Leaderboard
-
nicksaviking
Community ModeratorPoints18,707Posts -
Otto von Ballpark
Community LeaderPoints20,620Posts -
Mike Sixel
Old-Timey MemberPoints36,790Posts -
Popular Content
Showing content with the highest reputation on 11/16/2021 in all areas
-
Bye bye Buxton?
Bye bye Buxton?
tarheeltwinsfan and 15 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
16 pointsThere's still a lot of offseason left to go but after the Berrios extension in Toronto and its relatively reasonable dollar figure, let's just say it's unlikely I will support this front office remaining in control if they trade Byron Buxton. The Minnesota Twins are not the Cleveland Guardians or the Tampa Bay Rays and I'm gonna be mad as hell if they try to operate that way.16 points -
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
gunnarthor and 15 others reacted to chpettit19 for a post in a topic
16 pointsLooks like 7 years 131M. I defended the FO not extending him as him possibly asking for way too much, but if this is what he was asking the Twins for I'm pretty upset. He was absolutely worth that for the Twins and they should've signed that deal. I like Martin a lot, and SWR looks good, but it's really frustrating that it took less than 20 a year to sign him.16 points -
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
gunnarthor and 14 others reacted to nicksaviking for a post in a topic
15 pointsYeah, this one is going to require an explanation from the organization.15 points -
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
cHawk and 12 others reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic
13 points@Tom Froemmingtweeting my feelings this morning… Ugh.13 points -
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Dman and 11 others reacted to jmlease1 for a post in a topic
12 pointsSame. I'm shocked that this is what it took to get it done. Either he suddenly discovered that he really loved it in Toronto, or the Twins were really low-balling him, or there was something about MN he just didn't like but I was 100% convinced he wasn't signing an extension and was going to the free agent market.12 points -
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Hunter48 and 9 others reacted to bean5302 for a post in a topic
10 pointsMLB teams try to buy wins at $6MM / WAR. MLB teams generally get wins at a cost of $8MM / WAR. Berrios has proven himself as a 4 WAR pitcher at this point so in free agency, I could see Berrios getting up to $24MM per season. Keep in mind, that's not proven "Ace" money. Guys like Scherzer, Verlander, Cole, Kershaw, Greinke have all commanded well over $30MM / season. Based on how the Twins started negotiations with Berrios at the same time as Kepler and Polanco, I would wager the Twins were never ready to concede the concept of a bargain coming their way. Kepler and Polanco signed deals which were largely viewed as abusively in favor of the Twins. Those extensions were used as examples of how the MLBPA and CBA had failed MLB players right about the time it was revealed the Twins front office had won a trophy for beating down arbitration eligible players the hardest in MLB about the same time. Neither Polanco nor Kepler had the advantage Berrios did, though. Berrios had some track record and he was in a coveted position as a starting pitcher. Polanco was not viewed as a shortstop and Kepler played RF. Berrios was willing to bet on himself and it paid off. I'm sure the front office is confused at the idea Berrios was already worth more to Toronto after a couple months than he was to the Twins after they grew him in their own farm system.10 points -
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Hunter48 and 9 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
10 pointsIf you won't sign younger pitches to long deals.... That leaves older pitchers, and pitchers that aren't as good as your targets. So, you might not get the end of a long deal, but you might be left with only signing old pitchers to short deals, but never having received the younger years..... Or, just signing lesser pitchers.....10 points -
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Hunter48 and 8 others reacted to nicksaviking for a post in a topic
9 pointsIf Berrios and his durability aren't worth a long term deal, then clearly no pitchers are. As a Twins fan, this is disappointing. We aren't winning a WS without a bunch of top end arm talent and now we know the only way that's happening is if they somehow develop a bunch of their own all at once, even though they've only developed one in the last 20 years. As a baseball fan, it's BS. I don't like Scott Boras, but this would be a good time for him to call out the Twins for depriving players a chance at a fair deal. Berrios is lucky, he's still only 27. Nearly all the arms this team is counting on in the pipeline are going to be pushing 30 before they can break loose from the Twins.9 points -
