Everything posted by Steve Lein
-
Berardino: Twins close to extension with Dozier
Trout's just a name that demonstrates the type of player I'd do it for, not that I'm comparing Dozier to Trout. As I said, that type of player is a young superstar. If Dozier we're 24 or 25, I'd be much more inclined to do this, as you'd be getting a bunch of his "prime years" with such an extension. He's already in those seasons, so I'm far less inclined to believe he's still got anything left to improve, and there's the increased risk because of his age. Like I said, great player to have on your team and I don't want him going anywhere, it just seems premature and unnecessary to me.
-
Berardino: Twins close to extension with Dozier
In general I'm not a fan of signing a guy before he's had an arbitration year already, unless he's done something like Mike Trout. Meaning, the player is a superstar, and young. Dozier is neither. He just isn't the type of guy I'd try to buy out of arbitration at this point. He's not going to be super expensive in arbitration yet anyway, and the more data you can collect before an extension gives you a better foundation for what the $$ should be. Like I said, I think we're seeing what his peak is going to be like already, which is pretty good. But a new contract now to me would also pay him with expectations of continued improvement, meaning more $$ for something I'm not so sure we're going to see. If it's a Span like-value of a deal though, I'm all for it. I just don't think that's the type of deal he's going to get handed.
-
Berardino: Twins close to extension with Dozier
An extension for Dozier this year seems a year too early for me. He hasn't even had an arbitration season yet (at age 28!), and I don't like doing that for guys like Dozier. Great piece on your team, but he's not a superstar. I'm also guessing we're seeing the best of what we're going to from him, hopefully for a bunch more years yet, but contracts being handed out based on one season of that are never a good idea.
-
Article: Where Will Miguel Sano Play?
Plouffe in the OF ala Cuddyer seems like the 2nd best course to me with all these guys. The first being, you trade somebody. Which sucks because I like all those guys and want them to make up the team of the future. So the weakest link among them by the time that team comes together will have to be gone to make it work, and that link might not even be 'weak'. But if we're talking 2016-2018 for that team, that link is just as likely to be Joe Mauer at that point as any of these young guys.
-
Mauer: Buy or Sell?
I've shown this data several times here before. The most common RISP situation is a runner on 2B. It's much harder for a single to get those guys in then you think. Should they score most of the time? Maybe. I'd like to see that percentage. But I do know he gets a lot of line drive and grounder singles, and to the left side of the field (e.g.: in front of such runners). A line drive gets to the OF-er faster. A ground ball can require a runner to make sure it's getting through before taking off. Then the fact he draws a lot of walks in those situations. These are all contributing factors to this. But like I mentioned before, if the team around him is better, Mauer's game is elevated. This would be a reason I'm "buying" on him this year, because I'm "buying" on a lot of the other guys.
-
Mauer: Buy or Sell?
This is a big point of contention on him for me, actually. The Twins need Mauer to be more of a "run producer" (drive guys in) and not a "run creator" (get on base). Despite his great slash lines, Mauer (outside of his MVP year) has never been even average at "producing runs" (things like hitting with RISP, RBI's, etc...). He has a great line in RISP situations, but those lines come with a ton of singles to CF/LF and walks, which do not bring in runs. But, this is also a direct result of: The type of player Mauer is, relies a ton on the other hitters in the lineup, and you hit the nail on the head. No Cuddyer. No Morneau. No Span. No Revere. Those are the types of guys that bring out the best in Joe, so hopefully this is a year guys like Santana, Vargas, and Arcia start producing like those before them, and bring Joe along for the ride.
-
Article: Push Candidate: Brian Navarreto
I'd keep him in Elizabethton I think. I'm quite certain he was drafted more for his offensive potential than his defense, though he gets great marks for his arm strength. Pretty sure Pinto was excellent at throwing out runners back then too, and look how that has worked out. But if it's his offensive ability that could be his calling card, I wouldn't push him to Cedar Rapids to start because he hasn't shown anything with his bat yet.
