Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Thrylos

Old-Timey Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Thrylos

  1. The Twins just do not have many non-Latin American position player prospects, so hard to pick position players for the AFL. Here is what I think: Alex Meyer Pat Dean (likely one starter) Matt Koch James Beresford Kyle Knudson/Dan Rohlfing (maybe) AJ Achter Matt Hauser Zach Jones
  2. I have this feeling that Mauer will replace Morneau at first base next season. Then Pinto and Herrmann will be the 2 primary catchers with Herrmann playing occasionally other positions.
  3. First of all, hiring a steroid cheater as a coach is a major disgrace on Ryan. Allen should go. Period. There are a few things in play for Smith: a. Plenty of his former players, currently in the Twins' organization and not, have been loud and clear about how much they dislike him as a coach b. Lots of those "Twins' lifers" were Rantz' boys. Now that he has finally retired and there is a new Director of minor leagues, I think that this season was their evaluation season. I do expect several changes in the minors this off-season... c. Ask around (off the record) the NB front office about what they think about Smith; you will probably get some really enlightening opinions...
  4. The biggest reason this team needs a managerial change (and needed since 2005ish) is that the players are not mad when they are losing and are unemotional robots and if they are not, they get banished by the manager and/or get traded (Lohse, Garza, Gomez, et al. ). If you do not hate losing you will not win. Period. And this is something that the manager should install in a team. From Cuddyer's comments after the loss to game 163 at the White Sox "Oh well, we will get them next season" to Correia's comments six days ago after the Twins lost "I am very pleased with my start, I did everything right", there are plenty of examples of this... The Twins need a winning attitude. Losers should have no place in this team. And if you are ok with losing, you are loser (by definition.)
  5. As far as Hicks goes: a. His coaches, managers, GM and minor league directors have done him a disservice by letting him switch hit. Period. His OPS+ as a RHB in the majors is 92, which is higher than Doumit, Plouffe etc. b. He is 23. Span and Hunter were busts at 23 as well. Give him some time. c. Hicks is one of the nicest and most humble ball players that you can ever meet. He works hard and he keeps his mouth shut. A lot like Buxton as a matter of fact. But he is a really quiet guy, so do not expect quotes from him. He is not Mike Cuddyer...
  6. Interesting stuff, but I think that this chart is a proof that RBIs do not matter From all of those players listed who hit 100+ RBI only 2 (Hrbek and Ortiz) were All Stars. Another handful (Koskie, Kubel, Walker) were MLB regulars for more than 5 years, few more were role players (Larkin, Laudner, Teufel, Sorrento, Davidson) and the majority even never made the majors or did for a cup of coffee. Just this list is proof that 100+ RBI says zip for a players' future. Slugging percentage, wRC+ and OPS+ (outside the PCL) on the other hand...
  7. A September call up means that a player can double his income. A month of an MLB paycheck is about a season's worth of a AAA paycheck and more for a AA. And this can mean a lot to the players. So it is a form of a reward...
  8. No. I am talking after Santana. Garza and Santana departed the same season, and the Twins regarded the other 6 ready and good. That was part of the reason Garza was traded; think Span & Revere trades because of perceived depth at CF.
  9. That's kind of a chicken and egg situation... But, if you remember at some point, just after Santana departed, the Twins had 6 young starters who were supposed to be the pillar who will take this team to the next level. Baker, Blackburn, Bonser, Liriano, Slowey, Perkins. But, (not only because of Anderson, the GM, minor league director and the manager are responsible as well,) the only thing they got 6 years afterwards (i.e. in these guys' prime years) is a good closer. Unacceptable player development. Someone should be accountable for this, and also for the fact that the Twins have been on the tail of the league for pitching the last 3 seasons.
  10. Liriano is having a Cy Young season Dickie had a Cy Young season Lohse is having his third excellent season in a row Deduno barely is a fifth starter in a competitive team (no matter what he is in the Twins) Fien is a AAAA player who is coming back to earth after his .1xx BABIP the first half. Apples and pineapples as far as impact goes...
  11. Guess the last time the Twins signed top Free Agents, it did not help them.... As a reminder, that was 1991
  12. There others who are having great seasons, but Sano had a historic season, objectively. Analysis and argument here (kind of long and there are objective measures involved...)