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Hunter48 and 8 others reacted to LA VIkes Fan for a post in a topic
9 pointsWell, it sure looks like the kind of deal that the Twins that should have been willing and able to make either last year or this off-season. Add into that the fact that Thor has signed a one-year deal with the Angels for $21 million and I think we know the price of pitching this off-season. Any thoughts of Stroman or Ray signing for less than $22 – 25 million a season over at least three or four years, and probably more like five, are gone. Even guys like Jon Gray are going to cost more like $17 million a year, not $14 or 15 million a year. It is a tough day to be a Twins fan. It is becoming more and more clear that the current regime is either badly underestimating the market cost for starting pitching of various types or ownership is unwilling to commit to the market price for pitching. We can all rail about how these guys are "overpaid" or "not worth the money" but frankly that's all irrelevant noise. The market is what the market is. We can either pay the market price and in the case of the Twins, probably a small premium over that due to the weather, last year's bad results, and the lack of ancillary financial opportunities, or we simply won't get anyone. Given that the Twins don't even seem to have been in on what appear to be not overly generous contracts to Rodriguez and Thor, and were not really in on what now appears to be a reasonable price to Berrios before trading him, it is very hard to imagine that the team will belong to pay the necessary freight to sign even a second tier free-agent starting pitcher. I think the next couple of weeks before the current CBA expires and all free-agent activity stops will be fascinating for the Twins. The timetable is now accelerated; they have to make a decision as to whether we want to be competitive in 2022/2023, or tear it all down and go into a full rebuild. I really think it's a binary choice. To me, some middle ground where we sign a couple of number three type starters and proclaim that were ready to go is not only a bad choice, it's effectively a rebuild. Maybe I'm wrong and we are close to a trade for Sonny Gray or Castillo from the Reds, or maybe someone from Miami, but it sure looks like we are out of the free agency sweepstakes almost before it even really began. My prediction (admittedly based upon being irritated by today's news ) - this is the start of the teardown. We won't be able to sign Buxton and he will be traded. Once that happens, we will trade Donaldson rather than pay him $25 million to hit 4th on a sub .500 team. The FO will gush about the "great" prospect return for those two, and move forward with trading either Sano, Garver or Kepler, or perhaps all three, for more prospects. The cycle starts anew. The sad thing is that I could get behind that strategy if the team was honest and said we think we need to tear down and rebuild. What makes this hard to stomach is the public statements about how were going to reload and be competitive in 2022, followed by news that shows we aren't really even making an effort to reload. The good news is I live in Southern California so if Thor works out, maybe the Angels will be fun to watch this year for change.9 points -
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
glunn and 8 others reacted to nicksaviking for a post in a topic
9 pointsSeems like the Twins offered Yu Darvish and Zack Wheeler $20M+ per year, so I don't think whatever transpired here is exactly a definitive answer on future spending. Hard to wrap my head around this though as it's not like the Twins to overlook the bird in the hand for the two in the bush. My feeling was that the next CBA absolutely HAD to be player friendly and the free agents would be hesitant to sign early. With Rodriguez and Syndergaard flying off the board, maybe that perspective is wrong. Maybe something has changed. I'm certainly not happy about this, but perhaps there is a better than zero percent chance that whatever is about to occur with the CBA did change Berrios' prerogative.9 points -
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Heistyman and 7 others reacted to LastOnePicked for a post in a topic
8 pointsThis point seems inescapable to me: the Twins are not a serious MLB team. They are not serious about keeping top talent, and not serious about winning a WS title. They are muddling through year after year ... and the few fans that remain are mostly okay with it.8 points -
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
glunn and 7 others reacted to Cap'n Piranha for a post in a topic
8 pointsMLBTR now reporting the escalators can add up to $10M to the deal--if that is correct, I am shocked. As another poster mentioned, Martin/SWR will both have to really work out, otherwise this was a massive mistake.8 points -
Bye bye Buxton?
