Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Leaderboard

  1. SarasotaBill

    Verified Member
    Points
    224
    Posts
  2. Nick Nelson

    Administrator
    Points
    7,006
    Posts
  3. amjgt

    Verified Member
    Points
    2,852
    Posts
  4. Otwins

    Verified Member
    Points
    658
    Posts

Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation on 01/08/2021 in all areas

  1. No disrespect but it's not close. 1. Maeda 2. Berrios If Berrios is hurt the Twins have no shot on winning a playoff series. If Kepler is hurt then sub in Larnach/Cave/..... Trade value: nothing is more valuable than a top starting pitcher being paid less than the market (see Rays).
  2. 5 points
    We've come to my first major disagreement with your rankings. On the open market I have absolutely no doubt in my mind that Berrios would get more in return than Kepler. If we fast forward a year when Jose's service time is cut in half and we still have 3 or 4 more years of Kep, that might change, but I can't get on board with 2 years of Jose being less valuable than (insert any number here) years of Kepler And I like Kep Also, I think there should be a little "spiff" in your rankings for the fact that the team has exclusive negotiating rights with a player while he's still in arb
  3. I went back and forth on Berrios and Kepler. They are the stable rocks of the lineup and pitching staff, and you laid out a good argument. Ultimately, this was the reasoning that steered me to put Kepler in front: He's owed $21.75 million through 2023, which might be the cost of Berrios in 2023 alone. (If they can keep him around via QO or extension.)Kepler can play a solid CF which is essential given the Buxton situation. He's the only player in the corner OF mix right now with that capability. It's a big differentiating factor. If Buxton goes down, Kepler gives them the ability to go Kirilloff-Kep-Larnach. (Or Rooker or whichever of the many good corner OF options you like.)I mean, the Twins control Kepler for his age 28, 29, and 30 seasons, for 20 million bucks total. That contract is crazy. I realize this one's a repeat.
  4. 3 points
    Hot Take Here! Get You're Hot Take! Berrios ranks 21st among pitchers with at least 150 IP between 2019-2020 in FWAR. While's he isn't an Ace, he's also among the top 30 pitchers in baseball. You don't get there by being a #4 pitcher. He's a borderline #1-2, which is exactly as he's described. WAR might be flawed, but it isn't that flawed.
  5. The Royals signed Carlos Santana also. So the Royals have gained ground. But the Twins have time and money so we should revist this article in about a month.
  6. Lindor traded to Mets

    Danchat and 2 others reacted to KirbyDome89 for a post in a topic

    3 points
    Sad. Playoff berths 4 of the last 5 years. The only season they didn't make it they won 93 games. 2 CY winners and a WS appearance during that stretch too. It's a tough optic when a team like Cleveland "can't," produce even a league average payroll to keep talent around.
  7. Chris Archer: Update

    mnfireman and one other reacted to Dodecahedron for a post in a topic

    2 points
    I have not looked closely at Archer lately, but whenever I took a deep dive look at his numbers in the past, I always came out with the impression that he's not particularly great. His high K totals skew contemporary metrics too far to the positive given his actuals. The Rays got good production out of him because that's what the Rays do. And let's face it, the only reason Twins fans spend so much time looking at Archer is because he's closer to the middle -- and is thus a reasonable target for the frugal Twins. Archer could be an good player to nab to fill out the middle-to-back of the rotation, but so could a lot of other players. I'm not sure if a team wanting a deep playoff run spends a whole lot of effort targeting Archer.
  8. 2 points
    The list looks about right to me. I might quibble a little with some of the individual positions, but the reality is there's not much difference between a guy being ranked 8 or 10. Garver is probably the toughest call on the whole list, I think. His value is higher if he's 2019 Garv. If he's 2020 Garv, he doesn't make the list at all. If he's 2018ish Garv...this is pretty close? And we just don't know who he is, if 2019 was a fluke or not. If 2020 should just be written off as a fluky, injury pandemic year. It's a really tough call. I'm excited to see Kirilloff in MLB this year.
  9. Any of the above except Bryant. Don't think he will be worth his big contract. Nice list
  10. Lindor traded to Mets

    wabene and one other reacted to Dman for a post in a topic

    2 points
    I Agree. I think the Dodgers had a pretty nice package set up for Lindor that might have made more of a difference. Even if the Mets do not resign Lindor I think they came out OK in the deal. They will definitely get a comp pick if they don't resign him and Lindor could make a huge difference for them this year. Carrasco will probably be better in NL as well. IMO Josh Wolfe is the headliner of this trade. I wanted to Twins to pick him but they chose someone else in the draft. Cleveland knows how to find pitchers and I think Wolfe will be a good one in time. Cleveland did a good job dumping salary so they should have some flexibility to fix their lineup with one year deal bargain players until their young guys step up.
  11. Lindor traded to Mets

