Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • Minnesota's Misuse of Meyer?


    Cody Christie

    One start...

    That's all Minnesota wanted to see from Alex Meyer before he was returned to Rochester. After making his first start at the big league level, the Twins decided that Meyer's performance wasn't good enough for a team floundering at 11 games under .500.

    If you are reading this article and a frequent visitor to Twins Daily, you are likely a fan of the Twins organization. For those that have read my work before, you know I am a fan of the team and I follow the minor leagues and Twins prospects with a passion. However, I feel the Twins are misusing Meyer at this point in his career.

    Image courtesy of Troy Taormina- USA Today Sports

    Twins Video

    To paint the full picture, let's go back to Meyer's Minnesota origin.

    The Twins traded for Meyer in the winter of 2012 as they sent Denard Span to the Nationals. Meyer was a year removed from being a first-round pick after a three year collegiate career at the University of Kentucky. He's been a top-100 prospect on all three national prospect rankings (Baseball America, MLB.com and Baseball Prospectus) from 2013-15. Baseball Prospectus ranked him as the 14th best prospect as recently as 2015.

    There have been plenty of bumps and bruises for Meyer as he has gotten closer to the big leagues. After being considered one of the top starting pitching prospects in the game, Meyer struggled so much last season that he was sent to the bullpen to try to improve his performance. As part of the transition, things didn't go perfectly but he lowered his ERA and his SO/9 rate increased.

    2016 was a new season and the Twins decided to give Meyer another chance to be a starter. He made three Triple-A appearances, two as a starter, and posted a 1.04 ERA with 19 to 4 strikeout to walk ratio. Opponents hit .183/.234/.217 against him as he only allowed two earned runs. This was a very small sample size but it was a step in the right direction after a miserable 2015.

    Minnesota promoted Meyer to the majors on April 25, 2016 but he wouldn't appear in a game until April 29 as a relief pitcher. In his first outing, he allowed two earned runs on five hits. During his start on Tuesday, he pitched into the third inning and allowed three earned runs with four strikeouts and three walks. After the game, he was informed that he would be going back to Rochester.

    For the second year in a row, the Twins let Meyer pitch in two big league games before demoting him.

    There are a lot of factors that go into a player being on a big league roster and it could be that Meyer is being subject to a roster crunch at this point to fit Ervin Santana back into the rotation. Minnesota wants Meyer to continue to start and there doesn't seem to be a spot for him at the big league level.

    From the player's perspective, it must be hard to be in Meyer's shoes. He was on a path to be a regular in the big leagues at this point in his career but that hasn't come to fruition. The Twins have shifted Meyer from starter to reliever last season and now this season he has gone back to being a starter before being brought up to be a reliever and being sent back down so he can start again.

    Meyer can't get settled in any specific role. He's moved between starting and relieving while also moving between Triple-A and the big leagues. There are different mindsets when it comes to starting and relieving and it can take a mental adjustment to prepare for these different roles.

    If Minnesota wants to know what they have in Meyer, the team should allow him to pitch at the big league level. Decide on his role and let him sink or swim. This team is not winning games right now and Meyer was supposed to be a part of the long-term solution.

    There has already been plenty of discussion in the forums about Meyer's demotion. I'm in the camp that Minnesota is misusing Meyer at this point in his career. He will get other opportunities but these brief tastes of the big leagues are not helping his long-term development.

    What camp do you fall in? Should Meyer have been demoted or should he still be part of the Twins 25-man roster?

    Leave a COMMENT and add to the discussion.

    MORE FROM TWINS DAILY
    — Latest Twins coverage from our writers
    — Recent Twins discussion in our forums
    — Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook or email
    — Become a Twins Daily Caretaker

     Share


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

     

    He has talent. He needs wisdom. Unfortunately, it seems like the Twins shy away from this profile for pitchers and don't have a good track record of teaching wisdom, which is why veterans of moderate talent are given more opportunities.

    A lot of player have talent and never make it.  I'm not saying the Twins management is faultless in developing players, just that most of the responsibility falls on the player.  I don't think the coaches can take a lot of credit for Mauer's turnaround this year, do you?.  I give Mauer credit for what he's done. 

     

    But we seem to blame management for everything bad - if a player comes up at 22 and fails, they rushed him, if we player fails at 26, we waited too long to bring him up and didn't show confidence in him.  It's not the Twins fault if he has an ugly girlfriend :)

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    But we seem to blame management for everything bad - if a player comes up at 22 and fails, they rushed him, if we player fails at 26, we waited too long to bring him up and didn't show confidence in him.  It's not the Twins fault if he has an ugly girlfriend :)

    Along with coming up with a strategy, the most important actions for any organization are (1) attracting talent and (2) developing talent. Supposedly, the Twins have done a pretty good job of attracting talent (although I would have traded a lot of veterans for a larger stock of young players, going back to when Cuddyer and Kubel were entering free agency, and the "draft college relievers" strategy seems shaky, so far), but the track record of successful development is not good. Perhaps it will take a couple more years, but you'd expect a team with years of high draft choices and supposedly superior scouting to have a more than average number of successful young players. Yes, that's management's responsibility.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    A lot of player have talent and never make it. I'm not saying the Twins management is faultless in developing players, just that most of the responsibility falls on the player. I don't think the coaches can take a lot of credit for Mauer's turnaround this year, do you?. I give Mauer credit for what he's done.