Bye bye Buxton?
tarheeltwinsfan and 7 others reacted to prouster for a post in a topic
8 pointsDan Hayes and Ken Rosenthal have a piece about Buxton in The Athletic today. To summarize: Others in the industry expect them to trade Buxton. There has been no progress to date since their discussions broke down at the trade deadline. Falvey: “At this point of the off-season we’re still just navigating our planning and strategy and trying to understand what’s available to us and what the market looks like . . . There are people on our team that are interesting to other clubs and we just always need to work through what does that look like, what does our team look like as we navigate it.” The tea leaves seem to be signaling a Buxton trade. If that happens, then there’s not really a reason to watch this team as far as I’m concerned. The Twins brass should remember that the Twin Cities are mostly a football and hockey town.8 points -
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
USAFChief and 7 others reacted to Otto von Ballpark for a post in a topic
8 pointsHere you go!8 points -
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
gunnarthor and 7 others reacted to Otto von Ballpark for a post in a topic
8 pointsBerrios was estimated to receive about $11 mil in arbitration this winter anyway. So you could look at it as a 6/120 extension beyond that, for a total of 7/131.8 points -
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
glunn and 7 others reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic
8 pointsWho wouldn’t love a warm weather region like Canada?8 points -
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Hunter48 and 6 others reacted to LA VIkes Fan for a post in a topic
7 pointsI hear your point about a 7 year deal, but I disagree that to justify the contract Berrios has to pitch like an ace. $20 a year is not the price for an "ace" starter – that is closer to $25 million-$30 million a year. For $20 million a year in today's MLB, you get a solid to strong #2 starter. Not an ace, not even an average#1 starter, you get a good #2 starter. Toronto now has two good #2 starters in Ryu and Berrios, each at $20 million a year, but they don't have that ace unless Robbie Ray comes back and is the same guy he was last year (unlikely on both counts). I actually think that's a very viable strategy and applaud the Blue Jays for their moves. As for the Twins, looks like the strategy is to try to buy time for a year or two with a couple guys like Pineda and hope that the pitching fills out through guys that are presently in the minors or acquired through trades. The problem is the lineup will be gone/aged out by the time the pitching is ready to contend. That's why I think the likely move is to start dropping contracts and players from the lineup for prospects. I'm afraid we are becoming another Cleveland without the pitching pipeline. The 2022 Twins – Get To Know 'Em!7 points -
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
flpmagikat and 6 others reacted to bean5302 for a post in a topic
7 pointsExtension = 6 years and $120MM. Escalators worth $10MM (unreported). Limited No trade protection. Opt out after year 5. The contract includes his arbitration year slated at $11MM for next year. From MLBTradeRumors - https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/10/extension-candidate-jose-berrios.html "It should be noted that Berrios has already been vocal about his desire to test free agency. “[I will have been] waiting six years, almost seven, to get where every player wants to be — a free agent, able to maximize our value….We are in a good position, and we’ll see what the best deal is going to be,” Berrios told The Minneapolis Star Tribune’s Phil Miller back in July. Berrios turned down extension offers from the Twins in the past and also went to an arbitration hearing with the team to determine his 2020 salary." A very similar pitcher (Eduardo Rodriguez) just signed for 5 years and $80MM. Berrios engaged in negotiations with the Twins and Blue Jays rather than just saying "no." The Blue Jays came up with an overpay and Berrios took it. The Twins didn't seem to get any traction with Berrios at all and the way Falvey beat down Kepler and Polanco makes me believe they were probably low-balling the heck out of Jose as well. The total extension was right where I expected Berrios to be in terms of cost and the fact Berrios took it after a career season shows he was still reasonable. It's a great deal for Berrios and Toronto recognized the value of having a very good starting pitcher locked up long term. Something the Twins are completely oblivious to.7 points -
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Richie the Rally Goat and 6 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