    Danchat and one other reacted to nicksaviking for a post in a topic

    2 points
    I don't know much about the pitchers, who appear to be the Mets last two second round picks, but both infielders appear to be glove-first types. I certainly wouldn't be excited about that end of the haul if I was a Cleveland fan. They made the playoffs last year, so maybe that was their motivation, but it certainly seems like it would have been a better move to deal Lindor last winter while he still had two years of control left. In any case, I hope this deal helps Cleveland in no way whatsoever.
  12. Yes for Polanco. 2 years of control vs 4 years for Polanco. With Jeffers it depends on how they project his bat but probably given 5 years vs 2. Garver is a toss up with 3 years vs 2. The Rays have been able to compete despite a substantial revenue disadvantage. They maximize asset value in part by valuing years of control. Philly lost big in the Realmuto trade. They were still a 500 team for the two years of service they got by trading for Realmuto for Sanchez. How much better would the Philly's future look with Sanchez?
  13. 1 point
    There have been several excellent "how would you spend $x?" articles written this off-season. There is some point in the winter when the ice breaks and teams start signing players; there are often several points at which these occur, and I've often wondered how that math gets done, realizing that one would be criticized for either moving too quickly (gross overpay for Player A) or too slowly (completely missed out on Player A, you numbskull!). It is one thing to say that the Twins' payroll for 2021 should be in the $125-140M range, take the existing (probable, considering Maeda's incentives) payroll in the low 90s, and figure out a way to spend the remainder, given the estimates of value on all existing free agents, or the +/- in dollars exchanged in any trade. This year, however, presents a different set of possibilities. One can scour the team pages here and there, and come up with a list of teams that are either a)shedding payroll; or b)not going to spend any more than they have already. That limits the number of teams still in the race for the existing assets. For each of those teams, a little deeper dive can also unearth a relative number available to spend on any of the talent out there (the Twins' $30-35M figure, for instance). But what happens when you combine all that? Take the Twins, and several high-budget (or "available money") teams and pool them all. How much is available to spend, total? Then take the existing free agents, and their potential salaries, and see where that number lands you, in a.a.v. It occurs to me that we are in a market where the "available money" is far less than the "potential salaries." In that economic circumstance, it changes the dynamic of the when and where and how much in the acquisition of players. If a team can (accurately) project the available space for spending of all the competitors, and (logically or illogically) evaluates those teams' greatest needs, one can whittle down the available market for players. And somewhere in that analysis, bargains can be found. A couple of good examples exist in JT Realmuto and George Springer. Of the teams who possibly could afford a reasonable Realmuto contract, how many of them need a catcher? Of the teams who possibly could afford a reasonable Springer deal, how many need an outfielder? Carrying that further, once those players sign, and the teams who sign them have their available money evaporate, where does that leave the remaining teams with money to spend? Yes, I realize there is no hard cap in baseball (though the luxury tax and certain teams' stated desire to get under it does add some clarity), and a team who signs a Realmuto or Springer might well decide to change their budget, or go all-in. But in most cases, that won't be true. Now, we're left with a smaller number of teams, with a smaller budget, scrambling to sign the remaining free agents - and yes, the agents for these free agents can also do the math and see that there is now, hypothetically, only 75% of the available money to sign these players to "market value" contracts, and advise their clients accordingly that they are going to need to sign (now!) for 75% of what they hoped, or fall further and further behind in the dollars-to-talent available pool. This is where several teams will end up - those with relatively few dollars to spend are going to have to wait until all the big dogs have eaten before looking around for what remains available. Somewhere in between, before the scrounging occurs right up to and including spring training, there is a proper moment to strike. We aren't there yet. Once Bauer signs, the market for Odorizzi, Tanaka, Paxton, and a few others will heat up. Teams desperate (public relations-wise or otherwise) might overpay for the next available tier, but that leaves arms available that are beyond the price of the teams who are cash-strapped, and almost no competition from teams who have already filled their rosters. It makes business sense, though risky, as you are allowing other teams to snatch up the "best available" talent and contenting yourself with the best of what is left over. I don't have a perfect match for the Twins (though to me getting Sugano for 3 years ($9M/yr), Kluber for 3 years ($8M/yr), Kiki for 3 years ($5M/yr?), and then selecting the best non-Cruz DH candidate on a one-year deal in the $5-7M range, and a solid LH/RH relief tandem at $3-4M each) adds the most to the club and keeps us in the $125-$130 payroll range. Who do you think will have to come off the board before the Twins will react? What do you predict the next move will be? I'm curious to hear people's thoughts on the subject.
  14. A little caution for anyone looking at that trade site - it can be very distorted. Example: let's trade for Baez and send over Smeltzer, Astudillo, and Gordon. This is big overpay by the Twins, but will the Cubs really consider this offer? Would you? The site may be worth a look but it is pretty bogus overall.
  15. “Even with a poor 2020 season, Báez has an extremely favorable outlook. He isn’t as good as Lindor but also costs nearly $10 million less. His price in a trade would likely require one of the Twins’ top five prospects or a slew in the 6-15 range.” https://www.baseballtradevalues.com/teams/457/ Baseball trade values has Baez median value at 11.7. Therefore a package of Cavaco (7.6) and Enlow (4.1) would be about right.
  16. Cleveland sure didn't demand much.
  17. Jake Odorizzi, What's going on w/ him?

