Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Leaderboard

  1. Aggies7

    Old-Timey Member
    Points
    17,347
    Posts
  2. Nine of twelve

    Verified Member
    Points
    5,171
    Posts
  3. Squirrel

    Community Leader
    Points
    31,121
    Posts
  4. Vanimal46

    Old-Timey Member
    Points
    17,338
    Posts

Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation on 08/21/2021 in all areas

  1. Revisiting the 60 Day IL

    Minny505 and 16 others reacted to Nine of twelve for a post in a topic

    17 points
    Smeltzer's life story is a great one. But in spite of that I don't see how he should outrank younger rising talent. I think he has pretty much peaked. I'm much more willing to let him try to continue his career elsewhere than to risk losing a prospect who is still improving.
  2. Game Score: Yankees 10, Twins 2

    joefish and 7 others reacted to Otto von Ballpark for a post in a topic

    8 points
    I’m just glad that Rocco left Barnes in long enough to qualify for the win.
  3. I hardly doubt they don't have a clue. I think this kind of rhetoric is just ridiculous. With all the injuries and illnesses this team has had this year, it's been more juggling of the roster and players than usual. And at this point, they are trying out a lot of the fringe players to evaluate before jettisoning, because that's what you do in a lost season. We have seen a lot of rookies this year, even if not the ones or the many we want. Because it's not always what we like or want to see doesn't mean they don't have a clue. They know better than us, even with the seeming mistakes or actual mistakes they make. But I agree, I haven't a clue what they will do, either.
  4. Because he hasn't played in a game in 2 months... get some ABs under his belt before being thrown into big league games.
  5. 5 points
    Donaldson, after poking at cole: 0-6, 4 k’s
  6. Reading about guys shining like Leobaldo Cabrera is a big reason I enjoy these reports. He may not be a prospect but fighting back into affiliated ball through the Empire League after getting released by the Yankees in 2018 makes for a good story. Thanks to the crew that provides these reports. I really appreciate them.
  7. When do you think we'll see Ryan pitch for the Twins? Our next home stand? September? or next season? (I actually started a poll on this earlier in the week.)
  8. Sticky air, high winds, and a foreboding forecast didn’t stop 8,209 baseball fans from coming out to CHS Field on Friday night to watch highly-touted prospect and Olympian Joe Ryan make his Twins organization debut. Even better? The game marked Byron Buxton’s highly-anticipated return after a lengthy stint on the IL from a hand injury he suffered on June 21st. Ryan was electric out of the gate, hitting 93, 94, and 95 MPH in his first matchup of the night, striking out former Twins outfielder Ian Miller on six pitches. The former Rays prospect carried his dominance through the first inning, striking out the side on a total of 15 pitches, 11 of those being strikes. After a perfect first inning, Ryan’s second inning was a carbon copy. The 6’2 gun-slinger needed just 18 pitches to fan the heart of the I-Cubs order. Six hitters, six strikeouts. After two innings of strikeouts, Ryan must’ve realized that it would be selfish not to get his fielders involved in the action. Ryan drew two groundouts to the middle infield and tossed in another strikeout, bringing his total to seven. One of Ryan’s few mistakes came in the fourth inning when he left a pitch up that Cubs’ outfielder Nick Martini hit over the right-field fence. Yet just as he showed in Tokyo, Ryan wasn't phased, striking out two of the next three batters to end the inning and a stellar first outing as a Minnesota Twin. In today’s game, it’s not uncommon to see managers take top prospects out of games early to protect arms and hone in on development. Given that Ryan hasn’t pitched since starting (and winning) the Olympic semifinals for Team USA on August 4th, it’s not shocking that Toby Gardenhire removed his starter after four dominant innings. The organization had developed a plan that included Ryan throwing 60-70 pitches on Friday night. Four innings of one-run ball with nine strikeouts, one walk, and 49 strikes on 67 pitches. Not bad for a guy pitching in a new environment that hasn’t thrown in a Minor League game since July 18th. Twins fans knew that Joe Ryan was a talented pitcher when he was acquired in the trade that sent Nelson Cruz to Tampa Bay. As a recent MLB Top 100 Prospect and two-game winner at the Olympics, Ryan’s numbers speak for themselves. Yet like so many other things in life, seeing is believing. Twins and Saints fans got to see arguably the strongest debut performance from a pitcher in the organization this year on Friday night. Here are three takeaways from Ryan’s debut in the Land of 10,000 Lakes. Ryan’s velocity on his fastball ranged from 92-95 MPH all evening, and he was painting the corners of the strike zone. It’s no secret that the heater is Ryan’s pitch, but his ability to consistently nail his spots was impressive. Pitching with a lead is a pitcher’s best friend (Editor's note: It's right up there with the double play and dogs.). The Saints provided that to Ryan by scoring six runs in the first inning. It will be interesting to see how he handles tighter game situations. Perhaps the most impressive feat of the night for Ryan came after he gave up the mammoth homer over the right-field wall. For many, the situation could have been a slippery slope. Not for Ryan, who struck out the next batter, got a ground ball, and retired the final batter with another strikeout. Ryan’s confidence shows when he’s on the mound. The guy has swagger, and he’s not afraid to show it. Buxton Returns Buxton’s performance wasn’t as noteworthy as his last rehab debut with the Saints, when he went 2-for-3 with a triple on June 8th against Omaha (Royals). Buxton went 0-for-2 with an RBI sac-fly and a strikeout before being removed from the game after the fifth inning. Buxton’s sac fly was inches away from being a double but was caught by a sprawling Greg Deichmann in right field. (Editor's Note: Slo-motion replay showed that it likely was a trap, but with no replay in Triple-A, the call stood.) No, it wasn’t the April MVP-caliber Buxton that fans had hoped to see but just watching the organization’s centerpiece compete again was a treat for all. Buxton will likely stay with the Saints over the weekend and longer if needed. There’s no rush for the superstar. With the Twins out of playoff contention, it’s crystal clear that getting Buxton healthy is a priority of the organization. For more in-depth recaps from across the Twins minor league affiliates be sure to check out tonight's Minor League Report!
  9. Game Score: Yankees 7, Twins 1

