Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Brandon

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Brandon

  1. If WAR costs an average of 8 million. He needs to be worth 12 WAR to justify the contract. If he produced 6 WAR in his first 2 years any positive value the last 2 years are surplus value anyways. It's fun to bend stats.
  2. Definitely, not a bad idea. If we don't go out and get a difference maker or top of the rotation arm having a good swingman makes sense if not another depth arm. I am not sold on Homer yet. I think he could be better or he could be a Martin Perez redux. having an extra arm is about all that we need to wrap up the offseason. Not saying we absolutely have to have another arm either as we do have several arms ready to come up and a few more that are close enough. but having one more depth option if not an ace is a good idea.
  3. Is the entire Marlins staff better than Odorizzi? If so they should be a good team.
  4. I am now happy with the off-season. A solid B grade. A-/B+ with one more solid pitching addition.
  5. Brandon posted a blog entry in Brandon's Blog
    It seems like the Twins are settling in on a 4-year window of being competitive. Last year the Twins signed 2 of their core players to 5-year contracts totaling just over 60 million. Note, they now have 4 years left on those extensions. Just a few days ago the wins signed Sano to an extension that has a guaranteed 3-year extension with a 4th year option. The Twins are looking to sign Donaldson to a 4-year contract as well. I am beginning to think the longer Donaldson doesn’t sign the better our odd are of signing him become. I think the more extensions they sign that give more payroll certainty, the more the Twins will feel comfortable increasing their offer to JD and get the deal done. As far as the other position players go, we have 5 years control on Garver, 3 years for Buxton, and 5 years for Arreaz. That is 7 of the 9 starters who are locked up for 3 years and 6 can be locked up for 7. The 2 positions not locked up the full 4 years are DH/ 1B and LF. The Twins have Killeroff, Rooker, Raley, Larnarch and Blankenship among others. To replace Gonzales as the everywhere player is Lewis. He has shown he can play CF, 3B and SS in the minors. He can come up and be an everyday player at every position. In the pen and back of the rotation there were numerous pitchers who have shown they can be effective in those roles. It’s a matter of giving them another year to show who is really ready and who is not. As far as extensions go for pitchers; if we can sign May and Rogers in the pen to extensions and Berrios and maybe Odorizzi in the rotation, we would have a really strong core locked up and quite a few young pitchers with years of team control remaining. That makes the next 4 years where the Twins are working around the edges and looking for a star starting pitcher to come here. Looking forward at the next 4 years starting in 2024, the Twins will still have 2-3 years control for players coming up like Killeroff, Larnarch, Lewis, Rooker, Baddoo. Plus, they will have any players extended in arbitration under control for an extended period of time like Arreaz? Garver? On the pitching side the picture is not as clear but as of now we have Graterol as either a starter or reliever, Balazovich is on his way, and we have numerous other pitchers who came up in the last year or next year and may be at the back of the rotation or in the pen as well such as Thorpe, Smeltzer, Littell, Dobnak, Alcala, Wells, Jax, Stashak, and so many more. And the Twins will have 4 years to develop other players and pitchers as well and the Twins could be well set up to have another 4-year window….
  6. I'm fine with the Bailey signing. I don't feel he is too much of a downgrade over Bumgarner and is in par with Gibson. I feel the Twins were aggressive with Wheeler offering mlbtraderumors predicted 100 million early in the process. I got the sense the Twins would go a little higher AAV for a three year contract for Ryu. Where I will get annoyed is if the Twins won't step up and be willing to overpay a little to get Donaldson. If we don't get a key player over a difference of 10 million over 4 years or less it will be maddening. We are just like the Terry Ryan teams of having a good floor and the next upgrade up is expensive. I wouldn't ask the Twins to pay o erage costs on lots of players but once in a while an overpay that brings a difference maker would be nice.
  7. I don't know. If we are already willing to spend 20 million on Bryant or Donaldson, I think paying Donaldson an extra 5 million or even 8 million a year and having Killeroff and Graterol during their low cost years makes more sense then a trade.
  8. Fred McGriff is at 493 career HRs. The strike cost him the shot at 500 and he either barely made it or just missed it. So 500 HRs is required. Also there are very few players with 1525 or more RBI not in the Hall of Fame. Cruz is a long way from that many RBI so I doubt he gets in. Though if he hits his 500th in a Twins uniform and is a World Series key contributor he could make the Twins Hall of Fame
  9. I also got from that report the Twins haven't been asked to submit their final and best offer. I imagine they would go higher to win the bidding. If they are at 85 million then 90 or 95 would be tops. Of the three teams, Atlanta, DC, and Twins, it looks as though the Twins have the most financial flexibility to sign him...they just need to meet his asking price or be closer to it.
  10. It's definitely a game a chicken That's for sure. I don't think JD has over played his hand yet as he does have the floor of what Washington offered. So if we back out he can go to DC or sign with Atlanta. I don't think we backed out just don't think he will sign here. I imagine we get a contract negotiated with someone else like Moreland next week and make one last round to JD and up the offer a little with a 24 hour time limit or we sign Moreland......
  11. 110/8 = 13.75. if JD signs for 110 million he needs to produce 13.75 WAR to justify the contract. He produced around 6 last year. 13.75 is just shy of 3.5 WAR per season. I feel like even with regression he should be able to hit the number or close to it. I don't think it's a huge overpay to sign him. If there was ever a time to strike it is now. But if the Twins want to play chicken with him and the other teams over 10 million whatever. They should make a small concession when he is ready to sign if no one else blinks to get him here.
