Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Leaderboard

  1. Seth Stohs

    Administrator
    Points
    24,042
    Posts
  2. chpettit19

    Community Leader
    Points
    3,028
    Posts
  3. Vanimal46

    Old-Timey Member
    Points
    17,338
    Posts
  4. Fire Dan Gladden

    Verified Member
    Points
    847
    Posts

Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation on 11/14/2022 in all areas

  1. Lewis will be a All-star SS for us. I am a million percent in on Lewis as the face of the team in two years. All of his injuries have been fluky and it sucks. He is so good.
  2. Simple answer - YES. And that is an historic Yes. We have been led on by the Sano story, the video, the minor league stats, the rookie break-out and then the crash. The First round draft busts never got to a point that they truly disappointed - except to make the FO look bad. Nishioka was so bad that the expectations flagged as soon as he took the field - once again it was the FO. Donaldson did what he also had done, the fact that his attitude is a cancer is something the FO should have been aware of. But Sano seems like he is uncoachable. He regressed. Not being a three true outcome guy I was disappointed in the lack of plate discipline. The stupid statcast mph and distance measurements mesmerized him and no one seemed to be able to tell him that a HR counts the same no matter how hard or far it went. Nor did he understand that with players on base and the team needing a run that a hit of any kind might work and maybe with two strikes it might be a change of strategy by the batter. So yes in a big and loud way, I am very disappointed.
  3. Nishioka has to be right up there. At least he had the decency and honor to realize he was in over his head and leave in such a way that the Twins weren't on the hook for the remainder of his contract.
  4. 5 points
    He's not on the 40 man so if they were to waive him it would be for the purpose of releasing him.
  5. Sano is certainly not a bust: he was 3rd in RoY, made an all-star team, and had some fine seasons with the team. Even with the rough years, he's leaving the Twins with an OPS+ of 116 (which this season would have tied him for 6th with Jose Miranda, 1 pt behind Jorge Polanco). He had big, impactful years in 2015, 2017, and 2019 (and wasn't bad in 2021 either, with a terrific second half of the season). he couldn't do it consistently year over year, and had some stretches where he was basically in an unplayable slump. The gazillion Ks drove some people crazy, and the injuries started piling up too, reducing his availability and his impact. I think it's fair to say his overall career with the Twins was a disappointment, but only in the context of how great it could have been. We saw enough of the heights to wish it could have been like that every year for at least 4-6 seasons. instead it was every other year at best. Under no circumstances was he a bust; he made it to the majors, he had success in the majors, and when he was rolling it seemed like he carried the club for a month with his bat. It's not his fault the front office & manager threw him out in the OF for 1/3 of his appearances in 2016 (indefensible then and now), and he was certainly more impactful than many other highly touted prospects (Adam Johnson, Tyler Jay, Kohl Stewart, Levi Michael, Matt Moses...those are busts). Moving on from Sano is the right decision. but we still got good value out of him while he was here (at $8M per bWAR he far out-performed the amount we paid him). It's too bad that the highs weren't sustainable, but so be it.
  6. Sano came from a small town in the DR and signed with an MLB team in a foreign country. He finished 3rd in the Rookie of the Year vote. He was an All-Star and participated in the HR Derby. He hit 25 or more homers FOUR TIMES in his seven years with the team. He wasn't the best fielder but he did make some highlight-reel defensive plays at 3rd base, including a couple memorable triple plays. Speaking of memorable, his grand slam on the road in Cleveland was one of the biggest hits by any Twin in 2019. He learned a 2nd language and became bilingual. To see a headline that says "How Big of a Bust is Sano?" is frankly just low-brow clickbait in my opinion. If his career ended today, he'd still have an above-average career better than most guys who make The Show. Any Twins fan who thinks Sano's career has been a "bust" needs to have their head examined and start learning to adjust their expectations in life.
  7. 4 points
    He's way too far off for me to think he has any sort of real ceiling. He very well may develop nicely into a real piece, but any team willing to take a guy who just hit .246 in A ball can have him as far as I'm concerned. I think you're saying it nicer than me by saying it's low risk that someone would stash him for a year. To me the Rule 5 is mostly nothing. People freaked out when Baddoo got off to a crazy start in 2021, but he then came crashing back to earth for the last 3/4 of that season before being terrible in 2022. Like @Fire Dan Gladden said, the Rule 5 simply doesn't produce great players at any sort of a regular rate. If you can't replace a 65 OPS+ outfielder you lost through Rule 5 you're doomed anyways. I love the idea behind it and it's great for these prospects to get a chance to see a major league field, but there's very, very few that turn out to be real losses to their clubs. The amount of time we spend talking about who to keep and who they'll lose doesn't match the actual impact of Rule 5 drafted players.
  8. 4 points
    Dobnak's under contract. He was DFAd and went unclaimed, so he's with the organization until the contract runs out. Obviously, the options wouldn't be picked up. Of course, the Twins could release him and at that point he'd be a free agent.
  9. 4 points
    I think the challenge at using Gray as our test subject here is that people want to point at his usage as being based on not wanting him to see the order a 3rd time. I think there was some of that, but I think the bigger variable was health. I don't think the Twins went into 2022 saying "let's trade our most recent #1 pick for a guy we think can only go through an order twice." I think his inability (for years now) to stay healthy caused his usage to change from what him and the Twins wanted it to be. Spring training started late for everyone. It started even later for Sonny as he was traded right as it was about to get going and he had life things to deal with with that change and he didn't get the ST innings in that he needed. So his first start was a little short (4.2 innings, 2 earned). His next one he got hurt after 1.2 innings and went on the IL. So now he's had an extra short ST and an IL stint after 1+ starts (April 16th). So when Sonny came back the Twins were understandably cautious with him. 4 innings in his first start back (May 7th) followed by 4.1 innings (May 13th). In his 3rd start back from the IL he went 6 innings. Followed that with a 7 inning start and a 6 inning start. Then went back on the IL (May 29th). So the Twins haven't made it out of the first 2 months of the season and he's hit the IL twice. If someone wants to make the case that he isn't being used long enough in games you point out that through 7 starts he only has 3 that he went into the 6th, but that's ignoring a whole lot of context. After coming back from his 2nd IL stint they were again a little cautious. 5 innings (June 15th) followed by 4 innings (he was bad and gave up 4 runs that game). Then in his 3rd start back from his 2nd IL stint he went 7 innings. His next 3 starts were shorter, but he also wasn't good in them. He wasn't pulled cuz of "analytics" (in quotes cuz it really is analytics that tell you those number of runs in those number of innings is bad, but those are "acceptable" analytics to the anti-analytics crowd) in games where he went 4.2 and gave up 5 earned, or 3.2 innings and 6 earned. The next start after those 3 bad ones he went 6 innings. He was then in basically a 5/6 inning per start range for the rest of the year until he got injured again in September. The problem was that when he had his now infamous statement of frustration about not going deeper into the game it was during his hot stretch and people went back and looked and his innings/start numbers were very low. They ignored the context at the start of the year that caused that and decided the Twins were just using every starter as 2 times through the order guys when it wasn't the case. The Twins had some starters (Bundy and Archer as the obvious examples) that weren't talented enough and the plan from the jump was to use them in shorter stints and piggyback them with Winder. Then Winder got hurt and messed that up. Ryan and Gray were given more leash until Sonny hit the IL twice in his first 7 starts and Ryan got crushed by COVID and wasn't the same guy for the next month after he returned. This fed the "Twins use analytics too much and Rocco has no feel for the game!" crowd by adding some context ignoring data points to their narrative. The Twins had a more individualized plan to start the year, but it gone blown up by injuries. My problem with them is they never adjusted and just went through the rest of the year overusing 1 inning guys and it cost them a lot of games.
  10. There are a couple others that could be taken off. Contreras, perhaps even Garlick for position players. Would anyone take Enlow in rule 5 at this point. They could cut Pagan loose as well. It will be interesting to see how this plays out.
  11. His bat speed lessened. His discipline was never what it might have been. Paul Molitor had him figured out. He said that Sano and his agent (Rob Plummer, who has his own problems) decided that he had made it and he could relax and live the dream. Molitor suggested that attitude would be his undoing. The Twins would be better off if Molitor was still managing the team, but that's an argument for another day. In this instance, the man was a prophet. Sano's career isn't over. Maybe this wakeup call will give him some motivation. I wish him luck.
  12. 4 points
    The game has changed. And has arguably changed faster and more dramatically then it's ever changed before in its history. Not all fans are going to keep up with that. Not all of them will even want to, and that's fine. That's the risk of change. Analytics aren't going anywhere, so those that choose to stay do need to adapt to what the game has become. Analytics are everywhere. Not just baseball. Not just sports. Everywhere. Not using them is simply putting yourself at a disadvantage.
  13. 4 points
    The Twins will certainly have players at risk no matter who is added, but given that teams all across baseball have similar issues due to the lack of a Rule 5 draft last year, teams will have a lot more players to choose from which will work in our favor. I like your choices. I saw Helman a couple of times this summer as well as on Minor league TV, and I think he would be attractive to any team looking for a utility guy who does a lot of things well, including stealing bases. Severino has the potential to really break out, so I think hanging on to him makes sense. With so many players in the "portal" this year, what do you think the Twins might be looking for if they make a pick? Great article as usual.
  14. 4 points
    I am always amazed by how easily blame can be confidently matter-of-factly assigned to a process or person that you have no access to.
  15. 4 points
    100%. I think some of the complaints about Rocco & analytics are more of a complaint about the current state of baseball, where certain fans hate starters being pulled at 90-100 pitches, rather than being allowed to go as deep in the game as they can, and only getting pulled when they run into trouble. Or want more base-stealing. Or hate strikeouts. So I'm not sure it's really about Rocco all the time, he's just the focus as our manager for what they feel is a bigger problem (but maybe don't/can't articulate it like that)? Of course, I'm also the guy who thinks fans tend to overrate the impact of the manager on a team; I think there are only a handful of superior managers (and even they can't win without the talent) and increasingly few terrible ones. Most of them fall in the mushy middle and in aggregate only go plus/minus 2 wins based on strategic decisions throughout the year. I don't mind analytics in baseball at all. It's always been the most stat-driven sport and the least interactive by the players compared to basketball, hockey, football, etc when players have to be in synch at all times or things can go off the rails quickly. Digging in on the stats has always been part of what's fun for me in baseball.
  16. Garlick signed

