Everything posted by cmb0252
-
2013 Draft: The Boards
WARNING! Just in case you didn't know I'm not a professional scout and the Twins front office doesn't care what I have to say! I built this list from things I have read, videos I have seen, the few players I have seen live, and my gut.....which thanks to beer is a lot larger than it should be. I started making draft boards when the mlbnetwork started to air the draft, 3 years ago, and have found it makes the draft a lot more interesting. Like betting, but with out losing large amounts of money. By draft day I will have about 50 players ranked but for the forums sake I will only post my top 10. When I set up my board I not only go from 1-50 I also separate players into tiers. While the number next to their name shows where I rank them, in reality I could argue any player in that specific tier could be flipped around. While I specifically follow the Twins this board is ranked in talent, not need. I don't rank pitcher higher just because the Twins need them. With out further a do, here is my board. Feel free to tell me how dumb I am. Also, don't be scuurrred to post your own board. Tier 1 1) Jon Gray- Yes, I have Gray ahead of Appel. While Appel has a better third pitch and command, give me the guy with better "stuff". 80 grade fastballs don't grow on trees and I feel his slider is a grade above Appel's too. 2) Mark Appel- Long track record, above average command, and 3 pitches that range from 60-70 grade. Boras as his advisor doesn't bug me as much as the fact he has a ton of mileage on his arm already. Both him/Gray profile as aces. Tier 2 3)Kris Bryant- Leads all of college baseball in walks and more importantly HRs (by 6). While I put it around 40% that he could stick at 3B, at best, it wont matter because his bat will play any where. The only questions in my mind is if he will make enough contact to harness his 70 grade power. 4) Kohl Stewart- Is super athletic and already has two plus pitches in a 92-96 fastball with a hard breaking slider. Has a chance to have 4 above average pitches. He has a strong commitment to A&M but if he is selected high enough I don't think he will pass on baseball. The bigger issue are the injuries. 5) Clint Frazier- What can I say? I love bat speed! Quoting Law, "fastest bat speed in the draft-- possibly best I have seen from an amateur ever." While he will be stuck to a corner OF, he should be a plus defender in right, but like Bryant has a bat that can play anywhere. Biggest question is if he can make adjustments to big league pitching. Lots of swing and miss potential. 6) Meadows- Super athletic, has a chance to have plus power, 8 months younger than Frazier, and has a chance to stick at center. While he has a higher ceiling than Frazier my gut tells me Frazier is going to be a better big leaguer. Questions have come up about Meadows effort and commitment which scare me a little. Tier 3 7) Moran- Has a 4-1 BB/K ratio which isn't only insane but typically is a good indicator for future success. Has answered some questions about his power this year but there is a fear if he is moved from third to first he might become the next James Lonely. If you truly believe he can stick at 3B I could see an argument for having him higher. 8) Manaea- Big time lefty who even though his fastball was a tick down from the Cape Cod league was still a 60 grade pitch. While his change up has improved his slider, which was flashing a 70 grade, has been so inconsistent I don't know what to make of it. Also has injury concerns. 9) Shipley- Reminds me a lot of Zimmer from last year. Super athletic, converted SS, and has a 60 grade fastball/65 grade secondary pitch/average third offering that flashes plus. Difference is Zimmer had a 65 grade curve ball while 65 grade change up. Quoting Law again, "you can be taught a great change up, you are born with a great breaking ball." 10) Stanek- Came into the year as a top 5 talent but has slid due to inconsistency. Still has filthy stuff but just cant harness it. Due to his violent delivery some scouts see him as a reliever but if someone can fix his inconsistency issue they might have a steal. Has 3 pitches that could be plus.
-
2013 Draft: The Boards
After posting the "The Mocks" thread I realized that with out seeing draft boards they make little sense. With Law releasing his updated board some point today and BA releasing theirs tomorrow I figured no better time then the present. Im only posting boards that have been updated recently and from credible sources. As I say this don't be afraid of posting your personal draft board, if you are a nerd like me and actually have one, because they are helpful to sparking up debate. Christopher Crawford: http://mlbdraftinsider.com/2013/05/the-board-2013-volume-vii/ Jonathan Mayo: 2013 Prospect Watch | MLB.com: News Laws Board(stuck behind insider): http://insider.espn.go.com/mlb/story/_/id/9255085/mark-appel-jonathan-gray-kris-bryant-top-prospects-2013-mlb-draft Baseball America: http://www.baseballamerica.com/draft-preview/ Bleacher Report: http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1638411-mlb-draft-big-board-2013-mike-rosenbaums-complete-pre-draft-rankings Matt Garrioch: http://www.minorleagueball.com/2013/5/17/4335648/2013-mlb-draft-matt-garriochs-draft-board (Like with the mock page if you find one I missed post it on here and I will update the thread)
-
One Stop Shop for the 2013 Draft.