7 pointsIf he would have signed for that in MN, we don't know.....but if he would....this team will likely never sign a pitcher to a long deal. That's what this tells me. Now, if he wouldn't sign here for that, the FO needs to ask itself why......... I'm surprised at this.7 points -
Trade Target: Chris Bassitt
7 pointsI personally wouldn't trade Larnach for 1 year of Bassitt. Its not like He is going to be the 1 piece that puts us over the top into the series. Larnach should have many years of good to very good play ahead of him. If the FO feels Bassitt is enough of an asset to risk a player rated that high then they should make sure Bassitt is willing to negotiate an extension before agreeing to the deal.7 points
-
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Heistyman and 5 others reacted to beckmt for a post in a topic
6 pointsTwins seem like they could have done this. It might be bad only the last 2 years (maybe). $19.5 million a year is not out of reach for a reliable starter. Twins blew this, unless he really didn't want to be here.6 points -
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Otwins and 5 others reacted to mikelink45 for a post in a topic
6 pointsCongratulations to both the team and the player. Major League monies are hard to comprehend but the twins are in the marketplace and they better figure out what true value is. Jose is the best we've developed and I'm happy to see him prosper but sad to see him gone.6 points -
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
gunnarthor and 5 others reacted to Linus for a post in a topic
6 pointsI guess the notion of the Twins going after a front line free agent starter seems pretty foolish right about now.6 points -
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
glunn and 5 others reacted to umterp23 for a post in a topic
6 pointsWe can blame the FO all we want on this signing, but it could have been very easy by the Twins that Berrios wouldn't sign with the Twins regardless of offer, so they traded him. Not going down would / could / should have done this that or the other. We roll into next year with a new squad makeup and have at it.6 points -
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
glunn and 5 others reacted to Otto von Ballpark for a post in a topic
6 pointsHe took his talents to South Beach... of Lake Ontario! (Full disclosure: Toronto is technically on the north side of Lake Ontario.) Joke attempt #2: It's All About the Latitude!6 points -
What the Hell Are the Twins Doing with Byron Buxton?
What the Hell Are the Twins Doing with Byron Buxton?
Heiny and 4 others reacted to Nick Nelson for an article
5 pointsOn Tuesday, Dan Hayes and Ken Rosenthal bylined a report in The Athletic with the headline: Byron Buxton’s future with the Twins remains in limbo as team gauges trade interest, potential extension offers. The article depicts a team struggling to decide whether it should trade its best player with one year remaining under contract, or hold him for the 2022 season. The option that seems most obvious and desirable — striking a long-term extension with this generational talent in his prime — doesn't really seem to be on the table, even if it hasn't been ruled out. "Chairman Jim Pohlad, according to major-league sources, is reluctant to move Buxton, knowing such a decision potentially would upset a fan base tired of seeing the team part with homegrown stars," per The Athletic. Pohlad's absolutely right in his assessment of how trading Buxton will be perceived by Twins fans, who just watched Jose Berrios sign an extension with Toronto. Fortunately, it would seem nobody is in better position than he to ensure Buxton sticks around. Pohlad and his ownership group have the power to greenlight an offer that keeps Buxton in Minnesota long-term, and such a framework — from all indications — is extremely achievable under team-friendly terms. The article from Hayes and Rosenthal reiterates that a 7-year, $80 million offer was extended in July, which we've heard before, but later offers up this detail: "Sources said talks about an incentive-laden extension in July broke down because of the Twins’ unwillingness to push the potential total value to $100 million." Back in July, reports indicated Buxton's side was amenable to that guaranteed amount of $80 million (which surprised me), but that an agreement couldn't be reached over the incentive structure. In my mind, I figured Buxton's camp must have been demanding some extravagant bonuses that could've done something like double the base amount. Yet, the wording of this new report — talks about an incentive-laden extension in July broke down because of the Twins’ unwillingness to push the potential total value to $100 million — well, that sure sounds like the team was not open to a contract that would