Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Leaderboard

  1. Mike Sixel

    Old-Timey Member
    Points
    36,790
    Posts
  2. Vanimal46

    Old-Timey Member
    Points
    17,338
    Posts
  3. Otto von Ballpark

    Community Leader
    Points
    20,620
    Posts
  4. Steve Lein

    Twins Daily Contributor
    Points
    2,751
    Posts

Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation on 10/22/2019 in all areas

  1. 14 points
    I have no idea what Royce Lewis is like defensively. However... if he can play SS, 3B and CF. By all means let him play all 3 positions. There is extreme value in that ability. Trying to shove him into one spot is a mistake. Once Royce establishes himself as ready and becomes the top call up option. When Royce gets called up, it will be due to an issue on the 25 man (injury or performance related). We don’t know where that injury or performance related issue will spring up. Could be OF, could be 3B, could be SS. His ability to play all of those positions opens up more doors for him to come through. Leave him at one position like SS. He is waiting for one specific door to open and Polanco may not get hurt. It then forces Lewis back to the minors if when Polanco returns. If the injury happens in CF. This forces the club to call up a lesser player because Lewis is a SS only. Let him play all 3 positions and we will see him sooner. Leave him at one position and it will take a specific set of circumstances to get him up to the majors.
  2. 10 points
    The better question is his offensive future... He still has a ways to go with the bat before thinking about what position he plays in the majors. Also, positional flexibility is good for anyone.
  3. I think Kepler's contract puts him over the top as a more valuable trade asset. Which would I want to hang on to? Both! If forced to choose I guess I would choose Kepler due to Buxton's injury history, but Buxton has the higher ceiling.
  4. 8 points
    "It’s also not like there is a better shortstop prospect ahead of him on his AFL roster. Tampa’s Vidal Brujan has played the majority of the time at short and his own organization rarely uses him at that position (377 2/3 innings over five seasons)." There's not a higher overall rated SS prospect on the roster (Lewis is probably the 2nd highest rated prospect in the league behind Jo Adell), but as for defensive considerations I'll answer these statements with one of my comments from last weeks AFL report: "There's been reports that the Twins actually liked that there were other SS prospects on the team in Arizona, so they would have to put him elsewhere to get at-bats. Those other shortstops are pretty good ones too: Geraldo Perdomo, Jose Devers, and also Vidal Brujan and all three are easily better defenders than Lewis at SS at this point in time. The Twins obviously want him to work at multiple positions so that when he's ready, they have options on where to put him. I think Lewis still has a lot of work to do if he wants to play SS in the majors —and that's not in any way a knock on him. He's incredibly young and you don't develop a major league SS in two years if he wasn't already a fielding wizard at the position. You also have to consider that those fielding wizards usually don't carry a bat like Lewis potentially does. Jorge Polanco was the same way, his bat was way ahead of his fielding and he didn't become even an average-ish guy at the position until last season, essentially his third year in the majors at 24 years of age. I think Lewis has excelled at 3B in the Fall League however, and he can run down fly balls in the outfield too. He's getting more run at 2B the last few weeks too, but I don't see him ending up on that side of the infield."
  5. 8 points
    Great topic, Cody. I agree with those above who favor his playing all three positions next year which will enable him to be called up at where he is needed....short, third, left or center. Speaking of his success in the AFL, have you seen what Raley has done of late? After a horrible start to his AFL season, he has hit homers in each of his last three games with his average up to .250.
  6. 7 points
    He's got a good arm, but it's an outfield arm at this point. What I mean by that is he's a bit "long" in his motion to get to that arm strength. Watched quite a few games of his this year and can recall a few plays where he didn't get to a ground ball quick enough, then his release wasn't fast enough to get the ball there on time to beat the runner with his arm. While I wouldn't call the plays I'm recalling 'routine' necessarily, I'd also expect a SS to make them. But again, these are things he's going to improve. I have no doubt he can be better than Polanco there eventually if that's the path they go down.
  7. Arraez is a nice counterbalance to today's swing for the fences or strikeout culture. Arraez is a professional hitter who is a treat to watch. His ABs are reminiscent of a simpler time when working the count, drawing a BB, and playing strategically were valued. The way he moves/struts around the batter's box on a close take is entertaining as well.
  8. 7 points
    Yes, and also the Twins are happy to get him ABs at 3B and CF... No intent to play him at SS, but when he gets to spring training, he'll be at SS.
  9. 6 points
    Link: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/10/22/sports/baseball/baseball-popularity-world-series.html
  10. Astros assistant GM outburst

