Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Leaderboard

  1. Craig Arko

    Verified Member
    Points
    9,566
    Posts
  2. twinsnorth49

    Community Moderator
    Points
    11,777
    Posts
  3. Mike Sixel

    Old-Timey Member
    Points
    36,790
    Posts
  4. Brock Beauchamp

    Administrator
    Points
    29,627
    Posts

Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation on 02/29/2016 in all areas

  1. It is really surprising to see people here completely discount the impact of defense on successful teams. All of the people suggested in this thread including Dave Parker, Puig, Pena, and Carlos Lee were all smaller than Sano some by a lot but more importantly all had experience playing the outfield prior to doing it in the majors. Sano is trying to do this for the first time at the major league level. People should also remember that the closest comp to Sano size wise (Carlos Lee) was an absolute DISASTER defensively by any metric but even he had experience playing the position prior to playing it in the majors. All the other justifications like RF in Target Field is small, someone else in CF can cover more ground, or my favorite "he's pretty athletic" are really nothing more than hope. Successful GMs don't construct rosters for successful teams banking on hope. This move of Sano to the outfield is going to be most likely a complete disaster and at best a really bad idea that will negatively impact the team's defense. A very predictable result given any reasonable analysis of it. The bigger question is going to be what Ryan and the Twins are going to do once it becomes obvious this was a really bad decision and you can't ignore the dumpster fire anymore?
  2. I'm curious to see if Arcia can turn it around.
  3. I don't like him in the outfield. I think it's an injury waiting to happen. I think it's poor asset management and unnecessary risk with a cornerstone type player. I would move other pieces around to accommodate my premier players. Not the other way around.
  4. It's also probably fair to say that baseball hasn't had a lot of 260+ pound outfielders because baseball hasn't had a lot of 260+ pound players. The game and its athletes are changing dramatically. If you watch any ESPN classic baseball game from the 80s you'll see that the players today generally dwarf those guys. The time of the 6'2", 175 lb Jack Clark's playing corner OF and 1B is gone. So, while Sano might be rare now, he might not be all that rare in 5 years. We'll see.
  5. Guest
    I'll tell you who I probably WOULDN'T want as a teammate (or even a friend) and that's the guy who did the weed and left me hanging with a 30 day suspension that was almost certainly going to cost me a ton of money due to the drop in draft status instead of stepping up and admitting his culpability, himself.
  6. 2016 Election Thread

    twinsnorth49 and 3 others reacted to Craig Arko for a post in a topic

    4 points
    I'd only let Trump go eye-to-eye with Putin if we took away the launch codes, thank you very much.
  7. Delmon Young, wasted talent...... the others should scare the ABW fans some.
  8. I mostly like the image of Thome in the lawn chair manning RF. There should be a bobblehead of this.
  9. Food and other such holidays

    Squirrel and 3 others reacted to Craig Arko for a post in a topic

    4 points
    And deeper in debt.
  10. 2016 Election Thread

    Hrbowski and 2 others reacted to twinsnorth49 for a post in a topic

    3 points
    Says more about Trump's supporters than it does about Trump. Repeatedly spewing obnoxious garbage louder than everyone else does not make someone "good at it". He's good at jingoism I'll give him that, it helps that his supporters are the laughable segment of the American public that eat that **** up.
  11. When Miguel was in Elizabethton in 2011, he was listed at 6'3" and 232#. The only thing he could say in English the 1st night was, "Will I get enough to eat here?" Not a problem! I had a houseful that year, which also included Eddie and Kennys. I would take 2 buggies through the grocery store every week.
  12. Chuck Klostermann's HYPERtheticals

