Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • Opening Day Roster Nearly Set


    Seth Stohs

    On Tuesday morning, the Twins made four roster moves leaving their roster at 25. The Twins optioned LH RP Ryan O'Rourke and RHP Tyler Duffey to Rochester. They also re-assigned LH RP Logan Darnell and RH RP Brandon Kintzler to minor league camp.

    Image courtesy of Kim Klement, USA Today

    Twins Video

    In dropping four players and getting the spring training roster to 25, the Twins most likely have their Opening Day roster. That said, with five days until Opening Day, anything can happen.

    LH RP Fernando Abad has not yet been added to the Twins 40-man roster. The Twins theoretically could still take Michael Tonkin off of their 40-man roster if there is someone else they would like to add from another organization.

    There were a couple of big stories in today's transactions.

    First, Ricky Nolasco "wins" the 5th starter job. Tyler Duffey was optioned to Rochester where he will work through some things. It was clear that he would need a third pitch (probably the change-up he's been working on to be a viable long-term starter. He was asked at the beginning of spring training to work on it. He did, and he struggled. So it makes sense to send him to Rochester where he can continue to work on that pitch. But it was more than that. Duffey noted that in some games hitters were sitting on his curveball, and hitting his fastball. While fans (and in my opinion, the Twins) wanted Duffey to be in the rotation to start the season, it is clear that he needs to work through a couple of things. I expect Duffey will be back with the Twins within four to six weeks, though Jose Berrios will likely factor into the timing as well.

    As for Nolasco, it is my opinion that his salary got him an opportunity to be in the rotation, but it was more about Duffey's issues that allowed him to actually be in the rotation. His numbers were certainly not inspiring in spring training. Then again, he's healthy and his curveball is terrific. It would be nice if he could return to the form from his days in Miami. I don't know that I would expect it. (I wouldn't.) His leash could (and should) be short.

    The other possibly controversial decision is keeping Michael Tonkin on the roster. While he is out of options, he really struggled for the first month of spring training. However, he has been very good his last three or four outings. He throws 94-96 and he does have a slider that can be effective. He's certainly not a guy who you would want to lose for nothing.

    As their roster is currently set, the Twins really don't have any relievers who can throw more than two innings. If the starters do their job most times out, that shouldn't be an issue, but a couple of consecutive sub-four inning starts and it could create issues. Then again, they are fully capable of calling down to Rochester and calling guys up in those scenarios. Brandon Kintzler is a veteran who will go to Rochester. No word on whether he's got an opt-out at some point in the season.

    It does appear that Fernando Abad has made the roster. He will still need to be added to the 40-man roster before Monday. Two weeks ago, Mike Strong was removed from the 40-man roster so there is a spot. Abad is the only left-hander in the bullpen aside from closer Glen Perkins.

    Ryan O'Rourke and Logan Darnell had very solid camps. O'Rourke did what O'Rourke does. He gets lefties out, and did better (in the small sample) against right-handed bats. Logan Darnell would have been the options as a long-reliever.

    So, as of right now, the Twins Opening Day roster looks like this (subject to change):

    SP - Ervin Santana, Kyle Gibson, Phil Hughes, Tommy Milone, Ricky Nolasco

    RP - Glen Perkins, Kevin Jepsen, Trevor May, Casey Fien, Michael Tonkin, Ryan Pressly, Fernando Abad

    C - Kurt Suzuki, John Ryan Murphy

    IF - Joe Mauer, Brian Dozier, Trevor Plouffe, Eduardo Escobar, Eduardo Nunez, Byung Ho Park

    OF - Eddie Rosario, Byron Buxton, Miguel Sano, Oswaldo Arcia, Danny Santana

    MORE FROM TWINS DAILY
    — Latest Twins coverage from our writers
    — Recent Twins discussion in our forums
    — Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook or email
    — Become a Twins Daily Caretaker

     Share


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

     

    I'll throw out my guesses:

    Duffey - by about May 10th.

    Berrios - by about June 10th. 

     

    Really?

    If Nolasco is released, that opens a spot on the 40 man for Berrios.  I would hope that he is ahead of Duffey.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Given how Nolasco/Duffey performed in the spring not a huge surprise Duffey isn't coming north with the big club.  If Nolasco performs well that's GREAT in different ways. 1) Is obvious..WINS/or at least keeping the boys in the game.  2)If he lights it up it he is building trade value!  If Berrios and or Duffey start lighting it up in the minors it opens up potential trade options for the Twins in the sense that if they want they can bring them up and sell high on Nolasco. Which on March 29th seems unlikely but you never know.  He wanted to start so here is his chance once again.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Duffey is not going to dominate with two pitches for very long, especially with an average fastball.  I am not opposed to him working in AAA for a little longer.  He was up last fall out of necessity and he did very well, but I don't think that is sustainable.  I'm hoping to see Berrios up before he is.  Ideally we see nobody else up because our staff is dominating.  We shall see.  

