Everything posted by LaBombo
-
Who could have seen this Pelfrey start coming...
Barring injury, Nolasco and Hughes aren't leaving the rotation after two months' worth of struggling, let alone two starts' worth. That leaves Correia, who was better than Deduno last year, Pelfrey, who was arguably better and had better seasons than his 2013 before TJ, and Gibson, who was worse than Deduno but has the 2014 rotation's only win and its only ERA under 6. Deduno will get his chances to start at some point, either due to injury or ineffectiveness of the front five. Until then, he should continue to work on turning himself into a relief pitcher. Most relievers in MLB were starters at one point in their careers, so it's an extremely common career arc and the odds are he'll get it figured out eventually. In fact, you could argue that he already has, with the exception of control, already started to do so based on his high K rate and low FIP/xFIP. Like the rotation, he's a work in progress as a reliever, and I hope he continues to progress. He's fun to watch when he's on, and entertaining in an America's Funniest Videos sort of way when he's not.
-
Game Thread: Twins v Athletics, 4/10 @ 12:10pm CT
That's because Pelf was pitching. It's a totally different vibe now with Nolasco or Hughes on the mound.
-
Article: Why is Joe Mauer Such a Lightning Rod?
The failure to defend Mauer from at least the unfair portion of that belief rests squarely on Ryan and St. Peter. Mauer probably has caused them to pass at times on signing free agents or get rid of guys they couldn't afford to keep, and he probably will again before his deal is up. But money hasn't been an issue for three seasons now, and arguably four, based on their own guidelines for spending vs. revenue. They've consistently underspent, and whatever the wisdom of that, it's pretty compelling proof that Mauer's contract hasn't been holding them back. Being more up front about that might take some heat off of Mauer, and put it where it belongs, on management and ownership.
-
Gardy's Favorite Axe Brand
Not sure how Rick Anderson keeps his job if the rotation is one of the three or even five worst in the AL again. As for Gardy, you could rightly point out that he's in the right place for lightning to strike twice. The only time since WWII that a non-expansion manager was retained by his team after four consecutive 90+ loss seasons, it happened here in Minnie to Tom Kelly. So he's in the right place to avoid accountability, in theory. Two problems with that. One, Kelly had two World Series rings and the enormous respect and gratitude that they commanded from the franchise. Gardenhire is highly regarded, but his post-season record isn't get-out-of-jail-free card that Kelly's was. If anything you could argue it's the opposite. Two, that Twins team had a different owner, one who cared so little for it that he didn't just try to sell it to out-of state buyers, he tried to eliminate it for profit and started exploring that option before Kelly's last year even began. Why would he waste time hiring it a new manager? Gardenhire's job probably is safe, and yet to assume so requires ignoring not only a mountain of historical trends, but plummeting TF attendance figures at a time when the league-wide numbers are up. However secure his job may seem, those are two very difficult factors to overcome. Also, what's it say that your employer recognizes the longevity represented by 1000 wins by giving the gift of carcinogens? Nothing, I know, but the irony is a little fun.
-
Article: Why is Joe Mauer Such a Lightning Rod?
So somehow Mauer's value was diminished because most teams during his catching career relied on catchers who were half the hitter he was? You realize that's a fantastic argument in favor of the notion that Mauer has been incredibly valuable, right?
-
Game Thread: Twins v Athletics, 4/10 @ 12:10pm CT
May have to avoid the game thread tomorrow night. Not sure I can stomach the virtual certainty that someone will lament the Twins' failure to sign Bruce Chen...
-
Article: Why is Joe Mauer Such a Lightning Rod?
Ten days into the season, it's pretty safe to say that's yet to be determined. In the mean time, yes, we "apologists" will continue to point to the decade he spent as a Hall of Fame caliber hitter, "for a catcher". The words you chose made it appear that such a standard is widely discredited, when the opposite is in fact true.
-
Game Thread: Twins v Athletics, 4/10 @ 12:10pm CT
That, or bad coaching. However unlikely, it's possible that Gallego told Punto, "See if you can find a spot that you can't score from, and also can't safely return to third from!" Had to laugh when I saw the play, because it was the perfect mirror image of the trademark Punto fake hustle play, 'running out the fly ball'. Which is great, unless you do it the Punto way. At least once a week you'd see him running hard for the next base after hitting a fly, and ending up in exactly the wrong place when the catch was made. Less than half way, full throttle, head down, virtually guaranteeing that if the fielder were to muff the catch he'd just get thrown out sliding head first when the fielder or another one backing him up recovered it. Good to see that even long after his departure from the Twins, all those lessons at the Yasiel Puig's Dad Baserunning Academy are still paying off for Li'l Nick.
-
Game Thread: Twins v Athletics, 4/10 @ 12:10pm CT
Figured they would, but thanks for confirming it. Takes away some of the disappointment of missing the first half of the game.