    chpettit19 and 2 others reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic

    3 points
    That’s likely where he ends up on the depth chart on opening day 2023. He’s making $50k more than the league minimum. MLB Trade Rumors had him projected at $1.1 million for arbitration and they’re generally accurate with their projections. Instead of rolling the dice as a FA, he took the guaranteed cash. Can’t blame him.
  17. 3 points
    Poor, poor Bill James. Based on many of the comments here, it sounds like if the majority of TD readers had their way, they would go back in time and make Bill James "disappear"... I have been wondering for a long time why everybody seems to blame all of the bad things that happened this year on "Rocco's overreliance on analytics". Does he use analytics? Sure... so does everybody else in baseball (not to mention football, basketball, hockey, curling, and any other activity that analytics can give you an advantage). But why the attack on the analytics usage? More directly, why the attack on specific parts of his analytic usage? Defensive shifts General defensive placement Pinch hitting Lineups Defensive replacement All of these rely (to some degree) on advanced analytics. Rarely are any of these discussed here. The vitriol is always around pitching usage, but really seems to stem from Sonny Gray's complaining about not being allowed to go through the third time of the order and some relievers pitching poorly in the middle of the season. The problem with analytics is the same problem with everything else: it is not 100% accurate. But they do increase your chances. I remember the comments when Gardenhire was the manager: He never uses analytics!! The Twins are light years behind on metric usage!! How quickly the pendulum swings... Call me a Rocco apologist. That's fine. I have said many times before I have no clue if Rocco is a good manager. Too many variables the general public knows nothing about. What I would actually like to hear are logical arguments that Rocco's reliance on analytics actually cost the Twins games, not the emotional responses that come with the Twins collapsing.
  18. 3 points
    That's the thing... if they DFA him, teams can claim him for nothing. I definitely think there are teams that would do that. If not, then it's possible he would get through the Rule 5 draft since it costs about $100K to select someone in the Rule 5. But there is no reason to remove him until absolutely necessary. They added him last offseason, knowing he was rehabbing from Tommy John last year and would get eased back in. He came through 2022 healthy and can take off in 2023.
  19. 3 points
    The timing of these is strange to me too. For instance, Garlick and Pagan could be non-tendered on Friday. If they add two, they're at 38, but they say they drop two, they're at 36. And that's fine as they will obviously add free agents and such. So, I think that adds to the intrigue and the difficulty of the decision.
  20. 3 points
    The biggest difference is that teams now have one more year to evaluate their own players before they are Rule 5 eligible. That extra year is huge. So yeah, I would agree that the odds of finding a great player aren't good. But there are exceptions still. And often teams are just looking to add talent, and they'll add a potential bullpen arm or utility player. That's why I think Helman would potentially be lost, and frankly, maybe Sisk.
  21. 3 points
    or the two teams work out a trade.
  22. This is such a huge part of the process. Even with the upside, most of these players have little risk of being drafted because they will not stick on the MLB roster the entire year. The Twins still have fond memories of their Rule 5 picks, but the reality is that these drafts rarely amount to anything. Consider this article from 2018: https://www.forbes.com/sites/ryandavis/2018/12/17/looking-back-on-the-10-greatest-rule-5-picks-of-all-time/?sh=15e0f07c92b1 There are a few exciting names there, but when you get in depth, you realize there really isn't a huge amount of risk here. This is the top 10 out of hundreds and hundreds of picks. The Twins have four spots. Protect your top four guys that you believe will have the best chance of impacting the team and move on.
  23. Since the end of the season, the Twins' front office has been cleaning up the 40-man roster that, had way more than 40 men on it. When the World Series finished, several players automatically came off the roster and became free agents. Carlos Correa exercised his option and became a free agent. The Twins Designated five players for Assignment early in the offseason. Three of them (Jermaine Palacios, Jake Cave, Caleb Hamilton) were claimed by other teams. Just last week, players still on the 60-Day Injured List were removed from the Injured List. At the same time, Cody Stashak was outrighted from the roster and elected free agency. All that is to say that a lot of roster work has been done already. Some of that is because, on Tuesday, teams have to submit additions to their 40-man rosters by 5:00 central time. The Twins' 40-man roster is currently at 36 players. There are 21 pitchers, one catcher, five infielders, and nine outfielders. The Twins (and other teams) may make a few small trades to clean up a couple more roster spots before the additions. Friday is another key date in the offseason when teams will need to decide which arbitration-eligible players to tender (or non-tender) a 2023 contract. A couple more players could potentially come off of the roster at that time. Before getting into the predictions for which Twins minor leaguers will be added to the team’s 40-man roster, it is important to note that some of these decisions were already made during the season. Louie Varland, Matt Wallner, and Simeon Woods Richardson all were added to the roster in September. If they had not been, they would have been Givens to be added now. Those three put up tremendous 2022 seasons in both Wichita and St. Paul and earned their late-season promotions. Secondly, who is eligible to be selected in the Rule 5 draft if they are not protected? Players who signed when they were 18 or younger in 2018 or earlier. Players who were 19 or older when they signed in 2019 or earlier. The age at signing is the key, but a general rule would be: Players drafted out of high school in 2017 or 2018. (unless they signed when they were 19) Players drafted out of junior college or four-year college in 2017, 2018, or 2019. International players signed at 16, 17, or 18 years old in 2016, 2017, or 2018. Finally, players added to the 40-man roster on Tuesday cannot be removed from the 40-man roster until spring training. That is important to remember when the team signs free agents or makes a trade this winter. So, here are my quick thoughts on players that should be, or at least should be considered to be, added to the Twins' 40-man roster. THE GIVENS 1.) 2B Edouard Julien - The 23-year-old from Quebec was the Twins 18th round pick in 2019 out of Auburn. Just this weekend, he was named the Breakout Prospect in the Arizona Fall League after he hit .400/.563/.686 (1.248) with five doubles and five home runs in 21 games. However, you could argue that he broke out during the 2022 regular season in Wichita where he hit .300/.441/.490 (.931) with 19 doubles and 17 home runs in 113 games. He even stole 19 bags. Of course, I would argue that he broke out in 2021, his professional debut after missing 2019 and 2020 due to Tommy John surgery and the Covid pandemic. He split that season between Ft. Myers and Cedar Rapids. In 112 games, he hit .267/.434/.480 (.914) with 28 doubles, 18 home runs, and 34 stolen bases. Where will he play? Well, he spent most of 2022 at second base. He has played first and third base in pro ball. Yes, he played a couple of games in left field in 2021, but that isn’t an option. Regardless, his all-around offensive game makes him a future top-of-the-lineup contributor. 