Everything posted by TheLeviathan
- Berríos or Buxton: Who is Worth a $100 Million Deal?
-
Byron Buxton's Body Has Betrayed Him Yet Again. It Sucks And It's No One's Fault.
You are literally agreeing with the original post but continuing to claim you disagree with it. It's nonsensical. At best you devolved to pure semantics about the words ability and trait which is fallacious and unfair.
-
Byron Buxton's Body Has Betrayed Him Yet Again. It Sucks And It's No One's Fault.
It came up because it seemed odd as a sarcastic dig at a post that agrees with you. I think the problem came when you bristled at a completely innocuous post, not with your overall point. You found (or implied at the very least) disagreement where there really was none. I think we all share lament that the young man can't play and there isn't much he can do about it.
-
Byron Buxton's Body Has Betrayed Him Yet Again. It Sucks And It's No One's Fault.
Durability is a natural athletic ability and the extent to which it can be improved is limited. Nelson Cruz, Max Kepler, and pretty much every other human on the planet has no chance of improving their speed to the degree that Buxton possesses. Minor improvements? Sure. But they can't transform into something they're not. Likewise, there is nothing Buxton can do about his natural durability and resistance to injury. It's simply not a gift he was blessed with. It's not a "skill" like hitting or throwing a curveball, it's more like how fast you run or how tall you grew. At this point I'm not even sure what you're trying to say. I'll leave it at this: The original poster just lamented that for all of Buck's talents, he wasn't blessed with the ability to stay on the field and there's nothing he can do about that. And it sucks for all of us, but especially his career. Whatever "weird" road you took us down from there is due to your interpretations of that rather simple, and IMO undeniable, observation.
-
Is it time to eject pitchers for HBP?
It's definitely not a rights violation because this kind of enforcement and oversight is a power given to the league, in negotiations, with the player's association. They've already consented to enforcement and inspection, if necessary.
-
Is it time to eject pitchers for HBP?
Well with a sound counter-argument like that, including insults, how could I possibly disagree? Strange to visit message boards and then be completely uninterested in discussions.
-
Is it time to eject pitchers for HBP?
If almost all their customers are stealing......yes they should. Especially if they know their department managers as actually facilitating the shoplifting by giving them tricks for how to avoid being caught. Yeah, baseball was lazy and stupid in the past. They deserve condemnation, but now the behavior has to stop. The only way to know guilt, because of how slick these guys have become at this, is to do a quick inspection. Just like taking drug tests or anything else that maintains fair play. If you wait until you can somehow prove guilt all you really do is encourage more slick cheating. Consistent enforcement and observation is the best way to stem the tide.
-
Is it time to eject pitchers for HBP?
If pitchers don't want to be hassled they should have been complying with the rules for the last few years. Instead they brazenly spit all over them and now find it appropriate to whine that the league is enforcing fair play. I don't get the manager challenges, just check every half inning when nothing is going on anyway. No one is harmed by that unless they're cheating. What's not good for the game is consistently turning a blind eye to blatant cheating... Especially when that cheating is having a demonstrably negative effect on the game between the lines.
-
Byron Buxton's Body Has Betrayed Him Yet Again. It Sucks And It's No One's Fault.
You quoted something but then interpreted it in a really strange way.....Let's try a simple analogy by using the same phrase you think is so dastardly and then subbing a few words: If I say "Kepler doesn't have the same ability to run the bases as Buxton"....have I somehow created an "onus for Kepler to cultivate that"? I would think not. It's just an acknowledgement of natural ability and natural abilities vary from player to player. Can Kepler work around the edges of his speed or baserunning to make modest improvements? Sure. I feel like Buxton did that by adding some muscle in fact. But at the end of the day, just like speed and power, durability is something I'm not sure you can fix. And some players, again just like speed and power, either have it or they don't. You seem to acknowledge what the poster said, but then twisted it for some reason I can't understand. Nowhere in that post does it blame Buxton for anything, that's something you read into it. (Unfairly, IMO, given how easily your example can be exposed by analogy) Yes, it's not in his control, but there is no reason not to acknowledge it either. The guy has been a pro for almost a decade now and this is what it is. His body just doesn't allow all that talent to stay on the field. It sucks. I feel bad for him most of all.
