Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Leaderboard

  1. Mike Sixel

    Old-Timey Member
    Points
    36,790
    Posts
  2. Otto von Ballpark

    Community Leader
    Points
    20,620
    Posts
  3. jimmer

    Verified Member
    Points
    10,027
    Posts
  4. nicksaviking

    Community Moderator
    Points
    18,707
    Posts

Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation on 02/12/2018 in all areas

  1. 10 points
    He's a starter, and a decent one at that, I think he'll cost more than expected. But I also don't think taking Houston's number six starter and making him the Twins number two starter is a great way to surpass Houston.
  2. Am I the only one who has a hard time believing that anyone in the Twins organization would say the above in an official capacity?
  3. 8 points
    Clayton Kershaw or GTFO.
  4. Do we think they're going to surpass Houston's rotation? Cuz they aren't, even with Archer. I just think that McHugh makes the Twins better.
  5. Twins make offer for Chris Archer

    gagu and 6 others reacted to jimmer for a post in a topic

    7 points
    Over the last four seasons, and while pitching against usually extremely tough offenses in the AL East, Archer ranks 5th for starters in the AL in fWAR. Over the last THREE seasons, he ranks 3RD in the AL in fWAR. 3RD. He has blemishes but you have to look hard. I think some people's idea of Ace might be a biiiit too high.
  6. 7 points
    You have to get to game 163 first. Who knows, Darvish might be hurt by then?? Rotation depth is always a concern, Lynn, Cobb, even Garcia makes the Twins better. Also it's possible that another good year and some progression Berrios becomes that guy who can take on Sale etc.... The Twins might already have that guy, but if they finish 72 - 90 then they will never know. But I say keep the prospects, especially the ones that are close, like Gonsalves, Romero, etc.... Because they could be the next wave of top starters, or when they are 10 games over .500 in August and need to make that trade to put them over the top, that's when you play those chips. Until then get Lynn, Cobb, etc... Someone to help out, especially now that Santana is down for awhile.
  7. Twins make offer for Chris Archer

    snap4birds and 6 others reacted to Oxtung for a post in a topic

    7 points
    The fact that just about everyone has been willing to trade Kepler+ for Archer should tell us all it isn’t going to happen. If it isn’t painful for both sides then it isn’t an even trade.
  8. Twins make offer for Chris Archer

    kab21 and 6 others reacted to Nine of twelve for a post in a topic

    7 points
    I'd rather have Archer than Darvish, but I'd rather have paid money than players to make the acquisition.
  9. It's easy to get frustrated when looking at the Twins and their lack of landing a top free agent. I didn't see Darvish ending up here, but I'm still disappointed. Still, it's not like every other team in baseball has made big splashes into the deep end of free agency. I don't believe the White Sox, Royals, Athletics, Pirates, Padres or Cleveland have ever given any player a $100 million contract. The Twins broke that barrier for Mauer. They offered Darvish a deal in excess of that mark. Will the Twins ever sign a top free agent? As in the top free agent? I doubt it. Are we all just wasting our time? Of course. We're talking about baseball. Its whole point is to waste or time and distract us from other crap we'd rather not be thinking about Signing top free agents would help the Twins' chances of being competitive, but as the 2016 Clevelanders and 2014/15 Royals showed, that's not a requirement. Draft well, make some savvy trades and get a few lucky bounces. If you want to root for a club that's going to be signing top free agents, I'd suggest you pick a new team.
  10. 6 points
    While still concerning, that dip in velocity his senior year must be the reason he dropped out of the first round (where all bonuses were > $2MM). A plus curve, 94 MPH fastball, projectable frame and good control at 18 years old seems like a recipe for high first rounder. Twins may have gotten very lucky he dropped - and then executed the strategy perfectly to grab him in round 3 with an over-slot bonus.
  11. Twins make offer for Chris Archer

    gagu and 5 others reacted to Danchat for a post in a topic

    6 points
    Or, you know, maybe it means the Twins are upping their efforts to trade for Archer because they didn't get Darvish. I highly doubt the Twins are just pretending to have interest in the best pitchers just to get fans' hopes up... just to let them down later. That makes no sense to me.
  12. Twins make offer for Chris Archer