  13. One thing about this coming off-season: One can spend $30-35M/year and build a rotation with 3 free agents who were below expectations this year, but their peripherals show that they will rebound, and they are young enough (alphabetically) : Dan Haren Phil Hughes Josh Johnson (Also Ervin Santana and Ricky Nolasco and Tim Lincecum... there are plenty younger FA Ps out there, unlike last off season) but Ryan has to go or go off his bottom feeding spendthrift ways that brought the likes of Correia, Marquis, Ponson et. al. to the Twins. He's got the cash to spend ($20M off the books for Morneau and Blackburn) he better spend it.
  14. Kepler is not a top ten by any means. Nobody will claim him in the MLB portion of the draft. As is he can be claimed at the AA portion of the draft. They need to put him in Rochester's roster to keep him from the AAA portion of rule 5 (Vargas too) and he will be fine.
  15. don't you love typos
  16. Twins' own Pedro Hernandez is a good comparable for Miguel Surbaran. Similar statute and very similar stuff.
  17. The Twins should not trade Sano and Buxton, but they have some decisions to make and mainly: Do they trade one of Rosario/Dosier ?(before their stock slips and sell low again). The farm system is not deep enough in many positions to really afford them trades. Others of value I see potentially being trade bait are Harrison, Kepler (in my book, Walker, DJ Hicks and Baby Papi are ahead of these 2) and some of the Lefty relievers. But it is not that deep of a system after the top 10-15 and there is not much overlap...
  18. What amazed me with Blackburn is that the Twins never tried to turn him into a pen guy, like they did with, another failed starter, Perkins. In the minors Blackburn used to have a four-seamer (which he practically abandoned in the majors for the sinker) that used to run up to 97. He could have really been a good pen part and even maybe earn the contract money. Hope he turns it around for a National league team that does not play the Twins
  19. It's a back to the future situation... Ryan carries a 5 pounder notebook (like a big three ring binder size) to ST games with him
  20. Agreed with Oldgoat about that game being the highlight of his career (and funny enough, 2 beloved by most Twins' fans players were the reason the Twins did not make the post-season: Jim Thome with that home run and Mike Cuddyer who did not try to knock AJP out and score) I am amazed that the Twins did not try a pen role for Blackburn (like they did with Perkins) It was probably the $ and that ill-advised contract. In the minors he did have a 97 mph four-seamer (that Andy took away) which would had been a decent weapon in the pen. Maybe he'll surface as a pen guy someplace
  21. About Meyer's (and May's too) numbers this season: - Meyer has a 2.82 FIP - His (and May's and most of the NB Ps) BABIP is in the .3xxs because of the bad New Britain D (of the range part, and this is obvious to all of us who have watched them play) - His xFIP is probably in the low 2s This seems like a guy who if healthy can do better than most (if not all) the people in the Twins' rotation today. I hope he has a chance to fight for a spot in the rotation next ST.
  22. I think that if this is the rotation to start 2014, Ryan should be fired on the spot.
  23. went the way of the dinosaurs, where they should be... Great stuff, btw.
