Everything posted by Thrylos
-
Article: TD Top Prospects: #2 Stephen Gonsalves
Gonsalves's fastball is 88-91 usually. It might drop to 86, it might hit 92. That's about it. The problems I have with Gonsalves are: 1. He has maybe one plus pitch (his changeup), the rest are average/below average 2. His command is problematic. 12.5 BB% in AA is worrisome 3. He has survived by generating bad contact because of his FB "high spin rate". This translates to BABIPs in .250s and very low HR/9 (0.12 in AA last season.) When those numbers go back to reality/league average in the majors, his WHIP will jump to 1.400ish and FIP to 4ish. He is a back to rotation starter in a competitive team maybe. A step above the Alberses and the Deans of the world. Think Scott Diamond's career season or Glen Perkins as a starter. Not bad, but not that great.
-
Reusse makes case for Danny Santana at shortstop
Let me try to put this nicely: Danny Santana is a "SS candidate" only in Reusse's (and maybe his own) head.
-
Reusse makes case for Danny Santana at shortstop
I think that this article makes the case that Reusse should retire...
-
Berardino: Sano working to take on 3B
About the same height and weight as Jarred Allen. Any questions?
-
Hammond Happenin
Get well soon! Wishing you the best
- Article: Twins Roster Projection 2017: Version 2.0
-
MLB Pipeline: 2017 Twins Top 30 Prospects
They grossly devalue IFA at lower levels. Arraez at 28 and Javier at 17, in this organization is a joke. They think that Jorge will end up a starter with that ranking. Biggest surprises are two pitchers who we do not know whether they will pitch professionally (for different reasons) Thorpe at 18 and Jax at 30.
-
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
14 starts in the majors is an "extremely small sample size", and 17 in AAA is not?
- Article: Twins Roster Projection 2017: Version 2.0
-
Article: TD Top Prospects #3: Alex Kirilloff
Not quite. .952 fielding percentage in the OF is not very promising... And speed is a tool he has not. Was 0/1 in SB last season. There is room for improvement and he did play centerfield in 11 games, I suspect just to have a look at him over there. Strong arm and I think that he projects as a right fielder, but still needs to do work with the glove. Interesting to see what he can do in the Midwest League. His swing is somewhat complicated and has too many moving parts and I am curious to see how it plays against better off-speed and breaking pitches...
-
Berardino: O'Rourke leaves it all on the field... and in the bullpen?
Didn't Jose Mijares do something similar once? Trying to remember.
-
Article: Twins Blunder Polanco's Development
And then he retired saying that he was behind the times. Probably his truest statement ever
-
Article: TD Top Prospects #4: Nick Gordon
See above re: OPS and why it is not a good thing to compare them. I prefer OBP for middle infielders who do not hit. And it is not a prospect comparison, it is a ceiling comparison or who will serve the Twins better in the nearer future. Career numbers do not matter, because players click at some point. The fact is that Vielma had a higher OBP (.345, and above his league average .321) against more advanced competition in AA. Gordon has not yet reached AA. His best OBP was .335, achieved against lesser competition in high A. Whether Vielma or Gordon have higher ceiling with the bat is up for discussion, but Vielma can hit ok. Previous post. .750 OPS, 40 SB, above average glove at SS is about 2.5 fWAR. And that .750 is about .030 points higher than Gordon's best, btw. To Vielma a .265/.321/.338 .659 OPS, 5 SB, elite glove SS has 3.2 fWAR (Andrelton Simmons's 2015 numbers). I'd give a bit more to Vielma because of the SB (and Vielma's best OPS was higher than that). So if Vielma hits .270/.330/.350 (very doable for him) and steals 40 bases (career best 35 vs Gordon's 25) , he will be a 3.5fWAR player, about 1 point more valuable than Gordon.
