Leaderboard
-
chpettit19
Community LeaderPoints3,028Posts -
rwilfong86
Verified MemberPoints1,477Posts -
tony&rodney
Verified MemberPoints2,874Posts -
Popular Content
Showing content with the highest reputation on 01/23/2023 in all areas
-
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Nine of twelve and 18 others reacted to FlyingFinn for a post in a topic
19 pointsWe can really put together a great defense in the OF late in games. Jhoan Duran has to be happy. To me, the best part is now we should allow Celestino a year at AAA. Develop some power, hit the cutoffs, learn to run the bases properly. Taylor is gone in 2024. Do everything well and Celestino will be ready for 2024. I'm not giving up on him yet.19 points -
Keeping the Rolls Royce in the Garage
Keeping the Rolls Royce in the Garage
TopGunn#22 and 14 others reacted to GKuehl for a post in a topic
15 pointsBased on the title, I really thought this piece was going to be about giving Royce Lewis plenty of time to recover to avoid rushing him back.15 points -
Keeping the Rolls Royce in the Garage
Keeping the Rolls Royce in the Garage
nclahammer and 10 others reacted to Alex Boxwell for an article
11 pointsAdvanced analytics love Byron Buxton . The eye test screams even louder. If you sit down next to a random person in Target Field who has never watched baseball on a day Lord Byron is in center field, ask them in the 5th inning, “Hey, who do you think the best player on the field is?” Anyone that can focus on the game will see the undeniability of Buxton’s baseball ability. Inconsistent playing time will never equal a .300 batting average at the Major League level with the stuff guys are throwing now. I felt it myself as a player dealing with wrist and hamstring issues. Being in one day and out the next, a week on and a week off, hitting big-league caliber stuff is based on comfort, rhythm, and timing. That comfort, rhythm, and timing are so fragile at the highest levels, and we saw what happened last year to a player with all-world ability. Byron looked like the MVP front-runner, but then the knee injury led to sporadic playing time, a strange playing time structure, and a dip in his performance at the plate. We got a flaccid Buxton last year. An ambivalent playing schedule alternating center field, designated hitter, and off-days isn’t suitable for Byron Buxton or his performance. The less time he spends in the outfield, the more it feels like we’re declawing a jungle cat. He was born to roam the outfield and steal bases, so why deny it? The one glaring thing that can and has denied Buxton and his ability is injury. Buxton is well worth his contract if he plays 80-90 games a season. So why not write him in the lineup every day? The risk is worth the reward, and 80 games of linear playing time in center field is more valuable than 90 of intermittent playing time. Baseball is not a dangerous sport. Some of his injury history can be attributed to happenstance. If the baseball gods smile on us, he will keep pace and play those 145-150 games, likely leading to an MVP or, at the least, a top-five finish. We will get a much better Buxton if he stays on pace for 150 games and plays center field. If he gets hurt at the all-star break after playing 80 games, or plays 90 games sporadically and gets shut down in August, what’s the difference? I want us to unleash the glass cannon that is Byron Buxton. Even if it’s just by sheer good fortune, he will stay healthy eventually. Luxury is meant to be lived in. Keeping the Rolls Royce in the garage isn’t good for the engine. We have to let Buck buck!11 points -
Who Will Be the Twins' Opening Day DH?
Who Will Be the Twins' Opening Day DH?