maximize at $100 million. And if true, that's nothing short of embarrassing. Shameful. And egregiously foolish. I mean, come on, that would average out to about $14 million per year. That's Ricky Nolasco money, for a homegrown MVP-caliber player in his prime years. I'm having a really hard time connecting the dots here. If Twins ownership is adamant about keeping Buxton, and the center fielder's side is open to a reasonable deal, then what is the hold-up? Why are the Twins mired in internal debate over whether to trade Buxton or let him leave as a free agent, rather than opting for the best choice, which is neither of those? Here are a few possibilities I can conjure. If you have others, I'd love to hear them in the comments. The reported numbers are inaccurate. Hayes and Rosenthal are two of the more respected writers in the biz, and I trust they're providing a realistic view of the overall dynamic, but that doesn't mean every single detail is spot-on. Perhaps there are some specifics getting obscured in the communication loop. Or maybe they're receiving false info from a biased source with an agenda. (Ostensibly, this would be Buxton's agent, but I'm not sure what their end-game would be in leaking a low-ball offer?) Also: the numbers that've been reported would have be a loooong ways off to not make sense for the Twins. The Twins front office doesn't believe in Buxton. Or at least doesn't have enough confidence in his durability and aging regression to feel that a long-term extension is in their interest. I find this kind of hard to believe, but when you look at the evidence available to us — an owner expressing his desire to retain a player who is seemingly open to reasonable terms, and a front office that isn't making it happen — it's a plausible explanation. Buxton has no interest in signing an extension in Minnesota. This would run contrary to what he's said publicly, but it'd hardly be the first time a pro athlete gave lip service to appease fans. Maybe the bridge truly was burned when the Twins held Buxton in the minors in September of 2018. Or maybe Buck has a yearning to return to the South where he was raised. Or maybe he simply recognizes an opportunity to earn a much bigger payday one year from now if he can deliver in 2022. Sadly, I think this is probably the most likely answer behind everything, and also the only one that completely ties the Twins' hands. Pohlad is bluffing, and doesn't really want to pay up. It's the favored explanation for many, I'm sure. Maybe it's true, and Pohlad is portraying himself to media as the good guy who fought for Buxton before an inevitable trade. But if the reported number he's targeting is anywhere close to correct, there's no reason that Twins shouldn't be able to keep Buxton while building a quality team around him under the payroll parameters that have become standard under this ownership. One thing I will say: if Pohlad is pushing to prevent a Buxton trade solely to mitigate fan blowback, knowing the team won't be able to re-sign him (which is one way to read the opening in the Athletic article), the front office needs to shut him out and not listen. Team strategy cannot be dictated by such factors. Trading Buxton will be a bitter pill to swallow, but it may result in making the best of a bad situation. A totally self-inflicted bad situation, if reports around these negotiations are to be believed. MORE FROM TWINS DAILY — Order the Offseason Handbook — Latest Twins coverage from our writers — Recent Twins discussion in our forums — Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook or email5 points -
What the Hell Are the Twins Doing with Byron Buxton?
What the Hell Are the Twins Doing with Byron Buxton?
chpettit19 and 4 others reacted to tarheeltwinsfan for a post in a topic
5 pointsNick, I agree 100 % with your article. Thanks for writing it and for expressing what a lot of us Twins fans are thinking: "What the Hell?" Maybe the FO and/or owners don't care what we rabid Twins fans are saying here, but they should pay attention. I contend this website is frequented by incredibly bright, thoughtful, loyal Twins fans. I really do not remember a subject matter that has been as strongly agreed upon on this site as the absolute necessity to sign Buck to a long term deal. Ans so I say in no damn uncertain terms: FO, do not mess this up by negotiating too much. I have seen this happen in negotiations involving my law practice many times. Feelings get hurt and lines get drawn in the sand and next thing you know, the whole thing unravels. This impasse is not just about money. Find a way to address the pride puffing up on both sides. Think outside the box and see what Buck really wants, and find a way to give it to him.5 points -
What the Hell Are the Twins Doing with Byron Buxton?