    Vanimal46 and 2 others reacted to twinsnorth49 for a post in a topic

    3 points
    A. I didn't even read the rest.
  13. This weekend marked the first day of full squad workouts and they did not disappoint. Friday started off with positional players playing catch on Field Four. Kennys Vargas looks like he lost quite a few pounds, and was talking it up with fans and a few old friends at the park. The two uber prospects, Miguel Sano and Byron Buxton were playing catch and long tossing side by side, Buxton's throwing motion looks so smooth and effortless, can't say the same for Sano. Still Sano throws better than Adam Brett Walker, who I heard from a coach has been fighting the "yips" for a couple weeks already. After the warmup tossing, the players took batting practice. The first group consisted of Brian Dozier, Trevor Plouffe, Byung Ho Park, and Ryan Sweeney. While the second group was comprised of Buxton, Sano, Eddie Rosario, and Carlos Quentin. Quentin and Sweeney both pulled a few pitches deep. Dozier hit the warning track and fence a couple times and was quickly teased for having "warning track power" by his fellow players. Plouffe was ripping off ropes left and right. Park was using the entire field which was mildly impressive since he had been looking to pull heavy the past two weeks. Buxton looked tentative at the plate and of course had the most fan detractors about his swing; heard everything from his poor use of backleg, coil of the hands, he's all wrists...it was one of his first days so he gets a pass. The group then broke out and started working on their base running; from home to first, home to second, first to third, second to home, and third to home. Leading the baserunning drills was Brian Dozier who is inequivocally the team leader - it's not even close. Dozier was first in line, while Vargas was last and his teammates let him hear it everytime he was running the bases. Max Kepler was with the group but was sitting out for the day just watching. With most of the hitters done for the day, I traversed across the complex to the Stadium where the catchers were working on their blocking skills. John Hicks was pretty impressive and looks to be a strong defensive backup option for the club. Joining Hicks was Centuro who showed off his lateral movements behind the plate. Last but definitely not least was JR Murphy who worked one on one with Coach Vavra on blocking bounced pitches to the plate with just his body. The last action of the day was Byron Buxton and Mastro working on their bunting skills. Mastro has a strong ability to deaden the ball to the third base which is ideal for a sac bunt situation on the other hand his ability to bunt for a hit wasn't as pretty. Buxton laid down a few pretty good bunts and he definitely looks to have the aptitude to work a few in for base hits especially with his speed. Friday provided a great framework for Saturday which was the first full squad official workout for the club. The players were greeted by fanfare as they took to the fields to warmup. The players were not wearing their typical jerseys but instead were wearing "heart of 29" in honor of Rod Carew who made it to camp and was quite vocal with a few of the players in the batting cage. The Hall of Famer was joined by fellow Hall of Famer Tony Olivo, and recent retiree Torii Hunter. If you listen to Hunter, everything is great in camp, this player looks in great shape, this guy looks the best in his career; he's a walking posterboard of positivity. After a few warmup with the pitchers on Field Five half the group split to work on defensive drills with half of the infielders. Front and center of the pitching core was Phil Hughes followed by Trevor May and Glen Perkins, working on slow rollers hit to each side, some situational base coverages, all the same stuff you'd see in little league/high school/college. While the pitchers were working on their defensive craft, Tom Kelly was working the rest of the infielders on Tom Kelly Field, Plouffe and company at third, Nunez with others at short, Dozier and his bunch at second with Park, Mauer and Vargas taking turns at 1B. Early on, Park and Mauer were talking about base coverage and positioning via translator. Underneath the stadium, Sano (in the cage), Buxton, Arcia, Quentin, Kepler, Rosario, and the rest of the outfielders were taking batting practice in the cage under the guidance of Tony Olivo, Rod Carew, Tom Brunansky, and Butch Davis. Also underneath Hammond in the bullpen, Tommy Milone and Ervin Santana were warming up to then face some live batting practice. The second pairing was Ricky Nolasco (who looks to have shed some lbs too) and Jose Berrios in the bullpen. Ricky faced off against Kepler, Sweeney and Park and was rather erratic with his control as Park didn't lift the bat off his shoulder. Jose Berrios faced off the tandum of Sano, Buxton, and Rosario, has an amazingly live arm and despite his size creates great torque and force from his lower half. The last pitcher I watched in live BP was Nick Burdi, kid throws smoke even when he's not trying. Coach Lepel told him to only throw at 50% effort, lets just say his half effort is more than most pitchers' full. The day finished off with Joe Mauer working one on one with hitting coach Tom Brunansky. One could overhear a fan say "What is Tom going to teach Joe about hitting a baseball?" Sometimes it's just not that simple. I did pick up where Tom was praising Joe for his loose wrists but was trying to gett Joe to slightly move his head with his swing when opening up and pulling the ball. The former catcher picked up quickly and continued to work on it the rest of his cage session.
  14. 2016 Election Thread