2.) RHP Matt Canterino - Maybe not quite as “given” as Julien, but Canterino is absolutely a given to be added. He was the team’s second-round draft pick in 2019 out of Rice University. Since turning pro, two things have been true of the 24-year-old righty. First, when he has pitched, he has been absolutely dominant. In 11 games and 34 1/3 innings for Wichita in 2022, he posted a 1.83 ERA and struck out 50 batters. In 23 innings in 2021, he struck out 45 batters. His stuff is electric. Unfortunately, the second truth is that he has missed a lot of time with injury. He was shut down early in the 2021 season after experiencing some elbow pain. The rest-and-rehab was tried, but in 2022 at Wichita, he was limited to three innings per start and eventually four innings, but as his arm threw more, the pain continued. Finally, in mid-August, he underwent Tommy John surgery in Arlington making his availability to pitch in 2023 unlikely. But again, with this kind of talent, particularly with a pitcher, you keep him around and add him and don’t even give it a second thought. STRONG CONSIDERATIONS 3.) LHP Brent Headrick - In 2022, Headrick made 15 starts in Cedar Rapids before moving up to Double-A Wichita. In 2021, he was limited in the second half with some shoulder impingement. He stayed healthy throughout the 2022 season and went 10-5 with a 3.32 ERA and a 1.08 WHIP. In 108 1/3 innings, he walked just 25 batters and struck out 136 batters. Now, his Double-A numbers don’t look as good. In 10 games, he went 2-3 with a 4.81 ERA. However, in his first Wind Surge appearance, he gave up seven runs on 10 hits (including five home runs) in 2 1/3 innings. Take away that outing, and he went 2-2 with a 3.54 ERA, and in 40 2/3 innings, he gave up just six more home runs. Headrick was the Twins seventh-round pick in 2019 out of Illinois State. 4.) UT Michael Helman - The Twins were excited to select Helman out of Texas A&M in the 11th round of the 2018 draft. After a strong pro debut that year, he really struggled in 2019 at High-A Ft. Myers and ended the season injured. After a lost 2020 season, he hit .246/.336/.462 (.798) with 21 doubles, four triples, and 19 home runs in Cedar Rapids. He added 21 steals. He finished that season by playing in the Arizona Fall League. He began the 2022 season with 39 games at Wichita where he hit .278/.368/.472 (.840) with six doubles, two triples, and six home runs. He finished the season in St. Paul where, in 96 games, he hit .250/.325/.416 (.741) with 17 doubles and 14 home runs. Combined, he ended the season with 23 doubles, 20 home runs, and an impressive 40 stolen bases. He has made himself a solid contributor at the bat. He has also worked very hard to get strong all over the field on defense. Drafted as a middle infielder, he started playing all over the place in 2021. In 2022, he played 43 games in center field, 41 games at second base, 29 games at third base, and 11 games at shortstop. In 2021, he played more in the corner outfield spots than in center field. He legitimately can play seven positions on the field, and maybe I should mention that when he went to junior college, he was a catcher. 5.) Misael Urbina - This is the potential upside addition. This is the guy with talent and athleticism and tools. The 20-year-old Urbina signed in July of 2018 out of Venezuela. He spent 2019 in the Dominican Summer League where he posted a solid .825 OPS with 21 extra-base hits and 19 stolen bases in 50 games. After the lost 2020 season, he came to the States in 2021. He didn’t make the Mighty Mussels Opening Day roster, but he was on the roster about a week later. He played 101 games for the Mighty Mussels and hit .191/.299/.286 (.585) with 12 doubles, four triples, five homes, and 16 steals. Unfortunately, Urbina missed about half of the 2022 season due to some visa issues. In 50 games for the Mighty Mussels, he hit .246/.323/.419 (.741) with 16 doubles, five homers, and nine stolen bases. The Twins have added players after they spend a year in Low-A. They did it in November 2013 when they added Jorge Polanco and Max Kepler after they played in Cedar Rapids that season. Of course, they also added Deibinson Romero and Estarlin de Los Santos to the 40-man roster after their Low-A seasons. (I’m sure @Roger will appreciate that reference.) It’s hard for me to believe that Urbina would be able to stick on a big-league roster all season, so this is very borderline. 6.) IF Yunior Severino - As you know, Atlanta signed Severino as a 16-year-old in 2016. He spent the following season with the Braves organization until they were deemed to have broken the rules of international signing and a bunch of their recently-signed international players became free agents again. This time, it was the Twins that gave him a big, seven-figure signing bonus. Severino has shown glimpses of talent, but he’s also missed time with injury. He broke out with a strong 35 games at the end of the 2021 season in Cedar Rapids when he hit .321/.414/.493 (.907) with 12 doubles and three homers. He began 2022 with 46 games with the Kernels and hit .283/.398/.572 (.970) with nine doubles, two triples, and 11 homers. He moved up to Wichita and hit .273/.338/.497 (.834) with eight doubles and eight home runs. At Cedar Rapids, he played mostly second base (and DH). With the Wind Surge, he played almost exclusively at third base. He is now 23 and could be a year away from being ready. 7.) C/1B Chris Williams - Chris Williams was the Twins' eighth-round pick in 2018 out of Clemson University. In 75 games for Wichita this summer, Williams hit .277/.372/.542 (.915) with 16 doubles and 18 home runs. He finished his season with 42 games in St. Paul. He hit just .192, but he had five doubles and 10 more home runs. This season, he played 83 games at first base and caught 24 games. He will turn 26 this month, but the Twins have a need for right-handed power and currently have just one catcher on their 40-man roster. Now, Williams is not going to do a lot of catching in the big leagues, but he can be a guy who can be a #3 catcher, a backup first base option, and a power bat off the bench might provide some value to the organization. 8.) RHP Cody Laweryson - Laweryson (pronounced Lor-ih-sun) was the Twins 14th round draft pick out of the University of Maine in 2019. In 2021, he missed the first two months of the season and then posted a 4.91 ERA and 1.33 WHIP in 15 games for Cedar Rapids. He did have 73 strikeouts and just 19 walks over his 58 2/3 innings. He went to the Arizona Fall League and struck out 18 batters in 14 innings and pitched in the Fall Stars game. He began 2022 in the Kernels' bullpen. In 35 innings, he struck out 42 and walked 12 batters. He posted a 2.57 ERA and a 1.06 WHIP. He moved up to Wichita where after 11 bullpen appearances, he made eight starts. He went 5-0 with a minuscule 1.06 ERA and a 0.94 WHIP. In 59 2/3 innings, he struck out 69 and walked just 15 batters. In the entire season, he gave up just two homers over 94 2/3 innings. He’s got decent stuff and a bit of a funky delivery. Was his half-season in Wichita enough for someone to select him in the Rule 5 draft, or for the Twins to add him? 9.) OF DaShawn Keirsey, Jr. - Keirsey was the Twins' fourth-round pick in 2018 out of the University of Utah. He had a brutal injury after crashing into the wall at the end of his sophomore season in college, but inexplicably returned for his junior season and posted an OPS of 1.049. Since the Twins drafted him, his biggest issue has been staying on the field. He was limited to 45 games in Cedar Rapids in 2021 due to leg muscle issues. He never was able to get into a rhythm. In 2022, he was bumped up to Wichita and was on the field for 121 games. He had a solid showing, if not a bit of a breakout season. He hit .271/.329/.395 (.724) with 26 doubles, three triples, and seven home runs. While not a power hitter, at times he can really drive the ball and use the whole field. But his speed is absolutely electric and can be game-changing. He stole 42 bases in 49 attempts this year (86%), but he is an elite defensive center fielder, able to run down almost anything and unafraid to throw his body around to make a catch. His athleticism alone has to get him considered, and in 2022, he stayed on the field and really contributed. 10.) LHP Kody Funderburk - When the Twins drafted the lefty from Dallas Baptist in the 15th round of the 2018 draft, they had him as a pitcher only. In college, he was a very good hitter as well. Over time, he has worked solely as a pitcher and very quietly has made himself into a prospect to watch. He had a solid 2021 season between Cedar Rapids (where he started) and Wichita (where he was a reliever). He then went and made six starts in the Arizona Fall League. In 2022 at Double-A Wichita, he went 10-5 with a 2.94 ERA. In 107 innings, he had 103 strikeouts to 44 walks. He has a bit of a funky delivery that might make him intriguing to a team in the Rule 5 draft. 