Everything posted by TheLeviathan
-
FO's tentativeness is killing the team
Honestly curious....are we linked to ANYONE right now?
-
Reusse's Turkey of the Year includes some Twins candidates
He's not wrong about the risks/problems with Buxton.
-
Your Top MLB Rule Change
Universal DH. There's no good argument against it beyond sentiment.
-
Debate No. 3: Building a strong lineup vs. building a strong pitching staff. Which is more important? (Debate concluded/thread open)
This paragraph feels like 2 + 2 = banana. At the end of the day no amount of great pitching can save a flailing lineup. That was the point.
-
Debate No. 3: Building a strong lineup vs. building a strong pitching staff. Which is more important? (Debate concluded/thread open)
I think the hitting side won this debate in the first post and from there it was an informative, even matchup. I say that because, at the end of the day, team building needs to be about predictability and reliability and it's evident hitting is the better bet from that end. Even in these comments there are a lot of false, preconceived notions about the "requirement" of ace pitching or top end starters. As @chpettit19rightly points out....the role of an 8 inning starter who chews up playoff games for you is basically extinct. It's been replaced with flexible 6-8 man groupings that do well enough for long enough that the lineup you field wins it for you. The Brewers, as @Vanimal46rightly points out, are the clear example: badass starters who put up cartoonish numbers can't save you when your team has an OPS that Andrelton Simmons would be ashamed of.
-
A case against signing the top free agents
I'm going to be succinct: Your entire claptrap (and given how often we all have to endure it, I'm sticking with that description) can be boiled down to one fact-free assertion that is not justified: that one must have the other pieces "before" the big FA. There is no fact about that. It is undoubtedly true, and no one has asserted otherwise, that teams need to have homegrown and traded-for talent to go with any FAs they have acquired. The sequencing of how that happens is in no way whatsoever consequential. If the FA comes a year before the homegrown talent....you still wound up with both, just like if you reversed them. FA/Trade/Develop....what matters is that you've utilized all three to compose your team. Not that you HAVE to develop and THEN sign. That is not supported by any facts no matter how many times you try to bloviate it into existence. Now it's time for the Twins to spend some of that 130M swell of revenue they've been Scrooging for a decade and go add some talent to their coming wave of homegrown ones.
-
Defense at shortstop
I think prioritizing defense at shortstop makes sense. However, they have to be able to hit their way out of a paper bag if you're going to pay them, say, 10M a year.
-
Report: Rays, Wander Franco agree on 12-year extension
We've had some great hits in the past, but it's such a great route to bring in big time talents.
-
FO's tentativeness is killing the team
Worried? No? Increasingly bored and disenchanted? Yes. I think the latter is way, way worse from the Twins' perspective.
-
Report: Rays, Wander Franco agree on 12-year extension
Wow, that deal is fascinating. There is a chance the Rays regret it, but there's a damn good chance they are cackling as they write his paychecks for the next decade.
-
A case against signing the top free agents
I'll repeat: The Twins are making a 130M more in revenue than they were a decade ago and are only spending about 70M more than they were a decade ago. Mid-market successes like St. Louis traded for Goldschmidt and Arrenado, ChiSox added Grandal, Lynn, Hendricks, Kuechel, Kimbrel over a span of years, Padres are a 'Nuff Said. Waiting for the stars to align is folly.
-
A case against signing the top free agents
The right guys signed to 5 year deals should provide help to several potential windows of contention. That's the beauty of it....sign Corey Seager or Robbie Ray and they should be a factor for several potential runs. Signing stop gaps only ensures they never help your future. That's what a stop gap is.
-
A case against signing the top free agents
Why does spending in FA equate to team building in FA? Free Agency is for supplementing. And you can supplement at high price tags. And....you can supplement your future teams that may be only 1 or 2 players away a year or two in advance. I believe this team has a bonafide group of young pitchers. I think in two years that Miranda, Martin, and Lewis are players for this team. If so.....I want to add now to have those supports in place for them. Signing Seager or Ray or any other top FA doesn't mean you wipe your hands clean and pat yourself on the back for a job well done or mission accomplished. But it means you are one more good player closer to where you want to be in the future. And you have one less offseason where all your "I need to add one or two players now!" eggs are not in the same basket. It's not like St. Louis waited for Arrenado and Goldschmidt to be simultaneously available. They added periodically. Ditto the White Sox. Waiting for the perfect moment is folly.
-
A case against signing the top free agents
This is your schtick. It's not fun: http://www.stevetheump.com/Payrolls.htm#2010payroll https://www.statista.com/statistics/196669/revenue-of-the-minnesota-twins-since-2006/ I see basically no non-pandemic drops in the last 20 years. Additionally, revenue jumped by 50M in 2010 and by 130M from 2009 to 2019. Pray tell....did the payroll jump by 130M? (That seems hard to do given the current payroll is struggling to be 130M total) Go ahead and look at what the payroll has done since 2009. Hint: It hasn't gone up by 130M. So get off the excuse making. This team has plenty of revenue to increase their spending significantly. (Best part? I am not actually calling for an increase! Just previously established high points!)
-
2021 Vikings Season Thread
Fair, I think we could've taken more time than that and still scored the TD, but point taken. Also....given Zimmer's clock management, I wasn't 100% sure we were going to successfully drain all the time.
-
A case against signing the top free agents
And when revenues have gone up the purse strings still stay tight. So using that excuse doesn't fly for me.
-
A case against signing the top free agents
Whatever 40-50M buys you.
-
A case against signing the top free agents
Since that is always what spending in FA entails, I don't see why that distinction is relevant. The team has virtually nothing on the long-term books.
-
A case against signing the top free agents
And I stated there is no such case to be made. The team has ample budget room relative to past budgets they have authorized. This free agent class is ripe with players that would dramatically help this team and address organizational weaknesses. If the Twins are unable to sign a player the number one reason is unwillingness to sign that player to a term or contract value that exceeds their competitors. Whether that is ownership's fault or not I don't care, but there is simply no reason this team can't spend 40-50M this offseason. None.
-
A case against signing the top free agents
If they start cutting payroll they are pocketing fan money. I don't care how long the deals are, the amount of money they are taking in from fans isn't going to radically decrease. I'm not sure what your goal is here unless your last name is Pohlad or you're on the payroll. Seriously, this line of questioning doesn't make any sense. As fans who contribute to the team we are absolutely entitled to expect them to spend money on the product. It's literally the least they can do.
-
A case against signing the top free agents
Well....at least those of us that want them to actually, you know, use it.
-
A case against signing the top free agents
Only if I'm looking to make excuses. And I'm not. They can spend. Sometimes you invest to turn your product around, not wait for it to magically happen.
-
A case against signing the top free agents
Actually, it's our money that we choose to give to them. Plus the stadium they profit off of that we paid for. And, best of all, I'm only holding them to the spending amounts they have authorized in the past. Not even an increase. If they won't spend their fan's money to improve their product....they don't deserve fans.
-
A case against signing the top free agents
There is absolutely no reason they can't give out 40M in allocations for next year. Personally, I think it's more like 50.
-
2021 Vikings Season Thread
True...but that was too close. Joseph needs it on the other hash, his kicks drift to his right.