Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • The Only Twins-Yankees History That Might Actually Matter


    Tom Froemming

    Despite how much the laziest members of the national baseball media want to cling to how the Yankees have dominated the Twins in previous postseasons, it doesn’t really matter. The only Twins-Yankees history that might be worth revisiting is how the teams fared against each other this season.

    Image courtesy of © Brad Rempel-USA TODAY Sports

    Twins Video

    We’ll do a lot of looking ahead to this Twins-Yankees ALDS here at Twins Daily over the coming days, but I thought it was also worthwhile to take a quick look back at how these teams have played against each other so far in 2019.

    There’s no denying the Yankees dominance over the Twins in postseason play, but it’s also completely irrelevant. Rocco Baldelli’s response to whether he was aware of the recent postseason history between the Twins and Yankees was the exact message the entire organization and its fans needed to hear.

    https://twitter.com/dohyoungpark/status/1177986288194113537

    So how about 2019? The Twins went 2-4 against the Yankees this season, though New York only held the advantage in run differential by five (43-38). Here’s how things went at Yankee Stadium, with links to the Twins Daily game recap for each contest:

    May 3 | NYY 6, MIN 3

    May 4 | MIN 7, NYY 3

    May 5 | NYY 4, MIN 1 (8 innings)

    The Bomba Squad was uncharacteristically quiet in that series, and a few untimely errors crippled the pitching staff. There were three unearned runs allowed the first game and one more in the finale. The teams met again nearly two months later in Minneapolis.

    July 22 | MIN 8, NYY 6

    July 23 | NYY 14, MIN 12 (10 innings)

    July 24 | NYY 10, MIN 7

    The Twins evened up the season series at two games a piece, then had New York against the ropes in the second game at Target Field. The Twins led 8-2 through the first four innings, but suffered a crushing extra-inning loss in what was among the most thrilling games of the season.

    https://twitter.com/TFTwins/status/1178505743558959104

    Over the entire season series, the Twins combined to hit a solid .254/.343/.512 (.855 OPS), but the Yankees had a much more impressive .327/.402/.588 line (.989 OPS). Poor starting pitching was a common theme throughout for both teams. Here’s a look at the numbers:

    NYY SPs: 8.54 ERA, 1.78 WHIP, 6.5 K/9, 4.4 BB/9, 1.045 OPS against in 26 1/3 innings.

    MIN SPs: 7.45 ERA, 1.97 WHIP, 10.9 K/9, 5.6 BB/9, 1.047 OPS against in 29 innings.

    Ick. The biggest separator was bullpen performance. Twins relievers combined for a 5.87 ERA in 23 frames while the Yankees pen posted a 3.38 ERA over 26 2/3 innings. Blake Parker managed to give up five runs while recording just five outs against the Yankees, so I guess take that with a grain of salt. Parker’s dreadful appearance in that July 23 madhouse of a game was his last in a Twins uniform.

    Considering the changes both these teams have gone through since late July, even this season’s previous matchups might not matter. That alone illustrates how completely ridiculous it is to drag any prior years into the conversation.

    MORE FROM TWINS DAILY
    — Latest Twins coverage from our writers
    — Recent Twins discussion in our forums
    — Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook or email
    — Become a Twins Daily Caretaker

     Share


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

    Time to end the damn curse. They just need to pitch at the front end and I think we win. I have faith our best bullpen guys can do it. 

     

    Need to get to their starters though. Their bullpen is even better than ours has been once you shrink it down and only use their top guys. 

     

    Something will also likely happen in that stadium. It has every other time. Bad call, cheap HR, something. They need to play through it and no implode when it happens. Win 1 there and they are in good shape. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    The series will be interesting, as both teams have made a few changes since last meeting.  I hope the new bullpen for the Twins can get it done, else there will be a lot of late game blow ups that piss me off.  At least with instant replay the umps can only give the Yankees so much of an advantage

    Oh please.  We have lost the last 10 post season games against this team and we are 2-13 against them in post season games this century.  We have a ridiculously terrible record against them since Gardy took over the team in 2002.  To complain about umpires is ludicrious.

     

    If you want to complain about things then complain about how gutless this team has played against the Yankees over the last almost 20 seasons.  Complain about how this team cannot hit in the postseason against the Yankees. Complain about how we have scored 4 runs or less in 13 of the 15 post season games we have played against them.

     

    As for the Phil Cuzzi abomination, we aren't in that situation if Joe Nathan doesn't spit the bit in the 9th.  THen he had the nerve to complain about the umpiring after that.  He needed to just own it and say "that doesn't happen if I do my job".  Totally unacceptable from Nathan right there and it gives you an idea of the mindset Gardy helped to foster.  THat is the kind of attitude I hope no longer exists in the Twins clubhouse.