    bighat and 5 others reacted to h2oface for a post in a topic

    6 points
    Glass houses. I guess the Twins (and most teams) just prefer to look the other way on PED violations of several players (including darling Nelson Cruz), allegations from a credible female reporter, and Puckett behavior, to name a few right off the top of my head. It certainly is not a shining moment, but it also is not representative of an entire organization, it's goals and its standards, nor should it be. Perspective. One amped up person that has torpedoed his own life should not be lauded as organizational.
  11. In the OP, there was mention of Lewis' fielding percentage compared to Polanco's this year with the Twins. That should be regarded with a grain of salt, if that. Major league stadiums, with their manicured infields and excellent lighting (and kind official scorers) make that comparison near meaningless. That there are scouting reports showing that Lewis has issues as a defensive shortstop would be meaningful, but what are the issues? Does he have the necessary range and arm strength? Can he make a quick release throw? Steve Lein has pointed out that Lewis isn't that quick with his release. I would think that is a problem that can be corrected. I think it is good for Lewis to have work in at third base and the outfield. Year to year conventional wisdom changes on players. Currently, there is discussion about the long-term futures of both Buxton (due to injuries) and Sanó (due to defensive liability). Perhaps both will play their way through those questions, but perhaps these two positions may be where Lewis will get a chance (if he is ready to hit in the majors). Manny Machado was a shortstop who took a third base vacancy to get to the majors and he's played 80% of his innings at third base through eight seasons. Regardless, Royce will need to carry his good hitting from the AFL next season to even be in consideration for a promotion to Minnesota.
  12. 6 points
    This reminds of the supposed book on Polanco: he couldn't play SS either. While Polanco struggled in the field, especially late in the season, he was the AL representative at the position. I hope the Twins give the same opportunity for Lewis to stick at short as they did Polanco.
  13. 5 points
    If they parted ways with Cron, they would then need a first baseman too. I think it’s more than fair to bring back Cron while also giving Sano some time at first and ease in a young guy later in the season if warranted (Rooker or Kirilloff)
  14. 5 points
    FYI, in case it wasn't clear from the thread title, I didn't post this to discuss Osuna himself. I posted this to discuss the Astros assistant GM. We all have different opinions, but I think we can all agree that employing players around these circumstances is a pretty complicated situation. What isn't complicated, though, is no tolerance for front office personnel taunting reporters in this fashion.
  15. 5 points
    I'd keep him at SS for the future, but sprinkle in some games at 3B and in the OF to keep him fresh with it. The more position flexibility a player can have the better. I do think that he makes his MLB debut as a 3B, unless Polanco is injured.
  16. Such versatility is an assett for Royce and a number of Twins. Good to see as it gives us much flexibility.
  17. Luis is the prototypical #2 hitter. Carew like. Puts the ball in play, moves the runner over. 2b is his spot to lose.
  18. Astros assistant GM outburst

    Vanimal46 and 3 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic

    4 points
    the Astros have a habit of not doing well with the media....and their initial statement that the report was fake news was a deplorable lie.
  19. Astros assistant GM outburst

    DocBauer and 3 others reacted to David HK for a post in a topic

    4 points
    I would agree with your premise, that you can't paint a whole organization with the brush of one idiot, if not for the Astros coming out with that lame, lying, non-apology covering for that amped-up person, which was easily debunked by those who were there, and then the perp's own non-apology after that. (The same old, lame old, "sorry if I was misinterpreted, blah blah blah...) How could an organization who walks what they talk do something like that in the first place? That guy's actions, according to those who were there, went way beyond 'exuberance;' it was intentional, targeted bullying of a group of reporters who happened to be standing together, who also happened to be women. Most if not all of us have been in places where our exuberance at some victory leads us to carry it over the line at times. But there's a difference between shouting and acting the fool, and targeting people with taunts about violent behavior. The fact that he did so not once, but repeated his taunts a half-dozen times is beyond 'exuberance.' Then, for him and his team to come out with such despicable statements in the aftermath- well, it's like Watergate; the cover-up becomes worse than the crime. The Astros rolled the dice, and got damaged goods (albeit a lights-out talented player) at a bargain price, thinking they could manage the backlash if or when it came. There probably would have been mention of it during the broadcasts, but thanks to Brandon Taubman, Osuna himself is now under a big spotlight, and so is his team. Thanks a lot, Brandon. Sidebar- if ever there was a guy who needed a knuckle sandwich, right there on the spot, it's this guy, in spades.
  20. CJ Cron Has Thumb Surgery

