Everything posted by LaBombo
-
The 2013 Davenport Projects released
Sure. They lost Span and Revere, and there's a chance that neither Hicks or Mastro will measure up immediately as offensive replacements. Willingham is 34 and a candidate for some regression from his career year. Doumit will be 32 and is coming off a career high for PA's, so a tad less production in 2013 seems plausible. Carroll is 113 in middle infielder years. The rest of the middle infielders might be better than last year, but by how much?
-
Hicks - Hunter comparison
Really? It would seem like the pitchers who really matter when evaluating hitters in spring training would be working on the control of off-speed offerings and ensuring that the arm angle and release match the fastball as closely as possible. But maybe you're right, that a crucial phase of the game magically disappears in an otherwise really meaningful set of exhibition games. Does that make a bunch more sense than the possibility that a kid who has been christened the default opening day center fielder by a borderline-negligent organization, and by much of the media and fan base as Torii Hunter and Kirby Puckett's love child, would be, I dunno, maybe pressing a bit, overly aggressive even? Yeah, silly me.
- Hicks - Hunter comparison
-
Plouffe out at least a week
Totally agree. Just thought it was interesting to see that the staff is pre-exonerated for... whatever this turns out to be. At this point I'm much more interested in seeing the Twins field players worth keeping healthy than I am in the Chicago Hope theatrics of the people who are supposed to keep them healthy.
-
Plouffe out at least a week
It seems to me like there's an old story that Mark Twain once comforted a friend who was nervous about giving a speech by telling him something like "Don't worry, they're probably not expecting much." And that's pretty much where I am with the Twins trainers and medical people. All they have to do is make it through the season without performing an unnecessary amputation or incinerating a player with a massive Bengay overdose, and I'll be happy. Plouffe's injury, if it lingers, is the kind of thought exercise I'd want to avoid if I were hitting the division contender Kool-aid especially hard this season. How many competitive franchises in MLB would be forced to admit that their best backup option at third base is an adorable hobbit with 13 career home runs and an AARP card?
-
Plouffe out at least a week
Important dates in science fiction history: August 4, 1997 - SkyNet becomes self-aware. August 29, 1997 - SkyNet launches preemptive strike against the USSR. March 10, 2013 - SkyNet launches preemptive defense of Twins medical staff.
- Hicks - Hunter comparison
-
Hicks - Hunter comparison
Maybe if we're desperate for a twins CF comp for Hicks, we should start thinking Player B to keep expectations in line. He was a switch hitter who struggled from one side (albeit RH), had good plate discipline, some pop, and contact issues: Hicks: AA age 22. 472 AB .286/.384/.460 79 BB 116K 13HR 32SB 11CS Player B: AA age 21 516 AB .287/.398/.450 94 BB 117K 15HR 29SB 7CS B was a third rounder who was less highly regarded than Hicks but who marched through the minors without a level repeat. Half season of AAA and midseason call up at 22. 98 AB .265/.351/.327 before knee injury ended season. Struggled following year in 392 mlb AB's posting .232/.303/.296. Put it together at age 24, 525 AB .291/.372/.434 12HR 19SB 5CS as the Twins CF in 1996...
-
Reusse: Always are Angry Twins Followers
Don't feel too bad. You made some good points, but using mere logic to tackle a post with "love" and "Pohlads" in the same sentence is like handling anti-matter with salad tongs.
-
Gibson has a crazy wild outing
It's a starter/reliever thing for me, but great call on the comp. Also, Gibson strikes me as more of a likeable Nook Laloosh rube than a veteran of the California Penal League: http://www.minnpost.com/sites/default/files/KyleGibsonTwinsHeadShot210.jpg "Raye Anne, right? That's a beautiful name. Is that Greek? It's a beautiful name. There's a great song by Motley Crue. Do you know it? Raye Anne, she's a stay on..."
-
Gibson has a crazy wild outing
But we've already got one of these dudes, don't we? That Deduno guy who kept hitting the mascot last year, right? http://i.imgflip.com/gjf8.gif One more reason Gibson doesn't start the season on the 25 man...
-
Parmelee Out With Groin Injury.
Dear World Baseball Classic, Please go away. Or at least don't conflict with spring training. It's embarrassing to see players who've almost all just had five months off leave work the first or second week back. Thanks, LaBombo
- Hicks - Hunter comparison
-
Hicks - Hunter comparison
It's always nice to see a prospect look sharp in spring training, especially one who everyone hopes to see with the big club sometime this season. That being said, Hicks' homers say much more about what a ridiculously ineffective gauge of a player's ability spring training is than they say about Hicks. It's great for his confidence, but I'm just looking for him to make contact and get on base. If he adds power to the tool box, bonus. Regarding future potential, Hicks will go as far as his left-handed swing will take him. Everything else is there, from all accounts. And I'll throw Carlos Beltran into the mix for comps. Toolsie switch hitter, much more effective batting right-handed. They're grain of salt at best, but here are the Cube's grades for their offense: Beltran: Speed 77 Contact 54 Patience 71 Batting Average 62 Power 70 Hicks : Speed 78 Contact 47 Patience 94 Batting Average 60 Power 68 Beltran is a perennial All Star, so of course he represents the best case outlier for Hicks. How about 'Poor man's Carlos Beltran' as a realistic goal, with Hicks partially compensating for lower average and much less power (the cube vastly under-rates Beltran) with more walks and maybe a bit better defense. I'd be very happy with that, and I'll bet the Twins would be too.