     

    But we seem to blame management for everything bad - if a player comes up at 22 and fails, they rushed him, if we player fails at 26, we waited too long to bring him up and didn't show confidence in him. It's not the Twins fault if he has an ugly girlfriend :)

    I think you are reading too much into most of these recent complaints. I for one am not necessarily blaming management for Meyer's results. Just that the results would be easier to swallow if they weren't accompanied by completely nonsensical management decisions like promoting Meyer to park him on the MLB bench. Or promoting Kepler, starting him once against a tough lefty and refusing to pinch hit for him while he gets embarassed by said lefty in a game defining at bat, then parking him on the MLB bench. As the recent wave of waiver/DFA moves should indicate, we were nowhere near a 40 man roster crisis to warrant this handling of top prospects.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    They're giving him big league chances each time he starts to show he deserves a look...

    ...and he poos the bed.

    Not yet a starter. Not yet a reliever.

    I don't blame the Twins one bit for how he's used. If he was successful at this level, you could say they're jerking him around, but they're just trying to give him shots and he's blown them all.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    They're giving him big league chances each time he starts to show he deserves a look...

    ...and he poos the bed.

    Not yet a starter. Not yet a reliever.

    I don't blame the Twins one bit for how he's used. If he was successful at this level, you could say they're jerking him around, but they're just trying to give him shots and he's blown them all.

    Promoting him to be an emergency reliever, or Kepler to be a bench player, is almost the definition of not giving someone a chance.

     

    And pulling him early in his debut start, at the exact point you let Berrios work through it the night before, is also a pretty poor effort a giving someone a chance.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    They're giving him big league chances each time he starts to show he deserves a look...

    ...and he poos the bed.

    Not yet a starter. Not yet a reliever.

    I don't blame the Twins one bit for how he's used. If he was successful at this level, you could say they're jerking him around, but they're just trying to give him shots and he's blown them all.

    When you say "each time he starts", you mean the exactly ONE time that he has made a start in mlb, right?

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Meyer pitched better than just about every starter since his start, and better than most of the relievers since. That is not saying much, but if all are floundering on a bad team you have to keep trying to give the upside the chance...and NOT hoping that others can somehow regain what they no longer are, or only were for brief periods.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    What is the big picture for Milone? I would argue a lack of big picture view is what irritates many of us.

    Further, it is delusional to think we are going to get anything of value for Nolasco. So it is not in the best interest to allocate many more innings to him in hopes he yields something slightly better (versus breaking in a talented pitcher)

    I can't help but think that guys like May and Meyer just don't fit the mold the Twins are used to. They have not been able to adjust to guys with slightly less than perfect control, even if they are a good 2 additional k's per 9 than what we have.

    Well...I think we have the big picture for Milone...I cannot remember a time when the Twins were in so much turn over/around with players.  haha

     

    Delusional maybe, but the Twins don't look like they are going to just can Nolasco for youth...got to hope for a trade,  and so far he is doing better than anyone else.  And I agree, the "mold" thing, I think we will see Meyers back up sooner than later.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    The only indictment of the Twins handling of Meyer is that he was not given a chance to fail sooner. If he had the chance to fail in 2014  and did, then there are the rushed him to soon comments.  Easy criticism as there is no way to defend a move, no real way to say it was wrong as a move other than opinion.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    The only indictment of the Twins handling of Meyer is that he was not given a chance to fail sooner. If he had the chance to fail in 2014 and did, then there are the rushed him to soon comments. Easy criticism as there is no way to defend a move, no real way to say it was wrong as a move other than opinion.

    I am pretty sure no one would have said Meyer was rushed if we promoted him late in 2014, when he was 24.5 years old and was very successful in AAA. For example, no one said May was rushed under similar circumstances, or Gibson, etc.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Two general thoughts on the Twins pitching situation. If the FO has no issues with higher velocity pitchers, with both higher SO and walk rates than we are used to seeing, it has not shown itself in the last 20 years. In honor of Mother's Day, I quote her. "The proof is in the pudding" :). Second, if Alex Meyer does not get an extended look as a SP on the ML level this year an oversight is being made. There is absolutely nothing to lose, and what's the worst that could happen? A three inning stint by a starter?

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    To add insult to injury, we had a quick hook for Meyer in part to turn the ball over to Milone while the game was still close -- and Milone put the game out of reach, and two days later was waived and outrighted to AAA in favor of everybody's favorite fringe 40 man guy, Pat Dean.

     

    Who the heck is making decisions right now for the Twins? They are all over the map.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Any official word yet on what is going on with Meyer?  I still don't see him in any of the starting pitcher upcoming games for Rochester, they are all TBD from tomorrow on.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    He hasn't pitched for two weeks so far.

    Why would they not put him on the DL if he really had this type of fatigue?  He last pitched May 4 in Houston.  Exactly 15 days ago today.  Something is going on that is more than shoulder fatigue.  I hope he is alright, but something doesn't add up to shoulder fatigue  + no DL stint.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    Why would they not put him on the DL if he really had this type of fatigue?  He last pitched May 4 in Houston.  Exactly 15 days ago today.  Something is going on that is more than shoulder fatigue.  I hope he is alright, but something doesn't add up to shoulder fatigue  + no DL stint.

    I saw he played catch on Monday.  So that is a good sign.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites




    Join the conversation

    You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
    Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

    Guest
    Add a comment...

    ×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

      Only 75 emoji are allowed.

    ×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

    ×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

    ×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

    Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...