     

    I'd like to see a few of the younger fireballing relievers up before any of the other starting pitchers come up.  Let's see some gas, or preferably just hear it. ZZZZZZZZZ Pop.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I think the decision to start Duffey in AAA has everything to do with 3rd pitch development. Nothing more. Nothing less. This was the right move. Lets see what Nolasco can do as he's looked better as Spring Training has progressed. Come June 1 things will begin to look more clear as injuries and failings happen. Maybe Duffey never really develops that Change and becomes a dominant pen piece (probably not, but look at hiw they're utilizing May). Maybe Milone stumbles for two months? Or maybe he mows lineups down like a professional lawn service? Maybe someone gets traded? The point is, the Twins have QUALITY AND QUANTITY! About 8-10 QUALITY Starters that have demonstrated the propensity to get the job done and keep the team in games. It's time to smile and enjoy this folks!

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    I think the decision to start Duffey in AAA has everything to do with 3rd pitch development. Nothing more. Nothing less. This was the right move.

    Reasonable. However, Duffy already throws four (five?) pitches. A couple of them are fastballs and a couple of them are curveballs. They all move and they travel at a variety of speeds. So, how's Ricky's changeup? Must be pretty damn good. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I share the concern above, that some of the players might be "meh", but not awful, and will stay on the 25 man, blocking guys with much higher upside (that might not produce much better this year, but could).

    Edited by Mike Sixel
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    I share the concern above, that some of the players might be "meh", but not awful, and will stay on the 25 man, blocking guys with much higher upside (that might not product much better this year, but could).

     

    Yes. And what if the few cut-able guys aren't the problem? What if Tonkin and Abad are solid but Jepsen and Hughes are struggling? There is very little maneuverability with this pitching staff. Does anyone other than Pressly and May even have options left?

     

    I'm not saying they made the wrong decisions on the young players to start the season by sending them down, but I don't want to see them down longer than needed just because the decisions at the MLB level are too difficult. I understand why they didn't, but I wish the team would have just ripped the band-aid off of a couple of these painful decisions this spring and gotten it over with.

     

    I believe Pressly and May have one option each, if that's accurate and no one else has one remaining that would mean there are a total of two options remaining for 13 pitchers on a rebuilding team. I think this was a bit of a mis-step.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I don't get the flexibility argument.   If we had cut Tonkin and Nolasco we'd have less flexibility by not having them available at all.  Sure we could replace them with more flexible options, but the well with which we could draw from would be two-pitchers short.  

     

    In any case, if veterans prove ineffective the Twins will utilize the DL or even cut bait.  IMO, there's more flexibility with Tonkin and Nolasco starting on the roster, then the other way around.  

     

    (Though the argument of entrenched mediocrity argument does make some sense, there's too many other variables for that really to become a problem.  If Nolasco is league average this year, and no other starters get hurt, isn't that a very good problem to have?)    

    Edited by PseudoSABR
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    (Though the argument of entrenched mediocrity argument does make some sense, there's too many other variables for that really to become a problem.  If Nolasco is league average this year, and no other starters get hurt, isn't that a very good problem to have?)    

    Wasn't that the argument for Pelfrey last year?  And how much did he help us?  He was league average, we went 14-16 in his starts, and we actually skipped his turn in September rather than trust him in a pennant race.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    This team will need a lot of luck and a lot of upside showing to come out of April above .500.  

     

    The pen seems a mess to me.... and I really believed it would be addressed as promised.  A new cast off in Abad, but I never liked O'Rourke and his 5.00 plus ERA in Rochester, and he seems to have to face far too many righthanded bats when he is put in the game. Tonkin and a fastball that is so straight it is no trouble to hit, and I fear both Fien and Perkins will be on the way down. High hopes for Pressly and the misplaced May, and for Jepson (but not as much as he regresses to his career stats).

     

    Santana has found the ball with his bat at the right time. Sano is slumping a bit this last week, and in right field, but I really look forward to seeing what he can do for a full season. Murphy only knows a slump with the Twins so far, yikes. Plouffe, Dozier, Suzuki, seem ready. Mauer seems like the Mauer of the last two years. Happy to see Buxton in center, no matter what happens. Rosario seems ready. Arcia is a total crap-shoot without options. Park looks great and I hope blows us all away. I have no idea why Nunez is still around. Escobar looks ready but not in the form I hope he can continue to perform at.

     

    I have high hopes for dreaded Santana and Gibson, but cringe at watching Hughes in April when he has always (except one year in his career) tanked, and doesn't get going, if he does get going, until May. I can't believe we all have to see Nolasco set records on scratching himself on the mound between pitches and hope he doesn't pitch batting practice for the third year in Minnesota, and Milone could surprise, and should keep us in the game 4 out of 7 outings. 