- Joe Benson leading off?
-
Article: Are Gibson, Hicks Destined For Rochester?
It's not a precise science, but yeah, hitters can easily lose 30 or 40 points of average in transition from AAA to the majors. 50 might be a little bit over the average non-PCL drop. But then you throw in the intangible of a guy with one season above A ball struggling to adjust to his first two-league jump and pressing when he scuffles, and yeah, an MLB equivalency average 50 points below your hypothetical AAA .230 average seems very plausible. Liked your take on spring training, though. There's definitely a psychological element to the sorting process of spring training, especially when a non-contender has multiple unknown quantities battling for roster spots.
-
Berardino: Boggs Looking To Replace Thome
Beyond parody, yet part of what makes ST interesting for a non-contender like the Twins. Almost nothing is too crazy to contemplate, not even a '30 year old non-prospect vs. 106 year old retired HOF'er' cage match for a roster spot that may or may not exist. Can Hrbek referee, please? On the other hand, there's maybe a glimmer of hope for the Twins in this. Their interest in Boggs and his lone possible skill of getting on base may represent a quantum leap ahead 20 years in talent valuation philosophy, all the way into the late 1980's. Suck it, baby steps! Next stop, the 21st century!
-
Article: Are Gibson, Hicks Destined For Rochester?
As for the "paragon" snark about the Rays, well, they certainly are a paragon of both competitiveness and payroll efficiency compared to the Billy Smith-era Twins. In the past 5 seasons the Rays have averaged 91+ wins and made the playoffs three times despite playing in the same division as a team against which the Twins have managed nothing but a decade-long collective pants-wetting.
-
Article: Are Gibson, Hicks Destined For Rochester?
Uh, dude, you know that actually happened, right? Before we get to that, Hicks/Upton is an apples-to-atom bombs comparison. Upton was an unbelievable phenom who had exactly one season of minor league experience when he mastered AA and then mashed AAA pitching for a half season (.311/.411/.519). At the ripe old age of 19. Playing shortstop. Until 2012, the perennial debate about Hicks every spring was whether that would be the year the organization would give up on his switch hitting and go righty-only after he struggled constantly from the left. And at age 20, he was repeating Beloit. Bad comp. Where was Upton in his age 20 season? Despite acquitting himself very nicely for a 19 year old in the majors, posting a .258/.324/.409 line there in 159 AB's, he spent the entire following year in AAA and didn't play the majority of a season in the majors until three years later, when his service time started. So the "unprimed" Upton who mashed in the playoffs had over 1000 AAA at bats despite being a much more promising prospect than Hicks in the minors, and the Rays delayed his service time clock two years until age 22 despite his having hit AAA well and holding his own in the majors at 19.
-
Mackey: Tom Kelly has changed his tune on Brian Dozier
Dozier seems to epitomize the kind of player most fans DO like, but who seems like a bit of a long shot to be an everyday player for a contender. And yes, he's only one guy, but so far part of a lengthy cautionary tale about skipping AAA in a year where the two most exciting Twins prospects are apparently being considered for...skipping AAA. At any rate, it's nice to hear that Kelly, who is a merciless evaluator of rookie fundamentals, thinks he's made progress. Lord knows there's not much else to be excited about with the other middle infield suspects.
-
Lots of good reports about Kyle Gibson...
Agree to disagree on the effect on cost. But how does the timing itself not have the potential to impact payroll in a big way? Would you rather have had the Twins determine whether or not to give Nick Blackburn $13 million for 2011-13 before his stinkbomb 2010 campaign, or after? How is this even possible? He was hardly lights out in AAA (though better than his ERA) before the injury, and after it he's thrown a total of six innings against hitters higher than A ball. The Twins may bring him up out of self-inflicted necessity at the rate they're going, but I can't imagine how Gibson being "clearly ready", or even completely healthy for that matter, can be determined by a handful of spring training innings.
-
Lots of good reports about Kyle Gibson...
So in effect you're saying that even if less team control were to make an extension more expensive, it won't matter because they can afford it, but would never use the saved money on a worthwhile FA or other means to improve?
-
Lots of good reports about Kyle Gibson...
Good, now I know that you get how I feel about reading your repeated, misinformed ravings over this same topic. Yes, let's magically wave away the concept of team control with An Extention! That's it! The enchanted kind signed with a pen fashioned from the horn of a unicorn, and that is totally and utterly unaffected by the length of team control. That's the irrelevant concept which necessitates a player living with a series of one year deals whose value is decided by a stranger with a limited knowledge of the player's actual value. Team control affects the cost of an extension. The end.
-
Lots of good reports about Kyle Gibson...
The cost of that extension is directly related to the length of team control, so you've spent an entire thread arguing that a team with a decidedly finite payroll should disregard money. That sounds foolish to me. As for the reputation of the organization, I'd like to see it bolstered by not gambling on disco demolition night stunts like bringing up kids who aren't ready, with the goal of profiting from the hopes of the few fans who are knowledgeable to know who guys like Hicks and Gibson are but not knowledgeable enough to know they're not ready.
-
Article: Where are they now: Former Twins in big league camps
Another reason to respect the Rays' approach to the game...