exhibiting improvement, has better stuff, and should be part of the future. Pelfrey had a couple decent starts and management fell in live with him. He would have been a much better choice. I also don't understand misgivings about May physically. Unless I've forgotten something, he was a horse in his milb days. Sometimes guys just get hurt. For a team that has had such a hard time finding and developing quality young starters, him being stuck in the pen is almost unforgivable. Get him back to starting. If the improvement he showed last season doesn't follow through, he can always be turned to the pen again.
-
Who Fits Where at the Deadline
Hitting on a couple points: While we can cry roster mismanagement, and we'd be right, bringing back Plouffe was a ni-brainer if there was no market. The downfall was an injury plagued season. But his time is now passed. Don't get down on Sano! How many times do we have to be remembered that it takes time to smooth things out? Think about early Gatti or Koskie or Plouffe. I'd like to keep Nunez. He won't be expensive, and even if this season is a complete mirage, he's a solid role player for 2017. Escobar possibly/probably reclaims the SS job, and Nunez and Polanco can play all over if you keep the under 30 Dozier. Those are nice options to have. I also had no problem bringing back Milone as a #5 option. Cheap, experienced and fairly dependable. The only problem was, I viewed him as the 6th SP because I would have had May in the rotation. His time is also probably up. I don't get the dislike by some for Gibson. He's relatively young, shows potential, and is only in his 3rd season. He was better last year than his "rookie" season (missed true rookie status by something like 1/3 of an inning). Healthy again, he's pitching well. Santana, Gibson, Berrios, Duffey and May for 2017 with Wheeler, Meyer and Dean as possibles. You simply can't count on Hughes at this point for anything.
- Article: Twins Minor League Report (7/22): Berrios Baffles and Diaz Delivers
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (7/22): Berrios Baffles and Diaz Delivers
Berrios's next start simply has to be with the Twins. A little disappointed Jay came out of the pen. I hope this doesn't mean he's done starting for the year. I understand limiting his innings, but they aren't very high at this point either. I'd think he could make a few more starts before switching to the pen for the remainder of the season.
-
Article: To Tank Or Not To Tank?
Neither. Still debatable in my mind to keep Santana vs keeping him to help stabilize next year. (Or trade in the offseason after teams begin their re-set) Same with the younger Dozier. Nolasco, Milton, Plouffe, Suzuki and probably Kinzler and Abad should all go. Otherwise, keep doing what you are doing on the field, promote the youngsters up to take the places of those traded. Bring up more in September. We're building for 2017 now. Win or tank as the end result is not the point IMO. It's all about experience and building up the kids.
-
Article: Rob Antony's Audition
Also, I do see the Twins job as being a bit of a plumb, as long as there are no harsh restrictions involved. You wouldn't be in a high pressure media market. You have a fabulous facility here and in Ft Myers. And with the restocking of the farm system, a lot of good young talent close, and some of it already "arrived" some of the heavy lifting for the continent rebuild has been done.
-
Article: Rob Antony's Audition
I don't see any way Antony can really do anything in 2 1/2 months to impress anyone he should be the new GM. For starters, any trades made would doubtfully be splashy, and would take time before you'd even see a payoff. Further, said trades may have been well in to conversation before Ryan was removed. The fan base is frustrated, and ownership knows this. And the comments about system wide failure speak to me of an outside hire. And while Pohlad has been blasted for is "research" of examining other teams media guides at least suggests he's further considering/opening up addition spots for new personnel. I'm really kind of excited here. Though until I actually see the list of candidates and the final choice, I remain a tad leary.
-
Mr. Consistency
Walker is intriguing, no question about it. If it were feasible for him to perform at the ML level as he has done at the milb level, lower BA and high SO totals, his power and production would still be excellent in the lower third of the lineup as a DH. But money is on Palka as the better prospect. He's more legit defensively, may be able to play 1B as well, and simply makes better contact. Wow, can you imagine if Palka gets it and Vargas keeps getting chances and proves he belongs? 1B/DH looks really interesting.