-
Article: TD Top Prospects #4: Nick Gordon
Not quite. See: .288/.325/.432 (.757 OPS) with 40 steals and about +1 UZR is a 2.7 fWAR player (those were Eduardo Nunez's numbers in 2016, and I don't think that Gordon can get there, esp with the SB department, but he will be overall in the ballpark as far as comparables go) So, would you pick Eduardo Nunez with the 5th overall pick, when Trea Turner and Aaron Nola were still on the board?
-
Article: Twins Roster Projection 2017: Version 2.0
Back to the OP: Still very early, but the only differences I have are: Pitching: Vogelsong making the team over Rogers (actually it is Breslow over Rogers) and Santiago to the pen as the second lefty with either Vogelsong or Haley making the 5th rotation spot. Duffey over Chargois likely, as well. Still have to see them all pitch, so this is on paper only. Position players: Gimenez getting the back up C job over Garver I think that they will try to get several of the veterans they signed on the team.
- Article: Twins Roster Projection 2017: Version 2.0
- Article: Twins Roster Projection 2017: Version 2.0
-
Article: Twins Blunder Polanco's Development
This excuse is not a valid one, since Dozier was untradable when Polanco was playing 2B in AAA. Dozier was hitting a Butterible .202/.294/.329 in the end of May, with 5 HR in 198 PA.
-
Article: TD Top Prospects #4: Nick Gordon
That was not a comparison. Direct or indirect. I used Smith's career .666 OPS to support my argument that OPS does not matter for some players, esp. the ones with not much power, and OBP is a better way to judge those players. I based it on his improvement as a hitter that culminated to a respectable .345 OBP in AA, which matter of fact, is higher than the Southern League average of .321 OBP, plus his .400+ OBP as a RHH What supporting evidence are you using to support what claim? Or are you just arguing against my earlier claim that Vielma at .345 OBP in AA is a better hitter than Gordon with .335 OBP in A+, without presenting any evidence?
-
Article: TD Top Prospects #4: Nick Gordon
He is not a power hitter. He will get on base at .345 clip. OPS does not do him justice. There is a certain shortstop with career .666 OPS who is a first ballot Hall of Famer...
-
Article: TD Top Prospects #4: Nick Gordon
Vielma hit .271/.345/.318 in AA, while Gordon hit .291/.335/.386 in High A. Vielma has less power but gets on base more often than Gordon. Vielma's problem is swinging from the left side. As a RHH last season he hit .338/.407/.416 in AA. And the jump from A+ to AA with the stick is significant. Let's see what Gordon will do in AA. This is his first season with OPS > .700 Vielma "cannot hit" is a suburban legend, brought to you by the same people who said that Polanco cannot play shortstop and Molitor apologized for yesterday...
-
Article: TD Top Prospects #4: Nick Gordon
Gordon is blocked by a player better than him (Polanco) and is followed by another better than him (Javier). Add to the fact that Vielma is probably ahead of him in MLB-readiness, much better with the glove and not that much lesser with the stick (esp if he quit switch hitting), and Gordon's future with the Twins should be obvious: He should be traded as soon as possible for something the Twins need, like young starting pitching, possibly in a package with Dozier, Santana and/or other veterans...
-
Article: Twins Blunder Polanco's Development
1. General Manager - Terry Ryan (he gone) 2. VP of Player Development - Mike Radcliff (he should go) 3. Minor League Director - Brad Steil (he should go) 4. Minor League Fielding Coordinator - Joel Lepel (he should go) 5. Polanco's manager at AAA in 2016 - Mike Quade (he should go) for starters... Molitor played him for 5 games at 2B and 9 games at 3B in 2016, which is also ridiculous...
-
Butherus: Dreams come true for Twins coach Jeff Smith
The thing that is not really reported is that he hit that HR off an ex-teammate who used to be a pain in the ass for Sano and all other Latinos in the clubhouse...
-
Berardino: Breslow passes first test (plus Polanco, Dozier, Slegers more)
Seth, thanks for holding up the party line and apologizing for what does not need apologies after a 99+96+96+oops+103 L seasons. Those "evaluators" have proven themselves wrong by default. About time to call things the way they are, isn't it?