Everything posted by cmb0252
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
Crawford released his new board. Heavily linked to the Twins Gordon moves up to #6. Check out his top 50 draft prospects here: http://mlbdraftinsider.com/2014/05/the-board-2014-volume-iv/
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
Draft notes on Fedde, Tous, and Ramos from Callis: http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20140502&content_id=74018400¬ebook_id=74018908&vkey=news_&sid
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (5/1): Eight Games in the Org.
I rather Stewart's minor league numbers suffer by not throwing his best pitch to develop as a player.
-
Sickels top 150 prospect list
According to major league baseball's rookie status rules he is a prospect. While stupid, that is how it works.
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
Definitely an odd grade. I trust Law's grade.
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
Definitely seems to be the popular name right now. Super athlete with a good bloodline. Crawford has a draft chat tomorrow so I will get in a question about Gordon/Twins to him. Here are Law's future grades for Gordon: Hitting:50 Power: 55 Running Speed:60 Fielding Range:60 Arm:70 MLB.com definitely have different numbers: Hitting:55 Power:40 Running speed:60 Fielding range:60 Arm:60
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
Haha, maybe. Mayo also linked Gordon to the Twins.
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
Few more Law questions: Where do you see Kyle Freeland fitting into the MLB Draft? I know he wasn't on your most recent rankings, but earlier on you had mentioned him as a first round candidate. I've read some really glowing reports about him recently in other sources, so trying to get a handle. Klaw (1:08 PM) He came on over the last 4-5 weeks - one scout said he was a top 15 pick, then compared him to Chris Sale, which would say to me he should be the first overall pick, no? - although I know there are still concerns about him starting between the delivery and heavy use of the slider. Been up to 96 as a starter and holding low 90s through his outings. Is Alex Jackson going to end up in the outfield or is there a chance he can stay at c/3b? Klaw (1:12 PM) I believe he'll end up at 3b/rf. I think he could catch, but the team that drafts him will likely take the Myers/Harper route.
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
I meant to put 60 for the arm not 70. Not sure what i was thinking. Mlb pipeline has his hit/power both at 60 and arm at 55. Law has his future tools at 65 hit/60 power/60 arm. Matt Garrioch suggests he has 30+ HR potential which would put his power well above 60. Here is what Crawford reported one scout had to say after seeing Jackson: "I think Jackson is the best hitter in the class," an NL scout said. "He had some timing issues early in the year, but he's impressed me with the way he's made adjustments. I think you're looking at a guy who can hit .300 and give you 25-30 homers during his best seasons, and I don't see any other hitter with that kind of potential this season at either the college or high school level. I think he's going to end up in right field, and he should be an All-Star there." This scout also suggests 25-30 HR power that would put his power tool at 65+. Maybe I'm dreaming on him but with a little work on his mechanics I can see a 65 hit/65 power RFer.
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
If Hoffman doesn't pitch again before the draft he would have a serious arm issue. Without knowing what it is it is hard to say. As for poor performance as long as his stuff is still top notch I would still look at taking him at 5. I would explore both options but would prefer to move him to RF if his bat is as good as advertised. 65 hit, 65+ power, with a 70+ arm is a potential all star even in RF.
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
My current top 10 by tier is the following: Tier 1: 1. Aiken 2. Kolek 3. Rodon Tier 2: 4. Hoffman (if healthy could be moved to tier 1) 5. Jackson Tier 3 6. Holmes 7. Beede (could move up or fall depending on his next couple starts) 8. Gordon 9. Zimmer 10. Freeland
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
Gordon is a solid prospect and he should at least be in the conversation at 5. Personally I have him in the tier below Jackson. It is interesting that both Mayo/Callis have the Phillies taking Gordon a year after drafting J.P. Crawford.
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
Callis and Mayo took a crack at the top 10 and both ended up having the Twins draft Jackson. It was one of four picks they agreed on. Here is the link: http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article/mlb/mlbpipelines-first-year-player-draft-experts-update-top-10-draft-projections?ymd=20140430&content_id=73746266&vkey=news_mlb
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
Great write up. Definitely agree.
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
I believe you definitely can but I'm not a professional scout so feel free to disagree. Part of the fun of following the draft/prospects is building your own board and discussing how you got there. Even if we all had the exact same information we might not reach the same opinion. My info points to Zimmer and Freeland being nothing alike but maybe your info does.
