Everything posted by kab21
-
Trade rumors
I think they would trade Cingrani but certainly not for guys like willy and Suzuki. suzuki might get a prospect in the Adam Walker (optimistic end), Travis Harrison or Goodrum/FJorge type. I don't think he would bring back anyone close to Vargas, Polanco or Thorpe. I really don't see the reason that he needs to be traded if that is the return when the catching depth behind Pinto is exceptionally awful.
-
OF situation thus far, and looking ahead.
This thread is a painful read. Why on Earth should the Twins trade on its only good, established, young players because he will be a FA in 5 years? His value will still be very high in 2-3 years. The Twins do have a couple of nice 2B prospects but they are still question marks and this team DOES NOT NEED more question marks on the field. Parmelee hasn't shown any indication that he has turned a corner. He had 40 some awesome AB's in June and 40 some terrible AB's in July. He's nothing more than backup OF'er. Finally some people have come to their senses on Fuld. Plouffe shouldn't be moved anywhere or traded until Sano is actually back at 3B and knocking on the MLB door. I'm not convinced Sano will be at 3B for long and Plouffe is actually a solid MLB 3Bman despite everyone's angst against him. The fact is that despite a supposed depth of OF'ers that almost everyone thinks the Twins have they actually have very little depth anywhere. People didn't like my Delmon Young comparison for Arcia a couple of months ago but that is what he is right now. He is an extremely talented raw hitter and he could be a star (so could have Delmon) but he has some big issues that need to be addressed at the MLB level before that happens. Hicks can still come back and be an MLB contributor but his upside has dropped a lot in the last couple of years. Right now I would be happy if he became an solid MLB starter. Buxton can still be an elite player and is really the only OF'er that the Twins have that I would feel comfortable inking in as an MLB starter in 4 years. Walker has hit HR's but can't manage a .300 OBP in A ball. The opposite is true of Harrison (not a 3B for long). He can't hit HR's. Kepler hasn't hit anything. The point is that the Twins OF is hardly an organizational strength that we have thought it was. It's full of players (aside from Buxton and Arcia) that you hope are able to become solid MLB starters but most likely disappoint. It's possible that someone goes Dozier out their depth but you can't count on it. Or it's possible that Rosario and Sano are moved to the OF. At that point the Twins have a good OF but at the price of depth at every other position. And 2014/2015 MLB OF most likely will be below average. Possibly terrible unless Arcia breaks out or Buxton is promoted early.
-
Do you still view Dozier as "untouchable" ?
I would certainly move him for a pitcher like Alex Wood. He shouldn't be viewed as untouchable but this team should not be in a hurry to move him because of Rosario or Polanco. The Braves have a pretty obvious 2Bman as gunnarthor mentions. That 2Bman is like this year's version of Dozier but with a better MiLB resume. He has a cumulative .322/.408/.474/.882 line from the minors.
-
Article: Deal or No Deal: Considering Contract Extensions
Suzuki - Deal. I don't think he will want an unreasonable amount. I like Pinto but the Twins have no depth at catcher and if Pinto struggles or gets injured the Twins won't be worrying if they catcher slinks back to a .260 hitter but rather they will be worrying if their catcher hits .160. Morales - No Deal. I'm bullish on Vargas and Morales/Mauer completely block him. I think he's a guy whose body is older than his actual age. That injury a couple of years ago really messed him up. Willy - Deal but not now. Trade him now but look to bring him back in the offseason. I don't see him getting a multi-year contract and despite the Twins depth of OF'ers in the minors they have almost nothing at OF in the majors. Another year of an experienced middle of the order bat would be nice. Dozier - whatever. My preference would be a deal giving the Twins cost certainty during arb years and reward Dozier with some guaranteed money (perhaps a little more front loaded than his projected arb money). BUT THEY SHOULDN'T TRADE HIM unless they are completely blown away.
-
Moneyball II: Oakland Strikes Back
The problem is that there aren't a lot of singularly great 16 yr old prospects like Sano. Additionally even the best international FA's have a poor track record of success. Aside from MCab 15 years ago the top 20 int'l FA's have done very little in the majors and aren't very good prospects. http://www.baseballamerica.com/today/prospects/international-affairs/2011/2611342.html A lot of that list is still in the minors but Thorpe and Polanco would easily be considered better prospects than all but Gary Sanchez (Heredia vs thorpe could be argued). Most of that list would rate below Felix Jorge. Those are 3 examples of prospects that the Twins acquired in their spread the chips around quantity over quality approach. They were all acquired for 250K-1M.
-
Wait, we have a GREAT bullpen?
Swarzak didn't have trade value over the offseason for the same reason that Duensing doesn't have trade value now. RP's with below avg K rates are not valuable trade chips. The best you can hope for is an A ball player that profiles as a utility player or RP'er.
-
How much credit does Anderson get for Hughes
This thread wasn't really about pushback to keep Anderson as pitching coach. It was more about applying blame and credit equally. If you are going to blame Anderson for failing to make mediocre pitchers into a solid rotation/bullpen then you should also give credit when a pitcher shows an improvement. If you don't think Anderson (and pitching coaches) has that much of an influence on pitchers that improve then the same is true for pitchers that struggle. Thrylos's list is an awful use of statistics. At least half of the pitchers on there didn't make a meaningful contribution to their next team. Eyre... Seriously??? Some took half a decade before becoming a valuable member of another team. Balfour for example. There are probably 5 at most pitchers that showed significant and unexpected improvement after leaving the Twins.
-
According to LEN3- It appears the Twins are near the end of their patience w/ Hicks
It took Gomez 5 years to post a .700+ OPS. And he had a better offensive starting point that Hicks. The lesson that should have been learned was that Hicks looked really raw and he should have stayed in AAA last year and this year.