  24. And what exactly this would do for the Twins in the long run?
  25. Originally published at The Tenth Inning Stretch --- The art of evaluating performance inside a baseball diamond has undoubtedly changed the last few years with the infusion of science (math & statistic notations.) In the "good old days" if someone "hit 300", with more than 30 home runs and either more than 100 runs scored or 100 "ribies", he had a great season. That was the measuring stick that separated great from very good. And it still does, mainly on the mainstream press, game broadcasts and talk radio. The expressions "he hits two seventy five" and "he cannot hit his weight" will be there as performance measures, albeit as crude as an Amish scooter is for propelling devise when compared to a Tesla . Still, even that is light years ahead than the Fred Flintstone mobile of a hitter's performance evaluation, the "eyeballing" method, which introduces measures such as "the special sound a ball makes when leaves the bat" or "the quickness of someone's wrists" or the way "someone is flying on the bases" or . There has been evolution. OPS as a concept was introduced in 1984, and then was refined to OPS+ or adjusted OPS, that normalizes for park and league effects, plus adds an easy to compare baseline of 100 that is the league average that season, for an easy reference. So an OPS+ higher than 100 is better than average and less than 100 worse. Much improved from "ribies" and other cumulative stats, but still one dimensional Gremlin-like. What OPS lacks, is that it disregards the ability of someone to sacrifice runs, steal bases, score runs, avoid hitting into double plays, and all the other goodies that are happening in real life baseball with the bat or at the bases. A year after OPS was created, in 1985, Bill James introduced a measure for offensive performance he called Runs Created . This concept has been improved (see previous reference) constantly to account for things like stolen bases and sacrifices. Tom Tango, eventually improved the concept or Runs Created and morphed it into weighted Runs Created or wRC. wRC is a good way of looking at someones performance, but (like RC) it is cumulative; think Runs, HRs and RBIs. This is fine for evaluating a season (like who had the best season in an MVP type of consideration) or whether someone's career is HOF worthy (both cummulative questions; for the record I do prefer WAR over wRC to answer those, since it includes fielding, among other reasons); however it does not answer the question of who performed the best for the time he was on the field (and maybe play him more, or call him "up", if necessary.) So we moved from a Gremin to a 'cuda (Yes, I like 'cudas too, especially the Hemi version, but they are not without faults) Enter wRC+ to the equation. wRC+ is a lot like OPS+. It is based on wRC (runs created with the bat and on the bases, independent of league and park,) but it normalized to 100 (denoting league average, like OPS+,) and furthermore it is a rate metric (think UZR/120 vs UZR) so you can look at chunks of performance, moving plate appearance variations (sample size) aside. A good writeup in basic terms about wRC+ is found here: This interesting article from Denver Post (an enlightened mainstream newspaper), uses wRC+ to argue the greatness of Carlos Gonzalez. Here is a real life field test of the effectiveness of cumulative measures like wRC (and WAR) compared to rate stats, like wRC+. Work with me: Let's rewind to the Twins' last good season (2010) and ask the question: who was the best Twins' player on the field (for the time he played, assuming that it was significant; I like the 200 PA mark as a cut-off point) and try to find an objective quantitative measure to support your argument. "Ribies" and ball sounds and the like are not allowed. Here are the top 6 in wRC, a cumulative measure, with Plate Appearances (and OPS for reference) in parenthesis, in descending order. Joe Mauer 93 (584, .871) Delmon Young 87 (613, .826) Michael Cuddyer 82 (675, .753) Justin Morneau 75 (348, 1.055) Denard Span 73 (705, .679) Jim Thome 71 (340, 1.039) So basically, the cummulative stat, because of the disparity of sample size favors an average player (Cuddyer) and a below average player (Span) because they had twice as many PAs as Morneau and Thome; the "longevity" effect in HOF discussions. Let's look at the best wRC+ with a 200 PA minimum (to filter players like Luke Hughes and Carl Pavano who make the list but had less than 10 PAs) : Justin Morneau 184 Jim Thome 178 Joe Mauer 136 Delmon Young 120 (Danny Valencia 118) Michael Cuddyer 104 . . . (4 players) Denard Span 88 This is what wRC+ does. And this was the season that every single Twins' fan was saying what that season would have been, "if" Morneau did not hit his head. I hope this little example illustrates the value of wRC+ vs things like wRC and WAR. After the long but necessary introduction, back to the original subject, Miquel Sano. If trying to find objective measures that evaluate performance on the field is difficult, finding objective quantitative measures that can estimate future performance, used to discuss who is the best prospect or to create prospect "lists" is borderline impossible (like trying to create a vehicle that is using air for fuel and emits water for exhaust.) But we can dream and play. Earlier this year, during the off-season, I looked at potential future performance of the starting pitchers in the Twins' organization using objective quantitative measures. I will repeat the exercise this coming off-season looking at the position players and the whole slew of pitchers and not only starters. I will be using wRC+ as the basis of that endeavor, based on the discussion above. In addition, age and level of play will also be major factors. But for this piece here, before it turns into War and Peace, let's focus on Miguel Sano's performance this season in a quantitative way and putting it in perspective: Miguel Sano in 243 PAs in A+ (average league age for hitters is 23) at age 20 had a 201 wRC+. In 190 PAs in AA(average league age for hitters is 24.5) at age 20 he is having a 158 wRC+. His AA numbers are in flex and we can discuss more after the season is over, but his A+ number are final. To put that 201 wRC+ in perspective: - It is the highest in the minors this season (second highest is Chris Colabello with 197 in Rochester, who is well in his prime and older than the average AAA player) - It has been achieved by only 5 major leaguers in the past 30 years (mininum 200 PAs): Miguel Cabrera, Barry Bonds, Mark McGwire, Jeff Bagwell, Frank Thomas; and Cabrera's is this season, so it is not final. For the fun of it, and the perspective of Sano's dominance, here is a list of all the MLB leaders in wRC+ (and some close to the leaders) with career highs indicated for the last 30 seasons: 2013: Miguel Cabrera, 210, in progress 2012: Mike Trout & Miguel Cabrera tied, 166 2011: Jose Bautista, 180 (career high) 2010: Josh Hamilton, 175 (career high) 2009: Albert Pujols, 180 ; Joe Mauer, 170 (career high) 2008: Albert Pujols, 184 (career high) 2007: David Ortiz & Alex Rodriguez tied, 175 (career high for both) 2006: Travis Hafner, 176 (career high) 2005: Alex Rodriguez, 174 2004: Barry Bonds, 233 (Todd Helton, 166, career high) 2003: Barry Bonds, 212 (Albert Pujols, 184) 2002: Barry Bonds, 244 (Jim Thome 189, Manny Ramirez 185); all three career high 2001: Barry Bonds, 235 (Jason Giambi 193, Sammy Sosa 186; career high for both); 2000: Manny Ramirez, 181 1999: Manny Ramirez, 172 (Mark McGwire, 168) 1998: Mark McGwire, 205 (career high) 1997: Mike Piazza, 183, career high (Frank Thomas, 179, Larry Walker 177, career high) 1996: Mark McGwire, 190 (Garry Sheffield 185, career high) 1995: Edgar Martinez, 182 (career high) 1994: Frank Thomas & Jeff Bagwell, 205 (Albert Belle 186); all three career high 1993: Barry Bonds, 193 1992: Barry Bonds, 198 1991: Frank Thomas, 179 (Chili Davis, 139) 1990: Rickey Henderson, 190 (career high) 1989: Kevin Mitchell, 184 (career high) 1988: Jose Canseco, 169 (career high) 1987: Jack Clark 176, Wade Boggs 171; both career high (Kent Hrbek, 134) 1986: Don Mattingly 160 (career high) 1985: Pedro Guerrero 181 (George Brett 168); both career high 1984: Mike Schmidt 154 (career high) 1983: Wade Boggs 155 And here are the wRC+ career highs and career averages for selected Twins' hitters Harmon Killebrew, high: 176, 1967; career average: 142 Tony Oliva, high: 154, 1971; career average: 129 Rod Carew, high: 175, 1977; career average: 132 Kent Hrbek: high: 146, 1988 career average: 126 Kirby Puckett: high: 150, 1988 career average: 122 Dave Winfield: high: 161, 1975; career average: 128 Paul Molitor: high: 145 1991; career average: 122 Joe Mauer: high: 170, 2009; career average: 133 Justin Morneau: high: 184, 2010; career average: 118 Sano's career worst wRC+ is 146 last season in Beloit. As you can see, his wRC+ numbers this season, in combination with his age, his level of play and the average age in that level, are totally out of the stratosphere. How about Byron Buxton? Buxton is only 7 months younger than Sano, and has been playing at a full level below Sano. So the age/level combination is very similar (but still on Sano's favor). Here are Buxton numbers: in 321 PAs in A (average league age for hitters is 21.5) at age 19 had a 173 wRC+. In 174 PAs in A+ at age 19 (average league age for hitters is 23) he is having a 129 wRC+. For comparison's sake, the Angels' Mike Trout, at the same age (19), at the same league (Midwest), at the same team (Cedar Rapids) had an identical 173 wRC+. Objectively, Byron Buxton, looks like he is the prospect Mike Trout was and had a great season in Cedar Rapids (and this is great news for the Twins), but Sano had a monumental season in Fort Meyers. Better than Morneau's 2010 with the Twins. I just cannot see how objectively anyone can justify ranking Buxton higher than Sano, or not rank Sano as the number one prospect in baseball this season; unless it is the sound the ball makes when it meets his bat (or something) Sano is poised to be a centerpiece in the majors for years to come. Fans will enjoy seeing his #PowerBananas for a long while. I just hope that they are all with him in a Twins' uniform... http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8257/8607105428_fcbd66e42a_z.jpg

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.