    wabene reacted to mnfireman for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Odorizzi's 2nd half wasn't as bad as you might think. Take out the 4 IP, 9 ER clunker against the Yankees and he was 5-2 with a 2.98 ERA. He was actually very good in Aug/Sep, posting a 3.04 ERA with 65 K's in 50.1 innings. That being said, I don't know if he worth $13+ MM a season at this stage of his career.
  18. 1 point
    This list is so much fun Nick. Thank you. My only substantial point of disagreement, which has been pointed out by many others already, is the ranking of Arraez. You seem so low on him, it's borderline shocking. He is projected to have the 2nd most WAR on the roster in 2021 by ZiPS. Steamer has him as the best two bagger in the AL per 600PAs. Add in that Arraez is essentially the same age as Jeffers and Larnach, only a half year older than Kirilloff, under team control for five more years, vs six with those guys, and I feel like you have a more valuable asset than either Jeffers or Larnach, one that is much closer to Kirilloff. Just my two cents. Thanks again Nick. Keep doing the things. Appreciate you.
  19. 2021 Off-Season Thread

    DocBauer reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Early offseason plan: OC: I’m not going to pretend to know coaching talent in the NFL/college. In the Zimmer era, we’ve been the most successful with older, former HC types running the offense. Norv had one decent year, Shurmur went on to be a HC, Stefanski grew into a HC candidate under the guidance of Gary Kubiak. So, while the thought of going with the trendy young offensive mind is intriguing, maybe it’s better to go with a more established name. I would love to have someone who’s been successful as an OL coach so we can finally start developing more than 1 player every decade. Kirk Cousins: I would try like hell to trade him within the first 3 days of the new league year. Do I think he will be traded in real life? Sadly, no. And that’s going to be a huge burden in 2022. Doesn’t mean I wouldn’t try, and I would look for teams that were similar to us when we signed Kirk in 2018. Good defense, solid running game, just missing a QB... like NYG, SF, WAS. Also, teams like PIT, NO and IND who have old QBs bound to retire, and drafting too late to get one of the top QBs. Cuts/restructures: Some tough decisions will need to be made here. Reiff makes the most sense to outright cut, but I am secretly hoping for a restructure/extension. Barr needs to restructure. I think it’s fair to ask Harry the Hitman to restructure. Rudolph and Stephen will most likely be outright releases. Free agency: I’d like to find veteran talent to fill IOL, 3T, CB, WR, and EDGE. Obviously we won’t have a lot of money to work with, so they’ll have to be relative bargains. 3T is pretty weak outside of Leonard Williams. I think with the right combo of old veterans on 1 year deals and other bargains we could head into the draft sitting okay. My targets: Austin Reiter - C Kansas City - better pass blocker than run blocker. Which is desperately needed here. Melvin Ingram- EDGE LAC - A solid veteran to pair with Hunter Matt Feiler - OT Pittsburgh - Swing player for the OL who’s started at RT and LG for Pittsburgh. Mack Alexander - CB - should be extremely cheap this winter. Ndamukong Suh - 3T Tampa - He’s the only intriguing option at our price range. 34 years old. Draft: Since free agency doesn’t offer much in IDL help, I think this is where we need to focus our efforts. Not necessarily with 14 overall, but with our multiple 3rd/4th/6th round picks. As of now, I think the Vikes end up trading back from 14 overall to recoup the lost 2nd round pick and acquire other draft capital along the way.
  20. Story's stats are much better at Coors than away, this needs to be considered but Story is a stud. Baez has a great bat too, last year shouldn't be considered. Baez there's no doubt about his health, if the Twins are sure there won't be any problems w/ Simmons's ankles, I'm fine w/ Simmons also. But I prefer Baez's bat. I also like that Baez is Berrios's brother in law (I`d love the camaraderie between them) maybe you could to talk them both about extensions
  21. My friend had a multi level marketing opportunity that might interest them. There’s also this Nigerian prince that keeps emailing me.....
  22. 1 point
    Agree with the list, but I absolutely hate this sentiment that Alex Kiriloff wont be up until May and were ok with it. If he's the best option in a playoff elimination game, than he's the best option to win games in April. If we want him around in 2027 than pay him what he'll be worth.
  23. Hard to say how I feel about this -- I'm "surprised not surprised" I suppose, which is an odd thing to say. I would not count Cleveland out just yet. The Twins had a lot of turnover in the 00s, but kept things rolling due to a good culture. Cleveland could continue to be good. We also don't yet know what the Twins will do before 2021. They may make similar moves.
  24. Twins DH