11.) C/1B Alex Isola - In 2017, Isola and Keirsey were teammates at Utah. Isola transferred a couple of times before the Twins made him their 29th-round pick in 2019 out of Texas Christian University. Isola just completed his six-week stint in the Arizona Fall League where he hit five doubles, and in the semi-final game launched a 420+ foot home run to help send his team to the championship game. Like Williams, part of the allure of Isola is his ability to play behind the plate as needed. With Wichita, he made 17 starts at first base and 17 starts behind the plate. He won’t win any Gold Gloves, but he could be a #3 catcher in the big leagues. His calling card is his bat. In 58 games with the Wind Surge in 2022, he hit .286/.377/.471 (.848) with nine doubles and 10 home runs. He puts together solid plate appearances with a good knowledge of the strike zone. He’s willing to take his walks, but he also can drive the ball to the gaps and over the wall. 12.) RHP Austin Schulfer - The 26-year-old was the Twins 19th round pick in 2018 out of UW-Milwaukee. In 2021, he led all Twins minor-league pitchers with 110 innings pitched over 24 starts at Double-A Wichita. In 2022, he returned to the Wind Surge to start the season and worked in 15 games out of the bullpen. He gave up just one earned run over 23 innings (0.39 ERA) and struck out 30 and walked only four batters. He recorded seven saves. He moved up to St. Paul where he went 4-3 with a 5.23 ERA. In 32 2/3 Triple-A innings, he struck out 31 batters and walked 13 batters. Schulfer has always made adjustments and should return to the Saints in 2023. Depending on the injury front in the Twins bullpen, we could see him debut at some point. HAVE TO AT LEAST CONSIDER LHP Evan Sisk - Acquired from the Cardinals at the deadline in 2021, he was the 2022 Twins Daily Minor League Relief Pitcher of the Year. 5-1, 2.08 ERA in a combined 63 innings between Wichita and St. Paul. Had 76 strikeouts to go with 29 walks. SS/OF Will Holland - the fastest runner in the Twins minor leagues, he is a great athlete and could provide a team with solid outfield or shortstop defense and pinch-running abilities. He was the team’s 5th-round pick in 2019 from Auburn. LHRP Denny Bentley - Bentley has been very good in the Twins minor leagues and can record a lot of strikeouts, but he does walk a lot of batters, as he did in the Arizona Fall League. RHRP Osiris German - German remains a very intriguing 24-year-old reliever. His best pitch is his changeup. After six games in Cedar Rapids, he worked in 37 games for Wichita. He posted a 3.02 ERA and had 17 walks and 59 strikeouts in 53 2/3 innings. RHRP Hunter McMahon - he was the ninth-round pick by the Nationals in the 2019 draft. The Twins acquired him that offseason for Ryne Harper. He has pitched very little since. In 2021, he pitched in just five games. This year, he began in Ft. Myers (2.23 ERA), moved up to Cedar Rapids (1.19 ERA), and finished with four games in Double-A. In 73 2/3 combined innings. He had 76 strikeouts and just 16 walks. RHP Sean Mooney - The Twins 12th round pick in 2019 from St. John’s had Tommy John surgery that spring. So, he didn’t make his pro debut, officially, until 2021. In 42 innings, he had 71 strikeouts. In 2022 with Cedar Rapids, he posted a 3.30 ERA and had 82 strikeouts in 60 innings. Needs to stay healthy. UT Anthony Prato - 7th round pick in 2019 from UConn, Prato had a nice breakout season in 2022. He was limited in 2021 due to a broken hamate bone. In 2022, he played 45 games in Cedar Rapids before ending with 87 games in Wichita. Combined, he hit .285/.383/.444 (.827) with 30 doubles, eight triples, 10 homers, and 22 stolen bases. He played 60 games in left field, 34 games at second base, and 22 games at third base. RHP Randy Dobnak - Off the 40-man roster, if a team selected Dobnak, they would take on his contract too, so that’s unlikely. But, when he was healthy in 2019 and 2020, he was a solid back-of-rotation starter, and if he is healthy, could be that for a non-contender. RHRP Steven Cruz - MLB Pipeline ranks Cruz 28th in the organization. Ten (or even five) years ago, he would have ranked higher because he is capable of reaching triple-digits with his fastball. At 23, he posted a 5.14 ERA and a 1.59 WHIP in Wichita in 2022. In 56 innings, he had 72 strikeouts, but he also walked 35 batters. Love the arm, but hard to see him sticking in the big leagues. OTHER ELIGIBLE PLAYERS Hitters: David Banuelos, Andrew Bechtold, Kyle Schmidt, Seth Gray, Charles Mack, Jeferson Morales, Daniel Ozoria, Willie Joe Garry, Carlos Aguiar, Luis Baez, Wilfri Castro, Alexander Pena. Pitchers: Tyler Beck, Francis Peguero, Jon Olsen, Ryan Shreve, Brock Stewart, Michael Boyle, Jordan Brink, Jordan Gore, Casey Legumina, Alex Phillips, Regi Grace, Bradley Hanner, Derek Molina, Owen Griffith, Tyler Palm, Miguel Rodriguez, Matthew Swain, Zaquiel Puentes, Niklas Rimmel, Elpidio Perez, Wilker Reyes, Rafael Feliz, Danny Moreno, Alex Scherff, Andrew Cabezas, Ben Gross, Zach Neff, Josh Mitchell, Jose Brito. My prediction? This is as tough as I can remember this being. Again, we should be able to assume Canterino and Julien are added. After that, there are at least six to 10 others (and maybe more) where a legitimate case could be made. I am going to officially predict that they will also add Headrick, Helman, and Severino. I think Urbina is just not yet in a spot where he could stick in the big leagues, but I think he is at risk of being taken. He is probably the most interesting case (which is why I found a photo of him for the article). I think Chris Williams and Alex Isola are guys that could be at risk as well. Your turn? How many players will the Twins add to their 40-man roster by Tuesday’s deadline? Make your predictions for which players get added below.
  24. 2 points
    By 5:00 central time on Tuesday, teams will need to make their 40-man roster additions to keep eligible players from being selected in next month's Rule 5 draft. There are probably only a couple of sure-fire additions for the Twins, but there are at least another dozen players that the Twins likely had to have some discussion about as well. Who will they add? Image courtesy of William Parmeter / Mighty Mussels Since the end of the season, the Twins' front office has been cleaning up the 40-man roster that, had way more than 40 men on it. When the World Series finished, several players automatically came off the roster and became free agents. Carlos Correa exercised his option and became a free agent. The Twins Designated five players for Assignment early in the offseason. Three of them (Jermaine Palacios, Jake Cave, Caleb Hamilton) were claimed by other teams. Just last week, players still on the 60-Day Injured List were removed from the Injured List. At the same time, Cody Stashak was outrighted from the roster and elected free agency. All that is to say that a lot of roster work has been done already. Some of that is because, on Tuesday, teams have to submit additions to their 40-man rosters by 5:00 central time. The Twins' 40-man roster is currently at 36 players. There are 21 pitchers, one catcher, five infielders, and nine outfielders. The Twins (and other teams) may make a few small trades to clean up a couple more roster spots before the additions. Friday is another key date in the offseason when teams will need to decide which arbitration-eligible players to tender (or non-tender) a 2023 contract. A couple more players could potentially come off of the roster at that time. Before getting into the predictions for which Twins minor leaguers will be added to the team’s 40-man roster, it is important to note that some of these decisions were already made during the season. Louie Varland, Matt Wallner, and Simeon Woods Richardson all were added to the roster in September. If they had not been, they would have been Givens to be added now. Those three put up tremendous 2022 seasons in both Wichita and St. Paul and earned their late-season promotions. Secondly, who is eligible to be selected in the Rule 5 draft if they are not protected? Players who signed when they were 18 or younger in 2018 or earlier. Players who were 19 or older when they signed in 2019 or earlier. The age at signing is the key, but a general rule would be: Players drafted out of high school in 2017 or 2018. (unless they signed when they were 19) Players drafted out of junior college or four-year college in 2017, 2018, or 2019. International players signed at 16, 17, or 18 years old in 2016, 2017, or 2018. Finally, players added to the 40-man roster on Tuesday cannot be removed from the 40-man roster until spring training. That is important to remember when the team signs free agents or makes a trade this winter. So, here are my quick thoughts on players that should be, or at least should be considered to be, added to the Twins' 40-man roster. THE GIVENS 1.) 