Everything posted by kab21
-
Extra Money/Less or Lower Prospects for Price?
This is a fantasy trade (as in not a chance of happening). There is no way the Twins can pull this off w/o including one of Buxton or Sano and there isn't any indication that Price is signing a long extension (that I have read). Perhaps a team like Texas pulls it off but I'm guessing that Price reaches FA next year. I would hope that the Twins would open the vault for him but even that's pretty unlikely.
-
How to get Tanaka, wouldja?...
There's no way I would pay 150-200M for Tanaka. Even if it was a 7 year contract we are talking about 21.5-28.5M/yr. that's silly money for a non-ace (upside) that has never thrown an MLB pitch.
-
Berardino: Herrmann, Pinto struggling in Winter Ball
I'm comfortable with someone other than Mauer. I like Pinto's potential but I don't like him as plan A when plan B is Herrmann and plan C is awful.
-
Berardino: Herrmann, Pinto struggling in Winter Ball
I am not comfortable with Pinto/Herrmann as the Twins catching duo and that has not changed based on these winter league stats.
-
Hypothetical: Would you have traded Joe Mauer for Fielder or Kinsler?
If the Twins were a 85 win team that was looking to contend I would love to get a guy like Prince. Comparisons to his father are silly. They were both big but that's about where the comparison stops. Prince is a responsible adult while his father never made it out his teens mentally. I think Prince is going to have 5 really good years (better than last year) followed by a couple of average or worse ones to finish the contract. Overall he will earn his contract and I wouldn't have a problem paying it (with the Pohlad's money). But I wouldn't trade Mauer for Fielder in the Twins current situation or in the hypothetical one. I wouldn't even consider making the trade for Kinsler. That is justifiable only for financial reasons and the Twins have plenty of free money to spend.
-
Berardino: Capuano, Floyd, Arroyo are targets
And to think people were REALLY UPSET that Correia got 2/10 last year. I think Arroyo is a find pitcher to have on the team but 3/36 is just silly. If they are spending that much money then I hope they spend twice as much and get a better and younger player. Unfortunately I think they are only going to target guys to survive the next couple of years.
-
Pirates Reacquire Duke Welker from Twins
I can't believe there are 5 pages on this completely non-interesting transaction. Neither of these guys are interesting and would just be 40 man roster hanger-onners.
-
Prince Fielder traded for Kinsler!!!!
Kind of a good trade for both teams although it's brilliant for the Rangers. They needed to open up a spot for Profar and they needed a big slugger. They do pick up 8 more expensive years of Fielder though. That won't end well. The Tigers needed to get MCab back to 1B and they needed a MI'er. Kinsler is on the decline but he's good and he's only owed 4/60. It will be interesting to see if the Tigers use this money to pick up another slugger.
-
Baseball Prospectus Goes Twins Crazy!
I like Vargas bat best but he has zero defensive value so it has to be better. He is old for his level but he also has very little pro ball experience. Despite being 23 almost half of his MiLB experience came last year. His future in the MLB is becoming a .275/.350/.475/.825 DH for the Twins. And there's a lot more downside to that projection than upside. Walker is the best athlete but he is going to have to be more selective as he moves up because better pitchers won't give him good pitches to hit. Harrison is the opposite in some ways to Walker. Despite having a sweet swing he hasn't dazzled statistically. He walks a lot but also K's a lot. He's hit some bombs but only has a so-so .160 isoP so far. His offense is going to need to carry him because very few think he will stick at 3B. D.J. Hicks seemingly has no buzz and is even older than Vargas and is a step behind him on the depth chart. Hicks differs from Vargas since he played college ball and his significantly more baseball experience. His stats are similar to the rest but he seems to be org depth similar to Brock Peterson, Erik Lis and Garrett Jones from 5 yrs ago. One of those did become a solid role player though. I think Vargas is the best bet to be an MLB startable player (at DH). Walker and Harrison have higher ceilings but neither is likely to make the majors. The good news is that the Twins have several of these guys and combined one is likely to make it. Kepler kind of matches up with Harrison. He's a solid prospect that hasn't flopped but his raw skills haven't translated to his statline.
-
Josh Johnson to the Padres
The most obvious benefit - not having to watch a team getting mauled in 2014. The 2nd most obvious - pitching well enough that he's a lock to turn down a qualifying offer
-
Josh Johnson to the Padres
Excellent move by the Padres and something the Twins should have been in on. Of course the same could have been said about Marcum last year. The odd provision was also included in Lackey's (longer) contract. It gives the team some value if he's injured the entire time. It's possible that JJ's arm is pretty iffy right now.
-
Nolasco, Garza or Arroya?
Excellent comp but he only managed a couple of season with <4.00 ERA after a nice run with the Expos. Not something I would want to throw a lot of money at despite his awesome season with the braves.