-
Byron Buxton's Body Has Betrayed Him Yet Again. It Sucks And It's No One's Fault.
I think Byron Buxton is actively losing money not being on the field. This argument doesn't wash because, especially in baseball and now more than ever, teams are hesitant to dole out money to players they can't count on in the field. I think this post implies Buxton isn't "tough" which is different than acknowledging he isn't "durable" or "available". Make no mistake, every IL stint he has potentially costs him MILLIONS.
-
Byron Buxton's Body Has Betrayed Him Yet Again. It Sucks And It's No One's Fault.
I really think you read something in that wasn't there. It is a criticism of just, for whatever each individual reason, Buxton cant be available. It isn't to blame Buxton but acknowledge the reality. We should all be at that point with Donaldson too.
-
Byron Buxton's Body Has Betrayed Him Yet Again. It Sucks And It's No One's Fault.
No and that's a fallacious argument. The poster you responded to clearly said that injuries have a large component of luck to them. I will make no argument that Buxton's hand injury was some really terrible luck. But the point of that post was to put this unlucky break in the context of what seems like an endless array of "unlucky" breaks. At some point constantly falling victim to injuries of all sorts stops being a pattern we can deny based on luck and one we simply have to recognize isn't going away. Not all athletes can match their amazing skillset with durability. It sucks, he's a great person and a great player, but at some point we have to come to terms with the reality of his ability to stay on a baseball field.
-
Is it time to eject pitchers for HBP?
I would prefer the first option without the second half of it. I'd leave it as of now, but a continuing trend endangers players and at that point something has to be done. You can't allow your product to be harmed because pitchers are indifferent to how many people they hit. I feel like we need a megathread - Baseball: All the Ways It's Bleeding to Death. (hemorrhaging may be better....)
-
NCAA is Criminal Megathread
Is there a way to gamble on court cases? Cuz I'm taking basically anyone versus the NCAA based on this decision.
- Here we go again.....
-
Max Kepler, Utility Outfielder?
Because you mitigate some of that risk, or loss of value, with more team control. It's no worry anyway, he couldn't even stay healthy until June 30th much less the deadline.
-
Max Kepler, Utility Outfielder?
Sounds like Buxton is all about sentiment for you, I'm just over it, it's time to move on. But that's where I'm at. I think the value you have to throw in for Donaldson depends on a contender who needs a 3B. Maybe that same perception of need will exist in December, but then you're competing with free agency. I don't want to hand either of these guys away for nothing though.
-
Max Kepler, Utility Outfielder?
Well, I never suggested dumping them. I expressed hope that we'd have found deals and moved on by Aug 1. For three of those guys value might just be a lottery ticket and I'd be cool with that.
-
Max Kepler, Utility Outfielder?
I would suggest the reason to move on Donaldson and Buxton now, if it's even possible now, is that they're on the field and have value to a contender. I'm generally in agreement that the offseason is a better time to make a trade, these guys have some serious durability issues that narrow the window of value. Plus, in Buxton's case, team control narrows the longer you wait. I'm not moving these guys because we have to see Arraez at 3B as much as just moving on from what it makes sense to move on from.
-
Max Kepler, Utility Outfielder?
Ok, I can understand the hesitancy that it will happen. What about whether or not it should happen?
-
Max Kepler, Utility Outfielder?
How does hanging on to Cruz, Simmons, Pineda, Donaldson, and Buxton do anything for the team? Three of them aren't coming back and the other two are rarely on the field. You're chasing windmills standing pat.
-
Max Kepler, Utility Outfielder?
I'm good with that, I was just making a prediction based on the organization's patterns combined with who I'd like to see jettisoned for something, or anything, of value.
-
Max Kepler, Utility Outfielder?
I don't share your concern with whether we win 70 games vs. 72.
-
Max Kepler, Utility Outfielder?
Who plays SS? I get the sense the organization doesn't believe in Gordon there.
-
Max Kepler, Utility Outfielder?
Catcher would be a position I'd be ok with a rotation of guys. I'd love Garver to have a lot of ABs too, but there doesn't seem to be a time-table on that poor guy. Plus the Twins seem to be a 60/40 or 70/30 split as is so we have options there too. I'm not opposed to sending someone down that is being beaten over the head by major league talent if that were to happen over the last two months.