On ESPN, insider required, Jason Churchill put out an article called Draft Could Produce Run on Bats. It talks specifically about the age old Need vs BPA and how this is such a deep college pitching draft that teams might grab bats early. One executed said: " [There's] a better chance of getting that [college] pitcher with your second pick than the bat you're looking to add," said one high-ranking executive, whose club is not alone in such a realization. And: "top guys, Appel, Gray, Stanek, Shipley, those guys, they aren't going to fall out of the first round, the senior scout opined. "Some of the second-tier guys that have first-round abilities ... they could drop if the bats start to go quickly and teams react to it." While the Twins might he "stuck" taking a bat at 4 that doesn't mean they can't grab a college arm at 43. Last year after taking Buxton at two they went pitcher heavy and might do the same thing this year. Link to article below: http://insider.espn.go.com/mlb/blog/_/name/mlb_draft/id/9258106/with-much-dominant-young-pitching-mlb-focus-turned-bats-mlb
-
One Stop Shop for the 2013 Draft.
While I still don't think he will make it back to the Twins at 43 he has a significantly higher chance than he use to. Not only has the injury slowed him down but the whole living in Minnesota hasn't helped. His season just started while other HS prospects have finished up. When a HS season starts doesn't hurt a draft prospects ability, it does limit how much you get to see of them before the draft which might scare some teams off. He would be a steal at 43!
-
Scouting Reports
I saw this earlier and it was a pretty fun to read some of the scouting reports.
-
One Stop Shop for the 2013 Draft.
BA put out a nice article about this years draft class which they talk to the Astros new scouting director Mike Elias. Elias mentions that the group they are considering for the #1 pick is down to seven (doesn't give names) and talks about the pressure that comes with this high of pick. “It’s a little easier in one sense because there’s less guesswork as to who’s getting to you, so you can basically get as much information as you want on the players that you’re targeting,” Elias said. “The negative end of it is that it’s very time-consuming scouting those guys. Especially this year with there being several Friday night starters basically in contention for the spot, you’re using a lot of Fridays on those guys and it makes it difficult to scout and see the rest of the Friday night guys across the country. That’s one negative—and then yeah, it’s the No. 1 pick, so expectations are obviously very high. It’s good because you’re going to get a good player no matter what, but it’s a big decision, clearly, so there’s certainly a lot of pressure to deliver on it.” Link for the full article below: Sizing Up The Draft Class Of 2013 - BaseballAmerica.com
-
How you hope the draft falls
Your not wrong at all about him being pumped to go there. He loves A&M, loves football, and has family members there. I just find it hard to believe that the Twins would take a guy in the top 5 with out knowing if they could sign them. Especially the way the draft is set up now. While Stewart has stated many times how he wants to go to A&M he hasn't told teams not to draft him like kids have done in the past.
-
2013 Draft: The Mocks
Added a second mock from bleacher report which has the Twins taking Meadows.
-
How you hope the draft falls
If the Twins were to take Stewart at 4 you would figure they would know his "number" before pulling the trigger. From what is out there, still too early to be hearing about signability, but most experts see Stewart signing if he goes high enough.
-
May 8th
John Sickels from minorleagueball.com is in Iowa to see Cedar Rapids play Quad City.
-
How you hope the draft falls
While I would love to steal Anderson in the second round, which a month ago would have been impossible, but I can't get behind Manaea unless he shows some real improvements over the next three weeks. Kid just isn't the same player he was in the Cape.