What the Hell Are the Twins Doing with Byron Buxton?
howeda7 and 4 others reacted to tony&rodney for a post in a topic
5 pointsThis Buxton situation has completely stymied the Twins front office apparently. "I'm having a really hard time connecting the dots here." - This is almost everyone, both Twins fans and those who follow baseball around the country. Something is amiss and it is frustrating to wait for the other shoe to fall. As to the possibilities .... it seems what numbers were shared/published are likely real or quite close. The other three possibilities seem much more to the heart of the problem in signing Buxton: the Twins don't believe in Byron, he is ready to move, and the Twins do not intend to pay for a Buxton contract. Whew, this is too much to get our head around. I mean the Twins could put a team on the field that does better than last year's record for $100 million. That team would need to include Buxton, even if the bill for BB was $25 million (a quarter of the payroll). Without Buxton, the Twins need to go into a full rebuild like Baltimore or boost the payroll to $150 million. So many posts and the article in The Athletic puts a new twist in our expectations/hopes for Twins baseball. How is it possible that Falvey is still analyzing their own roster and wondering what to do? The quote from The Athletic was somewhat disturbing. “Now, we’re working through understanding all sides of this ultimately. We’ll proceed accordingly. At this stage of the offseason, we’re still just navigating our strategy and planning and trying to understand what’s available to us and what the market looks like on all periods. As is always the case, this isn’t unique to Byron or otherwise, there are people on our team that are interesting to other clubs and we just always need to work through what does that look like, what does our team look like as we navigate it.” This entire past year has been confusing. My default is to accept what Falvey sees as best for making the Twins competitive, even when I disagree. The unfolding of this drama with Buxton causes me to question. Yah, what the hell is going on?5 points -
What the Hell Are the Twins Doing with Byron Buxton?
What the Hell Are the Twins Doing with Byron Buxton?
Seth Stohs and 4 others reacted to roger for a post in a topic
5 pointsWould be another fantastic article, Nick, if the subject/situation wasn’t so damned depressing.5 points -
Bye bye Buxton?
Bye bye Buxton?
Emjay and 4 others reacted to USAFChief for a post in a topic
5 pointsFalvine have driven this franchise into a pretty bad spot in a short time, haven't they?5 points -
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Twins33 and 4 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
5 pointsdon't start drinking every time they point out their business experience. We want you around a few more years...5 points -
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Hunter48 and 4 others reacted to DocBauer for a post in a topic
5 pointsI have little doubt there's more to this than the tired old mantra of "the Twins are cheap", but I'm sure we'll never know all the details/facts. It may be Berrios, after being traded, simply decided the $ was fair and he wanted the security for his family. Something may have changed within his family. So I'm not going to needlessly speculate or blame the Twins for anything at this point. To continue, the Twins are paying Donaldson more than $20M per. They lost out on but offered both Darvish and Wheeler more than $20M. So I don't think it's the money that is/was the overriding factor here. I think there's at least a good chance it was the length of the deal. And I can be disappointed without being angry. 6+ years is a very, very long time to guarantee a pitcher $20M+ per season. So I get it. That being said, Berrios is the best arm produced by the Twins in years. He's actually really good and has upside remaining. He's a tireless worker who is a bulldog competitor. And at only 27yo, he's the kind of arm young enough to deserve an extension that long. I don't think the Twins look very good here.5 points -
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Unwinder and 4 others reacted to sampleSizeOfOne for a post in a topic
5 pointsJust to clarify... Are those $130 million american $ or canada $? Kudos to Berrios! And if the Twins are a silly team, i will still root for 'em!5 points -
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Darn, I’m surprised he took that deal, I thought he could get more in FA. I would have inked that deal in a heartbeat if I were the Twins. They did at least trade Berrios at his peak value and got a haul for him. The FO has doubled down on their prospects panning out - especially their pitching prospects. They’re going to need some success in that department soon or our pitching is going to continue to be a millstone for this team. Also, what is it with Twins getting traded and then inking below market deals? (See Escobar, Pressly)5 points
-
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
TheLeviathan and 4 others reacted to Otto von Ballpark for a post in a topic
5 points5 points- Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
glunn and 4 others reacted to nicksaviking for a post in a topic
5 pointsI will say, there may be a silver lining with this. While I have no idea if it was the front office, the Pohlads or some other (very unlikely) unnamed force which kept the Twins from doing this deal, the Pohlads now at the very least know the magnitude of the crapshow they'll be facing if they also let Buxton get away without an extension. They stepped in and made the GM take care of business instead of the fan revolt of losing Kirby Puckett and Joe Mauer. Now is Buxton on the same level as those two? Probably not, but the riot they'll face may be.5 points- Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
DocBauer and 4 others reacted to wsnydes for a post in a topic
5 pointsHe did actually relocate further south, so there is that!5 points- ROSENTHAL: Byron Buxton Trade “Likely”
ROSENTHAL: Byron Buxton Trade “Likely”
Mike Frasier Law and 3 others reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic
4 pointsIf we somehow end up trading Berrios and Buxton within a calendar year of each other, I’m going to have to take some time to see if I really want to prioritize the Twins and MLB in my free time. The pain is going to be too much to handle. The FO created 2 self-inflicting, horribly managed situations. There’s still time to right this ship before it’s too late and a trade occurs4 points- What the Hell Are the Twins Doing with Byron Buxton?