    Bill Tanner and 3 others reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic

    4 points
  10. If they want Ryan up at the start of next year, he'll pitch in MN this year to get acclimated. If they don't do that, I would bet money he's not on the opening day roster next year. He's 25....no need to baby him. Now, he might need work on certain pitches, that's different. But, there is no reason to protect him at this point. Me? I'd call him up to get him acclimated to the majors. But I don't know what they'll do. I am not worried about losing a fringe player at this point, so I'm not worried about the 40 man.
  11. Revisiting the 60 Day IL

    Minny505 and 3 others reacted to nclahammer for a post in a topic

    4 points
    I will be cheering for Smeltzer wherever he continues his career, such a good story, agree that it may be time to move on. I thought Garlick might stick early in the season until Refsnyder came on the scene. We have so many corner outfielders.
  12. Label me an optimist, but Ryan's outstanding pitching line coupled with Buxton making it through (paritial) a game without an injury, gives me a ray of hope (a dangerous thing I know) that 2022 and beyond won't be the absolute s-show this season has been.
  13. Game Score: Yankees 10, Twins 2

    joefish and 3 others reacted to Aggies7 for a post in a topic

    4 points
    It’s pretty funny how the twins just went toe to toe with three division leaders, winning all series and being very competitive. Now they show up in NY and are blown out early. If there was ever any doubt about the intimidation factor in NY, that should be cleared up by now.
  14. Revisiting the 60 Day IL

    Mike Sixel and 2 others reacted to gunnarthor for a post in a topic

    3 points
    Honestly, outside of Kiriloff, none of these guys has to be kept. None were/are highly regarded prospects. Some are getting pretty long in the tooth. I suspect there will be many comparable arms looking for jobs in the offseason. None of these guys should be a priority. The FO has to fix the bullpen and a few of these guys might fit into their plan (scary thought) but I would be surprised if we kept more than two of them, counting Kiriloff.
  15. Noah Syndergaard Vs Top 5 FA SS

    TheLeviathan and 2 others reacted to nicksaviking for a post in a topic

    3 points
    The Twins likely aren’t even a 90 loss team this year. 90 losses next year doesn’t actually sound likely at all. But that’s really immaterial. If you’re signing a big time free agent, you likely aren’t signing him for one year. Most contenders build their clubs over a series of years, not all at once.
  16. Game Score: Yankees 10, Twins 2