    lecroy24fan reacted to Dodecahedron for a post in a topic

    1 point
    We are all sick of it. But this is usually the right take.
  25. 2021 Off-Season Thread

    DocBauer reacted to nicksaviking for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Hasn't it been a do-or-die year for this club each of the past six years? But Spielman has utilized Rob Brzezinski's magical skills of deferment to annually push back the date they need to pay the piper? If anything this ability to delay the inevitable is pretty impressive. However, if they are this good at managing the cap even when there appears little hope of getting anything done, I have to think that if they took one year to reset and wipe the slate clean of albatross contracts, this skill could possibly be utilized for dynasty building moves a year or two from now.
  26. Lindor traded to Mets

    Otwins reacted to MMMordabito for a post in a topic

    1 point
    I'll miss the smiling, eccentric Lindor, but I won't miss the clutch dingers he seems to hit against the Twins. It seemed like every series with the Indians he always did something to crush Twins fans.
  27. I cannot make the purchase - it looks like they are keeping their red ink pen!
  28. Lindor traded to Mets

    Dman reacted to Doctor Gast for a post in a topic

    1 point
    The more I look at this deal the more I think the CLE didn't do so bad. I believe 1 of the 1st thing Cohen did was to try to obtain Lindor. It took him this long to finalize it because CLE wanted Wolfe & NYM maybe didn't want to give him up. CLE does have a great eye for pitchers, any pitcher that they're interested in has to be good
  29. I agree with not trading Larnach. Somebody will get hurt in the outfield and he'll reward that decision and then he'll rise up these rankings big time. Fitting all of our outfielders into a lineup is a good problem to have. Starting pitching is what we really need but I hope we don't trade Larnach or Kirilloff to get it.
  30. 1 point
    Nettles immediately hit 26 and 28 home runs for Cleveland in the following two seasons. He was still playing when the Twins won the world series in 87. He would have solidified 3B for years. Not to mention after Tiant was released he went on to have 3 20 win seasons plus many double digit win seasons.
  31. Lindor traded to Mets