    Twins33 and 3 others reacted to Seth Stohs for a post in a topic

    4 points
    It shouldn't change people's minds. He was nearly an all-star caliber guy pretty much right up until the injury and then he faltered. He had the 2 IL stints and the power was sapped and we knew that it was almost completely thumb related. So, whatever decision they should have made in late June is probably what they should do now... unless something else has changed in your mind... (like moving Sano to 1B or deciding kirilloff or rooker is ready for Opening Day, etc.
  21. Astros assistant GM outburst

    bighat and 3 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic

    4 points
    To the poster that said fans don't care if this is true about their own team, that's just not true of all fans, thank you very much. Have a great day!
  22. Astros assistant GM outburst

    David HK and 3 others reacted to Otto von Ballpark for a post in a topic

    4 points
    The Astros haven't covered themselves in glory here either. Their first statement alleged the SI article was a "fabrication" when it appears the Astros own excuse for Taubman was the actual fabrication: https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/2019/10/22/astros-respond-sports-illustrated-report-alleging-executives-clubhouse-blowup/ I suspect Taubman is not alone in his views and judgments in the Houston front office, and that's something I don't want to emulate in Minnesota (even if it's a pro sports reality that we'll occasionally have to deal with players in situations like Osuna's).
  23. 4 points
    That's encouraging. Also was curious about the participation in youth baseball compared to football, and found this: http://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/27448703/youth-baseball-participation-rise "Between 2013 and 2018, the number of U.S. kids playing baseball and softball combined increased by nearly 3 million...The number of participants in youth football -- including tackle, touch and flag -- was down by nearly 1.7 million over the same stretch, and soccer participation dropped by nearly 900,000." Good news for the future of baseball.
  24. 4 points
    Thanks for sharing! I wish the NY Times went a little bit deeper in regards to local TV ratings. By that, I mean what demographic watches baseball the most? IIRC from past articles, the largest demographic that watches baseball is 50+ years old. I forget how localized games are on TV... We've had discussions before about trying to market MLB stars better than they do. It's alarming in the article that only 43% of Americans have heard of Mike Trout. Maybe MLB should consider not relying so much on the local TV model and broadcast more national TV games to show off their young stars. What baseball has over other sports as a fan is not being required to watch at full attention all the time. On numerous occasions the game is on my TV or the radio as background noise while I do other things in the house. It's comforting to know on a random Wednesday night in the summer when nothing else is worth watching on TV you can turn on a baseball game. And, of course, the beauty of this sport is sifting through the massive amount of data available at our finger tips. Stats have always been the back bone of the sport, and now more than ever we have so many ways to analyze the stats.
  25. 4 points
    It probably depends on the needs of the team we're trading with. If they are a contender who envisions missing the pennant race due to a lack of an adequate center fielder, then they'd pay more to get Kepler since he carries a lower risk of their having to revert to a backup. If they already have an adequate centerfielder (someone like Kepler) but want to go for the brass ring, they'd probably pay more for Buxton. For a rebuilding team, the extra control probably tilts toward Kepler again. Buxton and Kepler really are an ideal combo, so I'm not eager to deal either. Max supplements and complements Byron so well.
  26. He could play in every era. I loved watching him play. He reminded me of both Carew and Red Schoendienst.
  27. Twins were already set up with a young core and several high end minor leaguers, and then Luis comes along and looks like he will be a key piece for several years to come. That’s a huge windfall. His power should only go up from here (though Altuve-like would be a reach) and hopefully he can make some improvements at second base to turn into an all-star. He will also allow the Twins to be patient with Royce and potentially move him to CF, depending on Buxton’s injury status and willingness to resign in a few years
  28. 4 points
    I am NOT saying no to Syndergard at all. And any deal for him could hurt. But in the best deals, there is hurt and everyone wins. You don't get something for nothing. I don't hate the idea of trading for Syndergard. But I think a lot of people are obsessed with "stuff" vs production. Despite his highest IP TOTAL in his career...only topping 180IP for the 2nd time...he is coming off the worst season of his career. The potential is there, to be sure. But any trade for him is still banking on potential and not some "sure" bet.
  29. CJ Cron Has Thumb Surgery