    twinsnorth49 and 2 others reacted to Craig Arko for a post in a topic

    3 points
    This sounds like a fair job description for doing improvisational comedy. I will concede him that role.
  15. I think the Twins know Sano is going to be a bad outfielder. I think they also thought he would be a lousy third baseman too. Being a bad RF will always cost fewer runs than being a bad 3B.
  16. I don't think Dunn is as bad of an example as you claim. Most of his terrible fielding numbers occurred in the back half of his 20s. Your query cut out a couple of his better seasons (2001 & 2003) and the Rfield value includes both his outfield defense AND his 1B defense (a position at which he was significantly worse on a per/game basis). Focusing just on his outfield defense, it was mostly competent up through age 25: Age | OF Games | OF Runs 21 | 63 | +1 22 | 118 | +1 23 | 102 | -1 24 | 156 | -4 25 | 133 | -10 26 | 156 | -17 27 | 144 | -26 28 | 141 | -19 29 | 84 | -20 Carlos Lee had a similar trajectory, though he didn't fall off until he got closer to 30. Given Sano's relative youth, and how other big players performed at a similar age, I'm cautiously optimistic that Sano will be competent in the outfield for the next year or two, at which point there should be openings for him in the infield.
  17. 3 points
    I'm guilty of being a long-time lurker and will make an effort to post more often. Things I'm looking forward to this year: > Gibson taking another step forward to becoming a top of the rotation ace > Debut of Max Kepler, sooner than later > One of the young fireballers making their debut with the Twins this year, whether it's Burdi or Reed. The pen could use the help > What happens at the Catcher position. Hoping JR Murphy makes an impact and takes over the position. Many, many others but I tried to keep to the less-than-obvious ones (like the debut of Berrios!). Overall, just plain looking forward to them building on what they did last year. Go Twins!!
  18. 3 points
    If its not a DP situation, he doesn't slide that way, because his goal would be to get to the bag as quickly as possible, and stay on the bag. And they've also eliminated the SS "taking liberties." No more neighborhood play. A force play has to be a force play, just like every other force play. Also a good thing. Look, I'm old school. I want the game played hard, I want pitchers pitching inside, I want hitters knocked off the plate. And I want my base runners sliding hard into second base in DP situations. What I want eliminated is base runners sliding into fielders, on purpose, when the fielder isn't in the path to the bag. Don't slide late, don't jump into his legs, don't roll block. Don't alter your path to initiate contact. Simple. Slide hard, into the bag. That's a runner's right. If the fielder is in your way, knock his arse down. But slide into the bag, so the fielder can avoid you, if he so chooses.
  19. 3 points
    "Sell high" shouldn't be uttered by a team that is attempting to compete for a postseason berth and has no viable replacement at the position. Sheesh, you guys. This isn't a video game. There's no way Polanco even comes close to replacing Dozier's production in 2016. Are the Twins trying to win baseball games or an award for the best farm system in baseball?
  20. M. Sano - OF

    Loosey and 2 others reacted to Linus for a post in a topic

    3 points
    Um, no I don't believe that has been brought up.
  21. Chris Mitchell of Fangraphs wrote an interesting post this morning where he looked back at Baseball America's Top 10 Prospects from 10 years ago, and where they ended up. It's pretty interesting to read the names and remember the fact that they were baseball's darlings. Some panned out better than others, and some never made their impact in the MLB.... Here's the link to look back at the names.
  22. 2 points
    Kinda pointless to argue about ERA, but the above is a false statement, Duffey does.
  23. Article: Is The Twins System Broken?