     

    Maybe we can put this ridiculousness to sleep.  I am pretty damn tired of watching it 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    The Ringer tackled this, detailing the Twins 21st century ineptitude against the Yankees.

     

    https://www.theringer.com/mlb/2019/10/2/20894822/minnesota-twins-playoff-curse-alds-new-york-yankees

     

    It is kind of painful to read, but depending on where you fall in the Science vs. Magic debate, I'd say the Twins are due for some serious regression to the mean here.

     

    Can't deny the fact that we are 36-126 against this team since 2002.  They are NOT that much better.  We only acted like they were and that BS needs to stop now

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    Oh please.  We have lost the last 10 post season games against this team and we are 2-13 against them in post season games this century.  We have a ridiculously terrible record against them since Gardy took over the team in 2002.  To complain about umpires is ludicrious.

     

    If you want to complain about things then complain about how gutless this team has played against the Yankees over the last almost 20 seasons.  Complain about how this team cannot hit in the postseason against the Yankees. Complain about how we have scored 4 runs or less in 13 of the 15 post season games we have played against them.

     

    As for the Phil Cuzzi abomination, we aren't in that situation if Joe Nathan doesn't spit the bit in the 9th.  THen he had the nerve to complain about the umpiring after that.  He needed to just own it and say "that doesn't happen if I do my job".  Totally unacceptable from Nathan right there and it gives you an idea of the mindset Gardy helped to foster.  THat is the kind of attitude I hope no longer exists in the Twins clubhouse.

     

    Maybe we can put this ridiculousness to sleep.  I am pretty damn tired of watching it 

    I 100 percent agree that when Gardy led the team they rolled over against the Yankees and just let the Yankees have their way with the Twins.  I do not expect the same under Rocco.  Rocco does things like look at stats against players, not just say well he is our guy.  Anyone could have managed the Twins like Gardy did, he went on auto and gave no thought at all.  Rocco and his team they change things based on data.  

     

    I was not blaming the umpire for the Twins short comings over the years.  I was pointing out fact that things like that will not be a factor anymore either, and they compounded the inept managing of Gardy.  The majority of my post was about how the history of the matchups do not have any bearing on this matchup.  Other than the few players from the wild-card game couple years ago, who was on the team last time Twins played in a full post season series?  Single game play in is not same as best of 5.   

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    I 100 percent agree that when Gardy led the team they rolled over against the Yankees and just let the Yankees have their way with the Twins.  I do not expect the same under Rocco.  Rocco does things like look at stats against players, not just say well he is our guy.  Anyone could have managed the Twins like Gardy did, he went on auto and gave no thought at all.  Rocco and his team they change things based on data.  

     

    I was not blaming the umpire for the Twins short comings over the years.  I was pointing out fact that things like that will not be a factor anymore either, and they compounded the inept managing of Gardy.  The majority of my post was about how the history of the matchups do not have any bearing on this matchup.  Other than the few players from the wild-card game couple years ago, who was on the team last time Twins played in a full post season series?  Single game play in is not same as best of 5.   

    We are not very far apart in our thinking.  Rocco is nothing like Gardy and maybe that is what we need.  I also think this team is every bit as good as the Yankees.  I think it goes five games

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    Two of the three most watched World Series in history are still 1987 and 1991. Which featured 0 teams from the north east, California, Texas or Chicago. Ratings for the World Series now are so bad it’s embarrassing. Fewer people watched the last TWO combined than watched in 1991.

    Doesn't change the fact that the national media drools over the big market teams, as do the advertisers.. A lot has changed since 1991 in the demographics of what and how people watch. A Yanks-Dodgers WS will get ratings..a Tampa-Atl will not. Even if on a relative scale, they will be a lot worse than in days of yore.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    This got me curious. Interesting to note that the Subway Series between Yanks and Mets only averaged 18M...a relatively small number considering the market. Perhaps it turned off many viewers outside of NY?

    Compare that with the Bay Area series between SF and Oakland in 1989...that averaged 24M. Also it looks like it was after the disastrous strike of 1994..that the numbers began to drop. That also coincides with the explosion of the internet, followed by cable and streaming and all the other stuff that they never had to deal with up to that time. The Twins series in 87 and 91 came before all of that. In fact I'm thinking most the playoff games were seen on non-pay TV back then too.

     

    Anyway...fun stuff.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites




    Join the conversation

    You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
    Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

    Guest
    Add a comment...

    ×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

      Only 75 emoji are allowed.

    ×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

    ×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

    ×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

    Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...