    ashbury and 2 others reacted to VivaBomboRivera! for a post in a topic

    3 points
    Steely Dan sing the Ballad of Barnes & Barraclough: Times are hard You're afraid to pay the fee So you find yourself somebody Who only makes league minimum When you need a few more innings 'Cause your man can't take the mound That's the time you get me throwin' And you know I'll be around I'm a fool to do your dirty work, oh yeah...
  17. Berriós was 22 on arrival and went 14-8 as a 23 year old. IN ‘17. Must take that into account when considering Ryan’s preparedness for the MLB. He’s already 25. Time to move him along. Looks like he’s too good for AAA.
  18. there's no way around it: a very exciting start for Joe Ryan. That's a lot of strikeouts in a short stint, and he was reasonably efficient about it. Obviously, it'll be tougher at MLB, but he's definitely looking like he's not far off from being ready to take a shot at the majors and you can see why the Twins jumped on getting him for Cruz. I think it's smart to ease him back in after the Olympics, but it's great to have the Twins staff finally able to get their hands on Ryan and start to work with him and evaluate where he's at under AAA game conditions. It's a really interesting question on him getting the call-up; he's going to get at least one more start in AAA as part of the ramp up, I'm sure. If he crushes it again, do you bring him up in September to test him against the best? I think you do. He's not got a ton of innings on him for this year (in some ways the Olympics were good in creating an innings limit of sorts without actually pulling him), he's 25...if he looks ready, let him fly.
  19. The Twins can only add two players. No one is a needed add, such as a third catcher. Ryan would have to be added to the 40-man roster (there is a vacancy I believe). There are also many players due back from the Injured List, including Alcala and Farrell. Dobnak is also probably ready to be activated, or at least sent on rehab assignment. Doing what is right for a good prospect like Ryan is the right move, but does that mean adding a month to his season to face big league hitters? I don't know.
  20. I watched the Saints game instead of the Twins to watch Ryan. He was impressive. Very good command of his FB. He did not use his off-speed stuff much and when he did the command was not great. Hopefully, the Twins staff can help him dial in his other offerings. He is going to be good but he could be very good if he sharpens his other pitches.
  21. Game Score: Yankees 10, Twins 2

    heresthething and 2 others reacted to h2oface for a post in a topic

    3 points
    Watch the next two days get rained out, and the whole pitching fiasco wasn't even necessary. No need to give Maeda extra rest and then match him up with Cole. Why not give us a better chance to win and match him up with a different pitcher? If you are going to give games away, Baldelli, you may as well give away one you would probable lose even with your best lineup and starting pitcher (that the team has left, anyway).
  22. Game Score: Yankees 10, Twins 2

    joefish and 2 others reacted to Melissa for a post in a topic

    3 points
    I wonder whether the umpires buy into the Twins-fan narrative of Yankee domination over our boys? The home plate umpire really squeezed Barraclough on the Voit AB before his home run. Two two-strike pitches nicking the zone but called balls before the cookie Voit inevitably clobbered. [edited to correct name of pitcher]
  23. Game Score: Yankees 10, Twins 2

    Dodecahedron and 2 others reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic

    3 points
    The announced lineup was not competitive. Equivalent of a Sunday matinee game. No surprise this is the result.
  24. 2 points
    The 60-Day IL allows teams to stash an injured player away without holding a 40 man spot. The Twins have utilized this six times this season in the way of four pitchers and two hitters. With young players needing 40 man roster spots to be protected from the Rule 5 draft this winter, it’s worth revisiting these players on a case-by-case basis. Alex Kirilloff This is probably the easiest one. The Twins former top prospect should be back with a healthy wrist by Opening Day and likely penciled in at first base. There isn’t anything that would change the Twins minds. Randy Dobnak Despite a nightmare season in which Dobnak put up a 7.83 ERA in 43 innings, he’s an easy add after the Twins extended him through 2026 on a very team-friendly deal. Regarding his role, it’s anyone’s guess at this point how the Twins plan to use him, but he’s been throwing bullpens recently and could even return from a finger injury before the end of 2021. The Twins can’t cut Dobnak loose given their commitment, not to mention his recent success in the MLB. Devin Smeltzer Smeltzer only threw 4 2/3 innings without allowing a run before being put on the IL with an elbow injury. His 2022 may largely depend on the nature of his injury and whether his health can be counted on. Perhaps his lack of ceiling may give the Twins pause, but he has shown to be a competent Major League pitcher and perhaps deserves a little bit of run in a bullpen role. If he’s ready to pitch for opening day in 2022, I’d expect to see Smeltzer get one more look. Edwar Colina Colina got shelled in his lone MLB appearance in 2020 but boasts what some call the best slider in the Twins system to go along with his high-90s fastball. Colina was an arm many were excited to see get some real run this year before he underwent elbow surgery which ended his season before it began. As the Twins look to rebuild a bullpen in 2022, it’s hard to imagine them not gambling on the upside of Edwar Colina assuming his injury appears to be recovering as expected. Cody Stashak It’s possible Stashak was dealing with his back injury longer than the Twins knew, but it was a bit surprising to see him get as much of an opportunity as he did in 2021. With a 91 mph fastball, Stashak’s skillset revolved around his ability to limit walks when he debuted in 2019 which made his 13.3% walk rate this year all the more unacceptable. He upped his strikeout rate to nearly 35% at the expense of every other skill a pitcher could have as he finished with a 6.89 ERA. Stashak will be 28 next year and his ceiling is probably just an okay middle reliever which may make him an easy roster spot to dedicate to protecting another player from the Rule 5 draft. Kyle Garlick Garlick looked like the Twins best offseason acquisition for awhile and slashed .232/.280/.465 before being shut down with a sports hernia. Garlick does one thing well and that’s mash lefties, something the Twins were unable to set him up for consistently as injuries piled up. Unfortunately for Garlick, the Twins just don’t have a lot to gain from keeping a defensively-challenged 30-year-old with such a niche skillset. It’s hard to see the Twins not parting ways with Garlick unfortunately. It’s easy to look at this list of players who haven’t been contributing for quite some time and forget about them, but the Twins do have some solid players coming back off injury next year. The tricky part is trying to balance the roster on who is worthy of a return as they try and protect the necessary players to avoid another Akil Baddoo situation. Should any more of these six be definitively kept or let go this winter? Let us know below. — Latest Twins coverage from our writers — Recent Twins discussion in our forums — Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook or email — Follow Cody Pirkl on Twitter here
  25. Game Score: Yankees 7, Twins 1

    USAFChief and one other reacted to Aerodeliria for a post in a topic

    2 points
    We seem to want to give Polanco a pass with the bases loaded in the 5th. His whiff was perhaps the more egregious because there was only one out. His homer was meaningless a few innings later.
  26. Game Score: Yankees 7, Twins 1

    joefish and one other reacted to jbeckr for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Take your average little league team, put Yankee uniforms on them, and they beat the Twins nine times out of ten.
  27. I think we're sympatico on Kerrigan and Gore. A useful "extra" OF who could be useful and is definitely flying under the radar. And who cares what age Gore is, right? You move to the mound and suddenly you find a role. IF you hit MLB at 28yo or so and do well, does anyone care? Absolutely agree on Whitefield as well. Of course I love his story! A hard softball leaguer from Australia who the Twins sign? How can you not love a story like that? And because of that, he's been a guy I've been following for some time. Just feels like he's been around for a while. And then I rezlize he's still only 24yo and teased us with a solid 2016-17 at rookie and low A ball before a pair of bad seasons in 2018-19. And after a brief 2020 ML appearance and time at St Paul, he's suddenly having a solid year for Wichita. Absolutely agree he is un-refined and needs work. The K's need to come down, better contact has to be made, and he's way too big, strong and athletic to show so little power. But what might he be with an off-season and a return to AA as a 25yo still learning the game? Not expecting greatness here, but could he be a bloomer in 2022?
  28. 2 points
    I am with you on Kerrigan he is having a great year. He has been patient at the plate his slugging is really good his K rate is just a bit higher than you would like to see it at 30% but other than that his metrics looks pretty solid. He has been very under radar good. I like Whitefield too but he is too aggressive at the plate so he doesn't walk much and his slugging is lower than both Kerrigan and Celestino. If he can solve that next year he would be legit option at the MLB level IMO. Gore has been far better than I ever imagined he could be. I agree they have to move him up and he could be an option next year.
  29. Revisiting the 60 Day IL