  12. He will make 12 starts and pitch 63 innings and go 5-3 with a 4.20 ERA. With 52 Ks and 28 BBs. Control takes a while to come back after surgery and that messes with his success a little.
  13. While the Twins posture and possibly walk away from Donaldson we are left wondering what are options are for an impact upgrade. The only other big one I see is a trade for Kris Bryant with the Cubs. They are asking alot but we fans are practically demanding the front office put up or shut up. So with an impact move that needs to be made do we trade for Bryant or go with JD s demand for 110 million? What would we need to give up to get 2 seasons of Bryant? larnarch, Graterol, Jeffers? I am not.going to pretend I know what it would.take.to make this trade but I am sure it's not cheap. What do you think the Twins should be do?
  14. I would call last season a success. I would say the front office needs to step up and pay the price to improve the team. I think signing Donaldson is a step in the right direction. If Donaldson can be a 5-7 war player the first 3 seasons and a 2-3 the 4th season it's a win for us. The contract is right at the end of our comfort zone or what should be our comfort zone. The Twins should give him the 110 million with a 12-24 window to sign and start negotiating with Moreland in the meantime so they can pivot away from him immediately if he doesn't sign. If the Twins are truly out of the running then Atlanta can sign him for whatever he wants and JD will have overplayed his hand. I think Washington is only in at this point to keep the bidding higher. If the bottom drops out they will gladly sign him but I don't think they will break the bank to sign him. I think what the Twins are doing is exposing this to JD by saying they are going to walk away from the table. And if you want to sign with Atlanta you can do it on their terms and if you want to get the best offer, you can sign what we have out there. I imagine the Twins would budge a little as a consession to get a deal done maybe 4 million or 1 million a year, but not up to 110 million.
  15. Maybe they circle back and get Price for the rotation. Not much else you can do.
  16. When Donaldson signs with the Twins, we will have 6 30+ HR hitters on the team so if one of them leads off, it's ok.
  17. Do it. If the Twins are going to punt on the pitching, we need to help what pitching we have and we also need to bludgeon the opposing team offensively.
  18. I will like the signings with one more upside play. If we could sign one of Walker or Wood. With more lottery tickets you increase the odds of hitting on one. We have 4 starter prospects who can either start or are good fill ins for a start or two. We also have several others on the way up so we have lots of opportunities for a starter to step up and be a number 2/3 starter. Rotation Berrios Odorizzi Pineda replacement for 6 weeks Homer Bailey The 4 who can step in Graterol Smeltzer Thorpe Dobnak Several others should be ready at various points throughout the season as well Jax Poppen Wells Alcala It will be interesting to see how this plays out. Though again I would be happier with a Wood or Walker signing to top this off.
  19. I was thinking maybe the Twins upped their offer or have a highly competitive offer out there. I think if leaked by Minnesota is to show their fans we have a 4 year offer out there so we are definitely competitive. They are putting their money out there. It's just waiting to be accepted. I just wished they could've leaked the dollar amount too so we can judge the offer ourselves.
  20. https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2019/12/twins-have-made-4-year-offer-to-josh-donaldson.html Hopefully this offer gets accepted as it would be a good way to wrap up the off-season. Big improvement on offense, improvement in the pen, and status quo with upside in the rotation.
  21. When Donaldson is 37 he will likely still be able to put up a .750+ OPS. He walks alot and power is the last thing to go. His average will drop as he ages. Think .220-.230/.320/.430. His defense will drop as well but should still be adequate. He will basically be Todd Frazier at 37. That's still worth around 10 million. So I am fine signing Donaldson. Now is the time we need his bat the most. If he is worth 10 million and on that last year we are paying 24-25 million we are paying that extra 14-15 million for the production the first 2 years of the deal. This is not a tragic overpay. I suspect though that this is worst case scenario. He could be moved to 1B/DH and hit better and field better at 1B. It's his reaction times that will drop not his fundamentals.
  22. I rate it incomplete. The Twins had impact starting pitcher in the list and it isn't done yet. Also 1B/3B needs to be resolved. There are lots of options for the corner IF and they all but Donaldson replace what we got for Cron so at worst we will be even there. If we get Donaldson then it's a big Improvement. Our bullpen is improved as we get Romo and Clippard for the year. On the rotation while we are hoping for a big upgrade, finding pitchers to outperform what Gibson and Martin gave us last year needs to happen at minimum. Incremental improvements on a 101 win team should be as good as we can do. Donaldson is the variable at this point which can swing our off-season pendulum.
  23. The Twins traded Denny Neagle for Jon Smiley back in 1992. That was the last time I remember the Twins trading a top prospect for pitching. Jay Bell as part of a package for Bert Blylevin back in 1985.
  24. The best reason to sign Donaldson? That would give us a lineup where our 3B Donaldson, 1B Sano, C Garver, and DH Cruz all had an OPS at or over .900. Add in other line up members Polanco, Rosario, Buxton, and Kepler who all had OPS over .800. Arreaz should be atleast a .750 OPS and our bench did well too. Add Moreland at 1B instead and our lineup I still strong but with Donaldson we are several levels above the Whitesox Even with all their improvements.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.