2B Edouard Julien - The 23-year-old from Quebec was the Twins 18th round pick in 2019 out of Auburn. Just this weekend, he was named the Breakout Prospect in the Arizona Fall League after he hit .400/.563/.686 (1.248) with five doubles and five home runs in 21 games. However, you could argue that he broke out during the 2022 regular season in Wichita where he hit .300/.441/.490 (.931) with 19 doubles and 17 home runs in 113 games. He even stole 19 bags. Of course, I would argue that he broke out in 2021, his professional debut after missing 2019 and 2020 due to Tommy John surgery and the Covid pandemic. He split that season between Ft. Myers and Cedar Rapids. In 112 games, he hit .267/.434/.480 (.914) with 28 doubles, 18 home runs, and 34 stolen bases. Where will he play? Well, he spent most of 2022 at second base. He has played first and third base in pro ball. Yes, he played a couple of games in left field in 2021, but that isn’t an option. Regardless, his all-around offensive game makes him a future top-of-the-lineup contributor. 2.) RHP Matt Canterino - Maybe not quite as “given” as Julien, but Canterino is absolutely a given to be added. He was the team’s second-round draft pick in 2019 out of Rice University. Since turning pro, two things have been true of the 24-year-old righty. First, when he has pitched, he has been absolutely dominant. In 11 games and 34 1/3 innings for Wichita in 2022, he posted a 1.83 ERA and struck out 50 batters. In 23 innings in 2021, he struck out 45 batters. His stuff is electric. Unfortunately, the second truth is that he has missed a lot of time with injury. He was shut down early in the 2021 season after experiencing some elbow pain. The rest-and-rehab was tried, but in 2022 at Wichita, he was limited to three innings per start and eventually four innings, but as his arm threw more, the pain continued. Finally, in mid-August, he underwent Tommy John surgery in Arlington making his availability to pitch in 2023 unlikely. But again, with this kind of talent, particularly with a pitcher, you keep him around and add him and don’t even give it a second thought. STRONG CONSIDERATIONS 3.) LHP Brent Headrick - In 2022, Headrick made 15 starts in Cedar Rapids before moving up to Double-A Wichita. In 2021, he was limited in the second half with some shoulder impingement. He stayed healthy throughout the 2022 season and went 10-5 with a 3.32 ERA and a 1.08 WHIP. In 108 1/3 innings, he walked just 25 batters and struck out 136 batters. Now, his Double-A numbers don’t look as good. In 10 games, he went 2-3 with a 4.81 ERA. However, in his first Wind Surge appearance, he gave up seven runs on 10 hits (including five home runs) in 2 1/3 innings. Take away that outing, and he went 2-2 with a 3.54 ERA, and in 40 2/3 innings, he gave up just six more home runs. Headrick was the Twins seventh-round pick in 2019 out of Illinois State. 4.) UT Michael Helman - The Twins were excited to select Helman out of Texas A&M in the 11th round of the 2018 draft. After a strong pro debut that year, he really struggled in 2019 at High-A Ft. Myers and ended the season injured. After a lost 2020 season, he hit .246/.336/.462 (.798) with 21 doubles, four triples, and 19 home runs in Cedar Rapids. He added 21 steals. He finished that season by playing in the Arizona Fall League. He began the 2022 season with 39 games at Wichita where he hit .278/.368/.472 (.840) with six doubles, two triples, and six home runs. He finished the season in St. Paul where, in 96 games, he hit .250/.325/.416 (.741) with 17 doubles and 14 home runs. Combined, he ended the season with 23 doubles, 20 home runs, and an impressive 40 stolen bases. He has made himself a solid contributor at the bat. He has also worked very hard to get strong all over the field on defense. Drafted as a middle infielder, he started playing all over the place in 2021. In 2022, he played 43 games in center field, 41 games at second base, 29 games at third base, and 11 games at shortstop. In 2021, he played more in the corner outfield spots than in center field. He legitimately can play seven positions on the field, and maybe I should mention that when he went to junior college, he was a catcher. 5.) Misael Urbina - This is the potential upside addition. This is the guy with talent and athleticism and tools. The 20-year-old Urbina signed in July of 2018 out of Venezuela. He spent 2019 in the Dominican Summer League where he posted a solid .825 OPS with 21 extra-base hits and 19 stolen bases in 50 games. After the lost 2020 season, he came to the States in 2021. He didn’t make the Mighty Mussels Opening Day roster, but he was on the roster about a week later. He played 101 games for the Mighty Mussels and hit .191/.299/.286 (.585) with 12 doubles, four triples, five homes, and 16 steals. Unfortunately, Urbina missed about half of the 2022 season due to some visa issues. In 50 games for the Mighty Mussels, he hit .246/.323/.419 (.741) with 16 doubles, five homers, and nine stolen bases. The Twins have added players after they spend a year in Low-A. They did it in November 2013 when they added Jorge Polanco and Max Kepler after they played in Cedar Rapids that season. Of course, they also added Deibinson Romero and Estarlin de Los Santos to the 40-man roster after their Low-A seasons. (I’m sure @Roger will appreciate that reference.) It’s hard for me to believe that Urbina would be able to stick on a big-league roster all season, so this is very borderline. 6.) IF Yunior Severino - As you know, Atlanta signed Severino as a 16-year-old in 2016. He spent the following season with the Braves organization until they were deemed to have broken the rules of international signing and a bunch of their recently-signed international players became free agents again. This time, it was the Twins that gave him a big, seven-figure signing bonus. Severino has shown glimpses of talent, but he’s also missed time with injury. He broke out with a strong 35 games at the end of the 2021 season in Cedar Rapids when he hit .321/.414/.493 (.907) with 12 doubles and three homers. He began 2022 with 46 games with the Kernels and hit .283/.398/.572 (.970) with nine doubles, two triples, and 11 homers. He moved up to Wichita and hit .273/.338/.497 (.834) with eight doubles and eight home runs. At Cedar Rapids, he played mostly second base (and DH). With the Wind Surge, he played almost exclusively at third base. He is now 23 and could be a year away from being ready. 7.) C/1B Chris Williams - Chris Williams was the Twins' eighth-round pick in 2018 out of Clemson University. In 75 games for Wichita this summer, Williams hit .277/.372/.542 (.915) with 16 doubles and 18 home runs. He finished his season with 42 games in St. Paul. He hit just .192, but he had five doubles and 10 more home runs. This season, he played 83 games at first base and caught 24 games. He will turn 26 this month, but the Twins have a need for right-handed power and currently have just one catcher on their 40-man roster. Now, Williams is not going to do a lot of catching in the big leagues, but he can be a guy who can be a #3 catcher, a backup first base option, and a power bat off the bench might provide some value to the organization. 