    spinowner and one other reacted to Platoon for a post in a topic

    2 points
    We were to the Yankees what the Detroit Lions were to Buds Vikings. Btw Mike, of course there's luck in cribbage! But I always thought it was a game that required a little more skill than others. I also think it tends to be a defensive game. Unless all hope is lost, I never thought bold play was a winning strategy. All that aside, your wife winning 90% of the time might be far better than her losing 90% of the time.
  24. 2 points
    I like to say our series victory over Oakland, and Oakland's series victory over us, cancel each other out, and both franchises should be considered without a playoff series win in the 21st century. Not unlike Braves vs. Indians in 1995, or a hypothetical Cubs vs Red Sox series in 2003 would have been. Although in addition to sweeping us, at least Oakland took all of their other first round losses to the full 5 games. After we beat Oakland 3-2, our next 3 series (LAA, NYY, NYY) followed the same format: we won the first game, then got swept in the rest. Our next 3 series after that (OAK, NYY, NYY), we just got swept, period (despite twice having the first two games at home). Admittedly still a small sample, but I'm willing to believe there's something to it more than just chance or a Yankees curse.
  25. No, this prospect list was a couple years before the Johan deal. Milledge had already been traded to Washington by that time. Fernando Martinez was the hyped outfield prospect for the Mets by then, although he never climbed higher than #20 on BA's top 100 list.
  26. 2015-2016 Offseason Thread

    James and one other reacted to biggentleben for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Though going to Texas in that environment and being able to push up his value for a weak class next year may be more valuable than returning to the cesspool that is the Washington Nationals clubhouse.
  27. 2 points
    It would be unusual for a coach to publicly criticize the ability of one of his players, regardless of what the coach honestly thought. (Thinking of the Twins moving Sano to RF right now...) And I'm not sure keeping Jay in the pen was a good decision for Illinois at all. They had a good season historically, but it quite likely could have ended better for them. They were ranked as high as #2 in the nation, and no lower than #5, in all the major polls entering the NCAA tournament: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_NCAA_Division_I_baseball_rankings Yet they were swept out of the double-elimination super regional (NCAA final 16), despite home field advantage. Every poll had them ranked ahead of their super regional opponent (although to be fair, that opponent was the preseason #1 Vanderbilt). They also failed to advance any further in the Big Ten tournament than they did in 2014. I previously broke down their tournament usage of Jay here, and it looks like Jay barely mattered (in fact, they turned to a well-rested Jay as a desperation starter facing elimination after their "trusted" starting pitchers put their backs against the wall): http://twinsdaily.com/topic/18552-article-twins-select-tyler-jay-sixth-overall/?p=351940 On last year's midseason top prospects article, I offered this opinion on Jay's college usage: "Personally, I think the team and player got comfortable with the situation early in his college career, and the team didn't really have time to try to develop him as a starter (imagine if the Twins were guaranteed to lose him to another league in another year or two, they probably don't mess with his role either)." In short, it's hard to conclude much about his college stats or usage right now. Will be very interesting to watch him develop this year and going forward.
  28. My biggest concern with Sano in the outfield isn't his defense. Don't get me wrong; that is a concern, and I think his defense is likely to cost the Twins runs. That said, my bigger concern is how the running required in playing the outfield may lead to an elevated injury risk for Sano. Certainly, it's easier today (with almost every park boasting natural grass) than it was 10-15 years ago. But I don't know we have a real sense of what that does to such a massive person's knees. I'm terrified of an ACL tear or a Griffey-esque chronic hamstring problem. That said, if he can just stick it out for two or three seasons, the Twins will be able to shift him to 1B by the time he's a disaster out there, as Bill notes.
  29. Article: TD Top Prospects: #5 Tyler Jay