    diehardtwinsfan and 2 others reacted to Seth Stohs for a post in a topic

    3 points
    Per his Instagram (via Doogie Wolfson), CJ Cron had successful thumb surgery... Now on to rehab. Certainly wish him well.
  30. 3 points
    We agree here, just think you're getting lost in the details. You started by responding to my comment that I think he could be better than Polanco eventually, so why waste his development time at SS. I wasn't at any point saying you do what they're doing with him in the AFL moving forward. You definitely focus on SS. You are correct in saying this is the low-risk path and that transitioning from SS to elsewhere is easier. All I'm saying is that this venture and experience in the AFL helps open that door when it gets to the point where you need to play him somewhere, but Polanco is still the (better) guy at SS. I definitely think this is a possibility, and the more likely scenario at this point. Maybe you play him at a different position a few times a month, but certainly not a scenario where you siphon significant development time.
  31. CJ Cron Has Thumb Surgery

    wabene and 2 others reacted to bird for a post in a topic

    3 points
    Yeah, I think I'd just have an honest, short conversation with Cron's agent, tell him we like him, he was a great teammate, and we want him back on a one-year deal. However, anything higher than $6M is a dealbreaker. Our hope is that Kirilloff or Rooker can not be held back any longer, maybe not even for all of the 2020 season. Your decision. The meter's running.
  32. Astros assistant GM outburst

    BenB and 2 others reacted to Craig Arko for a post in a topic

    3 points
    All? Nah, there are plenty of other things that override sports for that. But we all are, each in our own way. At times, anyway.
  33. 3 points
    I think Rosario, plus perhaps an add in, can return a pitcher in a similar situation. Talent, but warts, with both teams believing there's more in there, and it can be realized. Perhaps with both teams' immediate needs matchup up. Cleveland dealt a top line starter at the deadline, for example. The trick, of course, is to be the one on the right side of that deal, so you don't end up sending off Hicks for a AAAA catcher.
  34. Astros assistant GM outburst