Strombomb and 9 others reacted to Cris E for a post in a topic
10 pointsI'll do it. Let me try to get the day off and then I'll let you know for sure.10 points -
Keeping the Rolls Royce in the Garage
Keeping the Rolls Royce in the Garage
saviking and 8 others reacted to Doctor Gast for a post in a topic
9 pointsLove your article & metaphors, Alex. "We got a flaccid Buxton last year. An ambivalent playing schedule alternating center field, designated hitter, and off-days isn’t suitable for Byron Buxton or his performance. The less time he spends in the outfield, the more it feels like we’re declawing a jungle cat. He was born to roam the outfield and steal bases, so why deny it?" Couldn't agree you more. I've advocated against Buxton at DH all last season. If Buxton is healthy, play him in CF if he isn't, rest him or put him on the IL. Our focus shouldn't be to see how many games we can squeeze out of him during the regular season but to have him healthy for the post season. I'd love to see him healthy & let loose in the post season & see what this tiger can do. I'd love to see Buxton & Correa play off each other. That kind of electricity is catchy, I can see this team explode (rather than implode)9 points -
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
Heiny and 8 others reacted to terrydactyls for a post in a topic
9 pointsNo I didn't. But I did play 1B for many years and I can tell a good one from a bad one. Arraez was far closer to the bad end of the spectrum than he was to the good end. I was listening to three former GM's discussing the trade. One of the better comments was that a team doesn't make a trade hoping to "win" the trade. They make a trade to make their team better. The second interesting comment was that both the Marlins and the Twins should be very pleased because the each got what the felt they needed and only lost players that were from a position of strength. (P.S. They also said that the extra two players that the Twins received were a complete shock to them and that the Twins' front office should be congratulated.)9 points -
The Twins Have a Type
The Twins Have a Type
Doctor Gast and 7 others reacted to Matt Braun for an article
8 pointsBroadly speaking, that outline covers Chris Paddack, Tyler Mahle, and now López; one could argue that Kenta Maeda fits the mold as well. The idea probably stems from two sources: first, the Twins acknowledging themselves as an undesirable home for arms. Big-name starters have eschewed Minnesota for years. Despite recent infamous twirls with Yu Darvish and Zack Wheeler, Michael Pineda remains the richest starter to brace the cold under Derek Falvey’s watch. Realizing that players have no say in trades, Falvey and Co. decided to force the issue, utilizing the lack of consent involved in deals to pool together talented arms. The second part is the more interesting one—and its assumptions will likely decide how successful the Twins are with their strategy. Pitching in the modern baseball landscape is—and this is the technical term for it—absolutely bonkers. Arms become studs overnight—hello, Evan Phillips—as hefty advancements in technology make adjustments a science, no longer an art only understood by a few masters of the craft; a good pitching coach must communicate what the computer knows. Good teams aren't alone in claiming these resources; every team in MLB has them. But the most consistent franchises identify players most capable of breaking out, freeing them from the clutches of an ignorant team while reaping the rewards of a flourishing arm. The pickpocketed squad has no clue what happened. The Pirates lose 100 games. Looking beyond the horrifying societal implications of technological modernity, the scientific pitching movement hasn’t created an abundance of frustratingly talented pitchers—those will always exist—but it has made it tantalizingly irresistible to acquire them. “I can fix him,” thinks a team watching a guy with an ideal fastball get crushed for a 4.70 ERA. Phil Maton has pitched for three teams over six seasons. Phil Maton’s career rWAR is negative. Phil Maton will continue to have a bullpen spot on one of the smartest teams in baseball. Perhaps hearing the same information from a new source proves to be the catalyst. Or, as sports fans have known for decades, a guy just needs a change of scenery. If it doesn't work, the team may look silly, but that's the price of doing business. Minnesota took this concept and ran with it in 2021. They acquired Paddack, one of the more notorious problems in baseball, pulled some strings on his pitching package, and came out with a renewed starter… until he got injured. Players still have ligaments, after all. They then acquired Mahle, watched him be exactly as maddening as he was in Cincinnati for 16 1/3 innings, and failed to help him realize his potential… because he, too, got injured. This pitching business sounds hazardous. Whether López’s tale differs is up to him and whatever sacrifices the baseball gods choose to accept. While Minnesota hasn’t yet experienced success with the plan, other teams have reaped great riches. Perhaps most famously, Houston understood that Gerrit Cole should not be throwing sinkers, thank you very much, and they enjoyed two years of some of the most dominating starting pitching baseball has seen in recent years. Toronto somehow didn’t give up on Robbie Ray, transforming him into a Cy Young winner after a year where he walked nearly 18% of all hitters. Kevin Gausman evolved from pitching in relief for Cincinnati in 2019 into a legitimate Cy Young candidate. Minnesota hasn’t yet seen a transformation like the previous arms, but it injuries are the culprit, not poor targeting. Rather than tinker with potential, why not shoot for the best of the best? For starters, the most impactful arms in the game command a royal ransom in return, something that few teams are ok with meeting these days. You can criticize Minnesota for not going after Zac Gallen, but remember that no team yet has met Arizona's asking price for him; the Twins aren't an anomaly. Also, there just aren't many available aces these days. Sandy Alcántara is going to remain a Marlin for a few years, Milwaukee shut down trade noise, and Oakland is currently a picked-over walrus carcass. Is Cole Irvin your fallback plan? This isn’t to say that all their pitchers will figure it out eventually because, well, if everyone is super, then no one is. The game is in upside: what can you do in the future with your raw stuff? A player’s past hardly defines them; their measurables reign supreme and the Twins have gathered a hearty assortment of players with fascinating under-the-hood numbers. We shall see if the plan works.8 points -
Who Will Be the Twins' Opening Day DH?