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
Keith Law's scouting report for Zimmer (#10 prospect to start the year): "Zimmer will show you two 70-grade pitches in addition to his 93-97 mph fastball -- a yellow hammer curveball with depth and angle, and a mid-80s changeup with great arm speed and some late action to it. He's an outstanding athlete, as you might expect from a converted position player, and has less mileage on his arm than most college products. He does use a fourth pitch, a below-average slider that he needs to junk or at least limit to just a few pitches a game.... Zimmer finished his season on fire, punching out 63 and walking eight in his last eight starts of the summer, half of them after a promotion to Double-A Northwest Arkansas, and as long as his shoulder is happy he should move quickly to Triple-A. He's the future ace the Royals have been trying to develop since they traded Zack Greinke." While Freeland has a better mix of pitches and command he doesn't have a single one that is a potential 70 pitch. Zimmer has 2. Also, Zimmer's main secondary pitch is a big curve. You could definitely be right about the delivery. I haven't seen Zimmer pitch in a year. On a different note....how lucky are his parents for having two potential top 10 pick sons? I'm a huge fan of younger brother Bradley Zimmer. Wish he had at least one plus-plus tool so I could make a legit argument that the Twins should draft him at #5.
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
I don't see the comparison. One is lefty while one is a righty. One is a freak athlete while the other is average. While they both are draft risers it is for different reasons. Zimmer had, has, significantly better "stuff" then Freeland but not the control. Zimmer has ace potential while Freeland has #2 potential but a better chance to reach it. If you get a #2 pitcher at #5 in the draft not only would it not be a bad thing but a success. While I wouldn't be upset with Freeland but I would not be excited. I personally have 9-10 prospects ahead of him. Also, I'm not sure if you would get much if any of a discount taking him #5.
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
I would also be very....very disappointed if they took Nola. I personally have him 13th on my board. If the Twins are going to take a 6'2 pitcher at #5 with no projection give me Holmes. Not only does he have a better delivery but two pitches that are 65+.
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
Callis and Mayo are answering draft questions on Tweeter. Will Twins miss out on 4 player top tier? Callis: may not get a shot at Aiken, Rodon, Kolek, Hoffman. Jackson is still a very good option at 5. Who are Twins looking at if Aiken, Rodon, Hoffman, Kolek are off the board, besides Jackson? Mayo: Nola, Gordon. How is Beede? Callis: Beede less consistent recently, not impossible he could fall out of top 10 with quality of arms available. Does Nola have front line guy stuff, or more 3/4 SP? Mayo: Maybe No.2/VG No. 3? Plus pitch ability with good stuff. Can Beede move higher than 6-10? Mayo: right now, I don't see him hitting top 5, but way to go still. Who rates better pre draft between Gordon and JP Crawford? Callis: almost identical, really. Gordon better on mound!
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
Draft articles from Callis and Mayo: http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article/mlb/much-pitching-talent-in-this-years-mlb-draft?ymd=20140429&content_id=73636490&vkey=news_mlb http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article/mlb/jonathan-mayo-brady-aiken-tyler-kolek-vying-to-be-no-1-mlb-draft-pick?ymd=20140429&content_id=73423150&vkey=news_mlb
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
Agreed. Once Buxton/Sano graduate we might not have a single top 100 hitter.
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
Outside of an injury I have a hard time seeing him fall to us. Too bad because his arm is electric.
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
Definitely a lot of things I don't agree with on this list but that usually happens when Mayo is involved. Still fun the click through.
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
Crawford's new mock is up and has the Twins taking Jackson. He s going too host a chat, no sure when, but I will try and push the questions forward. http://mlbdraftinsider.com/2014/04/the-mock-2014-volume-iii/
-
2014 MLB Draft Thread
Crawford had a great quote from a scout on Nola after his worst performance of the year this weekend: "One bad start isn't going to make you not take a guy," an NL West scout said. "But it is a reminder that the margin of error for pitchers who rely more on command than dominating stuff is thin, and that's the case with [Nola]. I still think he's one of the safest college pitchers in this year's class, but if you're expecting anything more than a low-end third starter, you are setting your expectations too high, in my opinion."