-
Current Pitching Staff
I'm not going to pretend things are rosey when it comes to the Twins staff, but it has been much better of late. While there is a huge payoff of high quality SP and RP prospects just over the horizon...ETA 2018 with some arrivals in 2017...all is not lost in the here and now. Santana is still solid. Occasionally really good. And there is nothing to indicate some imminent failure as some suggest. (Part of the reason I'm in favor of keeping him) Gibson, now healthy, has been solid to quite good. He's shown the past two seasons what he's capable of. And there is still potential to be better. Berrios may or not be a stud from his next start on, but he has enormous potential. I like Duffey and except for a rough start early this year, he also is solid. The 5th spot is certainly up for grabs. Wheeler maybe, at least in the short term? Though I still maintain May should be there. The pen has a trio of guys to stick. There are a number of guys, not just Chargois, who should be auditioning soon and have a chance. I believe FA will see a pickup or two in the offseason. NOT a championship staff to be sure. But with a couple youngsters ready, or almost ready, and a couple moves, I feel the Twins are close to putting together a solid, competent staff.
-
Underreported
Agreed on the pen. The numbers will be even better with Chargois and others on their way. Despite a "bad" pen this year, I actually think it's improved. As stated, it was really the back end of the pen, especially early on, that caused bad numbers, losses and the such. Kepler's HR don't surprise me a bit. It's part of the maturation process. Physically, stroke wise, he's always had 20 HR potential. His overall power is just maturing. Also agree on trying to move Kinzler if we can. To free the roster spot if nothing else. Banking on him for the future of a number of interesting bullpen prospects seems a fools errand. Still a little torn on Abad however. The team HR production is nice, and helps bode well for the future. But more guys OB and better clutch hitting would also be nice.
-
Ramirez Outrighted, Boshers called up
Don't disagree Brock. Not a bit. And if more doesn't change soon, I will also become equally frustrated and be loud about it. But this is correcting one bad move. I'm just saying no-one should be bent that this is the first move. Heck, I'm tickled they jumped in and move this quickly, even if it's a small one to start.
-
Reusse thinks it's all about the money.
I think the colum itself reeks of a deadline with nothing more to say and is rather self serving to get attention. (As well as meet deadline) Look, if you owned the Twins, and they were losing, losing, losing some more...and the fans weren't happy...and ND receipts were down...wouldn't you finally axe the man who helped make all that losing happen? As a business, wins and loses, including perception, all works along with the money factor. Hand in hand. Move along now...nothing more to see here.
-
Ramirez Outrighted, Boshers called up
Losing Ramirez was smart. Bang on Boshers if you want, but the guy has pitched very well at Rochester and was solid for us. He was only sent down due to a crunch. No problem with his coming back up. And it's only oneive, the first move, and only a couple days after TR was dismissed. Chargois will be up, and probably really soon. Patience.
-
Article: Mauer Outage
First of all, I have always been a Mauer fan and supporter. And I dont care about the value of his contract. He earned his money fairly. It's not his fault his career has taken a dive due to his concussions (plus wear and tear) Get over the hate. And I've previously argued that fine defense at 1B, contact, and quality OB have a place in the lineup. There are many ways to build a roster/lineup, and not every position on every team is stocked by a player who is pigeon-holed in to a certain type. And while I wholeheartedly agree Sano IS a 3B, and is OK there, and will get better, (little weight loss would probably help), and any move to QB is probably years away, I do see a potential problem at 1B/DH. There are a lot of unknowns here to be uncovered still. But Vargas is not some fly by night washed out prospect. He's young, has some real potential, has a nice milb track history of production, showed his potential in 2014, but had a rough 2015. Park has real potential. Fully healthy, we may not be even debating his worth at this point. And he has a nice glove at 1B. Palka appears to have nice potential, and may have been a steal. Walker is an enigma, but an enigma who has produced at every level, seems to be making some adjustments, and shouldn't be counted out even if he needs more AAA time, or a full season, in 2017. Additionally, a team doesn't HAVE to have a full time DH. But if you've got real depth in the OF and 1B, you can roll everyone for half days off through the DH spot. Unfortunately, Mauer's skills as a batter have diminished greatly. I won't bag on him for his OB or good defense. Those are fine things. But are those things enough to continue taking up a roster spot these next two seasons when we may actually have good young hitters knocking on the door? I don't know if trying to move him to a team with a chance to compete for the next couple of years is the answer, (with his blessing and eating dollars of course), or attempting a buyout to move on, or suggested retirement are the answers. But I'm just not sure he fits with the future direction of this team any longer.