What the Hell Are the Twins Doing with Byron Buxton?
Twins33 and 3 others reacted to Cap'n Piranha for a post in a topic
4 pointsIf the Twins truly are not willing to pay Buxton $14M a year REGARDLESS of performance (miss 140 games, put up 1 WAR? Fourteen Million. Play 150 games, put up 8 WAR, win MVP? Fourteen Million)...then I just don't know what to say.4 points- Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
flpmagikat and 3 others reacted to LastOnePicked for a post in a topic
4 pointsIt also might be great if people asked themselves if the Twins are really a low-revenue team. At least, according to the data I could find, it looks like they're a mid-revenue team. Wasn't that the whole point of a subsidized new stadium just a decade ago? So it isn't ignorant *at all* to assume that if the Twins were serious about winning they would pursue a mix of lower-cost, high-impact prospect development strategies (like the Rays) as well as a few higher-cost signings of all-star quality players (like the Yankees). Particularly homegrown, fan-favorite players who play at a position of the team's greatest need. That's not "bitching" ... that's wanting the team to assert some intent to win. But I'm very much on board with the suggestion to search for a new PBO and GM. Spot on.4 points- Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Dman and 3 others reacted to TheLeviathan for a post in a topic
4 pointsI defended the deal on the basis that Berrios was intent on FA. It appears he was just intent to get a long, rich contract. I still like the deal from a talent perspective, but the organization needs to answer why they couldn't have inked this contract. Berrios is great value for Toronto at this price. Either Jose wouldn't sign that same deal here (which is a huge indictment) or we refused to offer it (which is also a huge indictment).4 points- Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
KirbyDome89 and 3 others reacted to USAFChief for a post in a topic
4 pointsI came here just to see MLR's use of the phrase "below average revenue." I'm keeping count.4 points- Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Hunter48 and 3 others reacted to Major League Ready for a post in a topic
4 pointsHow many other teams with below average revenue signed SPs to 7 year deals in the past 25 years? The answer is 1. Colorado signed Dan Hampton which was a horrific signing. Is Colorado the only serious MLB team among those teams with below average revenue? Tampa traded Snell last year. Are they not interested in winning? Oakland is looking to trade their established SPs. Does this indicate they are not a serious MLB team. Was Billy Beane demonstrating he was not interested in winning when he traded Jeff Samardzija for Bassitt and Semien?4 points- Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
jmlease1 and 3 others reacted to Cap'n Piranha for a post in a topic
4 pointsI always thought Wheeler's 5 yr/$118M was the baseline for Berrios--signed two years later, but with Berrios younger at the time of signing than Wheeler, with Wheeler having the higher ceiling, and Berrios the (much) higher floor. We'll have to see what the escalators are, and how the annual salaries work out, but it seems unlikely Berrios will make $118M in the first five years without activating those escalators. As such, it's hard for me to definitively say whether this is good or bad yet. If the escalators simply add $2M for every remaining year of the deal every time he hits 200 IP, then the Twins should have signed him to this deal. If they add $5M for every remaining year of the deal every time he hits 150 IP, then I'm glad the Twins didn't sign this deal. Clearly I'm exaggerating for effect here, but simply to prove a point--minus knowledge of the escalators, we can't confidently say what this deal is, therefore we can't confidently say if it's good or bad the Twins didn't sign Berrios to it.4 points- Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Analyzing the José Berríos Extension from Minnesota’s Perspective
Minny505 and 3 others reacted to D.C Twins for a post in a topic