    d-mac and one other reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Well, I can't in 1000000 years see the Twins getting him to the majors as fast as Sale did. They'll baby his arm (innings limit), and he'll be shut down by late August. Hopefully, he's in AA at some point, but I'm not holding my breath. He clearly has a shot to be a legit MLB starter, I just think some people need to temper their timeline beliefs some.
  30. Food and other such holidays

    twinsnorth49 and one other reacted to Craig Arko for a post in a topic

    2 points
    "Go through his pockets and look for loose change." http://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/how-miracle-max-nearly-shut-down-the-princess-bride
  31. Everyone was making a huge deal about Torii Hunter manning RF this time last year. Every metric said he was among the worst, if not the worst outfielder in the game in 2014, yet he was just fine last year despite having next to no range. Jim Thome could play RF at Target Field relaxing in a lawn chair, it's the size of a Manhatten efficiency.
  32. All good points (except the one that brings up Frank Howard as though I didn't devote an entire paragraph to him in the article--read the column, as Ken Rosenthal says). Markos' point is pretty close to where I was trying to go. There's no reason to think he won't be fine for the next year or two. He's just SO big, SO young--and likely to just keep getting bigger--he could quickly (within the next 2-3 years) become a Dunn-level disaster out there. I suspect there'll be a time down the road when Sano will be starting the All-Star Game at first for the ninth straight year and people will say "did you know he used to play in the OUTFIELD?" and laugh, like how Mike Morse came up as a shortstop and Miguel Cabrera played some short and second in the minors.
  33. Article: TD Top Prospects: #5 Tyler Jay

    beckmt and one other reacted to DocBauer for a post in a topic

    2 points
    I really liked the Jay pick when it happened. As I recollect the last draft, there were a couple "top" prospects and then various question marks up and down the line, high school and college alike. IMHO, he offers the best of both strategies:1] he's a quality arm with nice upside, though there is risk involved, 2] he's ALSO a very safe pick as it would almost seem a certainty that at worst he becomes a top LH set up man. And even if that becomes his destiny, a high quality, LHSU guy is not easy to find, and highly valuable. Just examine all the tremendous consternation and hand wringing taking place on the forums for the Twins not signing Sipp or Bastardo to finish off the bullpen. Again, Jay being that guy is probably a worst case scenario. Drafting a high quality ML end of the bullpen reliever is the floor of your draft pick? Hey....I'll take that.
  34. I don't worry about Sano's size at third or in the outfield. The point made earlier that athletes (and humans in general) are getting larger is a good one to point out. What concerns me about Sano's defense in the outfield is that he's never done it and is learning to on the fly as a major league player. I wouldn't care if he was 5'7 and 160 pounds, that would concern me.
  35. 2 points
    That wouldn't be good enough for me, as OPS+ is not position adjusted. Going by that stat, I'd want to see something around 115 before calling the deal a success. Over 120 is "resounding success" territory and a great return on the investment.
  36. 2016 Election Thread

    Hrbowski and one other reacted to twinsnorth49 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Ummm......Calgary isn't a state.....c'mon now, don't reinforce the stereotype I already have of you guys.
  37. I think of Sano comparisons and I just come up with NFL linebackers who are big, athletic and fast. I am guessing he is faster and maybe even much faster than Willingham, Delmon, Young, Mauer, Hunter and Arcia and probably just as fast as Escobar and Nunez. Can he get good jumps and catch the ball once there? I don't know. Young, Willingham, Arcia, Nunez and Escobar didn't do such a good job of it but Santana did and I don't think Cuddyer's transition was all that bad. Anyone that says he should have played there in the minors probably has a point but his bat was ready before his glove so its not like there was a ton of time for evaluation It will be interesting. I don't think he will be there in 3 years. Maybe because of weight but likely because of opening at 1st.
  38. http://mlb.mlb.com/images/2010/11/19/9ULHEmQ8.jpg My best comparison to successful outfield with a similar sized player to Sano would be the Pittsburgh Pirates when Dave Parker was in right. Parker was listed at 6-5 230 but was perceived to be larger. (Photo above suggests the same) Parker won 3 consecutive Gold Gloves because he had a deadly howitzer arm and, with Omar Moreno covering more area than Verizon in center, didn't have to have exceptional wheels. (We also have one of those Moreno-like center fielders, come to think of it.) Sano only needs to make sound decisions and accurate throws out there. (Be sort of an anti-Oswaldo Arcia) and this could work, fine. Not the ideal asthetic, I agree, but serviceable. What you DON'T want is for your center fielder to also have to cover ground to the other side - which he won't have to with Rosario or Kepler.
  39. M. Sano - OF

    big dog and one other reacted to Craig Arko for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Beats the heck out of me. Games can't come soon enough.
  40. Terry Ryan- I am not a fan

    bird and one other reacted to DiscGolfer for a post in a topic

    2 points
    I think this is the year to really see if Ryan can make the necessary moves to build a quality team. The farm system is more stocked with prospects close to being ready than any other year in recent memory. Will Ryan be able to make the tough move and bring up some of these guys if and when somebody struggles, I hope so. I don't fault him for not going out and getting a big name FA bullpen arm considering the depth in the system. No need to sign another guy to create more of a logjam. With the progress the Mets, Royals, Astros and Cubs have made with their farm systems the Twins should be able to make similar improvements this year. The opening day roster will be what it is, but it's the roster in June and after August that will determine if this will be a wining team. Can't wait for games to start so we can actually see how this all plays out.
  41. M. Sano - OF

    bird and one other reacted to Blake for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Back when the late Harmon Killebrew was broadcasting Twins games, he mentioned a couple of times he thought the outfield was the better place for long term player health, because players don't have to do all the bending and twisting, etc., that infielders have to do. We can speculate all we want about Sano's attitude and ability, but, in the end, we won't know anything until we actually see Sano play.
  42. M. Sano - OF

    HitInAPinch and one other reacted to twinsnorth49 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    What's a thread without an obligatory Mauer shot?
  43. Lurkers and rookies please post here

    glunn and one other reacted to twinsnorth49 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Don't listen to this Rez. Always is our resident moderator wannabe.......jump right in and join the fray. Welcome.
  44. And if they help the Twins contend in 2016 and 2017, that's just fine. Contending teams shouldn't think too hard about what a player might bring in trade and whether he's "devaluing" in trade value if he's actually contributing on the field. It's one of my pet peeves on sports forums. Sometimes, the smart move is to worry solely about the on-field product and not think about possible trade value. It's why I'm okay with the Twins letting Plouffe walk after the 2017 season if that's the smart play (ie. he's worth his yearly salary in production and helps the Twins win baseball games).
  45. 2 points
    Your right, of course. My big fear is that if we wait too long, Dozier & Plouffe will have about as much value as Dan Uggla & David Freese do right now.
  46. 2 points
    So, whom would you want as a teammate? The guy who snitched on his fellow teammate in high school for smoking pot. Or the guy who took a thirty day suspension and a financial hit in the draft rather than snitch on a teammate. This isn't a "Black Sox" violation, this is a fellow teammate smoking a little weed. If I'm a potential teammate, I like this guy's attitude! Gonsalves can be expected to have the back of his fellow players.
  47. 2 points
    He could be a high level utility guy if not traded. Just don't think he'll be an everyday SS.
  48. The sooner slides whose intention is not to get to the base as fast as possible, but to hit a fielder, are gone from the game, the better.
  49. 2 points
    Are we just ignoring this last part of the new rule? ".....and not changing his path for the purpose of initiating contact with a fielder." Why else did he do that awkward slide that took him longer to get to the base? Why would anyone throw their legs out there if not to avoid a player with the ball..... instead of make hard contact with him? He changed his path for the purpose of initiating contact with a fielder. He went out of his way to make contact. Pretty simple.
  50. 2016 Hammond Happenings

    nytwinsfan and one other reacted to Halsey Hall for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Oh happy day! Park put on a power display today with some traveling to the high school! There's hope.
This leaderboard is set to Chicago/GMT-06:00

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.