    chpettit19 and one other reacted to Dman for a post in a topic

    2 points
    I don't think I said we should, I just noted Garlics positives. I like Refsnyder better than Garlic and there is no guarantee Rob stays on the 40 man either. I still am backing Rooker to a degree (he needs to be better at the plate) but keep in mind both Refsnyder and Garlic have performed better than Roooker at the MLB level to this point.
  30. Anyone have word on Sands? Injuries to pitchers seems to be an epidemic this year. Just amazing to me how missing 2020 and losing that routine has affected so many young arms. Agree with jmlease1, just get as many IP as you can the rest of the year and keep everyone as healthy as you can. Just a couple quick thought: 1] I hope Kerrigan sticks around for 2022. Solid defense everywhere and a decent bat, he's njce to have around as a 6th/7th OF type. Whitefield is having a rezlly nice rebound season at Wichita and is still only 24yo. Athletically, he's a potential 5 tool talent who might need to repeat AA in 2022 to further harness his potential. Not saying he's a top prospect, but he has the potential be a solid reserve in a couple years. 3] Gore doesn't have ideal size, and he's a little long in the tooth after converting from SS to RP, but I don't care about his age for that very reason. Is he part of the St Paul pen in 2022? 4] The turnaround for Sabato is amazing. Was he hurt earlier? Was he putting too much pressure on himself? Or was it simply a young guy taking longer than hoped for/expected to make that initial transition? 5] Kind of ironic that days after an article on TD about Gipson-Long he has maybe one of his best performances. A little more "oomph" and/or movement on his FB and ANY variation of a change pitch and I just wonder if he could be a really fast riser in 2022. 6] I would love someone with more immediate energy than me to break down the monthly records of our affiliates. I might be mis-remembering, but it feels like everyone was hovering around .500 or so early in the season before just taking off.
  31. Game Score: Yankees 7, Twins 1

    Rik19753 and one other reacted to LastOnePicked for a post in a topic

    2 points
    The antics of team "E-Z Pass" continue, year after year. I don't really mind losing to the Yankees this year (draft pick booster), but I'll believe the Twins are capable to winning a playoff series the year I see them absolutely beat up on the Yankees. Here's hoping that year isn't too far off.
  32. I have a sincere suggestion. Twins should just forfeit tomorrows game to save the pitching staff...and just get out of town. They could also just not bother to complete this one too. They cannot win. They aren't competitive. Its almost not fair. Playing the Yankees is worse than a root canal. (or pick your worst nightmare) White flag waving. Churchill said 'nevah give up, nevah.' He clearly never saw the Twins try and play baseball with the Yankees.
  33. 2 points
    That’s actually a great job by Jeffers.
  34. 2 points
    I really have no idea on this. The Rays looked like they were keeping Ryan at 75-80 pitches max this season and Ryan threw 70-74 pitches per start in the Olympics. The Saints gave him the quick hook after 67 pitches and 4 dominant innings. Limiting his pitches a bit would make sure he's fresh for a call up, but there are plenty of players in the minors who've played excellently and haven't been called up. I think it makes a great deal of sense to have Joe Ryan up for his next available start at the MLB level. I know a lot of people don't think 1-1/2 months makes a big difference in Joe Ryan's development, but I think it could. It's not 1-1/2 months. It's the active game time, plus the offseason. Seeing how Ryan's offerings look against MLB hitters can more clearly show weaknesses in Ryans game. I think we've all seen players who get a brief time at the MLB level and learn something about what works in their game and what doesn't. If Ryan comes up right away, he could get 7 starts at the MLB level. I voted September because I think the Twins are going to try and manipulate his service time.
  35. I hereby claim Yankee Stadium in the name of the great state of Minnesota. It is now our home field, and they have to bat first! (Think that will work?)
  36. It’s a category 1 which can definitely be deadly the farther out to sea it goes the better
  37. Revisiting the 60 Day IL

    chpettit19 and one other reacted to Dman for a post in a topic

    2 points
    I think Kirilloff and Dobnak are pretty safe adds. I know Dobnak had a tough year this year but he showed signs early that he might have potential to be a number 4 starter. He was starting to K guys and he is a groundball pitcher. The Twins believed in his stuff enough to give him an early contract. Now would not be the time to completely give up on Randy. Colina is hard throwing pitcher with a plus slider and the Twins currently lack velocity in their bullpen arms so it would be hard to let him go and one of the bottom teams would surely pick him up if the Twins dropped him. He likely stays unless the Twins feel his arm will never be the same. Smeltzer is the tough one. I don't love the idea of giving up on him without giving him one more shot but from what I have seen his ceiling appears low. He is a lefty though and we don't have many of those and he could be good out of the pen as well so I don't know I guess it depends on who else we have to expose before I could decide. What Stashak can do seems to be easily replaceable. Would I like to keep him yes I would but their seems to be a fair number of pitchers coming up that will have higher ceiling's so if he needed to be sacrificed I could see it happening. Garlick has a nice bat and can play left field OK. He is a beast against lefties and would be good in a platoon but there is a reason he has been on the fringes of the 40 man for most teams and that is he doesn't look like a guy that hold down a spot on a regular basis and looks more like a situational bat. I could be wrong but he is also about to turn 30 and left fielders are not that hard to find. Refsnyder looks more versatile and I think his bat plays against lefties and righties as well. I don't see Garlick coming back unless it is on a minors deal.
  38. To expand a bit on Seth's response, it's not injury risk that is the concern and it's not that he needs "practice". He just needs a few games to shake off the rust and get acclimated to playing again. Even the most elite players need that in order to perform at a major league level.
  39. Revisiting the 60 Day IL