-
How you hope the draft falls
During the Cape Cod league Manaea showed a 65-70 grade fastball, a 65-70 slider, and a 50 change up that had potential to be better. That's ace quality grades. Since the Cape Cod league Manaea has shown nothing to makes me feel he is a top 5 talent. His fastball has been sitting in the low 90s, was in the 80s last week, while his secondary stuff has been inconsistent at best. While he has been injured which might account for the quality of his stuff do you really want to take a guy at 4 with injury concerns? As for Shipley, while he has potential to be a front line starter, I'm just not a fan of his stuff. He is still very raw because he hasn't been pitching that long and is a risky pick that high IMO. Like most I prefer Bryant or Stewart to Frazier but that doesn't mean Frazier isn't a hell of a talent. Law mentioned that Frazier easily has the best bat speed in this draft and maybe the best bat speed he has seen. While bat speed doesn't guarantee success it is a good indicator.
-
2013 Draft: The Mocks
Thanks for the link! Updated now. And yeah, Meadows is the toolsy one while Frazier profiles as a power hitting COF. I would actually be OK with taking Frazier. Players with his kind of bat speed dont show up often.
-
2013 Draft: The Mocks
Thanks for the link! Updated now.
-
Draft Developments
Wow that is a development. While I personally prefer Frazier to Meadows, nothing in Johnson's draft history would lead me to believe they do. McDaniels is very creditable so I have no reason to doubt him.
-
2013 Draft: The Mocks
Appel was considered a lock to go number 1 or 2 last years and he fell. The draft can be a funny thing. Minorleagueball did a community mock last year and plan to do one again this year. Kind of neat getting a ton of fans of different teams together and see what happens.
-
2013 Draft: The Mocks
Added Crawfish Boxes (Astros equivalent to TwinkieTown) first mock. While this was not done by experts but fans its validity could be in question. The reason I added it was because as stated above these are for fun, they actually did a really good job, but mostly because of the user comments. It was interesting to read how Astro fan view the draft. While most want Appel/Gray there are plenty that prefer other players.
-
2013 Draft: The Mocks
Added the Bleacher Report mock. It has two picks so that's why there are two names!
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (5/6): That Dirty Baxendale
As Jeremy stated above Baxendale is an advanced college pitcher who should be expected to dominate "lesser" competition. AA will definitely be the level wHere we can actually start to judge his performance. His relief pitching numbers from instructional league mean nothing. As I say this there is reason to like Baxendale (especially if he has gained a tick on his fastball). He was expected to go a lot higher than the 10th round last year and I believe Law said he was a steal in the 10th round. Also, for those of you who follow Sickels would know he picked Baxendale as one of his sleeper prospects this year. He is a prospect. It just depends what you expect from him. He is a back of the rotation starter at best but that's a steal in the 10th round.
-
2013 Draft: The Mocks
Let's get one thing straight, mocks are for the fans. No matter how much analysis there is there is no way anyone is going to get things 100% right. Heck, if you get things 20% right you have done a pretty good job. Look at the Astros last year. They had the #1 pick and had months to figure out who they wanted but didn't decide till the last day who they were taking. Not only did most mocks have them taking Appel but even on draft day there were reports, obviously false ones, that said Appel and the Astros had reached agreement. Why do we care about them then? Obviously because we are fans and they are fun! OK, other than just being fun they gives at least a little in site into what might happen. While specific picks might be different usually the area where the player is chosen is pretty close and this is especially true in high picks. Which by now you should know the Twins have. Oh and did I mention they are fun? With a month to go there are going to be a ton of mocks coming out and I figured its better to keep them in one place than flood the forums. I will keep the latest mocks and links up to date. Also, I will only be posting mocks that have been posted in May seeing anything else is already out of date. Without further a do the mocks: Christopher Crawford: May 29th mock: Pick Stewart http://mlbdraftinsider.com/2013/05/the-mock-volume-vi-2/ Bleacher Report May 26th mock: Rosebaum Pick Stewart. Wells Pick Stewart http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1645725-2013-mlb-mock-draft-bleacher-reports-first-round-projection-battle Another one from Bleacher Report: May 28th: Pick Stewart http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1653351-2013-mlb-mock-draft-landing-spots-for-top-pitchers-in-first-round Crawfish Boxes: May 27th mock: Pick Stewart http://www.crawfishboxes.com/2013/5/27/4366154/tcb-2013-mlb-mock-draft-v2-0 Scout.com: May 27th: pick Stewart http://sbb.scout.com/2/1294726.html Baseball America: May 24th: Pick Stewart http://www.baseballamerica.com/draft/jim-callis-2013-mock-draft-2-0/ Sports illustrated: May 30th: Pick Frazier http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/mlb/news/20130530/mlb-mock-draft-2-0-kris-bryant-jonathan-gray-mark-appel-dave-perkin/ John Sickels: May 16th: Stewart http://www.minorleagueball.com/2013/5/16/4335316/2013-mlb-mock-draft-version-two-john-sickels-may-16 Law: May 30th: Stewart http://insider.espn.go.com/mlb/story/_/id/9322119/houston-astros-take-colin-moran-mark-appel-second-mock-draft-2013-mlb-draft Mayo: May 30th: Stewart http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20130530&content_id=48991342&vkey=news_mlb&c_id=mlb (Also, if you find a credible one I haven't post please post it and I will add it)
-
Article: Draft Preview: "Personal Cheeseballs" (Hitters)
Haha, I almost completely missed this article because it got pushed down pretty quick. Good read and I'm excited to see your next list with pitchers on it.