-
Baseball Prospectus Goes Twins Crazy!
It's frustrating that you fixate only on the K's. The issue is that he doesn't walk also. Out of your examples only Chris Davis had similar K and BB rates throughout his MiLB career. Walker posted similar rates for his season in the midwest league and then he became a walking machine after that. And nobody is writing him off. He's a unique blend of physical tools and raw hitting skill. The big problem is that low of a walk rate (with the K's) is that he is not looking for his pitch and swinging at tough pitches out of the K zone. This wasn't an issue in low A but that was due to him just flat out being more skilled than the low A pitchers. This won't be true as he moves up in the minors and it definitely won't be true in the majors. And yes it is a big reason for concern.
-
Article: Twins prospect Eddie Rosario tested positive for banned substance?
He's a good prospect but what has he done to deserve a promotion after a 1/2 season in AA? I have posted longer responses in other threads about Rosario but you seem to ignore them.
-
Nolasco, Garza or Arroya?
5/75 for a guy that typically puts up 4.50 ERA's? that's an overpay regardless of the team.
-
Baseball Prospectus Goes Twins Crazy!
115 K's and 31 BB's is a pretty big reason for a concern.
-
Fangraphs on Arcia's Power Potential
xBAPIP obviously doesn't use batted ball speed but it's a lot more complex than you make it out to be. It also has a couple of components that try to incorporate power into the equation. Arcia has a special hit tool but he has some stuff to work on.
-
Baseball Prospectus Goes Twins Crazy!
For years people have complained about the system being too far away and now top heavy is an issue? And this is still how systems work. If there were can't miss guys in the minors combined with Sano, buxton, Meyer and Rosario then this would be one of the most ridiculous systems ever. And I would still consider a bottom portion consisting of Stewart, pick #5, Thorpe, Berrios, Polanco, Kepler, Harrison and Gonsalves (among others) to be really good.
-
Baseball Prospectus Goes Twins Crazy!
Good grief. I think your argument could be made about any system that will graduate two top 10 prospects and two top 50 prospects right after graduating 3 top 50 prospects (Hicks/Arcia/Gibson). The great thing is that there is still some nice talent in the system despite up to 7 young players being up with the Twins for good by opening day 2015. I completely disagree with thrylos's analysis of Kepler. Vargas (I like) and Hicks (I don't) are completely limited to DH and Walker has big plate discipline issues. Harrison and kepler are kind of comparable but I wouldn't say that Harrison is better (unless he sticks at 3B). Kepler's poor season was almost entirely BAPIP driven. He showed great plate discipline and pretty good power. These are things that I look at in prospects and Kepler has them.
-
Nolasco, Garza or Arroya?
Nolasco is a terrible investment. He just hasn't been very good for a long time. Do you think he had one lucky season or 4 unlucky seasons. Arroyo has continuously outproduced him and is likely the top target for the Twins because of fewer years.
-
Baseball Prospectus Goes Twins Crazy!
This isn't really accurate. RP'ers eliminate their worst pitch from their arsenal and just concentrate on 2 pitches. They also only see hitters once in a game and only a couple times per season. So a pitcher with control problems can seemingly be fixed with a move to the bullpen.
-
Jim Callis: Buxton's Batting Titles & who's on Second - Dozier/Rosario/Polanco
I'm not sure how you assess plate discipline but his K rate went from 16% (2012) and 12% (Ft Myers) to 21% (AA). He has never walked a lot but his BB rate has stayed about the same. Perhaps plate discipline isn't really the right term since we don't know if he was expanding the strike zone (bad plate discipline) or if he was swinging through strikes (overmatched) but he certainly hasn't earned a promotion to AAA nor will he be rushed to the majors this season like some think.
-
Neal: AJ, Hawkins, Trade, Polanco
The Twins had a lot of nice seasons in the bullpen but I'm skeptical of several of these arms. It's not the most glaring weakness but things could turn ugly in the bullpen next year.
-
Jim Callis: Buxton's Batting Titles & who's on Second - Dozier/Rosario/Polanco
I think people have gotten way ahead of themselves with Rosario. He did alright in AA but he didn't dominate and he isn't an elite talent like Buxton/Sano. I would be very surprised if he only spent 90 games in low A (2012), 50 games in high A and 70 games in AA before moving up to AAA. His plate discipline also nosedived in AA. I think he spends most of the year in the minors giving the Twins another year before a Dozier/Rosario issue is an issue.
-
LHP Pedro Hernandez signed with the Rockies
This is sugarcoating it. Liriano had been terrible for 1.5 yrs before putting together a solid 1.5 month stretch. And then he was terrible again after the trade. Waiting an extra start wasn't going to bring in a better offer.