    Rigby and 2 others reacted to Cap'n Piranha for a post in a topic

    3 points
    Yes, I'm definitely glad the Twins don't have any players on their roster who have been accused of wrongdoing, only for the accuser to provide no evidence of the alleged incident. How dare the Astros employ someone who has had no legal judgments against them--they should definitely work off the guilty until proven innocent method. As for the AGM's comments, sounds like a guy lacking tact to a nearly unbelievable level, to the point of looking to browbeat people for no good reason. That guy should be required to attend sensitivity training and then volunteer a large amount of hours at a shelter for victims of domestic violence, or find a different place of employment.
  35. 3 points
    You misunderstand slightly. I would venture Lewis' bat/other abilities get him to the majors before he's a better shortstop than Polanco, if that does happen. You're not going to leave Lewis in the minors for that reason at that point, you're going to bring him up to play somewhere.
  36. That poster was me and you don't need to keep reverting back to it. The Nationals and Astros targeted very talented pitchers, and crazy enough, talented pitchers cost money. Instead of continuing to discuss what the Twins CAN'T do, what would you recommend that they do? There are 4 open positions in the rotation right now.
  37. 3 points
    Who are the best two prospects we have in the minors? I would say Lewis and Kirilloff, as far as position players are concerned. Kirilloff plays first bast, left field and right field. Lewis played short most of the summer and third, center and a bit of second in the AFL. Continue playing both players at those positions and you have 7 of the 9 defensive positions covered. Either could come up in any of THEIR positions to fill in for an injury. Eventually they could come up to start in one of THEIR positions or to be a rotational starter, much like Gonzalez. After all, I recall wondering how Gonzalez was going to find playing time as we sat here late last March. Haven't looked at the stats, but I am guessing he started most of the days he was healthy. Think I will generate a new baseball term.........Rotational Starter!
  38. How many of those six pitchers were drafted and developed by their current team? One. And that guy was a #1, and might as well be a FA signing because of the contract he's on. Trades played a major role in getting those pitchers to their current (WS) teams. And here's the thing...I doubt ANYone, from fans to the GMs in question, regret those trades. The Twins can, and should, play in every avenue of talent acquisition, including trading top prospects when it makes sense. Not doing so is intentionally bringing a knife to a gun fight.
  39. Has someone out there not proven themselves wrong before?
  40. 3 points
    Echoing a few other thoughts. 1] Error numbers for a 19yo milb SS are pretty meaningless. It's still about potential at this point, and further development of that potential. 2] Totally agree he should keep playing all over, including some time at 2B, to increase his versatility not only for a future home at some point, but to increase his initial call up value. And maybe he ends up being a daily player at a couple spots. Who knows? 3] Having a problem of how to fit all of your talent on the field at once is a nice problem to have. At this point, where Lewis ultimately ends up really shouldn't matter.
  41. 3 points
    Can someone explain why the twins should trade important pieces off the MLB roster now that they’re firmly in contention? What other contending team has done this? I know it’s the off-season and we need stuff to talk about, but I legitimately don’t understand the reasoning behind all these replace/move/trade so and so threads.
  42. 3 points
    I think Kepler's trade value is higher in part because of his relative versatility on defense. He plays a better than average CF along with really solid defense in RF. For a team looking to add an outfielder, Kepler could play all 3 positions well. Due to the excellence of Byron Buxton in CF, there is no way he gets moved out of that position for a corner spot for the foreseeable future, which could block the path of a prospect to the big leagues temporarily (good problem to have, certainly, but not one you have with Kepler). Kepler also has a team-friendly contract for a known duration of time, which is valuable. Once Buxton gets an extension, the comparison between him and Kepler will become more clear, but I think the certainty of Kepler's contract gives him added value.
  43. I definitely see Carew, Wade Boggs, and Gwynn in Arraez. I expect him to get better every year until he becomes a perrenial league batting title contender. I don't see competition from Gordon any longer and expect him to be traded. I hope he develops more power as he may be our best option at 3B, though I like him anywhere. Nice to see how a prospect who was not a top ten has become a major contributor
  44. 3 points
    Versatility is great, but an above average SS or catcher doesn’t get moved around. This is especially true if they possess starter quality offensive skills. A well below average offensive player needs defensive versatility to stick in the majors. Unless Lewis shows himself to be below average as a SS without reasonable expectation for improvement, I would give him all the reps possible there. The other exception is the appearance of a better SS option. As of now that is not the case or likely in the foreseeable future. Another possibility for improvement of the infield defense is to greatly upgrade the third base defense to help cover some range and arm concerns with Polanco. If that is the plan I can get behind a Lewis move to third.
  45. Makes you wonder how staffs ever had a 4-man rotation with starters possibly starting 35- 40 games, completing almost half of them and throwing 250-300 innings. Must have been the beer.
  46. Actually, the Samardzija trade worked out pretty well for Oakland. They obviously didn't advance in the 2014 playoffs because, well, they're Oakland, but Samardzija had another year of control. So they flipped him for a great return from the White Sox (Semien, Bassitt, etc.), and after a hot start, Russell has fizzled out for the Cubs. Ideally you'd like a pitcher better than Samardzija and a deeper playoff run to show for it, but this isn't necessarily a bad trade for a team in the Twins position.
  47. Do the Twins currently have another almost-ready third baseman in their minor league system? My bet is Sano goes to first and Lewis goes to third. He's got the quickness, the arm and the bat to hold down the hot corner.
  48. 3 points
    I think Royce can stick at SS because of the advances in defensive positioning, but do wonder if he would be better utilized in CF (not better than Buxton, but if we lose Buxton it may be best for the team to have Royce in CF). ...and Jeter is not really a good example to go by to give anyone hope Royce can turn out to be great defensively at SS. Probably the opposite of a good example.
  49. 1) it's a bit of a nitpic, but the Yankees didn't get to the WS in 2018. Overall, I think the point is, having dominant starting pitching is a big advantage. Houston, Washington, and others have recognized that, and found a way to acquire it. Ideally, you'd have 5 dominant starters all pre arb and making peanuts, all drafted and developed. Since that's a tall order, other successful teams have done what's necessary to acquire it, be that trades, or free agent signings, including FAs at the very top of the food chain. It's pretty unreasonable to think you can have the top players, but never have to pay for them in prospect cost or salary. That seems to me the overall point. And there is no reason the Twins CAN'T do all of that.
  50. Ah, yes, there are many examples of teams trying to buy a good team failing, just as you can look at the Pirates, Reds, and many other teams that have spent decade(s) trying to only build from within and failing. It's not the strategy, it's the execution of the strategy, imo. Teams can be built many ways, but it's player development, scouting, luck, and a willingness to be aggressive when you are a real contender, that seem to be the keys to getting to the playoffs and winning.
This leaderboard is set to Chicago/GMT-06:00

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.