    gagu and 5 others reacted to jimmer for a post in a topic

    6 points
    you'd balk at getting a bonafide ace if it meant losing Kepler? I'm a Kepler fan, but that's an easy yes.
  13. The long term goal being winning a World Series I would hope, which isn't going to happen strictly through scouting and player development.
  14. Don't forget the opt-out clause, so you can leave after 3 innings if we get a bad SP performance! (Just kidding, I never advocate leaving a ballgame early.)
  15. 5 points
    Right now there doesn't appear to be any plan at #4 or 5 in the rotation other than throwing numbers at the problem. So I would say they have holes throughout the rotation. The Twins' priority should be acquiring any pitcher who projects to be better short term than Slegers, Jorge, Gonsalves, Hughes, etc. Which shouldn't be that hard to do.
  16. 5 points
    I'd rather have a team that's capable of winning it all but could miss the post season than a team that will make the post season but isn't capable of winning it all. There's no rule that the Twins have to go into the playoffs as the plucky, try-hard underdogs. That chip-chair-and-a-chance bit is so damn old and those long odds have yet to pay out for the Twins. This organization has to stop this business of hoping for the best. They need to PLAN for the best. Don't rely on luck and good fortune, make it yourself by stacking the odds in your favor.
  17. I've responded in snippets, but I just wanted to summarize my position of disappointment on the Darvish situation. I've seen our offer characterized as "serious", "competitive", and even that we were basically one of two finalists for his services. Insofar as our offer was possibly about ~80% of the winning offer (roughly accounting for the value of the opt out clause), it was serious/competitive, but that greatly overstates our chances. For Darvish to actually sign with us for that figure, the following conditions would have ALL needed to be met: Darvish would have had to change his mind. He'd been sitting on similar offers for 3 weeks, and probably would have been sitting on them since December if he had given any real indications of being willing to settle for 5/110. (Changing his mind like this could attract more suitors too.) Darvish would have had to NOT change his mind too much -- if he can't get 6 years or even 5 years with a preferred destination, he could have decided a one-year deal would be acceptable, in which case he'd have a lot more potential suitors. The Cubs or another preferred destination could not already be among the ~5 comparable offers. The Cubs or another preferred destination would have had to decline or not be allowed the opportunity to match or beat the offer. And even then, our offer still would have been only 1 of ~5 comparable offers. Assuming 5 and equal weighting (which is probably generous to the Twins), that would still only be a 20% chance of landing him, and remember that's only after the first 4 conditions are already satisfied.All told, despite our "serious"/"competitive" offer, we had, what, a 5% chance of landing him at the end? Maybe 10%? We can debate around the margins, but it wasn't good. Better than what was projected for us at the beginning of the offseason, but not meaningfully so. Still a very long longshot. However, if we had simply put forth the Twins Daily projected contract of 5/135, or ZiPS' 6/156, or one of many others projected by analysts, we quite likely would have upped those odds to 50% or greater. At the very least, that would have put *real* pressure on not only the Cubs, but also Darvish, his agent, and the MLBPA as a whole, who can't afford to turn down bigger contract offers in this climate of alleged collusion. To me, it's the difference between keeping a game close in the early innings, versus keeping it close into the late innings. Or keeping a series close early, versus keeping it close late. (Like all of those postseason Twins-Yankees matchups...) We kept it close early, but that doesn't comfort me much. We had a real opportunity to keep it close late, and we *chose* not to, far more than we were defeated in competition or held back by factors outside of our control. I know that proposed deal seems rich to a lot of people, but getting the top FA to come to a mid-market team, without having to blow away the projected market offer, was a rare opportunity that may never come along again. (By comparison, for Arizona to land Greinke, they had to overshoot MLBTR's projection by $38 mil in present-day value, or $50 mil before discounting deferrals.) That the top FA fit our greatest positional need, and we project to have an otherwise competitive squad, made it all the more significant. I've repeated the phrase "a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush" a lot lately, but it really does apply here. Not that the risk of ~$25 mil in potential annual dead payroll 5-6 years down the line isn't a concern, but to me, the risk is far greater to pass on this rare opportunity, in the present time when more facts are known and we have more confidence in near-term projections, including those of Darvish, our prospects, the rest of our roster, the rosters of our competition, and available comparable alternatives (or lack thereof). Sorry for the wall of text, but I hope this gets my position across clearly. (edited to correct spacing)
  18. I don't think that's fair to say at all. Darvish was the hope being sold all winter long... We discussed creative ways to sign him, discussed signing him regardless of the price, broke him down to the studs, and discussed the open windows Minnesota has to make a move such as this. It sounds like you got inside information weeks ago to make this news easier to handle. Many of us simpletons that followed this all winter just learned about it yesterday. When we were sold hope on him all winter and it doesn't happen aren't we allowed to be frustrated about it?
  19. 5 points
    Don't know why the Astros are dealing their depth. LA showed everyone how to use depth. Why not just sign lynn or Cobb, and keep the prospects?
  20. Twins make offer for Chris Archer

    kab21 and 4 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic

    5 points
    If I was Falvey, I'd be lobbying hard to take on Span to decrease the prospect haul required to get Archer. Given Tampa's apparent (perpetual) payroll woes, that might get the deal done.
  21. Twins make offer for Chris Archer

