Ummmm . . . (1) By Gonsalves' own admission, he has lots left to work on, including his control and command. (2) Even if he had nothing left to work on or prove at AA, it is usually wise to let a prospect go up against the aging sluggers, rehabing major leaguers and AAAA hitters in AAA to get practice against the best non-MLB hitters available nearby. (3) This season is over in terms of playoffs, so adding Gonsalves now isn't going to get us anything, other than maybe (if he plays really well) a lower draft pick. (4) Why start his service time clock now? If he is called up now, it means the Twins will likely need to wait until July next year to call him up while preserving the extra year of service time. And next year it might be much more valuable to have him in the majors earlier. Every day he is in the majors next year is certainly more valuable than every day he is in the majors this year. (5) The Twins can always call him up in September as a reliever, which will allow him to get at least two more starts at AA and limit his innings a little, and get the reward of pitching a few innings of relief under the bright lights. Why not wait till September (assuming you want to call him up as a reward at all - service time weighs against even doing that)? Gonsalves doesn't need to succeed at the Major League level in order to make non-tendering Santiago a good idea. Mejia is closer, and May is another option to join the rotation. If Santiago continues to be terrible, the Twins are in position not to tender him a contract.