     

    I really thought I would have higher hopes and the bullpen would have really been addressed, Sano would have been at third, Kepler in the outfield, and Berrios on the starting staff, but it is a long season and a lot can happen. At least Jordan Shafer is not starting in center this year (he was signed by the Dodgers to start pitching in the minors!). I hope we see a lot different team by June, and the march to 90+ wins is picking up momentum. All future and no past. Here we go again.

    Edited by h2oface
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    I don't get the flexibility argument.   If we had cut Tonkin and Nolasco we'd have less flexibility by not having them available at all.  Sure if we could replace them with more flexible options, but the well with which we could draw from would be two-pitchers short.  

     

    In any case, if veterans prove ineffective the Twins will utilize the DL or even cut bait.  IMO, there's more flexibility with Tonkin and Nolasco starting on the roster, then the other way around.  

     

    (Though the argument of entrenched mediocrity argument does make some sense, there's too many other variables for that really to become a problem.  If Nolasco is league average this year, and no other starters get hurt, isn't that a very good problem to have?)    

     

    I get that, and I'm sure it's the thought the front office is operating with. But it seems to me, with these guys on roster, there's a lid on the well.

     

    I understand that the counter option is to work with a very untested safety net, but I think having a roster where nearly every pitcher can only be DFA'd or rostered is asking for a long season of not seeing the young guys. Barring injury, there are not many guys the front office will replace, that's my inflexible angle.

     

    As to the last sentence, I think having a roster full of league average pitchers is probably the worst possible outcome. League average isn't good enough to win, but it's not bad enough for management to bring up the young guys. Having a staff full of 2015 Mike Pelfreys and Blaine Boyers is going to make for a bad year in terms of competing and developing.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    Barring injury, there are not many guys the front office will replace, that's my inflexible angle.

    And not only that -- but the Twins tend to target pitchers for their health, reducing the likelihood of injury.  If a couple of our opening day veterans were injury fliers, that would be a different story.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I guess it doesn't make any difference, but it seems to me that Nolasco appears to be arrogant, not a team oriented guy. In post games interviews, he has seemed disinterested and put off. Anybody heard on what type of team mate he is? He seems out of place in Minnesota.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    I guess it doesn't make any difference, but it seems to me that Nolasco appears to be arrogant, not a team oriented guy. In post games interviews, he has seemed disinterested and put off.

    Yeah but he wasn't born in the D.R., therefore he gets a pass by the local media on these things.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    I believe Pressly and May have one option each, if that's accurate and no one else has one remaining that would mean there are a total of two options remaining for 13 pitchers on a rebuilding team.

    I think May is out of options but Fien has one.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    This is about what I was expecting. Tonkin didn't deserve a spot on the roster, so I hope they keep his leash short. They shouldn't be afraid about losing him. If there's a decent bullpen arm getting optioned in the next few days, the Twins should consider swapping that guy with Tonkin.

     

    With some talented young starters waiting in AAA, Nolasco's leash should be short as well. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    .......Sano is slumping a bit this last week, and in right field, but I really look forward to seeing what he can do for a full season. ......

     

    ...... and a homer and 3 hits  and 3 RBI today......  he is more than ready. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Regarding the bullpen, my biggest gripe was keeping Fien for a role that would be better suited to a young developing reliever or (as it turns out) a guy who can on occasion go three or four innings. I have liked having May in the 'pen and think Tonkin deserves a legit shot. Pressly won a spot and Abad might be OK as a lefty arm there.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    I would guess they'd just release Nolasco.

     

    When was the last time that Terry Ryan ate $25 million?   The most he (Black)burned was $5.5M.  Huge difference.

     

    Most likely, and if they have a ready replacement, they trade him to the NL for an equally bad contract.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    When was the last time that Terry Ryan ate $25 million?   The most he (Black)burned was $5.5M.  Huge difference.

     

    Most likely, and if they have a ready replacement, they trade him to the NL for an equally bad contract.

     

    I don't think that the fact that he hasn't before necessarily makes it certain that he wouldn't now. Obviously some would depend on how well (or poor) he is pitching if/when removed from the rotation, and maybe if there is some need in the bullpen at that time...

     

    And yes, to trade him, it would take taking on a bad deal or taking on 90-95% of his remaining contract.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Kevin Correia

    Samuel Deduno

    Scott Diamond

    Pedro Hernandez

    Mike Pelfrey

     

    Those are your starting pitchers with the most games started for the Twins in 2013. Last year they combined for 6 MLB wins (thanks Mike Pelfrey!). It seems to me that there is a bit of improvement in the rotation this year over that group - Nolasco's 100 career wins don't look that bad in comparison. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    So the Twins have 3 pitchers on the 40 man who are a better fit for the final rotation spot. Two of those pitchers are at AAA (Berrios and Duffy), and one of them is in the bullpen (May) But hey the Twins expect to win the division and build on last year....Smh....

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites




    Join the conversation

    You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
    Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

    Guest
    Add a comment...

    ×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

      Only 75 emoji are allowed.

    ×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

    ×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

    ×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

    Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...