-
How much credit does Anderson get for Hughes
Except he isn't the same pitcher. He ditched his slider (according to fangraphs and Pitch F/X) and is throwing a cutter (a lot). These are substantial differences in how a pitcher is approaching the game and it probably wasn't Hughes doing it.
-
According to LEN3- It appears the Twins are near the end of their patience w/ Hicks
I think the twins are hoping that Eddie Rosario can be the CF option instead of a Jon Jay type. I would be very surprised if he doesn't get 2 months in CF this year.
-
According to LEN3- It appears the Twins are near the end of their patience w/ Hicks
Except it doesn't. OPS, wRC and wOBA are much better. http://projectprospect.com/article/2009/07/09/barrel-awareness-correlating-team-hitting-stats-with-runs But more importantly the thing that matters is what a player will do for the rest of the season. Hicks simply isn't hitting the ball at all. His hits are not hard liners and the only thing making his offense look halfway respectable is all of the BB's. So going forward does he continue to struggle to hit the ball? Does he continue to rack up the walks? My guess is the team isn't optimistic on either of those.
-
The Dump List
For whatever reason his Toronto (AAA) stats show up on the Rochester statsheet. I thought he was gone also but wasn't keeping that close of watch on the minors this year. But that just reinforces my point further. The Twins have almost nobody left to call up if they jettison Parmelee. Romero would be a nice story sometime. He is getting close to 10 years in the Twins system.
-
According to LEN3- It appears the Twins are near the end of their patience w/ Hicks
My interest in Hicks has increased since he has given up SH. Clearly he needs time in AAA to work on this but he has tools at least. I wish people would stop using 25 PA sample sizes as evidence that Hicks is doing better since time X. He's had like 5 hits in that time. All he needs is a couple bloopers and he looks 'average' over 25 PA's. I was at the Texas game (possibly his first day giving up SH) and he had a couple of hits but he also made a couple boneheaded plays also. I can't remember what but stuff like getting picked off or doubled off. I wouldn't be surprised if part of the Twins angst is that he's not only playing poorly but he is also making the bad rookie mistakes. Those might be tolerated if you are playing well (like the suzuki example) but perhaps unfairly they will get blown up if you are doing terrible.
-
The Dump List
Parmelee's future with the Twins is being able to take advantage of an AB here and a game there to show that he has some talent. He will certainly be glued to the bench for awhile (and deserves to be) but Willy, Mauer and Morales (maybe Arcia) will need days off. Right now the bench consists of Nunez, a backup C, and likely Fuld. that shouldn't be mission impossible to work his way to the top of that heap. He has dug himself a pretty big hole though. Larkin/Bush is an optimistic future upside at this point. He's a lefty so he could be fairly valuable if he could hit decently in a limited role. I'm guessing that he's DFA'd by the end of the month though. The Twins have literally no hitters left on the 40 man roster to call up after Pinto. Herrmann, Fryer, Colabello and Vargas. Kepler and Polanco have no shot at being called up. Mastro or Rosario (DOrtiz possibly) will likely see time but need to be added to the 40 man (not mission impossible).
-
Correia's last stand?
Why are we excited about a 31 yr old RP'ing prospect? It's too early to convert Meyer to a RP'er. If you do it now then he won't be able to handle a full season's innings next year. I'm not sure the Twins can give KC away despite his one solid start.
-
Correia's last stand?
I think I predicted that KC would pitch a gem in late April when there was a similar thread calling for his head. He did and we were blessed:cry: with another month. The thing is that he isn't truly bad (SSS so far). The problem is that he isn't really good either. It is time to give May a shot though.
-
Article: Twins Select Nick Burdi in the 2nd round
TWO is pretty statistically...
-
Dozier to Cleanup?
No, you don't mess with the players that are doing well. Dozier and Willy stay where they are at. Morales stays behind Willy. The 'bad' version of Mauer still has a .336 OBP. He will come around.
-
Article: Twins Top 10 Prospects: Post-Draft Edition
There isn't a huge difference in value between CF and 2B. Especially when most analysis said that Rosario played a tolerable 2B. VARGAS!
-
Correia's last stand?
and Correia tosses a gem. Welcome to one more month of KC.
-
Eddie Rosario - 2014
There is a singular reason that he is playing CF. Aaron Hicks and the disaster that CF has been the last two seasons. He was projected as a guy that could stick in CF but would be a better corner OF'er. He was not considered a long term answer in CF due to Buxton, Hicks and Revere already being in the system and 2B was a big position of need. Ironically CF is the current position of need so he's there and I wouldn't be surprised if he gets a shot in a month or two.
-
Correia's last stand?
Burdi is not several years away. We should see him by next year at the latest. And this year is possible.
-
Article: Twins Select Nick Burdi in the 2nd round
RP'ers only throw 15-20 pitches in a game. It's going to be difficult to develop a 3rd pitch and use it enough that it is remotely effective. Using a single time that a college hitter squared up and hit a high 90's heater doesn't mean anything. Nobody should expect anyone to never give up A hit. Statistically speaking college hitters weren't squaring up anything against Burdi this season. He gave up 15 total hits in 32 IP. The ONE hit you saw was an aberration and not worth slowing down Burdi's rise to the majors.
-
Correia's last stand?
You can only remove one of these guys from the rotation. There's no guarantee that Johnson or May are actually better and if they need to be sent down the team is setup to cycle through a bunch of mediocre AAAA starters. Deduno/Correia have not been great but there are worse options. Correia is actually the same pitcher as last year he is just having trouble stranding runners this year. Obviously Meyer is the guy everyone wants up and I want him up also but all indications are that he won't be in the starting rotation at the end of the season.
-
Thorpe, Romero Make Kernels Debuts
I want to read more about Romero. He has flown under my radar so far.