4 pointsContgrats to Berrios for working hard, staying focused, and betting on himself. He is easy to root for and I will continue to do so for years to come (unless pitching against the Twins of course Our FO underestimates or cannot palate the cost of reliable pitching. The free agent pitcher list is already dwindling and we have 0 established MLB starting pitchers.... Maybe we have 2 Liriano type breakouts coming from our MiLB, but alas, pipe dreams are not a plans. I'm starting to follow the plight of our 2022 starting rotation more with morbid curiosity than breathless anticipation.4 points- Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
wabene and 3 others reacted to Nashvilletwin for a post in a topic
4 pointsI know I’m in the minority again, but this FO does not sign 7 year deals for SPs, especially for close to $20MM/yr. Sorry, that’s just the reality - it’s just not happening. And I’m not upset about it. We will see how well Jose does over those seven years. What’s the over/under on his ERA from ‘23 onward? 4+? I’ll take developing our staff and the savings to redeploy annually to build a pen. I just don’t think the cost benefit analysis supports a 7 yr. $20MM SP who can only get through the order more than twice about 25% if the time. I’m addition, I’m betting right now Martin is a legit corner outfielder or super utility player for us for many years at basically league minimum. We will see on SWR too. This team going forward, until a window clearly opens, is primarily about developing controllable SP assets on the cheap. Don’t ding the Pohlads. When the window looked open they have spent. They are solid owners (they did right by the entire organization through Covid). Now let’s resign BB and trade JD so we can sign a long term SS solution. I’m very positive in this team’s prospects for building toward a new window in ‘23 and beyond. Good for Jose. He’s set for life. Well done.4 points- Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
DocBauer and 3 others reacted to Hosken Bombo Disco for a post in a topic
4 pointsI always read “wants to test free agency” as also meaning “wants a market offer.” If you followed Berrios after he was traded, it was plain to see that leaving Minnesota hurt him. Anyway, I’m happy for him and will always be a fan of his and this gives me a new AL East team to cheer for.4 points- Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Agreed, we only know half the story and we'll likely never know all of it. To this point, we still don't know what the entire deal he got entails either. There could be details in the deal that the Twins wouldn't give him. There's still a lot of things we simply don't know yet. It certainly doesn't look good at first blush though.4 points- Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
gunnarthor and 3 others reacted to LastOnePicked for a post in a topic
4 pointsI consider this a fireable offense. That's a completely reasonable contract for a very durable ace (and one of our very few homegrown pitching success stories). Twins should have matched or beat that offer easily, and Berrios is certainly worth more to a "retooling" team than the underwhelming prospects they received in trade. Shameful. We were told by this FO that Berrios wanted to test his value in free agency, and that he wouldn't accept an extension. Now we know that wasn't true. We were also told by Jim Pohlad that the Twins "absolutely" could afford to keep Berrios AND Buxton long-term. So much deception and misdirection. This team continues to embarrass and disappoint. I love Twins baseball, but it might be getting time to walk away. It's going to be too hard to see this happen with Buxton as well.4 points- Trade Target: Chris Bassitt
Trade Target: Chris Bassitt
tarheeltwinsfan and 3 others reacted to roger for a post in a topic
4 pointsIf we are only getting one year, the cost had better be closer to the Odorizzi deal than Larnach +. Otherwise, pass.4 pointsThis leaderboard is set to Chicago/GMT-06:00 - Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays