Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Leaderboard

  1. Brock Beauchamp

    Administrator
    Points
    29,627
    Posts
  2. Seth Stohs

    Administrator
    Points
    24,042
    Posts
  3. Squirrel

    Community Leader
    Points
    31,121
    Posts
  4. tony&rodney

    Verified Member
    Points
    2,874
    Posts

Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation on 11/21/2021 in all areas

  1. 6 points
    Last offseason, the Twins made the decision to move Jorge Polanco to second base. They wanted better defense at the shortstop position. With that in mind, the Twins signed Andrelton Simmons to a one-year deal. It didn’t go well. While Simmons provided the solid defense, he did very little with the bat. His .558 OPS was over .100 lower than it had been in all but one of his previous nine MLB seasons. His previous low was .617 in 2014. Even after his rough 2021 season, his career OPS of .683 should make the Twins consider bringing him back on a much lower contract, maybe in the $3 million range. courtesy Byron Buxton Instagram However, there was a shortstop that became available due to Friday’s roster transactions. One would be a player returning to the organization that he spent nearly a decade in and made his big-league debut with. Let’s discuss both, and then in the comments you can tell me if this player should be considered. But before that, I want to point out that my personal opinion is that the Twins need to spend available dollars this offseason on pitching. So while I would love to see the Twins grab one of those big-name, big-dollar free agent shortstops, I’m going to assume that they won’t and that they will spend big on pitching. (maybe not a fair assumption, but one that I will go with for this article.) Niko Goodrum According to MLB Trade Rumors, Niko Goodrum was projected to make $2.9 million in 2022 through arbitration. He wasn’t going to get that coming off of an injury-plagued 2021 season in which he hit just .214/.292/.359 (.651) with 11 doubles and nine home runs. He had several stints on the Injured List with calf and groin injuries. In the Covid-shortened 2020 season, he hit just .184/.263/.335 (.598) with seven doubles and five home runs. These two seasons have been rough for Goodrum offensively, no doubt, but still 10-20% better than what Simmons provided in 2021. That’s obviously a low bar. So why would I personally be interested in bringing Goodrum back to the organization where he debuted in 2017 and went 1-for-17 (.059) in September. He signed with the Tigers and had two really strong seasons. In 2018, he hit .245/.315/.432 (.749) with 29 doubles and 16 homers. In 2019, he hit .248/.322/.421 (.743) with 27 doubles, five triples and 12 homers. He stole 12 bases in 2018 and 2019, and 14 bases in 2021. Goodrum will turn 30 early in spring training 2022. While the upside may be somewhat limited and include a lot of swing-and more,, there is also great athleticism, tools, speed and power with Goodrum. The Twins drafted and signed Cartier “Niko” Goodrum out of high school in Georgia in 2010. Jorge Polanco had signed a year earlier. The two climbed up the organization ladder together. Goodrum played mostly shortstop while Polanco played shortstop. Could the keystone combination exist again? In 2020, Goodrum was a finalist for an AL Gold Glove at shortstop. He is a natural shortstop with good range and a strong arm. If the Twins signed him and told him to prepare to compete for the team’s starting shortstop job, he might be a terrific choice. Hey, if the other choices right now include a return of Simmons, then I would certainly support giving Goodrum a shot. What would it cost? I would think a one-year, $1.5 to $2.0 million would do it, especially if he was given the opportunity to start most days at shortstop. If he’s given an opportunity to start most every day at shortstop, it’s likely he would just want a one year deal, hope it goes well, and enter free agency again after the 2022 season when it isn’t the greatest free agent shortstop class ever. Because of the dollars, it would be a low-risk deal. Because of his defense, speed and power potential, there is a chance for reward. If it doesn’t go well, he can finish the year as a utility player, capable of playing seven positions (yes, all better than Willians Astudillo). If Royce Lewis is deemed ready-to-go sometime in 2021, Goodrum can become a utility player. In addition, Goodrum might have interest in a return because he has several former teammates from his minor league days with the. He played over his years with Byron Buxton, Miguel Sano, Jorge Polanco, Max Kepler, Mitch Garver, Tyler Duffey, Taylor Rogers, and Tommy Watkins was a coach and manager. An added bonus is that Goodrum has always been great in the community, going back to his Twins days when he was a Harmon Killebrew Community Service Award recipient in 2013 with the Cedar Rapids Kernels. Many times the concept of “Bring Back the Gang” gets a negative connotation. Sometimes that is fair. Other times, it just makes sense. If healthy, Niko Goodrum can provide really good defense at shortstop, some power at the plate and speed. Yes, that comes with some injury risk and a lot of strikeouts. But at the price tag, it is certainly worth strong consideration. So what do you think? Should the Twins consider a reunion with Niko Goodrum?
  2. Bring Niko Back to Target Field

    sjunisu and 5 others reacted to rv78 for a post in a topic

    6 points
    YES, he can have Jake Cave's spot on the 40 man roster.... please!
  3. This is literally what decides 90% of free agent signings everywhere.
  4. 3 points
    I question whether your bank account could handle the needed number of drinks.
  5. 3 points
    Same. Feels like Jake Cave just got a scholarship for 2022. I get that he's been injured and assuming the last two season are reflective of his real ability is probably foolish. But Cave still feels eminently replaceable and it feels like he's going to get a roster spot on scholarship for his contract and "veteran-ness" rather than being one of the best 26. Hope I'm wrong. It's a marginal move, but making bad choices on the margin still hurts and can lead to making bad calls on the bigger things.
  6. I don't get what they see in him but this contract isn't guaranteed. They can still cut Cave and only be out a portion of the $800k, I believe. And in that case, he's not a terrible insurance policy but I'll be disappointed if he's on the roster when 26 head north to Minnesota at the end of March.
  7. Back to the topic question ... It's not an easy question to answer, because I want to see who that $20million is spent on. If it's an impact pitcher or position player, then yes, absolutely would rather have that. But if it is Martin and W-R along with a couple of Happs or Shoemakers? Then no. I want to see the plan laid out before I can say this was worth it, even though I think trading Berrios was the right thing to do, especially now since it looks like he truly didn't want to sign with MN. If to replace Berrios, they find an equivalence, absolutely. Sorry if that's too much of a 'they won't spend it answer' ... but really it's a 'depends on who they spend it on' answer.
  8. I think Ken Rosenthal is one of the most plugged in journalists in baseball, so what he says holds quite a bit of weight for me. He's not throwing out hot takes like this if he doesn't have something behind it. Why would he? Here's what we know: he's been offered extensions (same with Berrios) for the last couple of off-seasons. He's declined them, clearly. Buxton was mentioned in trade deadline rumors during last year's trade deadline even though he was injured at the time. There is still no extension agreed to, and he's in the last year of arbitration. There is still time to get this figured out before his control expires... I want Buxton on this team, within reason. I am not one who says to sign him, no matter the cost. This specific negotiation is one of the most unique cases in MLB history. And I'm glad my job isn't on the line to get this figured out.
  9. Love is a good thing. Thank you. I am not aware of anyone offering a contract for $30 million per year. The main point in comments has been that a base of near $11 million would be accompanied by incentives. The incentives would raise the salary, yes, but it would also mean that Buxton is playing which has been a winning proposition for the Twins. Those who look back and dwell on the injuries have an argument to make and are fine with going on without Buxton. Those who have watched Buxton grow as a player and see his potential would like to see that potential shine in a Twins uniform. Both sides are entitled to their opinions as fans of who or who not to watch. I do believe TD comments should ease off the FO who are just following orders from above them. Still, the comments by Falvey this week were weak, poorly phrased, at best; not his best day.
  10. I love all the people on here. “We can’t trade Buxton, his value has never been lower”! Same people: “If they don’t give Buxton $30m+ AAV, the FO is crazy and should be fired.
  11. If you look at the moves the FO made while the “championship window was open”, I dread the moves they’ll make to “retool”.
  12. It is an option. Just doesn't seem like a good one, to me at least.
  13. 3 points
    Well they traded Gil for him so apparently they are all in on him. This is a seriously bad trade that nobody talks about. No decent pitching prospect should ever be traded for a 4th outfielder that are available in the discount bin.
  14. 2021 Vikings Season Thread

    Danchat and one other reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    What an incredibly entertaining game! This season has taken at least 10 years off my life
  15. 2021 Vikings Season Thread