    Mike Sixel and one other reacted to roger for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Kirilloff, Dobnak and Colina stay. The other three are likely headed out. Maybe there is a chance that enough spots will open up and one is kept around, either till spring training or to be included as an extra part of some trade this winter. Unfortunately, there won't be any opportunities to move them in a trade as everyone is looking to get rid of marginal players...not add.
  40. Revisiting the 60 Day IL

    Doctor Gast and one other reacted to Rosterman for a post in a topic

    2 points
    It is all about depth and where the guys now fall in the pecking order. Colina has age on his side, but will be spending his third year on the 40-man and, assuming he is healed by spring training, more than likely starting in the minors. The team has to look closely if they will be adding Enlow to the 40-man, who will also be spending a year in rehab. Ad you have Duran, who we hoped would be getting a major league tryout this season (along with Balazovic). That would suddenly be four names that you can't count being in the majors to start the season, and you play wait-and-see where they progress during 2022. Stashak is also the same. You can cut him and maybe resign him, but if no one claims him for their own 40-man, I believe he is a free agent. But a 40-man spot is valuable, unless you are arguing keeping him or any of the over 30-arms of Albers, Farrell, Thielbar, Minaya. All of whom could probably also be resigned to minor league contracts if they don't take services elsewhere. I believe Smeltzer may have an option year left with the Twins and they would keep him if no one else claimed him. Remember that all teams are dealing with the same dilemma as the Twins, which is why guys like a Smeltzer isn't waived until the last minute when all teams are adding their Rule 5 saves. I think the Twins could get Smeltzer thru waivers. The Twins can also move Dobnak off the 40-man. They still control him, they just have to pay him. Shades of Nick Blackburn and Joe Mays. If another team would claim him, the salary would be theirs to keep. The Twins could let him start the season at AAA without having him on the roster, and see where he goes from there. Garlick is so far behind the pecking order, once Buxton returns. Remember, he beat out the now released Broxton, Refsnyder, Larnach and Kirilloff for a spot on the major league roster. Celestino is now also ahead of him. Cave is still in the picture (although he ahs probably priced himself out of an arbitration backup job). And the Twins have Kerrigan and Contreras both performing well in St. Paul, neither of whom would probably be taken in the Rule 5. Do you take the chance someone will grab Colina? Remember, you always need a couple of names on the roster who can be jettisoned if you sign a free agent, and at that time it is often easier to get them thru waivers and late enough that the only alternative for the player is to sign and stay with their team. Be interesting to see how the Twins treat their roster of pitchers like Thorpe, Jax, Thielbar, Stashak, Farrell, Law, Minaya, Coulombe, Albers, Garcia, Garza, Gant, Barraclough, not to mention Hamilton. I would look at each case as a competing general manager looking to improve my club and if any of those names were available, would I leap, run, be joyful adding them to my own 40-man roster at the expense of...whom.
  41. I kind of wonder why Buxton isn't just playing games for the Twins ?? If he's healthy enough to play, is he any more likely to get hurt playing in the majors or the minors ? I would say he's probably MORE likely to get hit by a AAA pitcher who still has "command issues." I realize this season is lost, but if he can play CF and take at bats for St. Paul, he should be in CF taking AB's for the TWINS. He doesn't need "practice." He's GOOD. Get Buck up to the Twins and say goodbye to Jake Cave.
  42. I think Ryan is ready now. When thinking about the rookies Ober, Jax and Ryan let's remember Berrios' first year. It was terrible. I see all three of these guys out performing Berrios' rookie year. This might speak to better pitching development with this FO. Cleveland's guys seem to come up well prepared. It would be sweet if we started seeing the same.
  43. Revisiting the 60 Day IL