-
One Stop Shop for the 2013 Draft.
Bryant definitely has the arm and athletic ability to play RF but what do you do with Arcia? Move him to left? I actually think with Morny most likely leaving this year you can draft Bryant and have him up early in 2014 playing 1B.
-
One Stop Shop for the 2013 Draft.
After putting together several good starts in a row Stanek threw a very mediocre game last weekend. 5.1 innings, 7 H, 3 ER, 4/2 K/BB with reports that his stuff was really inconsistent during the outing. He is way too inconsistent to be a top 5 pick IMO. Shipley had a great game this past weekend but threw a clunker the week before. Like Zimmer last year, both converted position players, there is room to dream about them turning into aces but a ton of question marks. Also, I believe Jeremy has reported that the Twins aren't high on him.
-
One Stop Shop for the 2013 Draft.
The Twins are in a hard spot at #4. The year started with 3 elite pitchers in Appel, Stanek, and Manaea before the emergence of Gray. Due to inconsistency Stanek has most likely fallen out of the top ten while Manaea has been a mess himself. This leaves the draft with two top pitching prospects, which will most likely go 1-2, for the top four teams who all need pitching. Bryant, Frazier, and Meadows are great prospects, would be welcome additions to our minors, but they don't exactly fill any major need. We have the deepest group of young outfielders in the game and a bunch of fringe 3B. Clearly you don't draft for need but every Twins fan in the world was hoping for a college ace at 4. Then there is one of my personal favorites, Kohl Stewart. He is a pitcher with ace potential but is a HS arm with several big question marks. Add in the fact Johnson has only drafted 2 HS pitchers in his 33 top 5 round picks and I'm not sure I see the Twins pulling the trigger. Where does that leave the Twins? Some might suggest take a lesser player at 4 at a discount and spend the savings later but I'm not a fan. While we might not need one of the bats above there is a huge drop off of talent after the top 6 and I want a star if I'm drafting in the top 5. I also don't see punting the pick this year to get the #5 pick next year in what is currently considered a deeper class. Drafts are fluid and things change. There is no way to know if a better prospect will be there at 5. There isn't a ton of time left, college pitchers only get 3 more starts, before the draft. While everyone wants a college arm at 4 don't be surprised if it doesn't happen.
-
One Stop Shop for the 2013 Draft.
Baseball America has a weekly article called Ask BA which answers three reader questions a week. This week they had a very interesting draft question, also a question about the Twins own Adam Walker, but here is the draft question: The consensus is that 2013 is a relatively weak draft for top-end position players, especially from the college ranks. To put things in perspective, where would you have ranked San Diego third baseman Kris Bryant and Georgia high school outfielders Clint Frazier and Austin Meadows in the 2011 and 2012 drafts? What BA has to say is an interesting read and way too long to repaste here but here is the break down. In the 2012 draft Bryant, Meadows, and Frazier would be behind Buxton, Correa, and Zunio but in the same group as Almora which would put them in the 8-11 range overall. In the 2011 draft they would be behind Rendon and Starling (even though Starling's star has dimmed since the draft) but in the same group as Lindor which would put them in the 7-10 range in one of the deepest drafts ever. These placements focus on how the players were viewed before the draft and not what they have done since. For the full explanation of the question above or to reads the Adam Walker question click the link below: Ask BA: How Do Draft's Top Bats Stack Up? - BaseballAmerica.com