Everything posted by PseudoSABR
- Article: REPORT: Twins To Sign Jason Castro
-
Twins to sign Jason Castro (per MLBTR)
We did something!
-
FanGraphs: Top 24 Twins Prospects
Let's hope the new organizational pitching philosophy pays dividends with Jay, Stewart, Gonsalves, and Romero among others. Even though these guys have reached the upper minors, they are young enough to benefit from a new development philosophy.
-
2016 Election Thread
And that, my friend, is confirmation-bias. Too few are willing to admit that their predispositions shape not only their conclusions, but their analysis.
-
Article: Report: Twins Place Trevor Plouffe On Outright Waivers
The arbitration system is broken. It's stupid that every team but the Twins can pay Plouffe less money*. The forced pay increases within the system far too often force teams to non-tender their home-grown talent when they have an off-year (or injury) in the final years of arbitration. The previous salary should have no bearing on an arbitration number--perhaps time-served should or previous production (but not salary itself); if a player has a career year in his year of arbitration, but gets hurt or regresses back to the mean, non-tendering is far too often the outcome. The system deemphasizes teams retaining their own talent in such situations, when it should do the opposite. This is the right move. But Plouffe probably would have had a place on this team (or have been a tradeable asset) at a (much) lower cost. *I suppose Plouffe could have accepted a pay cut, but I doubt that outcome happens very rarely if at all.
-
Astros Yankees trade
This thread is too meta. Shouldn't threads about threads have their own thread? (kidding)
-
2016 Election Thread
It can be both. Even if his acceptance of such position was based (in part) on nobility, that Romney himself would benefit (prestige, influence, padding his political resume) from Trump's election is phony.
-
Castile shooting, police violence, race, etc side discussion
I don't know about Minnesota. In Arizona (for instance), the jury can convict on the charged crime or any "lesser-included" crime. I'll glance at the Minnesota statutes and case law, and see if I can quickly figure it out. Edit: "Second-degree culpable negligence manslaughter is a lesser-included offense of first-degree premeditated murder." State v. Penkaty, 708 N.W.2d 185 (Minn. 2006) Although, it looks like there, the defense requested the manslaughter instruction, so I don't know if the prosecution can make the request...
-
Castile shooting, police violence, race, etc side discussion
Murder can be down graded to manslaughter upon adequate provocation, at least at common law. And if there's a reasonable mistake about provocation, manslaughter might also fly. I think the charge is political, as typically, prosecutors will charge murder, and let the jury decide whether it's manslaughter or not. There must have been some belief that a jury would find him guilty of the murder charge, so they took that decision out of their hands. There needs to be an independent prosecution office for all law enforcement crimes.
-
2016 Election Thread
I agree with refining the roles of unions. Unions should be there for bargaining of contracts, not as an advocate in every situation which affects that group from termination to politics. But as long as we live in a Citizen's United world, taking away the political influence would be nary impossible.
-
2016 Election Thread
Of course, there's a wife gulf between pandering and dismissing. My point is that Democrats don't need to (and should not) pander, that's precisely why a Warren/Sanders liberal would have done better than Clinton, because they do speak to poor rural white's concerns. I know plenty of white guys who would have entertained voting for Sanders over Trump but were deadset against voting for Clinton. Warren may have had trouble with the liberal elitist angle, but she's very authentic messenger. She may not have 'swung the working class her way' but she'd fair significantly better than Clinton. A good deal of that working class vote for Trump was a vote against Clinton personally; Warren doesn't have the same defects, even if she still is a woman and a liberal.
-
2016 Election Thread
I don't disagree with anything you've said here. My point about pandering to rural whites was in response to the notion someone like Warren wouldn't have done better in this election. As you point out, liberals don't necessarily need to alter their message to be attractive to persuadable rural whites. I still think the analysis here is under-appreciating the lack of enthusiasm for Clinton. The loss probably has more to do with Clinton's flaws as a candidate than it does with liberal messaging. Clinton was never an authentic vessel for ideas on the left; her attributes--competency, experience, using political bureaucracy to get things done--hardened the anti-establishment critique.
-
2016 Election Thread
Warren would have gotten far, far more liberal enthusiasm then Clinton ever did. She may not have gotten the rural whites that went for Trump, but she may have turned out people from various other groups (which Clinton did not) that overcomes rural white vote. If the takeaway from this election is to pander to rural whites or lose, this country is screwed.
-
2016 Election Thread
Rarely (if ever) will the Court overturn cases, because of mere political change. Stare decisis is something the Court takes very seriously. What would need to happen is a state would have to pass a new law banning gay marriage, and then someone would sue to declare that law unconstitutional, and then it would go through the appeal process. This would all take years likely. Once the issue finally makes it to the Court, the Court would have to be pretty creative to overturn its very recent rationale, and would need a sound legal argument for such a change. What is more likely is that the Court would be able to chip away at the right. Like conservative Courts have done to abortion since Roe's passage, with their decisions in Planned Parenthood v. Casey and Gonzales v. Cahart (though this trend stopped this year with Women's Whole Health v. Hellerstedt).
