I've responded in snippets, but I just wanted to summarize my position of disappointment on the Darvish situation. I've seen our offer characterized as "serious", "competitive", and even that we were basically one of two finalists for his services. Insofar as our offer was possibly about ~80% of the winning offer (roughly accounting for the value of the opt out clause), it was serious/competitive, but that greatly overstates our chances. For Darvish to actually sign with us for that figure, the following conditions would have ALL needed to be met: Darvish would have had to change his mind. He'd been sitting on similar offers for 3 weeks, and probably would have been sitting on them since December if he had given any real indications of being willing to settle for 5/110. (Changing his mind like this could attract more suitors too.) Darvish would have had to NOT change his mind too much -- if he can't get 6 years or even 5 years with a preferred destination, he could have decided a one-year deal would be acceptable, in which case he'd have a lot more potential suitors. The Cubs or another preferred destination could not already be among the ~5 comparable offers. The Cubs or another preferred destination would have had to decline or not be allowed the opportunity to match or beat the offer. And even then, our offer still would have been only 1 of ~5 comparable offers. Assuming 5 and equal weighting (which is probably generous to the Twins), that would still only be a 20% chance of landing him, and remember that's only after the first 4 conditions are already satisfied.All told, despite our "serious"/"competitive" offer, we had, what, a 5% chance of landing him at the end? Maybe 10%? We can debate around the margins, but it wasn't good. Better than what was projected for us at the beginning of the offseason, but not meaningfully so. Still a very long longshot. However, if we had simply put forth the Twins Daily projected contract of 5/135, or ZiPS' 6/156, or one of many others projected by analysts, we quite likely would have upped those odds to 50% or greater. At the very least, that would have put *real* pressure on not only the Cubs, but also Darvish, his agent, and the MLBPA as a whole, who can't afford to turn down bigger contract offers in this climate of alleged collusion. To me, it's the difference between keeping a game close in the early innings, versus keeping it close into the late innings. Or keeping a series close early, versus keeping it close late. (Like all of those postseason Twins-Yankees matchups...) We kept it close early, but that doesn't comfort me much. We had a real opportunity to keep it close late, and we *chose* not to, far more than we were defeated in competition or held back by factors outside of our control. I know that proposed deal seems rich to a lot of people, but getting the top FA to come to a mid-market team, without having to blow away the projected market offer, was a rare opportunity that may never come along again. (By comparison, for Arizona to land Greinke, they had to overshoot MLBTR's projection by $38 mil in present-day value, or $50 mil before discounting deferrals.) That the top FA fit our greatest positional need, and we project to have an otherwise competitive squad, made it all the more significant. I've repeated the phrase "a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush" a lot lately, but it really does apply here. Not that the risk of ~$25 mil in potential annual dead payroll 5-6 years down the line isn't a concern, but to me, the risk is far greater to pass on this rare opportunity, in the present time when more facts are known and we have more confidence in near-term projections, including those of Darvish, our prospects, the rest of our roster, the rosters of our competition, and available comparable alternatives (or lack thereof). Sorry for the wall of text, but I hope this gets my position across clearly. (edited to correct spacing)