Who Will Be the Twins' Opening Day DH?
Swing Batter-Batter and 7 others reacted to AlGoreRythm for a post in a topic
8 pointsGallo is a Gold Glove caliber corner outfielder. It would be foolish of them to DH him and not take advantage of the half of his game that isn't all or nothing.8 points -
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Fred and 6 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
7 pointsSisk isn't all that, apparently. It's not like anyone selected or claimed him when they had a chance7 points -
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Fred and 6 others reacted to VivaBomboRivera! for a post in a topic
7 pointsOne Gold Glove two years ago. Will be 32 years old this season. Should we be feeling more than a little underwhelmed?7 points -
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
kmeyer14 and 6 others reacted to PseudoSABR for a post in a topic
7 pointsIs this right? Found at MLBTR7 points -
Keeping the Rolls Royce in the Garage
Keeping the Rolls Royce in the Garage
saviking and 6 others reacted to Karbo for a post in a topic
7 pointsI agree. The planned rest days last year didn't work out so well did it? Put him in the field and let him play. If he gets hurt again, put him on IL until he can play again.7 points -
Who Will Be the Twins' Opening Day DH?
Who Will Be the Twins' Opening Day DH?
SF Twins Fan and 6 others reacted to TwinsGM for a post in a topic
7 pointsWhy isn't anyone talking about Michael Helman being a right handed option this year? He can play almost every position except catcher but hits for power, draws walks, steals bases, etc.7 points -
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Fred and 5 others reacted to chpettit19 for a post in a topic
6 pointsIt's an "eh" depth move. Nothing to write home about. But, even given he's not a good hitter, he's significantly better than Celestino at this point in their careers. Taylor's career OPS is only .677. Not impressive at all. But Celestino has had an OPS over .600 for 2 months of his (short) MLB career. Last August he was a .606. May he was at .844 and it made his overall season look slightly less than completely and utterly unplayable. He OPSed .458 in June and .477 in July in 2021. March/April of 2022 he was at .581, June .589, July .468, September/October .552. He needs to be in AAA. He's absolutely, totally, and completely not ready for major league baseball yet.6 points -
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
cjj td and 5 others reacted to chpettit19 for a post in a topic
6 pointsWill be interesting to see where the position player moves go from here. Right now I have the 13 position players as: Jeffers- C only Vazquez- C only Correa- SS only Farmer- IF/cOF or C in a pinch Miranda- cIF/2B in a pinch Polanco- 2B only Buxton- CF only Gallo- OF/1B or 3B in a pinch Gordon- Utility with emphasis on OF Kepler- OF/1B in a pinch Kirilloff- 1B/cOF Larnach- cOF only Taylor- OF only Obviously all eligible to DH as well. But that's a lot of versatility. Even if they all have dominant position areas, there's a lot of guys who can cover other spots. And those are all guys who deserve a legit MLB shot. Wouldn't be shocked if they stick with this or if they make more moves. FO is cooking now.6 points -
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Splash and 5 others reacted to tarheeltwinsfan for a post in a topic
6 pointsI really like this trade. Michael Taylor and Byron Buxton are so fast, the Twins can just use these two players in the OF and use the third OF position for a lefty reliever, who can mow down lefthanded batters and the starting pitcher can remain in the game in the OF, with the lefty reliever remaining in the game somewhere in the OF when right handed batters are at bat. Alternate the pitchers. How's this for thinking outside the box?6 points -
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Not sure why the Twins didn't care for Sisk as his numbers were good last year. I guess I don't understand the Walks issue as his WHIP was only 1.02. They left Sisk unprotected in rule V and nobody grabbed him so there must something that other teams didn't like or think he wasn't ready for MLB ball. Personally I think this is a good get for KC. 6 Years of control of a likely solid Lefty reliever and a gamble on flame thrower Cruz who was starting to find more control. Cruz had tendency to groove pitches though so there is work to be done. The Twins get one year of control for Taylor and he is great Buxton insurance in the field not so much with the bat. Probably a necessary move. I assume an outfielder gets moved here shortly? Man the Twins are getting picked over on the pitching prospect side of things, but they got Sisk in the Happ deal so kind of found money\asset there and Cruz is a lottery ticket for KC so not a bad deal I guess.6 points
-
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
IndyTwinsFan and 5 others reacted to Rik19753 for a post in a topic
6 pointsI like it. The best defensive OF in the league just got better. I guess this signals the end of Celestino though. Really would have liked for them to give a chance to Evan Sisk. But it is nice that J.A.Happ actually provided some value to the team after all.6 points -
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
cjj td and 5 others reacted to Squirrel for a post in a topic
6 pointsThat’s just not true. One could say they valued him more than others because he’s the one who got the return they wanted and cleared space for Kirilloff, Lee, Julien and/or Lewis. This trade was all about value on many levels, not about lack of it. This game is played by human beings, and we all are emotional about our favorites and perceptions of good. FOs have to be more objective than that and view their players not just as human beings but as assets or no one would get traded ever. It’s probably the hard part of the job, especially with one as well liked as Arraez. I hate when players get traded away or non tendered. I still feel pangs for Eduardo and Eddie. But in the end, those were all the right decisions to make, imo, including this trade of Arraez.6 points -
Where Are They Now? The Twins Last 10 First-Round Draft Picks
Where Are They Now? The Twins Last 10 First-Round Draft Picks
Doctor Gast and 5 others reacted to mikelink45 for a post in a topic
6 pointsFour flops from my perspective - Sabato, Cavaco, Stewart, Jay, Three injury prone and still hoping - Lewis, Larnach, Kiriloff One traded - Petty One a staple on the MLB roster - Gordon And One we have high hopes for - Lee For this to be a good report the three injury guys have to make it along with Lee - if they all turn it around it is a good record..6 points -
The Twins Have a Type
The Twins Have a Type
Riverbrian and 5 others reacted to JD-TWINS for a post in a topic
6 pointsGotta like the fact that we have 8 guys that can get outs at 3.30 - 4.00 ERA level with a couple more behind them with potential & Paddack coming in August/September. Varland - Winder in St Paul SWR & Balazovic in deep emergency St. Paul Paddack in August/September possibly Maeda in Pen Mahle - Gray - López - Ryan - Ober ……………………….. Injured in last 2 years: Maeda - Gray - Mahle - Winder - Ober - Paddack - López Lots of risk - need lots of bodies!!!6 points -
Elephant in the Lockeroom.
Elephant in the Lockeroom.
TwinsDr2021 and 5 others reacted to lecroy24fan for a post in a topic
6 pointsClearly the demand is driving a tough market, as KC asked for Winder in a Michael Taylor deal. IMO Winder would be a very high price to pay for a 4th OF.6 points -
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Nine of twelve and 4 others reacted to chpettit19 for a post in a topic
5 pointsCelestino needs to progress at AAA. He's not ready for MLB yet. That's abundantly clear. Having him back in AAA is by far the better option for him and his development.5 points -
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
Twins33 and 4 others reacted to Musk21 for a post in a topic
5 pointsI continuously see the point being made that "Lopez is only a #3, do we really need more #3's?" I for one welcome the added depth to the rotation if it means no more trotting out pitchers like Bundy, Archer, Chi Chi Gonzalez, J.A. Happ, Matt Shoemaker, etc. It's a good thing to have solid starting pitching depth... No doubt Arraez's bat will be missed, but I think his production can be replaced relatively soon by whomever steps up out of Julien, Lewis, Lee, Martin.5 points -
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
cjj td and 4 others reacted to Major League Ready for a post in a topic
5 pointsSquirrel's point about the value of this trade having multiple levels makes this an interesting case. Arreaz did one thing extremely well. However, when the Twins look at how they replace him, it's not a simple player to player comparison. He was a below average defender and base runner with little power and he did not hit LH pitching well. The key to how this works out with a guy that fit in wherever they had room will be how they cover his ABs in aggregate. Can Kirilloff provide better defense at 1B and equal offensive production. Can Julien provide an equal OBP with more power and therefore a higher OPS / wRC+ along with above average base running and equal defense. Can Martin provide similar OBP with better defensive value and great base running. Will the additions of Lewis and Lee squeeze Arraez out? In other words, will the players taking his ABs collectively cover the offense of Arraez while gaining in other areas? The more I think about it, the more I think they can cover his departure.5 points -
Elephant in the Lockeroom.
Elephant in the Lockeroom.
DJL44 and 4 others reacted to tony&rodney for a post in a topic
5 pointsExactly. When you take a look through the guys who can actually play centerfield, you begin to have some appreciation for Celestino. It's a tough market.5 points -
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
Someone and 4 others reacted to rwilfong86 for a post in a topic
5 pointsThey filled a great need for another #3 starter when they have an entire rotation full? I think this could easily go down as the worst trade this FO makes. Trading an All-Star, Silver Slugger, and Batting Champion who is the best contact hitter with the lowest K rate in baseball for an average starting pitcher and 2 prospects who are at least 4 years away is another fleece job. At the end of the day, Miami is a better team, the Twins really aren't. They're still the #3 team in the AL Central.5 points -
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
Aerodeliria and 4 others reacted to Shaitan for a post in a topic
5 pointsTurning down an offer is the first step of any negotiation. I'm not reading anything into this. And find me one employee, anywhere, who doesn't think they're worth more than their boss pays them.5 points -
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
BigSkyTwinsFan and 4 others reacted to chpettit19 for a post in a topic
5 pointsWhen the 2nd sentence of the article is "Terry Ryan, the former Twins general manager, used a 2-through-8 system to have his scouts evaluate players" you know it's just going to be about how the game was better back in the day, and these new young guys, and their "analytics," don't know what they're doing. While I'll be the first to say that analytics have made the game far less entertaining with the 3 true outcomes, it's embarrassing to tie the scouting scale to Terry Ryan like that. News flash: the Twins current front office also uses the 20-80 scale! Terry Ryan wasn't some super genius who was doing something outrageous. The 20-80 scale for scouting players was used by Branch Rickey who died back in the 60s. It's been around for a little while. Using Terry Ryan's name there is simply an attempt to get the "old school" crowd riled up. As for Arraez and an extension, he's not the first player to turn one down and won't be the last. Good for him for not taking less than he feels he's worth. And good for the Twins for not paying more for a player than they think he's worth.5 points -
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
It seems like the organization had its fill of running overmatched youngsters out on the field last year when the injury train started rolling. Lots of quality depth and several top tier prospects on the 40 man now…we’ll see if it translates to wins.4 points
-
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
roger and 3 others reacted to Doctor Gast for a post in a topic
4 pointsHe has an option year that he can be sent down to AAA, But I believe he still needs to be on the 40 man or be claimed by another team.4 points -
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Fatbat and 3 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
4 pointsMeh. I get it, but it doesn't excite me4 points -
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
IndyTwinsFan and 3 others reacted to 2wins87 for a post in a topic
4 pointsPThe team certainly could use some speed at times. Taylor was still 86th percentile in sprint speed at 31 last year, though he's never really been a huge base stealer. It's a good depth move. I did like Sisk. With Thielbar a setup man and Moran more of a left-handed righty matchup specialist, I thought they still could have had room for more of a LOOGY type even with the 3 batter minimum. Cruz definitely has potential too, though I'm kind of skeptical he'll ever really learn control. End of the day, both marginal guys that are never going to make or break a team, so really can't complain about this move4 points -
Twins have traded for Michael Taylor from Royals
Twins have traded for Michael Taylor from Royals
Bigfork Twins Guy and 3 others reacted to notoriousgod71 for a post in a topic
4 pointsTaylor, Gallo, and Buxton lead MLB in runs saved since 2020. One way to improve this pitching staff.4 points -
Twins Acquire Gold-Glove Outfielder from Royals
So, now with another outfielder they must be going to trade Kepler or another outfileder. Can't help but feel there is still more to come. See you at the ballpark.4 points
-
Elephant in the Lockeroom.
Elephant in the Lockeroom.
Cris E and 3 others reacted to chpettit19 for a post in a topic
4 pointsSo, no, you have no proof of it, it just feels that way. You're certainly entitled to your opinion, but it's not "common sense" that Lewis shouldn't play OF. Why isn't Trout a 1B then? Or just a DH. Or Judge. He'd be a huge target to throw to at first. Mookie Betts was an infielder when he first started, but now he's a gold glove outfielder. Both Upton brothers were SS that moved to the OF. The Padres are shifting their $340 million man from SS to RF this season. You don't think going full speed to his right to backhand a ball, plant and throw back across the field puts any strain on his knee? Or going up the middle to get to a ball and planting and spinning to throw to first? If it was so "common sense" that OFers are at such higher risk to be injured it'd be super easy to prove. There'd be data for it. https://www.onlinegambling.ca/content-hub/mlb-injuries.php According to this article the OF doesn't look any more dangerous than the IF to me. CF averaged 1 more day on the IL than 3B. Only 10 more than SS. LF, CF, RF combined averaged 1 more day than 3B, SS, and 2B combined. Shoot, DHs averaged as many as RFers. If it were so obvious that OFers were getting hurt more than IFers it'd be really easy to prove.4 points -
Keeping the Rolls Royce in the Garage
Keeping the Rolls Royce in the Garage
Doctor Gast and 3 others reacted to Alex Boxwell for a post in a topic
4 pointsIs this Rocco Baldelli? Am I being punked? Seriously though, yes, I was that player in college. I played through various injuries to try and help my team and play the game I love, I get it more than you probably realize and that's ok. Like you said he was unable to run some days, I think most people that followed baseball were aware of that. In the instance of last year, the conversation should have been let's get it fixed so you can run and/or manage this so the at-bats can be consistent. A competitor will always want to take the field, it's the organizations job to protect them. Protecting them isn't a weird on again off again schedule where we watch a players batting average disintegrate. There's a great article on this at the top of the page.4 points -
Where Are They Now? The Twins Last 10 First-Round Draft Picks
What are the odds Cavaco ever puts on an MLB jersey? He was one of those really young guys we were told to "be patient" on, but he's been in the system for 5 years now and has been pretty much below average the whole time. Kind of a sad story, really. Will be very interesting to see how Petty turns out. Hard to tell at this point, I don't really have a guess either way. Lee is the most exciting 1st round pick since Royce Lewis. Speaking of Lewis, if I had to bet on any of them having a great career, he's the one I'd take. Can't wait to see him at Target Field in June. Fingers crossed.4 points
-
The Falvey Philosophies, Part 1: The Young Core
The Falvey Philosophies, Part 1: The Young Core
Melissa and 3 others reacted to chpettit19 for a post in a topic
4 pointsThe first thing I notice is that the vast majority of their starting pitching was acquired via MLB trade. I don't know if that'd be the case if guys like Canterino, Ober, and Winder could stay healthy, but that's where things are at. The key moving forward now is filling that rotation with more pre-arb guys. Ryan, SWR, Varland, and Balazovic need to step up and take over 60% of the rotation. Ryan is already there. So need 2 of the others, at a minimum, to step in as well. Ober is an interesting piece. He's broken down basically every year of his career, and a move to the pen may be the move for him, unfortunately. Same with Canterino and Winder. But a pen of Duran, Jax, Alcala, Moran, Canterino, Ober, and Winder could be real cheap and real good if they can all stay healthy in those roles. Prielipp and Raya are also really big pieces moving forward (but not on the 40-man so didn't want to discuss too much in this thread). The second thing I notice is that they seem to have a really good ability to develop legit MLB quality position players. They need their star position players to be healthy, but the last few years have seen a pretty steady flow of legit major league prospects graduating or being traded for current major leaguers. Steer and CES can be added to the current stable of Lewis, Kirilloff, Miranda, Julien, Jeffers, Larnach, Wallner, and Gordon. I'm not sold on Celestino, but that's 10 guys in the last couple years who look like guys legitimately worthy of a shot in major league baseball. You can build a team around that kind of development.4 points -
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
SF Twins Fan and 3 others reacted to jmlease1 for a post in a topic
4 pointsArraez did pretty well at 1B defensively this season, especially considering having basically never played the position before as a pro. As a 2B, he's below average. not awful, but not particularly good. Similar at 3B: acceptable, but not good defensively. the fact that he can play multiple positions in the infield adds value beyond just the results; positional flexibility is a very useful intangible benefit for a team. however, the Twins very clearly felt that it was going to be hard to keep Arraez on the field playing 2B or 3B and that his knees/legs needed the time at 1B/DH to stay in the lineup. Miami has him at 2B right now, so I guess we'll find out if the Twins were right on this one. But if he's missing more time and/or needs to slide down to 1B/DH, the need for more offensive production jumps up. As noted, even with Arraez's batting title, his overall OPS put him in the middle of the pack among 1Bs last season. And that was his best and healthiest (in terms of games played) as a professional. he doesn't hit the ball hard, and there's little evidence that he ever will on a consistent basis. He's got a great skill in making contact, avoiding Ks, getting on base, working counts, and collecting hits. there's real value in that, and it's also very fun to watch. But it does limit his upside, and it's more than fair to worry about his health. It was painful to see him limping through games last season, though I give him credit for fighting through it when we were so short-handed. but those leg injuries mean he's not adding value on the bases, and make it hard to see him getting through the season at 2B. I can understand people calling Lopez a #3 starter...but he pitched more like a #2 last season. Now, that was also his healthiest and most successful season (from a value standpoint) as well, so maybe we won't get more or even that much from lopez, but there's a very fair argument to be made that right now he should be seen as the 2nd best pitcher in the rotation, behind Gray. personally, I wanted any pitching acquisition to be better than Gray...but when the argument is now whether Mahle or Maeda is the 5th guy in the rotation, then that's a pretty deep group and a significant improvement over the rotation we had last season, which had a ton of starts made by Dylan Bundy (who was well below average), Chris Archer (who couldn't throw enough innings and was unquestionably below average), Devin Smeltzer (who was more lucky than good last season), and Josh Winder (who had results more like we should have expected from Smeltzer). I'll be a lot happier fan if those 77 starts are eaten up by Lopez, Mahle, and Maeda.4 points -
Where Are They Now? The Twins Last 10 First-Round Draft Picks
Where Are They Now? The Twins Last 10 First-Round Draft Picks
Barnacles and 3 others reacted to gunnarthor for a post in a topic
4 pointsJay got hurt, too. I mean, pitchers are so fragile anyway but I am positive that if he didn't get hurt, he would have been a solid ML arm. I think we'll regret the Petty trade. Loved the Lee and Gordon picks at the time. Sabato and Cavaco I was a bit unsure about but ... Also, the Twins used 1st round picks on Matt Wallner, Brent Rooker and Noah Miller. I liked the Miller pick. Wallner and Rooker were confusing as they were massive bats without obvious defensive positions. But Wallner might play a lot this year.4 points -
The Twins Have a Type
The Twins Have a Type
Doctor Gast and 3 others reacted to chpettit19 for a post in a topic
4 pointsTrading for these types of guys with with just a couple years of control left likely isn't sustainable. But isn't a bad part of an overall strategy. They need to start developing some frontline guys in house. Whether by drafting and developing, using the international signing period and developing, or trading for prospects and developing. A mix of improved development (I think they develop major league pitchers pretty well, but need to produce some frontline guys. My hope is on Prielipp) and these types of good, not great pitchers that they can turn into great pitchers would be wonderful and lead to real success. I will say that if Duran, Alcala, Moran, Jax, Canterino, Ober, Winder, and Henriquez can form a shutdown bullpen that is definitely a nice bit of internal development. Canterino, Winder, and Ober on the list due to real questions about their ability to hold up in the rotation.4 points -
Where Are They Now? The Twins Last 10 First-Round Draft Picks
Where Are They Now? The Twins Last 10 First-Round Draft Picks
Kummel and 3 others reacted to Nine of twelve for a post in a topic
4 pointsThis is a bit of a nitpick, but I don't think it's fair to say that a player was a disappointment. The way to think about it is which draft decisions were disappointing.4 points -
The Twins Have a Type
The Twins Have a Type
Doctor Gast and 3 others reacted to beckmt for a post in a topic
4 pointsThe Guardians have gotten a fair number of their pitchers in trade, only seem to identify them when in the minors. Same concept only they seem to get some of their pitchers as throwins to deals.4 points -
Who Will Be the Twins' Opening Day DH?
Who Will Be the Twins' Opening Day DH?
SF Twins Fan and 3 others reacted to Squirrel for a post in a topic
4 pointsMiranda could be a possibility if Farmer starts at 3rd with Kirilloff at 1B4 points -
Who Will Be the Twins' Opening Day DH?
Who Will Be the Twins' Opening Day DH?
Strombomb and 3 others reacted to PatPfund for a post in a topic
4 pointsI get the attraction of a new name, but one of the reasons I think Luis was a potential trade asset was to open space with a glut of potential bats on the horizon (some of whom might displace Miranda at 3b, namely Lewis or Lee). Adding somebody in this slot is akin to signing Wacha or another end-of-career person who keeps ready players from stepping up (hitting on the one hand, pitching on the other). This shifts a bit if they move Kepler (which won't bring back an MLB player, but opens an OF slot (for a prospect if not a signee like Profar), but I'd rather they sign Fulmer to bolster the 'pen, and start the year with internal hitting options.4 points -
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
adorduan and 3 others reacted to chpettit19 for a post in a topic
4 pointsWouldn't the change in the shift rules hurt Arraez's value? He wasn't shifted on to start with so he's not going to hit any better than he did simply because of the shift (he might hit better, but the shift wouldn't be why). But other guys will. If the rest of the league is now hitting for a higher average because of the shift ban, doesn't it make Arraez hitting for average a less valuable commodity?4 points -
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
SF Twins Fan and 3 others reacted to chpettit19 for a post in a topic
4 pointsIf Chourio makes the bigs at all it'll be quite impressive. I don't bank on any 17 year old who hasn't even debuted in full season ball making the bigs. He's just a nice lottery ticket to have. But I think 3 years for Salas seems reasonable. As far as prospects go, he's got as good a shot as any. My hope is that he ends 2023 in AA. If he does that he's a big time prospect and on the doorstep. A Miranda style season this year would be incredible and I'd very much like it. I'm not a Lopez believer. Cognitive dissonance has me trying to see the positives in him now that he's on the Twins, but I was very much against a 1 for 1 swap of Arraez for Lopez. But adding a borderline (some evaluators have him in, some don't) top 100 global prospect in the deal makes it reasonable to me. Really hope Julien tears Spring Training apart and is the leadoff hitter for the Twins sooner than later. Assuming there's no other trades that bring in a leadoff hitter type.4 points -
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
I get where PR is coming from. We all love watching Arraez bat. The guy most prospect watchers didn't think would make it to MLB let alone win a batting title. The guy who is always humble and hard working. The guy who can really make a pitcher work but Reusse only focused on one side of the story if you ask me. Reusse didn't mention Arraez's knee issue's. Didn't mention keeping him healthy meant keeping him at 1st and DH more and resting him versus lefties when possible. He didn't mention that the over all average OPS of 1st baseman was essentially the same as Arraez. Didn't have a plan for what to do with Arraez when Lewis, Lee and Jullien come up. He also is someone who always, always complains about Twins pitching and he didn't address that in his article either. He didn't mention that Trade values and most outlets thought the value the Twins got back was rated as significant and likely an overpay. That even the Rookie Miranda had a 750 OPS after having a really tough start to his MLB career so it isn't like Luis's 785 OPS is elite. His production can be replaced easier than then the Twins can find Pitchers of Lopez's caliber. I get Arraez is a unique hitter and I have loved, loved everything about him, but I still think this trade made the Twins a stronger team now and in the future.4 points
-
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
Rumor: Arraez turned down a Twins offer before last year
cjj td and 3 others reacted to Squirrel for a post in a topic
4 pointsNot only that, but by adding Salas, it's another piece we can use in a trade. It was a good move. Lopez wasn't the pitcher I'd have gone after, as I've said, but, I think the Twins made a good value trade.4 points