    Danchat and one other reacted to nicksaviking for a post in a topic

    2 points
    I actually thought the GB quick TD was a blessing in disguise. I do t want Rodgers to have the ball last.
  16. Bring Niko Back to Target Field

    wabene and one other reacted to Seth Stohs for a post in a topic

    2 points
    With the possible exception of Gordon, none of the rest of these guys would play SS in at least the first half of 2022 and some of them for a year or three.
  17. Pitching first. I think Winder has advanced the furthest and may have made the team last season except for injury. Hopefully he is healthy early and makes the roster out of spring training. Not saying he wouldn't get sent down for a while if he has multiple early failures.
  18. This is plan B if Buck walks. What a depressing thought. Drinks are on me.
  19. Because people are trying to have it both ways.
  20. It's true that if the Twins trade Buxton, they are admitting to not being competitive in 2022. But it won't be because they trade Buxton. If they are not able to find three quality and experienced starting pitchers, it is not realistic to assume they have a shot at the playoffs...probably not even a .500 record. There's a significant chance that they'll simply lose out on most if not all quality experienced starters. If the reality is that 2022 is a lost cause anyway, does that change our view of a potential Buxton trade? I think we should consider a new term in addition to "Rebuild" and "Retool". "Rebuild" suggests a team is tearing down to the studs, restocking a depleted farm system, and trading away high priced established stars in their prime in the hopes of returning to competition in 4-5 years. "Retool" suggests a team was recently competitive (meaning you weren't in last place this year) that's shuffling the deck chairs a bit to address a need or maybe up the ante due to a competitor in your division on the rise. Though there are elements of both that apply to the Twins, I think the FO believes they are in a unique situation. Consider the following: Position Kiriloff (1B?) Arraez (2B?) Miranda (3B?) Lewis (SS?) Jeffers / Garver (C) Larnach (RF?) Celestino (CF?) Martin (LF?) Rooker (DH?) SP Winder Balazovic Duran Sands Woods-Richardson Ober Ryan Strotman RP Alcala Moran Thielbar That's an awful lot of multi-year controllable major-league-ready (by 2023) talent across every position on the field. Though there are obvious question marks there and some of that talent will take time to establish quality major league effectiveness, regardless, after 2022 no one on that list will, in theory, have anywhere to go or anything left to prove in the minors. They kinda have to be with the Twins in 2023 at some point, or they're gone for one reason or another. If anyone on that list were a bust, it would be seen as a failure of drafting, development, or evaluation from multiple sources...so this is not fringe talent we're pinning our hopes on, even if they are not all current/former Top 100 prospects. Which means that as we sit here ahead of the 2022 season...everyone on this list below is essentially expendable by 2023 or sooner in the sense that there is a legitimate prospective player ready to take their place: Polanco (team friendly control) Kepler (team friendly control Buxton Sano (team friendly control) Rogers Donaldson Maeda (team friendly control) Whether quantity or quality, what could you add to the 2023-2027 major league roster noted above by trading the 7 (or 6 if you don't count an injured Maeda) players here? A few solid pieces at the very least. With a tiny payroll over those years, what kind of top dollar FA acquisition could you make to supplement a winning team? FWIW I think the Twins should sign Buxton to a contract of 100mil / 7 years for no other reason than inflation...in 5-7 years 14mil AAV for an average player will be commonplace (seems like it already is!). And I think they should keep Polanco cause he's very good and he and Buxton would be the veteran leaders for a young team. Heck I'm even fine with them signing an expensive FA shortstop now if they can free up the salary space to do it. I'm not in favor of trading big league ready prospects for 1 year of a pitcher (e.g. Manea) just to be mediocre in 2022. But to circle back to the original point...I don't think that "Rebuild" or "Retool" accurately describe the unique situation the Twins FO believes they are in. And I think 2022 might be a lost cause anyway if all you can scrape together are Pineda and 2 x J.A. Happs. I do know that their decision-making in this moment will define the next 10 years, so though I give them the benefit of the doubt...the pressure is most certainly on.
  21. Also to Buxton, sign the extension. They can make all the offers they want, but if he's unwilling to sign then that's his decision and the FO will be correct in moving him.
  22. Ted played in the 1946 World Series (all 7 games) and hit .200..... see end of first page comment.