    Jham and 4 others reacted to DaveW for a post in a topic

    5 points
    I’d be shocked if Kepler is the ‘centerpiece’ Quite confident they would have to include a couple prospects as well that we would hate to lose. Fact is if Archer is truly being shopped aggressively there will be about 15 teams competing with us, many of which will have more org depth to outbid us. Basically this being ‘leaked’ today is an obvious move by the Twins FO and prob indicates the Twins are more or less done in the market for any “real big moves” If the deal wasn’t good two weeks ago, doubt it’s gonna get the job today, also the rays have zero reason to need to trade him now anyways. Should have signed Yu and we could have kept Kepler and a bunch of prospects to boot!
  22. From today's Strib article: The Twins were 19th in the majors with a 4.59 ERA, 24th with 62 quality starts and 26th with a .266 batting average against. They have been unable to upgrade the starting rotation, and staff ace Ervin Santana is expected to miss up to the first month of the season following middle finger surgery. Apparently, Santana's procedure was performed by a long-time Minnesota physician who has been doing middle-finger surgery on Twins' fans for many, many years.
  23. Twins make offer for Chris Archer

    AWOLNATION_11 and 3 others reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic

    4 points
    Let's reverse roles. Would you trade Berrios for two 18 year olds?
  24. The Twins have impeccable timing

    Danchat and 3 others reacted to Thrylos for a post in a topic

    4 points
    That's right. That's why they did not demote Park for his bobblehead night.
  25. 4 points
    Elite talent/potential is more scarce. Four B prospects may not equal one A prospect. Obviously this can vary a bit by player/team, but you will probably have a hard time finding past trade comps based on quantity over quality returns as you describe.
  26. I think I saw the back half of our rotation hanging from those things
  27. Twins make offer for Chris Archer

    TheLeviathan and 3 others reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic

    4 points
    Any trade that doesn't include Lewis is a non-starter for Tampa IMO. We're fooling ourselves if we think Tampa isn't going to immediately ask for the top prospect of any team interested in trading for him.
  28. 4 points
    The only issue with that train of thought is that Lynn (& Cobb/Arietta) will cost a high draft pick, which is pretty much the same as losing a prospect...
  29. If they ever actually do something to improve the team, then those of us questioning them are likely to compliment them. Some people are capable of both complimenting the good, and criticizing the bad. No one is saying the Twins lied, when we take about being sold hope. They never sign big free agents. They said Darvish was a priority. That creates hope. Losing out on that is disappointing, because they created hope where normally none would exist. Why is it hard to understand that some people would be disappointed?
  30. I'd prefer forfeiting every game in April... That way ALL of our pitchers save wear and tear on their arms! Games in April are silly anyways.
  31. We could also save wear and tear on Buxton by sitting him until June. Anyone down for that?
  32. 4 points
    I think Lance Lynn might be slightly better than McHugh. I'm just throwing out a trade candidate, not saying they should or shouldn't do it. I think adding him would make the Twins better. I also think they are capable of doing multiple moves (trade and free agent, two trades, two free agents, whatever). I think McHugh is worth having the discussion with Houston and seeing what that cost might be.
  33. Twins make offer for Chris Archer

    rghrbek and 3 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic

    4 points
    Yeah, it does. Kepler wasn't very good last season. The rest of the offense was quite good and also very young. Many of them posted good half seasons, which lends some weight to them posting good full seasons in 2018. I love Kepler but if he brings back Archer, I won't even hold up a lighter for him, much less a candlelight vigil. Max had a 1.2 fWAR and a 2.1 rWAR last season. That's easily replaceable.
  34. Twins make offer for Chris Archer

    Jham and 3 others reacted to Tom Froemming for a post in a topic

    4 points
    I really hate to do this, but .. Player A: .272/.329/.427, .329 wOBA, 102 wRC+ Player B: .243/.312/.425, .315 wOBA, 92 wRC+ Both had 1.2 fWAR, tied for 59th among 83 outfielders with at least 400 PAs. A is Denard Span B is Max Kepler Obviously two guys moving in opposite directions, but still. Also, among the 197 hitters with at least 200 PAs in the second half, Kepler ranked 181st in OPS (.668). I still believe the best is yet to come from Max, but it's pretty difficult for me to imagine that he could be the centerpiece of a trade that nets four affordable years of Archer.
  35. Twins make offer for Chris Archer

    laloesch and 3 others reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic

    4 points
    A trade offer two weeks ago? Let me provide a reverse jinx and say I'm skeptical this news has any bearing. Tampa is not a motivated seller.
  36. Twins make offer for Chris Archer