-
Zulgad: Arcia's Transition to Left Field
This is why I was more comfortable in LF. Balls going to the gaps in RF were harder for me to track since my glove would be reaching across my body. More balls are hit toward gaps than they are the line (in the > 2/3 of the outfield is in that direction as opposed to toward the lines sense). I did like fielding grounders or liners toward the line in RF though as this made it easy to plant, spin, and quickly put extra oomph on a throw to second. Caught many guys at 2B trying to get a double by doing that. I also have bad memories about chasing balls down moving to my right, because that's how I tore my ACL! But I did catch the ball on that play!
-
Zulgad: Arcia's Transition to Left Field
haha, yup!
-
Zulgad: Arcia's Transition to Left Field
I tend to agree with this too. Frankly, I think he has issues tracking balls to his right (non-glove hand), which will pretty much be eliminated in left field.
-
Alex Meyer Focusing On Changeup
Don't think your "Velocity is much greater link" is right, brings you back to this thread. I'd be curious to read what you intended to link, though!
-
Alex Meyer Focusing On Changeup
I thought the same thing about that line. But probably isn't much behind it. New voices and new philosophies can be good, is likely all he means.
-
Alex Meyer Focusing On Changeup
Rhett Bollinger posted a new article discussing Alex Meyer yesterday: http://m.twins.mlb.com/news/article/110273640/minnesota-twins-prospect-alex-meyer-developing-changeup-this-spring It's brief, but discusses how he wants to continue to develop his changeup to have a 3rd weapon.
-
BA Top 100 (5 Twins, no Stewart)
I understand the first part, but don't think the second part is what the Twins are doing. To reiterate again: They wanted him to work on fastball command as a raw, highly talented, high-school pitcher.
-
BA Top 100 (5 Twins, no Stewart)
We may just have a different idea of what "unpolished" means. Mine is he hadn't pitched nearly as much as a lot of other high High school draft picks as pitchers, therefore he's behind the curve in development and polish as a pitcher (mechanics, command, track record, actual amount of pitching he has done). This has zero little initial relation to the quality of the pitches he can throw (velocity, movement). Fastball command is absolutely the #1 thing a pitcher needs to have. Nothing else they can do will offset an inability to throw a fastball for strikes. Therefore, they wanted him to further develop that ability -> throwing strikes with his fastball. The next thing to come, will be using that slider to put away hitters. And yes, he'll have to develop and polish that pitch just the same, but focusing on one thing at a time isn't a bad plan to me. I don't think he turned pro and all of the sudden lost the ability to throw a pitch that every evaluator loved leading up to that draft.
-
Berardino on Twins Minor leaguers
Good to hear the update on Thorpe. Getting more optimistic the arm issue won't be serious!
-
BA Top 100 (5 Twins, no Stewart)
Another Twins prospect came up in the chat: "Greg T. (Lake Central): Who, not on this list, has a chance to make the biggest jump onto the 2016 list? Ben Badler: Jorge Polanco has the skill set that tends to get overlooked, so I'm not sure if he's going to jump high next year, but I'm definitely higher on him than most. Marcos Molina, Forrest Wall, Ozhaino Albies, Brett Phillips, Nick Williams, Jorge Mateo and Gleyber Torres are all names to watch for next year." Good to see Polanco get some love. Agree he kind of goes a bit unnoticed, even around here!
-
BA Top 100 (5 Twins, no Stewart)
Had a question about the Top 100 discussed earlier here and answered in their chat: "Steve L. (Minneapolis,MN): I notice Kohl Stewart is ranked ahead of NIck Gordon and Alex Meyer on your Twins Top 10, but is missing from the Top 100. I know opinions can change, but question the consistency?! John Manuel: Consistency can be a great thing in a player; I argue for flexibility with prospect rankings. And if you check the BA grades for those players in the Prospect Handbook, they are very similar. Stewart and Gordon are both 60 Highs and Meyer is a 55 Medium. Those are really on the same level. So one being 4 and one 6, we don't do ties in the book, but they have the same grades. Gordon being a middle of the diamond position player is less risky, for me, than Stewart. Meyer has similar stuff and has done it in Triple-A. Stewart was in that 101-110 range, almost made it, but he carries a lot of risk, and that 6.4 K per 9 rate last year is a red flag for me. I want to see a supposed raw stuff guy do a bit more than that." He makes this omission sound worse with this answer, if you ask me (see bolded comments). Higher grades for Stewart, but misses the list. Calls the K-rate a red flag because of "raw stuff" while not failing to acknowledging or realize he wasn't using all of it to it's full potential.