-
Article: It's Time!
Honestly, with further reflection on all matters, I think what the Twins should be doing is trading/cutting the obvious and then staying pat. The obvious moves are to be rid of Nolasco, Milone, Kinzler, Ramirez, Plouffe, D Santana and Suzuki. Get what you can, probably A ball players with some potential, eat salary that is already spent anyway, and just clear space. These moves allow the team to instantly promote Berrios, Wheeler, Chargois, Wimmers (Boshers and Hildenberger are possibles), Polanco and Murphy as direct replacements. Promote as necessary to AAA, but especially include Garver, Granite and Hildenberger, plus probably Melotakis. (I've stated this before) I can see arguements for and against trading Abad vs re-signing him, but I'm on the fence there but OK either way. What I would not do, unless offered something pretty darn nice that I'd be silly to refuse, is trade E Santana, Dozier or Nunez. Why? Santana provides a solid, decent, still relatively cost controlled veteran SP for 2017 to help fill and stabilize my staff which probably includes Gibson, Duffey, Berrios and either Wheeler or May. (Meyer and Hughes on the outside looking in for now) Despite some arguements to the contrary, there is no reason to expect Santana to suddenly decline dramaticly. He may have even greater trade value this time next season with only a year and a half remaining on his deal. Further, he could still be traded during the offseason once teams begin to set their rosters. Dozier is good. Dozier is not old. We're still not 100% sure what we have in Polanco. (Twins own fault there) We are hedging our bets by keeping Dozier for now as Polanco auditions and gets experience. Perhaps he grows in to a full time slot gradually? I also feel the same about Dozier in trade value this time next year, or the offseason. And I'd keep Nunez. And not just because he's having this great season. What if Sano gets hurt? While I fully believe in Sano playing 3B, and only getting better, what if you move him suddenly to 1B/DH? What if Polanco struggles, especially if you've traded Dozier already? What's wrong with Escobar, Dozief, Nunez and Polanco all opening 2017 as your starting middle infield and utility reserves? And by not trading Santana or Dozier...at least now...you can audition Murphy, Polanco, Wheeler and a host of RP the remainder of the season, as well as how your other prospects finish AAA and AA, fairly assess their time table after a complete season and possible September audition, and then re-assess your top needs in the offseason and still look to move Santana and/or Dozier at that time.
-
Article: It's Time!
You are correct that Polanco hasn't had his opportunity and we all know that has to change. And soon! I'm still torn on trading Dozier. He still brings a lot to this team, but his return should also be good. And he's still young enough to be part of this rebuild. I find the Polanco vs Dozier debates to be interesting. I see no reason why Polanco can't be a fine defensive 2B, as good as or better than Dozier. But they are different types of players. And that's OK. Polanco may develop some double digit HR power, but will probably never be a 20+ HR guy like Dozier. But he will almost assuredly hit more, have a decent to good OB, and provide speed and quite a few doubles. Losing Dozier's HR would stink, but it should also be offset, eventually if not immediately, by 1B/DH becoming more settled, Rosario and Kepler.
-
Danny Santana
He is blocking Polanco via his roster spot. Kepler and Rosario can both play CF if Buxton needs a day off. Really, if someone got dinged, could Mastroianni be any worse for a week than Santana? Kid has talent, no doubt. But it's not manifesting in a positive, forward direction. Pass him through waivers. If he clears put him in AAA. I've always rooted for him. And he may yet find a role with another team. But we don't need him, and Polanco needs to be up.
-
Article: It's Time!
I would still consider keeping E Santana unless the return is nice. Plouffe, Nolasco, Milton and Suzuki should all be gone soon. Not convinced moving Nunez or Escobar is a good move. I don't feel the necessity to gut the roster for the sake of doing so. And both offer ability and roles, TBD, and offer additional roster depth and flexability. Especially if we do consider moving Dozier at some point. But I want Polanco up. I'd consider moving on from D Santana even though there is still potential there. And both Kepler and Rosario can play CF here and there when Buxton needs a break. Berrios and Wheeler in the rotation now. (Still want to stretch out May, but might not happen now until next year) Chargois and Wimmers up in place of Ramirez and whoever else is moved. I'd like to bring Boshers up too, but we need to see if we actually have something in Wimmers. And as crazy good as he's been, I'm not sure how you don't bring up Hildenberger at some point. Not sure about Palka. I like him. I still hold out real hope for Walker as well. But there are so many AB and Walker is still a work in progress and Palka just got to AAA, so I guess I'm a no for now. Granite and Garver should both be at AAA tomorow. Could see Garver in September, but Murphy needs a fair audition for now.
-
Article: Twins Fire General Manager Terry Ryan
I appreciate the job Ryan did his first term with the Twins. And his first couple of losing seasons on this second term weren't entirely is fault. But the past few seasons, it just seemed like he didn't have a plan in place. I was of the opinion he was gone, despite arguements of the previous TWINS WAY of doing things. Comments from Ryan himself seemed to indicate he was on the hot seat. But again, I'm really surprised it happened at this time.
-
Article: Deadline Primer: Catcher On The Rise
Just curious, but do we have any breakdowns for Murphy on a month to month basis? His numbers just aren't good overall, but he also planted himself in quite a hole to begin the season. It seems as though he's been at least a little better the past month or so. Mitch Garver is amongst the Twins milb batting leaders in slugging, OPS, HR and RBI. Every report I've ever heard has him as quality behind the plate and throwing. He's not ready now, and there is no guarantee as to how he turns out, but he provides future optomism. I'd still trade Suzuki if the market bears a solid offer. But it sure appears we'really going to have to sign a veteran of sorts in the offseason.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Leaderboard (Through Games On July 12)
Interesting and gratifying to see Garver on so many of the batters lists.
-
Neal: Home-Groan: Twins Trouble Drafting, Developing Starters
To further the negative, those of us who are "more tenured" fans remember a wave of prospects in the 80's that included names some of you won't know: Sontag, Newman, Banks, Pittman, Nivens, Baumgartner and Gasser. None turned out and all were considered top prospects. Not that there weren't some success stories as well, but some tremendous disappointment as well. On the plus side, as the article mentions, and as we all are well aware, there is a new wave of some fine talent getting close. This marks a change a few years back in drafting and signing philosophy of not going for the smooth, control and more ready-made arm, but more of a power arm "stuff" prospect and then molding them. This new approach has appears to be working. This is backed up by milb team pitching statistics the past few years that have sent the majority of Twins affiliates amongst the tops in their leagues with quality starts, strikeouts and other rankings. Hope is around the corner to be sure. But I do weary of arguements that arms have left the Twins only to find success elsewhere. Most of the names listed here on TD have turned out to be OK, or have one good year, as RP, but only after bouncing around from team to teame before finding a niche somewhere. The Twins themselves have had success in this capacity, as do most teams at some point, so I don't feel that is a valid complaint. The only exception may be Liriano, and his success came Inn the NL, and only after the White Sox gave up on him.