    Blake and 3 others reacted to Riverbrian for a post in a topic

    4 points
    Make it a good one Strap
  37. Twins make offer for Chris Archer

    gagu and 3 others reacted to jimmer for a post in a topic

    4 points
    Getting Archer would be better than signing Darvish!
  38. This is an oft repeated line by you, but it's not especially accurate. 7 of the last 8 world series champions did not have a comparable signing to Darvish. It would be more the exception rather than the rule to win the world series after a signing like this. There are many ways for a team to be successful.
  39. Phil Hughes's name has been thrown around by the media left and right. Is there any evidence that he will start Spring Training throwing the ball, instead of on the 60-day DL? I have seen zero reports about him starting a throwing program, and it has been about 6 or 7 months since his latest surgery.
  40. Signing Danny Darwin would be a disappointing retread move.
  41. 3 points
    But if you get an actual #1 than that fixes the hole at the top and beefs up the bottom by pushing Santana/Berrios/Gibson/et al down. I don't know why finding a #5 for the short term would be a priority over finding a #1 for any length of time.
  42. This is as "real" as your Dozier trade thread last year. I'm not sure why you do this stuff.
  43. I think what would have happened if the Twins offered him more is that the Cubs would have offered more and he'd still be in Chicago.
  44. The Cubs can afford to absorb a few bad years at the end of that deal much more easily than the Twins. This is a very basic market reality. Epstein understands this. Not much else to be said. It is not hard to understand and no one is telling you not to be disappointed. I'm disappointed. But there are more productive things to do than sit around and sulk about how disappointed we are. This thread was meant to be a counterbalance to the aforementioned 20-page misery fest in the forum but sadly it's just been turning into the same thing. Come on people: Buck up!
  45. This "sold hope" narrative makes it seem like there was something dishonest or misleading going on. It is pretty clear here that the Twins DID make a 5-year offer worth $100M+, which would be unprecedented in the franchise's history. I know everyone has these built-in suspicions about the Twins brass but why is to hard to accept that they were legitimately interested, gave legitimate pursuit, and legitimately got beat out by a franchise that always had an intrinsic edge over them? Be frustrated, sure. But there's so much "woe is me, we're screwed" going on here, as if Darvish was the only player out there with a chance to improve this club. The point of this article was to look forward and extract a few positives from a bummer of a situation.
  46. Twins make offer for Chris Archer

    Twins33 and 2 others reacted to puckstopper1 for a post in a topic

    3 points
    If we land Archer in a trade with the Rays, does that mean the Twins have 2 "archers" on the roster? (See Fernando R.'s "game over" motion).
  47. Isn't the opposite true that he's betting on himself? Again, I don't get the logic. It's not too much to plan around this, especially given the context that we have a lot of decent prospects in AA/AAA. Two years from now, it's quite possible these guys will be out of options and need to be traded or added. If they aren't that good, then the worst case with an opt out is that we are back on the FA market looking for an arm. If he doesn't opt out, then it means he hasn't outperformed his contract, but that's a risk we take anyways. I can see scenarios where an opt out isn't a smart idea, but I don't think this is one of them.
  48. The nice thing from the Cubs' point of view is that the AAV is so much lower than expected, they're essentially getting at least one year for free. Maybe even two, if they wouldn't have minded paying $126M/4yrs to get him, anyway. Unless his arm blows up in Year One, there isn't much risk for the club. I didn't really expect the Twins to get Darvish. It's just a little disappointing that they didn't make a serious offer. Everybody figured that they would need to offer 6 years to stand a chance, and they just didn't do it. Luckily, none of the fallback options are off the table, yet. Then again, there isn't really another starting pitcher on the FA market who is likely to move the needle as much as Darvish. We'll probably see the Twins give 4 years to some #3-4 starter. Is that going to push them back to the postseason? Eh.
  49. Twins make offer for Chris Archer

    HitInAPinch and 2 others reacted to jimmer for a post in a topic

    3 points
    Let me rephrase. We'd be getting a better pitcher. But yeah, what it would cost in prospects probably doesn't make it the better than just spending the money.
This leaderboard is set to Chicago/GMT-06:00

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.