-
Game Thread: Twins v Athletics, 4/10 @ 12:10pm CT
The 'Punto plays the game the right way' narrative was an aggravated assault on reason and empiricism. His base running buffoonery today has renewed my gratitude for Bill Smith's decision to surgically separate him from Gardenhire's hip.
-
Article: Why is Joe Mauer Such a Lightning Rod?
He was indesbutably an elite hitter as a catcher. He's not at first until the prognostications about big silver lining jumps in offensive quantity and quality about the switch come true for the next half decade.
-
Article: Why is Joe Mauer Such a Lightning Rod?
Has there ever been a more succinct, precise, compact and yet comprehensive summary of how the Twins have utterly and lately abysmally failed to capitalize on having one of the best players in the history of the game for a decade?
-
Article: Why is Joe Mauer Such a Lightning Rod?
Thanks for that; until now I had no idea what an arrogant knucklehead Verlander is: AB 62 2b 4 HR 3 RBI 9 BB 12 SO 10 AVG .371 OBP .473 SLG .581 OPS 1.053 Tip for Verlander: The next time you feel the inexplicable need to denigrate the game of one the best hitters in baseball, you might want to check ESPN Batter vs Pitcher and see if that player has kicked the living crap out of you at the plate, equaling or bettering his insanely great career year rates in the process...
-
Article: Why is Joe Mauer Such a Lightning Rod?
If there's a primary way to value a player without taking into account his position, we're all ears. Who is not all ears is the Hall of Fame, which Mauer "apologists" rightly point out he was well on his way to before the concussion, and wonder why that requires an apology. Not judging a player's offense relative to the peers of his era at his a position is a practice rapidly disappearing as the voters of the Reusse/Hartmann generation retire and the sun sets on the RBI's/Wins/'Popularity with the media' Age.
-
Article: Why is Joe Mauer Such a Lightning Rod?
Some interesting takes on Mauer, and my net takeaway is that there are a surprising number of reasons (and of varying legitimacy) for disliking Mauer. Will throw one more into the mix. In a discussion of the hand-wringing over Mike Piazza's defensive issues in his prime, Bill James posited that there's a very strong tendency for bad franchises to blame their struggles on their best player. Whether it makes them 'bad fans' or not aside, it seems to me like there's a similar tendency among fans. Nowhere was it more clearly on display than in a thread somewhere several years ago debating the relative value of Joe Mauer and, I swear I'm not making this up, Nick Punto. While on some basic subatomic level Mauer and Punto had the same exact job, to help the Twins win baseball games, every fan was free to make up any job description for them they wished. And there was a fair-sized contingent whose job descriptions went like this: Punto - Field multiple positions, use up bushels of outs at the plate, and turn his uniform brown (from the outside, not the inside). Mauer - Carry the team to a championship. Defined by those terms, Mauer was virtually guaranteed of "failure" due to odds alone, with only the details of how he failed (too little power, not 'aggresive' enough, lack of leadership, etc.) being argued amongst them. Meanwhile Punto was absolutely assured of "success" as long as his defense remained passable. Although that school of thought utterly baffles me the way breaking stuff baffled Greg Gagne, like I said, everyone is free to define a player's role and their expectations however they want. That said, the people who define Mauer's career in the terms above seem to me to have been missing some of the enjoyment of what was until the concussion almost certainly a Hall of Fame career.
-
Game Thread: Twins v A's, 4/9@ 12:10pm CT
The one regarding his golf game?
-
Game Thread: Twins v A's, 4/9@ 12:10pm CT
Was in fact thinking it's time for the Tonkin Resolution. The one regarding his golf game?
-
Game Thread: Twins v A's, 4/9@ 12:10pm CT
Suspecting there's a Reussie column in the works about the loss, in which all we learn about the game is that Mauer walked in his final AB instead of homering, and is therefore an indisputably over-rated nonleader and all-around disappointment.
-
Game Thread: Twins v A's, 4/9@ 12:10pm CT
Because closer, or something... Dunno. The 21 pitches and high usage to start the season probably didn't help. And Gardenhire only asked him to go two innings once last year, in the last week of the season, oddly enough. In fact he only recorded more than three outs three times last season.
-
Game Thread: Twins v A's, 4/9@ 12:10pm CT
So much for selling high on Burton...
-
Game Thread: Twins v A's, 4/9@ 12:10pm CT
The game or the thread?
-
Game Thread: Twins v A's, 4/9@ 12:10pm CT
At least he didn't throw a bat at him...
-
Game Thread: Twins v A's, 4/9@ 12:10pm CT
Dumbest mound charge of all time: Reggie Sanders, believing Pedro Martinez had deliberately thrown at him just five outs from a perfect game. What a tool.
-
Game Thread: Twins v A's, 4/9@ 12:10pm CT
You know you're bad against same-side pitching when you get pinch hit for by Nicky Punto. Would love to know what the usually quiet and restrained Perkins said to get Donaldson fired up enough to clear the benches.
-
Game Thread: Twins v A's, 4/9@ 12:10pm CT
Ball and strike calls suddenly competent in a tight game after being bad all day.