Everything posted by Dman
- Article: Draft News and Notes
- Article: Twins MiLB Report (6/16): Pitching Carries Trio Of MiLB Squads
-
Article: Twins Designate Oswaldo Arcia
As usual, I agree with most everything you say here. It is sad that we are giving him away for nothing especially given his age and potential. And yet on the other hand I don't see him as a good fit on this team. He doesn't have a great eye at the plate. He doesn't field any position well. Given his splits he looks like a platoon player. So basically he could be a DH with no real position flexibility. I just think the Twins can do better than that. If they had a crappy farm system I would say this is a huge mistake but they have Vargas, Walker and Palka in the wings as well and if Grossman is the find he appears to be I think they all are as good if not better options than Arcia at least at this point. While I am sad to see him go and have success elsewhere we can't keep everybody. It is a waste that they did not develop him properly and will get nothing back. I cannot defend that, but at the same time I think it is time to move on.
-
MLB Draft rant
I tend to agree with you. Not every pick is a value pick as sometimes they want to pay a player less to pay an other more (ie college seniors). Lot's of boards have players ranked way lower or higher than other boards so consensus beyond the top 50 is iffy at best. In the end hardly any of these players will make it to MLB. You hope the scouts can find one or two guys a draft that can help the big club. That is a lot of swing and misses every year for every team.
-
Article: Draft News and Notes
I like the picks 1-5 which equals 7 as they all seemed to be picked right about where they should be and if not have some high ceiling potential. I am coming around on the Kirilloff pick. I thought college pitcher was the better value there but going with a young hitter for the next wave probably makes more long term sense. He has a lot of tools and a higher ceiling than the college pitchers so it makes sense. I hope he is a good one. I loved the Rortvedt pick and his signing so fast makes me like him even more. Glad he is ready to get to work and become the star player I think he can become. I hope they can sign most if not all the top 20 players and that this becomes a great class for them.
-
Article: Cody's Post-Draft Top 10 Prospects
I like the list. It's a good list but tough going for a first round pick when you start out at 9th. Typically they start in the top 5. Lot's of first round picks and international signer's in that top 10 so I guess that makes sense. Like others I could quibble about placement but swapping is just a matter of preference at this point. I take it we would see the top high school catcher in the top 20?
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (6/11): The Ryans Lead The Lookouts
I have been a big Eades basher, but have to say he has been pitching pretty well lately. I still think he is better fit for the pen but am happy to see him playing well.
-
Another Jim Pohlad Interview
Touché good point
-
Another Jim Pohlad Interview
I guess I am the only homer that some what understands his statement about the focus on winning takes away some of the beauty of the game. To me if you are a truly unbiased and objective baseball fan you love watching players from both sides making great baseball plays. Sure you want "your" team to win but great baseball is great baseball. Even great teams lose. Granted ultimately we measure a teams success by wins and losses but if you really love baseball you just love baseball.
-
The 2016/2017 rotation
Hadn't really thought about it that much but I think you are right. Given the pitching we have and what is on the horizon, next year doesn't look much better. Unless guys really improve things won't change that much. Hopefully we can trade some guys at the deadline someway somehow and get the younger players experience to move up the time frames but as things stand right now next year looks bleak to me as well.
-
Article: Minnesota Twins Day 2 Draft Picks (Rounds 3-10)
Happy to see the Twins going hard for hitters and going young. Should help set them up for a second wave. Low minors has been short on good hitters the past few years as they focused on pitching. Hard to say if these guys turn out but they did seem to get a little of everything. 5 tool guy, power guy, speed, the best prep catcher etc.
- Article: Seth's Midseason Top 40 Twins Prospects: Part 3 (1-10)
-
Royals Yordano Ventura
Yep so highly regarded that the team that knows him best is desperately trying to get rid of him.
-
Royals Yordano Ventura
I don't think the context you are comparing is the same. In Basketball yes elbows get thrown around a bit in blocking guys out for rebounds and protecting the ball but really that is part of the game. If players purposely kick or elbow players especially in the face they face a fine and suspensions and the potential to be kicked out of the game. If a player repeatedly does that I think they can be booted out of the league as well. Flopping in basketball can get you suspended and technical fouls can get you kicked out of a game and fined. Football is pretty violent so stopping everything is very difficult but bounty gate got some players banned and the coach a 1 year suspension. That is a tougher penalty than baseball has for throwing at guys. Hockey has a ways to go but they are suspending more and more players all the time. I think your unwritten rules in all sports are going to go away before too long. Replaced by actual rules that better protect the players who play the game.