    wabene and one other reacted to jmlease1 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Smeltzer is the toughest question in this group. He's a useful pitcher...but with limited upside. If the Twins are really crunched on the 40-man with better prospects, someone like him could get left out in the cold. I have no doubt that he'll get a shot at a major league roster from another team in a heartbeat, which is where it gets painful. But I don't think he's got a lot of value in a trade either (he's a throw-in in a bigger deal, maybe). That seems harsh for a guy who has had some success in MLB, but his ceiling looks like 5th starter/long man. I had higher hopes for Stashak as an impact reliever, but he's looking like a fungible guy and proof positive for why you have to be careful in where you put your money on the relief corps. A lot of these guys are going to be good one year and not much the next. He's probably not as bad as this year's numbers suggest, but also probably not as good as he was in 2020. The K's are great, but he's also a bit too hittable, so if his control slips (for whatever reason), then the WHIP is unsustainable. But he could have a nice bounceback year and be a decent middle relief option next year, which I'm sure will cause people to call for Falvine's collective heads if he goes elsewhere. He's another guy who the team will have to balance his potential utility against his lesser upside in evaluating him for a 40-man spot against a prospect with a higher ceiling.
  44. A few September starts isn’t going to change his development. The Twins aren’t going to learn anything they wouldn’t learn working in the minors. I still think they should bring him up. They should bring him up because it will simply be more interesting and fun to watch the game. I would look forward to his few starts. The Twins are in the entertainment business. Ryan has earned the call up. Bring him up in September. Limit his pitches. Entertain us.
  45. Bummer about Sands leaving with an injury. All I want out of Most of our starters in the minors is health and inning right now, so seeing another guy who needs the development time go down just stinks. But Joe Ryan looks exciting! Wouldn't it be delightful if in a year everyone is talking about what a steal the Twins pulled off in dealing a rental for a rotation fixture?
  46. Revisiting the 60 Day IL

    HrbieFan and one other reacted to beckmt for a post in a topic

    2 points
    I agree on Smeltzer, Dobnak will be given the leash because of his contract and the Twins may need starters next year. Rest I am ok with.
  47. Game Score: Yankees 10, Twins 2

    joefish and one other reacted to Rosterman for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Wow. Barnes threw over 100 pitches and even got enough innings to win the game...if Sano hadn't decided to go on paternity leave. If the Twins could free up some roster spots, they could send Barnes and Ober (literally shutting them down early) to St. Paul and have Strotman, Ryan and Balazovic come up and join the rotation. Who could they jettison to give them a couple of roster spots, plus one for Miranda since Donaldson is the designated hitter now?
  48. Game Score: Yankees 10, Twins 2

    Clare and one other reacted to insagt1 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    First time in awhile where Twins were totally out of it. We've discussed it already...Twins can't beat NY. They go into games already wondering how they will lose. Crazy you say? Not at all. Over 15 years of data indicate this is THE classic MLB mismatch, perhaps of all time.
  49. Noah Syndergaard Vs Top 5 FA SS

    notoriousgod71 and one other reacted to bean5302 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    There's no reason to sign one player when the one signing won't make the difference for the team. Donaldson is on pace for close to 3 WAR this year. He's been worth near his $21MM salary. It seems to me teams try to buy at $6MM per WAR but the average actual production is $8MM per WAR. Donaldson is right in between. If he finishes the year hot, he'll more than earn what the Twins were trying to buy. The Twins' market size suggests the team should carry an annual player payroll in the $140-150MM range right now. In 2019, they should have been in a position to push it over their sustained max like other teams almost univerally do. Maybe $170MM+? In any case. Free agent shortstops. I don't anticipate the Twins are going to do anything other than re-sign Simmons. Maybe an outside shot at Corey Seager. The owner is extremely risk averse when it comes to long contracts. Just how it is. Noah Syndergaard may well not become a free agent. The Mets are going to give him a QO and depending on whether or not he plays, his velocity if he plays and how effective he is, there's a fair likelihood he'd take it just to rebuild value and get the QO off the table forever. Syndergaard is reported as throwing mid 90s yesterday. If he pushes back up to 97-98, and does well in his return to MLB in a couple weeks out the pen, he'll likely decline the QO and seek a long term contract. He'll get at least 5 years $125MM from somebody in that case, but likely more. The Twins won't do it.
  50. Lifetime ban for Rob Manfred.
This leaderboard is set to Chicago/GMT-06:00

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.