8.) RHP Cody Laweryson - Laweryson (pronounced Lor-ih-sun) was the Twins 14th round draft pick out of the University of Maine in 2019. In 2021, he missed the first two months of the season and then posted a 4.91 ERA and 1.33 WHIP in 15 games for Cedar Rapids. He did have 73 strikeouts and just 19 walks over his 58 2/3 innings. He went to the Arizona Fall League and struck out 18 batters in 14 innings and pitched in the Fall Stars game. He began 2022 in the Kernels' bullpen. In 35 innings, he struck out 42 and walked 12 batters. He posted a 2.57 ERA and a 1.06 WHIP. He moved up to Wichita where after 11 bullpen appearances, he made eight starts. He went 5-0 with a minuscule 1.06 ERA and a 0.94 WHIP. In 59 2/3 innings, he struck out 69 and walked just 15 batters. In the entire season, he gave up just two homers over 94 2/3 innings. He’s got decent stuff and a bit of a funky delivery. Was his half-season in Wichita enough for someone to select him in the Rule 5 draft, or for the Twins to add him? 9.) OF DaShawn Keirsey, Jr. - Keirsey was the Twins' fourth-round pick in 2018 out of the University of Utah. He had a brutal injury after crashing into the wall at the end of his sophomore season in college, but inexplicably returned for his junior season and posted an OPS of 1.049. Since the Twins drafted him, his biggest issue has been staying on the field. He was limited to 45 games in Cedar Rapids in 2021 due to leg muscle issues. He never was able to get into a rhythm. In 2022, he was bumped up to Wichita and was on the field for 121 games. He had a solid showing, if not a bit of a breakout season. He hit .271/.329/.395 (.724) with 26 doubles, three triples, and seven home runs. While not a power hitter, at times he can really drive the ball and use the whole field. But his speed is absolutely electric and can be game-changing. He stole 42 bases in 49 attempts this year (86%), but he is an elite defensive center fielder, able to run down almost anything and unafraid to throw his body around to make a catch. His athleticism alone has to get him considered, and in 2022, he stayed on the field and really contributed. 10.) LHP Kody Funderburk - When the Twins drafted the lefty from Dallas Baptist in the 15th round of the 2018 draft, they had him as a pitcher only. In college, he was a very good hitter as well. Over time, he has worked solely as a pitcher and very quietly has made himself into a prospect to watch. He had a solid 2021 season between Cedar Rapids (where he started) and Wichita (where he was a reliever). He then went and made six starts in the Arizona Fall League. In 2022 at Double-A Wichita, he went 10-5 with a 2.94 ERA. In 107 innings, he had 103 strikeouts to 44 walks. He has a bit of a funky delivery that might make him intriguing to a team in the Rule 5 draft. 11.) C/1B Alex Isola - In 2017, Isola and Keirsey were teammates at Utah. Isola transferred a couple of times before the Twins made him their 29th-round pick in 2019 out of Texas Christian University. Isola just completed his six-week stint in the Arizona Fall League where he hit five doubles, and in the semi-final game launched a 420+ foot home run to help send his team to the championship game. Like Williams, part of the allure of Isola is his ability to play behind the plate as needed. With Wichita, he made 17 starts at first base and 17 starts behind the plate. He won’t win any Gold Gloves, but he could be a #3 catcher in the big leagues. His calling card is his bat. In 58 games with the Wind Surge in 2022, he hit .286/.377/.471 (.848) with nine doubles and 10 home runs. He puts together solid plate appearances with a good knowledge of the strike zone. He’s willing to take his walks, but he also can drive the ball to the gaps and over the wall. 12.) RHP Austin Schulfer - The 26-year-old was the Twins 19th round pick in 2018 out of UW-Milwaukee. In 2021, he led all Twins minor-league pitchers with 110 innings pitched over 24 starts at Double-A Wichita. In 2022, he returned to the Wind Surge to start the season and worked in 15 games out of the bullpen. He gave up just one earned run over 23 innings (0.39 ERA) and struck out 30 and walked only four batters. He recorded seven saves. He moved up to St. Paul where he went 4-3 with a 5.23 ERA. In 32 2/3 Triple-A innings, he struck out 31 batters and walked 13 batters. Schulfer has always made adjustments and should return to the Saints in 2023. Depending on the injury front in the Twins bullpen, we could see him debut at some point. HAVE TO AT LEAST CONSIDER LHP Evan Sisk - Acquired from the Cardinals at the deadline in 2021, he was the 2022 Twins Daily Minor League Relief Pitcher of the Year. 5-1, 2.08 ERA in a combined 63 innings between Wichita and St. Paul. Had 76 strikeouts to go with 29 walks. SS/OF Will Holland - the fastest runner in the Twins minor leagues, he is a great athlete and could provide a team with solid outfield or shortstop defense and pinch-running abilities. He was the team’s 5th-round pick in 2019 from Auburn. LHRP Denny Bentley - Bentley has been very good in the Twins minor leagues and can record a lot of strikeouts, but he does walk a lot of batters, as he did in the Arizona Fall League. RHRP Osiris German - German remains a very intriguing 24-year-old reliever. His best pitch is his changeup. After six games in Cedar Rapids, he worked in 37 games for Wichita. He posted a 3.02 ERA and had 17 walks and 59 strikeouts in 53 2/3 innings. RHRP Hunter McMahon - he was the ninth-round pick by the Nationals in the 2019 draft. The Twins acquired him that offseason for Ryne Harper. He has pitched very little since. In 2021, he pitched in just five games. This year, he began in Ft. Myers (2.23 ERA), moved up to Cedar Rapids (1.19 ERA), and finished with four games in Double-A. In 73 2/3 combined innings. He had 76 strikeouts and just 16 walks. RHP Sean Mooney - The Twins 12th round pick in 2019 from St. John’s had Tommy John surgery that spring. So, he didn’t make his pro debut, officially, until 2021. In 42 innings, he had 71 strikeouts. In 2022 with Cedar Rapids, he posted a 3.30 ERA and had 82 strikeouts in 60 innings. Needs to stay healthy. UT Anthony Prato - 7th round pick in 2019 from UConn, Prato had a nice breakout season in 2022. He was limited in 2021 due to a broken hamate bone. In 2022, he played 45 games in Cedar Rapids before ending with 87 games in Wichita. Combined, he hit .285/.383/.444 (.827) with 30 doubles, eight triples, 10 homers, and 22 stolen bases. He played 60 games in left field, 34 games at second base, and 22 games at third base. RHP Randy Dobnak - Off the 40-man roster, if a team selected Dobnak, they would take on his contract too, so that’s unlikely. But, when he was healthy in 2019 and 2020, he was a solid back-of-rotation starter, and if he is healthy, could be that for a non-contender. RHRP Steven Cruz - MLB Pipeline ranks Cruz 28th in the organization. Ten (or even five) years ago, he would have ranked higher because he is capable of reaching triple-digits with his fastball. At 23, he posted a 5.14 ERA and a 1.59 WHIP in Wichita in 2022. In 56 innings, he had 72 strikeouts, but he also walked 35 batters. Love the arm, but hard to see him sticking in the big leagues. OTHER ELIGIBLE PLAYERS Hitters: David Banuelos, Andrew Bechtold, Kyle Schmidt, Seth Gray, Charles Mack, Jeferson Morales, Daniel Ozoria, Willie Joe Garry, Carlos Aguiar, Luis Baez, Wilfri Castro, Alexander Pena. Pitchers: Tyler Beck, Francis Peguero, Jon Olsen, Ryan Shreve, Brock Stewart, Michael Boyle, Jordan Brink, Jordan Gore, Casey Legumina, Alex Phillips, Regi Grace, Bradley Hanner, Derek Molina, Owen Griffith, Tyler Palm, Miguel Rodriguez, Matthew Swain, Zaquiel Puentes, Niklas Rimmel, Elpidio Perez, Wilker Reyes, Rafael Feliz, Danny Moreno, Alex Scherff, Andrew Cabezas, Ben Gross, Zach Neff, Josh Mitchell, Jose Brito. My prediction? This is as tough as I can remember this being. Again, we should be able to assume Canterino and Julien are added. After that, there are at least six to 10 others (and maybe more) where a legitimate case could be made. I am going to officially predict that they will also add Headrick, Helman, and Severino. I think Urbina is just not yet in a spot where he could stick in the big leagues, but I think he is at risk of being taken. He is probably the most interesting case (which is why I found a photo of him for the article). I think Chris Williams and Alex Isola are guys that could be at risk as well. Your turn? How many players will the Twins add to their 40-man roster by Tuesday’s deadline? Make your predictions for which players get added below. View full article
  25. I feel bad for Twins fans but even more so for Sano that his potential was only intermittently realized during his tenure with our favorite team. And I agree that the question asked at the top of the opening post is a bit out of line. Kind of like filling out a customer satisfaction survey that asks, "How disappointed were you in your experience with us today?" So I wanted to include a video of this high point in his career. For me this was the moment when the Twins locked up the AL Central in 2019. And based on pitcher Nick Goody's reaction I think the same was true for him. And Terry Francona too.
  26. Garlick signed