-
Royals Yordano Ventura
But where does the policing end. Does Manny get to bring his baseball bat out and repeatedly pummel the pitcher with it? After all he is only protecting himself. Self policing just brings on escalation. How about just creating a policy where if the league feels a pitcher is throwing at guys they say sorry you are out of the league. Problem solved. There is no reason for self policing it is a bad idea and all sports are trying to root it out with suspensions and better rules for player safety. If self policing is such a grand idea then get rid of the umpires and let the players decide whats a ball or strike or who is safe or out? It's not a good idea that s why you have impartial judges and now instant replay to decide things. When players decide things it ends up in a fight so get rid of the players that cause it and it will go away. No need for self policing then. If you follow the rules of the game you don't need any self policing. Self policing is a lie to enable players to get away with physically hurting their opponents for hurting their feelings. If players do this they should be suspended and ultimately booted from the game. Then it will magically stop and the game will be better for it.
-
Royals Yordano Ventura
the game policing itself is a farce. It is illogical. It why all games have to have rules. Yes I am willing to call Joe Maddon an idiot if he really believes that.
-
Royals Yordano Ventura
The guy just doesn't seem to get it. He is going to get his teammates hurt if he keeps throwing at guys. I kind of thought he was done with this stuff after teams started throwing at KC players all the time. Also it paints your team as having a black hat or at least in a negative light. Hard for me as a fan to get behind someone who intentionally throws at guys on a frequent basis. Personally I wouldn't want him on my team. Someone will likely be desperate enough to trade for him though.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (6/7): Hurlbut Hurls Gem
Any news on why Chad was released?
-
Article: Seth's Midseason Twins Top 40 Prospect Rankings: Part 2 (11-20)
Nice to see Wade moving up the list. He was quite a find in the ninth round. I love Walker but the K's are a killer. I think I am on to rooting for Palka. He appears to be a bit more well rounded. Bummer about Thorpe. I have been anxiously awaiting his return. Was hoping he could get himself moved up to high A by the end of the year. With all the past arm problems does this mean Meyer is officially a bullpen arm?
-
Article: Twins Daily Draft Preview: The Board
I am hoping there is value at our slot for a High school pitcher. Given the way our pitching is stacking up I think that makes the most sense at least long term. I also wouldn't mind a high school bat there but not sure the value will be there either. It seems like the value will be college pitchers where we pick but who knows how the draft will go. I am OK with a college pitcher there but we could have quite a glut of starters in High A and AA next year. Not a horrible situation but not ideal either. Not in love with a lot of hitters for pick 15, but would like to use second round picks on hitters if value is there as our system is in need of better hitting at most all positions except maybe SS.
-
The rotation that Ryan built.
My larger point is every team makes FA mistakes. You made a blanket statement of worst I doubt that assumption. If playoffs and World Series are your measure then maybe the Brewers would be the worst.
-
The rotation that Ryan built.
yeah I felt pretty much the same way. I could not have been more wrong about Nolasco but he seemed like a safe deal at the time and considering the crappy pitching we had at the time an upgrade to boot. Things just went horribly wrong there somehow. I was applauding the move so I can't take it back and say the Twins never should have done it. It seemed like a solid move at the time. I wasn't uber high on Hughes but it seemed like a safe bet for the money and years involved. I didn't want Santana either. Would have rather had the draft pick and gone with the young guys but I did get the crowd that said you can never have too much pitching and someone almost always goes down every season so I was OK with it. Just saw the future and wanted to see the young guys. I also like the idea of going big with signing an ace type instead of mid tier pitchers but was also worried if that one signing didn't work out well that it would sink payroll wise. If you look at it TR has not done a great job and this rebuild looks to be getting longer all the time. The young guys are the only ones who can bring this team up. Hopefully they figure things out sooner rather than later.
-
The rotation that Ryan built.
I think that is a pretty large exaggeration there. I mean the Yankees are in terrible shape because of large free agent acquisitions and long term contracts. The Angels have made terrible mistakes in FA and Boston had to have LA save them from themselves. So I think Worst is a bit over the top. Maybe lets go with one of the worst.
-
The rotation that Ryan built.
If I remember correctly many on this board argued that you can never have enough pitching, that you need to take risks in FA and or supplement your team via FA to make the team competitive. That there was no reason not to spend the money on FA's to try and field a competitive team. It looks like TR took some chances in FA and unfortunately failed miserably. It happens to a lot of teams.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (5/22): Good Pitching and Extras
I am sure you are right but have the Twins ever had a pitcher with a K9 rate that Chargois has? I don't know how much more Chargois can do to get his shot and I don't know how much more desperate the Twins can get for help in the pen. Considering all the other crazy moves they have made why not Chargois? I guess after the draft we will start to see changes as short season ball starts and they make room for more players.