  23. Oswaldo Arcia is only 30. That's crazy to think. I really felt like getting DFA'd by the Twins was going to light a fire under him. He had a huge year on a MiLB contract with the Diamondbacks, but he was jogjammed behind other talent and didn't get a shot at the MLB roster that year. Then it was off to Japan where he performed poorly for a single season. For a guy who seemingly had so much talent to fall so far and so hard.
  24. Are you really arguing that the current version is anywhere close to what we saw as a rookie?
  25. Of curse people are jumping to conclusions. It is what the internet is. Vert little information paired with a rant.
  26. If you think Buxton is so awesome and important, why would he only bring a couple fringe prospects?
  27. This isn’t the worst idea ever but I still ****ing hate it to the depths of my being.
  28. "In six years this front office has inherited a stinker of a team and converted it into a core of players" ... Just my take, but the current FO does the best that they can to put a team on the field that can play competitive baseball given their orders from above. The core of the current team was in place when they came, in fact. The previous FO also did what they could given their orders from above. The evidence would suggest that Ryan, etc. faced more restrictions than Falvey. TD needs to pull away from the idea that folks such as Gardenhire, Molitor, Ryan, etc. were inferior in any way to Baldelli, Falvey, etc. Baldelli and Falvey are good baseball people as are the others. The current group has less experience than the former but are learning. The Buxton conversation and the challenges of this offseason will test Falvey. A more important question concerns the view from above Falvey. The Twins cannot make the moves needed if the budget falls below $120 million and it may be set considerably lower. We just don't know. The premise of the post of the post is arguably correct. If Buxton goes, there is virtually no way the Twins are competitive for the next five years unless the budget suddenly goes to the $145-160 million range. A budget of that size changes the entire narrative. Buxton goes though and the core is broken. Lastly, I want to note that we still don't know whether Buxton actually wants to remain with the Twins. We also don't know what value Falvey places on Buxton. Those are two important answers to a puzzle. What tolerance does Twins Territory have for a rebuild? My guess - very little.
  29. 2 points
    You'd have to define "decent" pitching prospect... I don't think Gil was ever seen as anything other than a wildcard. He had only pitched in rookie league as a 19 year old when they traded him right before his age 20 season. The Yankees developed him from a lottery ticket into a legitimate top 10 prospect - good for them, but the real issue is that the Twins have been completely unable to develop their own fringe prospect pitchers into MLB arms. Getting a MLB ready 4th OF for a longshot prospect who isn't going to be relevant in the majors for another 4 years is a fine move in my book. It just gets worse the more they trot him out there despite losing the ability to hit, alongside the organization's inability to develop pitchers.
  30. I will take the Blue Jays side of this deal, I would easily give them back Martin and SWR for Berrios and his contract. I would also take Berrios and his contract over the assumed contract the older guys (Ray and and Gaussman) are going to get. Now if you told me the Twins are going to sign Ray or Gaussman, and their contacts is going to be between 3 - 5 years, that might change my mind. But I am also the type of person that would trade SWR and Martin for a consistent 3+ WAR pitcher. I love SWR as a prospect, but it also worries me a bit he has only pitched 177.1 innings since 2018, and with the way the Twins bring pitchers along it could be another three years to get him to 120+ innings a year.
  31. I thought the Caveman deserved his own thread! Many are probably wondering why the Twins would sign Jake Cave today. After all, he was already under team control for 2022 as a first-time arbitration-eligible player, and arbitration contracts don't have to be tendered until December or actually arbitrated/signed until January. It appears the Twins leveraged the possibility of dropping Cave to protect a Rule-5-eligible minor leaguer today, to get Cave to sign a reduced contract now. Cave was estimated to receive a $1.1 mil award in arbitration, per MLB Trade Rumors. So by signing him for $800k instead, the Twins potentially save about $300k, and we likely just DFA'd Barnes or Astudillo to make room for the minor leaguer instead. And for his part, Cave gets to have a guaranteed deal and not be thrown into free agent limbo, coming off a poor season and ahead of CBA uncertainty. Cave still has a minor league option year remaining too, so even if he stays on the 40-man roster on opening day, he may be optioned off the 26-man roster to become AAA depth. So in conclusion, it seems Cave's spot isn't too assured, as the Twins likely threatened to drop him today, but he's probably locked in for the opening-day 40-man roster, at least.
  32. Based on previous payrolls and statement from ownership and the front office, the Twins should have as much as $60m to spend on contracts for *this season*.
  33. Bring Niko Back to Target Field

