Everything posted by Thrylos
-
Article: Dozier's Case For American League MVP
AL fWAR: Trout 8.6 Betts 7.1 Donaldson 6.8 Altuve 6.6 Machado 6.3 Dozier 6.1 This is Trout's to lose, unless the majority of the voters would be of the opinion that an MVP should have helped lead his team to the post-season or at least be in a competitive team. If that is the case it is Bett's award.
-
Article: Early Returns: Polanco's Play At Shortstop
Don't be so sure about that... Vielma cannot hit a volleyball with a bat and Gordon's OPS in the same stop at the same age is 60 (A+), 120 (A), and 201 (Rk+) points lower than Polanco's, plus his fielding percentage this season (.952) is worse than Polanco's (and so is Vielma's, .954) I see no reason that Gordon will be a better player than Polanco, if he makes it to the majors, and Vielma's ceiling is Florimon.
-
Article: Early Returns: Polanco's Play At Shortstop
SSS. Give the kid the off-season and the entire Spring Training to play and prep as a shortstop and I suspect that he will be much better next season. Kepler has a .971 fielding percentage, which is worse for a RF than Polanco's .959 is for a SS. He also has a negative UZR (even though UZR is useless in both sample sizes.) Any concerns there? The bottom line is that both players are young enough to improve and unless you play them there, they will not improve.
-
Padres hid medical information from trading partners
Any suspension for the GM is weak. They got to take away draft picks and/or the ability to sign IFAs plus fine them an amount that they will feel (let's say $10M minimum) Anything else is a slap on the wrist.
- Article: Is The Buxton Era Beginning?
- Article: Is The Buxton Era Beginning?
-
Article: Updates On The Front Office Search
Family, location, location, location, family Frankly, I don't know many non-natives who are not dreading Minnesota winters. And if someone has Junior High/High School age kids, a job in Toronto (less than 1hr flight from Boston where the family is,) is much more appealing that a job in Minneapolis, esp. if one does not have any emotional ties with the team...
-
Sad News on the Pitching Front: May out for Season
Here are a few non-Twins scouting reports on Meyer at the time of the trade or thereabouts, with quotes from there: Number 1: "He has the makings of a true top-of-the-rotation starter." Number 2: "his ceiling is phenomenal and he has all of the tools to develop in to a number-one starter in the MLB. He's isn't a projection-only guy either, backing up his top prospect status with a lights out performance last year." Number 3: "If his shoulder holds up he could become a No. 1 or 2 starter in the Twins rotation and has a significantly higher ceiling than anyone currently found on the big league staff." Number 4: "looks the part of a potential front-of-the-rotation piece, and we could see him turn up in the Twin Cities in the second half" Number 5: "If you were to create a starting pitcher from scratch it might look something like Meyer: 6-foot-9, 220 pounds, above-average to plus strikeout potential, solid or better control, and fantastic groundball rates. If he can avoid injury, Meyer could develop into a legitimate frontline starting pitcher" Not sure where you got your information...
- Sad News on the Pitching Front: May out for Season
- Sad News on the Pitching Front: May out for Season
-
Dozier for Silver Slugger
2016 second basemen: WAR Jose Altuve 6.7 Brian Dozier 5.9 Daniel Murphy 5.5 Dustin Pedroia 5.4 Robinson Cano 5.1 wRC+ Murphy 158 Altuve 154 Matt Carpenter 142 Dozier 142 Cano 135 wOBA Murphy .411 Altuve .398 DJ LeMahieu .389 Dozier .386 Carpenter .384 OPS Murphy .990 Altuve .950 Dozier .929 Carpenter .910 LeMahieu .905 Depending on whether someone thinks that defense matters in awarding silver sluggers or not, it should be either Murphy (defense does not matter) or Altuve (defense matters.) My belief is that SS is complementary to GG, so defense does not matter, and Murphy should get it (unless those numbers change by the end of the season.) Dozier a solid third.
- Sad News on the Pitching Front: May out for Season
- Sad News on the Pitching Front: May out for Season
-
Who are our building blocks of the future?
I really do not understand how anyone could compare Kemper at a corner OF potistion to Polanco (who is also younger than Kemper) at SS and think that Kemper is a better player or deserves to be part of the Twins' future more than Kemper. Look at the data. As far as the original questions goes, at this point I would say: Sano, Polanco, Buxton, Kepler, Vargas (btw, what else does this guy need to do at the MLB-level to get any respect? And he is Duffey's and Chargois's age) with Berrios, Gonsalves, and May on the cusp and needing to prove more. Other than first 3, I would have no untouchables (if Kemper was a centerfielder, catcher, or middle infielder, I'd add him to that list, but corner OF is easier to find.)
- Another POBO candidate: J.J. Picollo
-
Bates: Trade Dozier? History suggests really hard to get good return.
He is cherry picking. Forgot to mention that Zobrist was also traded for Sean Manea plus a guy. And Dozier has more value than Zobrist had then. I'd take Manea plus another pitching prospect at that level for Dozier in a heartbeat.
- Article: What Are Molitor's Infields Telling Us?
- Article: What Are Molitor's Infields Telling Us?
-
Alex Meyer called up to LAA
Here is the composition of the current Cardinal Starters: Jaime Garcia - Drafted 2005, 22nd Round Michael Wacha - Drafted 2012, 1st Round (in the majors 2013) Luke Weaver - Drafted 2014, 1st Round (in he majors 2016) Lance Lynn (60 day DL) - Drafted 2008, 1st Round Mike Leake - Free Agent 2015 (5Y/$80M - Cinci's 1st Round pick) Carlos Martinez - Minor League FA 2010 Adam Wainwright - Traded for JD Drew in his prime - Atlanta's 1st Round pick So. They have 3 recent 1st round draft picks, they got good scouting to get younger pitchers like Martinez as FAs and are not afraid to sign long term contracts or to trade their stars in their decline to get young rising pitching starts I'd love it if the Twins do the same...
-
Article: What Are Molitor's Infields Telling Us?
I hope they rebuild. A veteran FA SS will not allow Polanco to get enough reps at SS and see whether he can play that position long term. Also rebuilding teams need veteran SSs as much as they need proven closers... They don't. The whole idea of rebuilding is to create a core of players that will reach their primes together so the team will be competitive until the next rebuild. The Twins' current/future core is at ages 22-25. So much outside that age range does not make sense. Figure out what you have and when they get closer to contending, you then can close holes with veterans (like MacPhail did in '87 for example,) but getting players at or past their primes makes zero sense at this point
- Article: What Are Molitor's Infields Telling Us?
- Article: What Are Molitor's Infields Telling Us?
- Article: What Are Molitor's Infields Telling Us?
- Baseball Brought Hope Back After 9/11
-
Baseball Brought Hope Back After 9/11
Agreed, but just a technicality: Gettysburg was a 3 day battle. Technically the singular most devastating day in American history was Antietam with 22,720 casualties. But that was before US Major General Abner Doubleday, who commanded the First Corps in the aforementioned Gettysburg, supposedly invented baseball But, yes, it was amazing to watch the first baseball game after 9/11, just as it was to watch the jet lines of clouds on the sky again...