    Lagputter and one other reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    If we’re anticipating making picks in the rule 5 draft we have bigger problems.
  27. If any of these guys can ride the AAA/MLB shuttle it could be worth a look. Otherwise nah. No reason to clog the 26 man roster with players out of options. Jeff Hoffman- out of options. Pass Lou Trivino - 2 option years. Possibly. Brian Anderson - says N/A on FanGraphs so I assume that’s none remaining? Pass. Elieser Hernandez - 1 option year remaining. Still, probably not. Hunter Renfroe - Also says N/A on FanGraphs. Probably not.
  28. Garlick signed

    arby58 and one other reacted to DJL44 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    It's a contract for $750k. That doesn't prevent the Twins from adding someone else later and putting Garlick on waivers.
  29. 2 points
    All this discussion and nobody even mentions Thielbar. How many times did he come into tha t Fireman’s role and get the job done. Heck, often better than anyone would have hoped. I like Rogers, a lot, but not certain he is the guy they should try to sign. I want them to get the best available, whomever that is. And based on last year that ain’t Rogers.
  30. I think he seems like this huge disappointment because his minor league career and rookie year caused us to get overly excited. I do not think someone that has had a career like his can be called a bust when compared to top draft picks that never made it at all. But the question is biggest disappointment not bust. Disappointment is more about our feelings changing and in this case, it is a big disappointment because we were excited! That Grand Slam in Cleveland? The potential was so there! Sano had his moments and yet he just never fully got to that consistent success we all could see was potentially in there. Yeah, VERY disappointing but I still enjoyed the ride. Biggest disappointment? I'm not sure I'm that far with it...
  31. 2 points
    I think Urbina has the ceiling of a starter but I also think he's low risk for a team to stash all year given how few position players are on a team's bench.
  32. 2 points
    If he's cheap and they aren't planning on just plugging him in as their everyday closer they should absolutely look at him. As a middle reliever he'd potentially be a very nice fit. We already know he can't go back to back days so I don't want him brought in as some late inning savior, but he could be a very nice lefty piece in the middle of the pen. I'm not sure I agree with the assessment that "San Diego changed the shape of his slider," though. When do you think they made that change? He got there on opening day. I don't think they chucked him in the trackman that day and told him to change the shape of his slider. Then he got off to a great start so I'm guessing they weren't out there telling him to change the shape of his slider in the middle of April when he was dominating. I don't think the San Diego staff told him to change anything. Maybe the reason they were willing to trade him to Milwaukee was because they couldn't get his slider back after he lost it. I think it's just the nature of 90% of relievers that they're finicky and any little thing being off leads to them being bad. It's why they're relievers instead of starters for the most part. Being able to get his slider back may be a nice tweak to try to make if they do re-sign him, though.
  33. They are really prospects 1A and 1B. I don't think it matters where you put either one. So much potential for both.
  34. Lee needs to be the starting shortstop at Wiochita. Lewis gets a little time in St. Paul. Austin Martin also moves to St. Paul and plays, where? Probably in the outfield, but at shortstop when Lewis is advanced. Yes, who will b the Twins starting shortstop for the first month of 2023. If, and when, Lewis comes up, do we let him stay and work anything and everything out if he doesn't dominate in the majors? The Twins can sign a good fill-in ultility guy for shortstop (like Adrianza of old). You would hope Julien would be ready sometime during the season to push that signing out of the backup-reserve position, giving the Twins a decent bench duo of Gordon and Julien. The Twins will shortly sink or swim on home grown prospects.
  35. 2 points
    I think the Twins gamble on Severino, Helman and Urbina making it thru. But they have to advance Severino and Urbina for strong consideration of a 40-man add next season. Helman was behind Steer, and seems to have fallen behind Julien, for now. Julien and Gordon as our reserves next season looks like a possibility. Canterino is just taking up a space into spring training. Better to keep him than fill the spot with some lame minor league free agent signing who wants to be on the 40-man, but is just designated anyway for space. So, the Twins really only have to add Julien and Canterino. Sisk would be my third choice, just because he is a lefty, and you have the spot. I wouldn't expect anyone else to come to the majors in 2022 from the list above. I'm just hoping most of them get time in St. Paul. Chris Williams didn't quite earn a spot with his play at St. Paul. You might be able to keep him off the 40-man and have him in reserve, like Hamilton was last season. The Twins need to sign another catcher for the 40-man. And also have some catching depth in the minors, notably at AA. I was disappointed they let Camargo walk. But he was still a good year away froim being a reliable backup. They could still offer him a higher minor league contract, I suppose. Pagan and Urshela will be tough decisions. You start looking at those two, as well as names like Megill, Garlick and Contreras and replacing them if anyone is released by other tems to make 40-man spots. Whoever you choose, or sign, has to be better than any of these guys in their respective positions. The Twins can go active in the minor-league free agent marketplace. Depending on Enlow, they would have at least Paddack (and Canterino) on the 60-day IL come spring training, so they would have two open sports for sure going into the season to draw from minor league hopefuls.
  36. 2 points