    Danielspr reacted to Seth Stohs for a post in a topic

    1 point
    I would think someone, maybe even the Tigers, would give him an MLB contract.
  34. 1 point
    To expand further, if Buxton is traded in the next eight months, the Twins are rebuilding. Martin is a top 5 Twins prospect who played CF more than SS at Wichita. If the Twins wouldn’t get a replacement center fielder in a Buxton trade, I expect the rebuilding Twins to give Martin the opportunity.
  35. Very, very, intriguing. I am keeping this in my head as they make their moves. If they are going to go the low payroll route, this would be the way.
  36. As a baseball fan, I want my team to sign the good players they have developed, and I'm not interested in lottery ticket prospects. I want solid, established veterans on my team and I want a rooting interest. I would take Berrios 10 times out of 10.
  37. I see opening the season with Kepler, Buxton and Kirilloff as starters and Cave and Rooker as bench players. Not horrible, and it doesn’t mean it has to be that way all season.
  38. 1 point
    So do I Brock!!! An absolutely miserable move! WHat are Falvey and Levine doing to our beloved Twins franchise. That was the biggest no-brainer release of a player you could ever find. Yuk!
  39. If the Twins discuss an expanded trade with Oakland that would bring a pitcher or two over in addition to Chapman, then the chance for being in contention increases substantially, and a move for Chapman makes more sense. Kirrillov, Martin, Larnach, Duran, Lewis, Enlow, Miranda et al should not be deemed untouchable, but hopefully we wouldn't lose more than 2 of our top 10 prospects. I'm not a fan of a deal for only Chapman. We need help up the middle.
  40. 1 point
    Well he obviously was a prospect of some value. The point more is you can get 4th outfielders anywhere. Why would you give up anything of value for him?
  41. 1 point
    At this point, I'm not upset, and have been 50/50 that the Twins would keep him. His defense is pretty decent and definitely improved in CF. We have to remember he was a solid hitter his first 2 seasons, OPS of .786 and .805. Personally I write off his 2020, as I have for a lot of guys who had a bad year then, and not just for the Twins. He also hurt his back very early in 2021, and I believe he even tried to play a couple of games before his season was basically over. With an option remaining, however, and a need to prove himself again, I don't think he's a lock to make the opening roster at all.
  42. 1 point
    I really don't see the point... there are better 4th OFs out there (a right-handed one would be nice) and now he's been guaranteed a 40 man spot through Spring Training. I guess the FO is convinced they can fix him...
  43. Interesting thought, but I just don't see that as possible. just 9 players beyond the 26-man roster... With the Twins injury situation in 2021, they would have run out of people.
  44. So OPS of .814 and .850 is poor/average? Almost any team would be thrilled to have a rookie OPS .744 or higher for 5 out of 6 months. League average OPS was .728.
  45. So he had five poor to average months and one good month. I'll take Martin.
  46. It's also a sad parallel that both players had their careers derailed due to injuries to their nervous systems, the brain in Mauer's case and the retina (which is anatomically part of the brain) in Puckett's case. It points up that the nervous system is by far the most important part of an athlete's body because it processes incoming signals and directs actions. There are millions of Americans who are the physical equals of star athletes but muscles and bones are not what sets star athletes apart from the general population.
  47. 1 point
    The mantra remains until it isn't true, and not by what they say, but what they do. The Twins are just cheap. That contract should be able to go over 200 million with incentives! “Now, we’re working through understanding all sides of this ultimately. We’ll proceed accordingly. At this stage of the offseason, we’re still just navigating our strategy and planning and trying to understand what’s available to us and what the market looks like on all periods. As is always the case, this isn’t unique to Byron or otherwise, there are people on our team that are interesting to other clubs and we just always need to work through what does that look like, what does our team look like as we navigate it.” That is one souless and lost comment by Falvey. Still trying to understand? Seriously? Looks like the same old plan.... wait and see what is left, underpay them and make them happy like Lynn, and hope for the best. It sure was fun watching the Braves this year. They had some soul.
  48. Bye bye Buxton?

    Emjay reacted to LastOnePicked for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Very likely that the core of solid young players they inherited (Berrios, Polanco, Sano, Kepler, Buxton, Rosario) will be reduced to nothing more than Polanco, an ineffective Kepler and a handful of magic bean prospects in a so-so farm system by the start of '22. And several top Twins prospects launching promising careers elsewhere. Oh, and zero playoff wins to show for it all. Unreal.
This leaderboard is set to Chicago/GMT-06:00

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.