-
2016 Election Thread
Noooo! Okay fine. But Levi is a doo-doo head.
-
2016 Election Thread
Whatever. In one post you say it's an echo-chamber in here, and in the a second one, you say there's plenty of middle ground. I don't think your arguments are right-wing so much as oddly liberal-shaming, a recurrent past-time of yours. Liberals can seek to restructure the EC for legitimate reasons. The assumption that you keep going back to--that desire to change the EC is rash and based on butthurtness--is the most prominent strawman in this discussion.
-
2016 Election Thread
So the EC has nothing to do with the GOP and minority voters, but the reason we should keep the EC is because the Dems ignored a minority group (in this case rural whites)? Your rationale about tyranny of the majority just doesn't hold up to scrutiny.
-
2016 Election Thread
So when everyone disagrees with you they are guilty of being an echo-chamber?
-
2016 Election Thread
This is such bluster. Buddy, you're the one who is being deadset and oddly delighting in punishing those arrogant liberals. Why the heck should the Dems be punished for ignoring rural whites, when the EC has never punished the Republicans for ignoring nearly every minority group except rural whites? The EC actually empowers what you suggests it mitigates: campaigning in only swing states is not any kind of solution to represent all the people. When every vote counts, both sides will rally every vote both rural and urban. Had the Republicans lost, would you be arguing for an increase in EC votes for urban centers so that Republicans would pay more attention to minority voters? I think not.
-
2016 Election Thread
Right. That's what's being alleged here. We need to inflate the rural white vote because only they can overcome tyranny!!!
-
2016 Election Thread
Why should the EC force parties to pay attention to one group and not another. Why should Republicans get extra points for pandering to Western Rural voters, and the Democrats get no points for appealing to urban non-white voters. IT MAKES NO SENSE. One group is no more equipped to root out tyranny than any other group. And even if we accept the rationale that EC is designed to protect from the tyranny of the majority, is that what you are alleging what happened here? If not, that justification does not apply here. There might be some hypothetical reality where the current EC scheme really does give light to hidden voices which overcome the tyranny of the majority, but such hypotheticals give little solace when the outcome here had no such result.
-
2016 Election Thread
Stop questioning people's motives. No one here is advocating changing the EC because they lost this one time. The EC, gerrymandering, voting rights issues, god knows what else have given republicans procedural advantages throughout recent history; this isn't isolated butthurtness. People have every right to question the Electoral College, esp. given the result. The EC did not result in our better selves. The decency of a minority group did not overcome the majority vote's tyranny. Is this a proposal for forced desegregation? If not, the EC makeup shows no signs of including any other minority groups. Maybe all the LGTB should move to South Dakota, I guess?
-
2016 Election Thread
1) I'm not endorsing the popular vote. If we're going to have the EC, it's the extra votes that go to small population states that I have an issue with. Even without the "extra" EC votes from WY/MT/SD/ND, Trump wins the EC. 2) Again, not arguing for the popular vote. The reason Trump won the election was because of rural voters in Michigan and Penn. and Ohio and Florida, not because of rural voters in the Dakotas. The voices actually benefited with the outsized EC count were no more listened to in this election than ones past. 3) Rural Americans are not a special minority, with special rights that are distinct from any other group. This notion that they, specifically, deserve some built-in procedural advantage is the stuff affirmative-action is made of. Many minorities have a claim in fighting against the tyranny of a majority, shall we divvy more EC votes among them? 4) In an election close as this, every vote would have been counted and recounted, in that sense every vote would have mattered. Even had Clinton won, her victory would be without a mandate (as is Trump's). 5) I'd avoid painting those that disagree with you as butthurt. Come on, dude.
-
2016 Election Thread
That the North Dakota republican somehow deserves more weight than the California democrat defies that notion. If your point is that presidential elections ignore certain population groups, that applies equally to rural westerners as it does to those living on coastal cities. Moreover, not all urban populations have the same values, nor do all rural people. You're arguing as if the weighted EC applies to all rural voters throughout the country; it does not. It's very small portion of people (rural or not) who benefit from the weighted EC by living in either North Dakota, South Dakota, Wyoming or Montana. Most of rural America, in spite of your argument, live else where in the US. The rural Minnesota farmer, rural Arizona rancher, rural Michigan former-factory worker is not benefited by this scheme.
-
2016 Election Thread
Of course they would have had a plan to paint Sanders as a socialist elite. That much is obvious. But would it work? With Trumps overt ties/praise of Russia, and his own Billionaire status, his decries of elitism and even socialism stand a pretty good chance of falling flat against Sanders. I also think you're underestimating how reviled Clinton really was for the supposed corruption, not to mention the lack of enthusiasm from her own base (which low turnout corroborates). So, in your opinion, the Dems need to get more pro-capitalist, more centrist in order to win? I really don't think that's the lesson to derive from the results of this election. The question about whether Sanders could have one isn't so much about hindsight analysis but carving a way forward as liberals and Democrats. I'm done with risk-adverse, calculated, liberal-is-a-dirty-word Democrats, and I hope the rest of the liberals are too.