-
BA Top 100 (5 Twins, no Stewart)
I disagree with this thought process for reasons already stated. I think they know already the slider is a good pitch, but being that he is relatively unpolished for a high-school pitcher due to playing (and excelling at) another sport, he had other things they wanted him to work on and develop first -> fastball command. Along the same thought process, you can (potentially) keep him healthy longer by not using a so called "stressful" pitch too much early in his career.
-
Article: TD Top Prospects: #1 Byron Buxton
I wan't him to be (and think he will be) the next "20-20-20-20" guy (2B's, 3B's, HR's, SB's). There's only been 4 players in the history of major league baseball to accomplish that.
-
Article: TD Top Prospects: #1 Byron Buxton
Haha, we always played this game in warm-ups. "Two-ball" we called it. You'd switch your hat to backwards the first drop, lose the hat the second, then were "out" on the third drop. I sucked at that game, haha, but it was fun and definitely challenged your hand-eye coordination.
-
Fangraphs article comparing George Springer to Oswaldo Arcia
Arcia was an OBP machine in the winter leagues this year (19 BB's in 31 VWL games), as he made a conscious effort to work on it (which has also been discussed here on TD). I think he'll be a key offensive cog for the Twins this year, and he'd probably by my guy to bat 3rd in this lineup if he's going good.
-
BA Top 100 (5 Twins, no Stewart)
He didn't show anything?! A 2.59 ERA and 1.14 WHIP while using his best out pitch sparingly?! That tells me nobody was squaring him up... And frankly, I think he was better (by a good amount) than Berrios was in the MWL at the same age... He definitely wasn't using it much. I know Seth wrote an article where Stewart himself said he didn't throw a single one in the game discussed. The idea, from what I've gathered, was because he was a HS draftee who didn't focus full time on baseball until being drafted. All the potential is there, but the best way to get him to reach that potential was focusing on the most important aspect of pitching, which is locating the fastball, as he hadn't actually spent a ton of time pitching to develop this based on his multi-sport background. All the reports and profiles leading up to the draft praised the slider as his best strike-out pitch, and a swing-and-miss one at that (plus). I would think it's quite logical (and obvious) that he wouldn't rack up as many K's as expected if he was throwing 5 or less of them per game, or none at all.
-
Article: TD Top Prospects: #3 Jose Berrios
You can read all kinds of opinions on how #1, #2, #3, #4, and #5 starters are defined (Kiley talks about this on fangraphs) But typically, I think you can say there are maybe 10 true "Aces" per season (this is greater than a #1). If you go by Kiley's scale, this would be guys with a >6.0 WAR. There were 6 such starters last season. There's probably a few more #1's than that, but not by much. If we classify them as >4 WAR, you come up with 9 pitchers in that range last year. Then you can probably double that total number of "aces and #1's" for #2's and #3's, which gives us about 30 names. Again, Kiley's scale classifies these as >2.5 WAR, and this gives 31 pitchers from last season. Then you have a boatload of #4's and #5's. The "league average" pitcher is what I'd typically describe as a #4 pitcher, or as an example from the Twins last year, Kyle Gibson (though he actually qualifies for a #3 in the exercise above, with exactly 2.5 WAR).
-
Article: TD Top Prospects: #3 Jose Berrios
I wouldn't put him above Stewart or Meyer yet either. Especially based solely on his age in comparison, which is what I think is being done here. But you can't deny what he did last year, at least in the FSL - he absolutely dominated it. But he was quite ordinary after being promoted if you ask me. If he makes the same adjustment to AA early this season as he did going into the FSL though, it'd be very hard to argue. And I also think it's a mistake to doubt him at this point. Just a bit premature on moving him ahead of Meyer (based on stuff) and Stewart (based on potential) for me.