    I would differentiate a bit between Archer and Bundy, but it might be splitting hairs. Archer wasn't going to go more than 5 innings due to his injury history. Even getting him through 5 seemed to be an adventure and more than once he rather suddenly imploded. There seemed to be ample reason to cap Archer at 5 innings and/or twice through the order. Bundy, OTOH, did have one of the longest starts for a Twins pitcher (8 full innings). Even when he was rolling, his margin for error was tiny. An inch of break or a mph or two of velocity took him from acceptable to batting practice. It is understandable that he too couldn't be given much rope. Having Ryan and Gray out for large chunks of the season and then following them with Bundy and Archer was a recipe for failure. I don't think the Twins had anyone better and injuries to Winder, Paddack and Ober took away any chance to supplant the two veterans. Better health will likely make for a deeper staff with far more deep (6+ inning) starts. Going into 2023, I think the Twins can be comfortable letting Ryan go on a 180 IP per season clip, probably the same for Gray if he can avoid non-arm muscle pulls. I'd imagine they'd be cautious with Ober, although his injury problems weren't to his arm and he looked very good at the end of the season.
  37. 2 points
    Enlow is already on the 40 man and is not Rule 5 eligible. If he is taken off the 40 man, he would be subject to a waiver claim. If the Twins kept him on the 40 man the 40 man all of 2022, I don't see them waiving him now. The Rule 5 draft is mostly about pitching so I add Headrick (Twins lack much quality in LH starting pitching after trading two away last summer) along with Julien and Canterino to the 40 man.
  38. Who really cares who is labeled as #1. Could we just have a top prospect come up, stay healthy, and have a great career!?!?!?
  39. I am not sure how much of a "bust" Sano truly is. He has had a modicum of success, and will continue to have opportunities for the next few years. I think we as fans view him as a bust because we had these huge expectations that he didn't meet. IMO, the biggest Twins draft busts are: Adam Johnson - drafted too high (full disclosure, I was at his one home start, so I may be a bit jaded). Kohl Stewart - was supposed to be a ready made starter. BJ Garbe - #5 pick, never made it past AA Honorable mentions: Tim Belcher - #1 pick, didn't sign, went on to have a strong career Travis Lee - #2 pick, Twins didn't sign him, another good career
  40. I'd still go with Lewis because his potential has already been realized on the MLB level with his elite bat & glove plus his leadership & understanding of the game. Love them both.
  41. 2 points
    They would have to figure they could trade Pagan for someone better than they could keep on the 40 man roster to keep him on. God, I hope they don't keep thinking they can fix him ..
  42. 2 points
    Position players rarely get taken in rule 5, mainly because they cannot hide them like they can a pitcher. Pitchers can get hidden in the pen and only pitch in blow outs, if they are not ready for MLB level, but hitters will only go to teams that are not trying to win. Julien would get taken if we do not add him so he will for sure. I think Sisk will get taken by a team. This is also a time to try and sneak guys through waivers as teams are adding guys to their own 40 man rosters, and passing others through. So do not be surprised if some of our other pitchers are DFA. Really, you just have to decide which pitchers you would rather have on the team.
  43. 2 points
    And we have to remember: If any teams do decide to take any of these players, they have to stay on the Majors roster for the whole year, otherwise they get sent back to the team they were drafted from.
  44. 2 points
    If I was running the Twins the only two that get added are Julien and Canterino. I could be convinced on Serverino as well, possibly. There is no reason to waste 40 man roster spots on minor league guys on the wrong side of 25, unless of course they think there is a real chance of them making the team out of spring training. Which I don't see any of these guys Brent Headrick - 25 in December Chris Williams - 26 in 9 days Michael Helman - 27 in May Cody Laweryson - 25 in May Kody Funderburk - 26 in two weeks DaShawn Keirsey - 26 in May Austin Schulfer - 27 in December Nobody is going to put Urbina in the majors next year
  45. 2 points
    Looks like a lot of teams are going to be struggling to find room for Rule 5 eligible prospects. I'm going to guess Julien, Canterino and Headrick get added. Then maybe a trade for someone's AAA SS or catcher to fill out the last spot on the 40 man and add some depth to a need position. I'd worry about loosing Sisk, Urbina and Severino. Without a trade I'd add Sisk. AAA lefty with a heart beat likely gets taken, Urbina is just to far away and Severino is probably to far down the depth chart to add.
  46. 2 points
    Kirk is maddening because he gets so much hate and he’s honestly a really good qb. But at the same time it’s always in the back of your mind that he’s going to inexplicably have a dud of a game at the worst time (National tv, night game etc). And no one knows why that is. Time difference? Routine out of whack? Nerves? Because he’s easily a top 10 quarterback most games but he’ll just implode when everyone is watching. But I guess today, a win on the road against a top 5 team with essentially a national audience, he kind of quieted that narrative for a bit, but it sure looked like it was going to be a classic kirk dud. I will say, he’s been doing what he did the last few games under heavy pressure which makes it more impressive. He’s been taking more and more hits. The offensive line will have to sew things up. Kirk must stay upright.
  47. Garlick signed

    arby58 reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic

    1 point
    This is like the Jake Cave deal last year. Won’t prevent future, better signings. He can be DFA’d when someone better comes along.
  48. 1 point
    I have never thought that Mudville was intended to be a real place. I still don't. I think it was just a name (that would never be given to a real town) that was well-chosen by the poet to reflect the mood of the team and its fans after experiencing the anticipation of a come-from-behind victory that turns into the disappointment of a loss.
  49. Lets go big!!

    tarheeltwinsfan reacted to Karbo for a comment on a blog entry

    1 point
    That would be a fun team to watch for sure!
  50. More new logo leaks

    USAFChief reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Are they about to become the Twin Cities Twins of Anaheim?
This leaderboard is set to Chicago/GMT-06:00

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.