    railmarshalljon reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Not spend money would be my guess, at least not more than 50-60 million total, I'd guess.
  32. Ridiculous? I mean I get that 2020 was ugly, but he's still a 30-year-old catcher with an .824 OPS and good defense. The uncertainties around both Garver and Jeffers (the small-sample caveats of 2020 work both ways with those two) led me to place them both in the top 10, and right next to each other. Catcher is such a crucial position and it's super vital that at least one of these guys clicks. I'd rank either one higher if not for the presence of the other.
  33. Good points. Believe me you're preaching to the choir in some ways. I have a hard time separating the idea of Buxton from what he has actually been. In terms of pure potential, absolutely he's in the top 3, but the reality is that he's got a .289 career OBP, .719 OPS, and has averaged 72 games played/season. My dream scenario for 2021 is that he finally stays healthy, produces like the MVP-caliber player he is, signs a long-term contract, and vaults back to the top of these rankings. Unfortunately, based on all past evidence, it's a big stretch.
  34. 1 point
    Won't disagree that Kirilloff and Larnach have ceilings equal to Kepler, at least their bats. I do believe, however, that Kepler's bat has another level yet to be seen. But most player's also must play a defensive position and it is in the field where Kepler's value far exceeds either Kirilloff or Larnach.
  35. So final 5 will be? (not in any order) Lewis Kirilloff Berrios Maeda Rogers
  36. Yeah, I don't get the love for Kepler. He was great in 2019, but his bat has consistently been middling the other 4 years he's played. His deal is pretty cheap, but he's starting to get more expensive. Kiriloff and Larnach have similar ceilings to him, and will be much cheaper. Also, Larnach is #10 and Kiriloff is in the top 5? Methinks they're very close as prospects and should be closer together in the rankings. Larnach's had the better minor league track record, but Kiriloff is younger (and younger compared to the competition throughout the minors).
  37. 1 point
    Twins should not trade Larnach. I really think he's the Twins RF of the future. Kepler is a career .237 hitter with a career OPS of .763. Those are not extraordinary numbers and I think Larnach will be able to match and even surpass those numbers after a year or two in the MLB. Give Kepler one more year in RF to potentially boost his trade value after a terrible 2020 and then shop him.
  38. Nowhere near bold enough. How about this: Tony LaRussa coaches Chisox hitters to hit the other way, shredding defenses employing the shift. Chisox starters are given the green light to go longer than 5 innings. This and a slew of other "old school" approaches see the White Sox go 35-5 out of the gate. Stunned sabermetricians are left reeling. Michael Lewis announces he will follow up on his book Moneyball with a book on the enduring wisdoms of Casey Stengel, Leo Durocher, and Tom Kelly, while advocating the brilliance of slide rules in making in-game calculations. Slide rule sales explode, and they become the hip new app on campuses across the country. The Twins FO opts for boldness in response, and hires Bruce Bochy out of retirement, giving him free rein to run the team. Bochy leads the Twins to 105 wins, tying the White Sox for the best record in MLB. Sportswriters across the nation proclaim the Twins/Chisox rivalry the greatest the game has seen. Network ratings for their games exceed anything elitists in the northeast have seen for franchises playing in the Bronx and Boston. The networks bid high to nationally televise games in the AL Central, and fans across the country return to baseball, glad to no longer have NYY/Bosox games telecast constantly. And then, for real boldness, in the playoffs, the Twins ... Oh, perhaps best not to get carried away.
  39. Twins DH

    DocBauer reacted to goulik for a post in a topic

    1 point
    So looking at the trade simulator, Sano has a Negative trade value so trading him is probably not going to get you what you think it will and also probably means many of us (including me) value him more highly than most of the baseball world.
  40. Indians no more

    Cap'n Piranha reacted to KirbyDome89 for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Eh they're different avenues of arriving at the same destination; using slurs as a mascot. My objection all along has been consistency. It's a can of worms trying to sort out who is allowed to weigh in on which words, and what phrases are acceptable for use by which groups.
  41. Twins DH

    wabene reacted to Physics Guy for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Nelson Cruz played 120 games in 2019 and isn't getting younger. Maybe he plays 130, but he needs days off as well. Plenty of room to get Donaldson some games there as well.
  42. Twins DH

    wabene reacted to Shaitan for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Too many good players is never a problem. I don't believe in logjams. Even in the rare case where a prospect is a sure thing, plans wills will suddenly change. See Mauer's rookie season...all 20 AB of it. Make the prospects force their way onto the roster; don't hand it to them. That said, this roster is built in a way that Cruz is not essential. They'd get by without him. But they'd be better with him.
  43. Twins DH

    wabene reacted to Physics Guy for a post in a topic

    1 point
    I don't think this is an outrageous idea. I would not move Sano to DH full-time yet. He was passable/average at 1B in his first season. Keep players in the field as long as you can. While I love having Cruz in the 3 spot in the order, I think rotating players through the DH spot to keep the healthy would be a wise option as well. Donaldson is still a stellar 3B, but putting him at DH every 4 days might help keep him in the lineup. Also, using a rotation of Kirilloff, Rooker and Cave at DH wouldn't be horrible either. We have options and aren't over a barrel in the Cruz negotiations. If he insists on more than $15M or two years it might be wise to move on.
  44. Twins DH

    wabene reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic

    1 point
    There's little concern about a logjam now that Rosario is gone. That's one of three prospects for LF and there's a good chance the Twins have to cycle through them all to find a good fit. I'm in favor of bringing back Cruz but only on a one year contract or a one + option contract, perhaps with a healthy $1-2m buyout in 2022.
This leaderboard is set to Chicago/GMT-06:00

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.