I think it's time to go ahead and tackle this topic. It's no secret that one of the prime reasons the Twins improved from a 90+ loss team to an 80+ Wildcard contender is they put together the best overall starting rotation they have had in years. It was downright respectable! And there were very few of the 3rd inning blowout sogoaheadandturnthestationorgettoyourhoneydolistsinceyouhadnothingbettertodo games. Despite a down-ish year from Hughes, half a season from Santana, brief contributions from Nolasco, May being removed from the rotation, having to actually depend on Mike Pelfrey every 5th day, and assorted injuries late in the season, the Twins were very close to shaving a run off their ERA from the year before. Imagine what better health, Santana for a full season and just a little better luck here and there could have meant?! But while we know how important pitching is to the game, while we are all a bit giddy that our beloved Twins actually had some and may have more coming, there is still a thought of "more" floating out there. As in more=better. What can we do to take that next step? So the questions for 2016 and the Twins starting rotation are: Should we try to get better? Can we really get better? How much better can we be and how do we get there? First, let's look at what is in house: 1) Phil Hughes. He was an outstanding FA acquisition for 2014 and had probably the best year of his career. His "pedigree" is outstanding, probably as strong as feelings of frustration over inconsistency in his career. But he has won 15 games 3 times, an OK AL ERA, a solid Whip, and excellent SO/BB ratio. After a bit of a slow start in '14 he was excellent. In '15 his slow start lingered a bit longer, and while he never quite hit his '14 stride, he actually pitched very well for about half a season before injuries slowed and shelved him. Talented, strapping and happy in Minnesota, I think a return to his 2014 numbers, or close, is not to be unexpected if healthy. 2) Ervin Santana. There is no question only half season from Santana was greatly disappointing. Despite the surprise first half contributions from Pelfrey, you almost have to believe having Santana for the full season would have been worth at least a couple more wins. An examination of Santana's career shows him to be very, very consistent. You can almost guarantee 32 GS, 195-ish IP, 165 SO and at least 13 wins with a shot at 14-17 if on a quality team. There are no guarantees, of course, but he seems healthy and fit for 2016 after his half season with the Twins. Looking beyond a couple weeks in August when he was very much off, he sandwiched some outstanding pitching to begin and end his inaugural Twins season. 3) Kyle Gibson. I get frustrated when people jump on Gibson. He is not exactly old, lost a season to TJ surgery, made a hell of a quick recovery back to the mound and competence, and has only pitched 2 seasons in the ML. And all he has done is pitch solid one year, pitch even better the second year, and at various times has been the Twins best starter. In his 2 ML seasons, Gibson has had moments of brilliance where he looks like a possible #1, and no worse than a quality #2 SP. Now, he's not really going to be a #1 pitcher, more than likely, but the point is how good he can be at times...that he is still improving...and really just needs a little more consistency. Only 2 years in the league, I think we can count on some additional improvement. 4) May. He might look great in the bullpen, but you just don't take a young arm talent like him out of the rotation until or unless you don't have a choice. The control issues that we heard would hold him back from being a top of the rotation starter have been curtailed. He showed real sign of improvement when still in the rotation, and lead the Twins in several categories. 5) Duffey. Converted from relief, the curveball specialist...along with Sano...almost single-handedly preserved the Twins second half last season. He was darn near "Ace-like" during his couple months of performances. I don't think anyone expects him to be a top rotation SP, but is what he showed all sustainable? Even close? We sure need to find out and he deserves the chance to prove it. 6) Milone. He is nothing special. But he is a pitcher. And he showed, when healthy, why he has won previously despite pedestrian stuff. Simply, he appears to be a very solid be counted back of the rotation contributor that can win. But he also has the least upside of any candidate here. And with a few breakdowns here and there, I wonder if he might be best as a swing man. 7) Berrios. I believe he has a very solid chance to break with the club. What could hold him back is not service time, but rather, a logjam of options in the rotation and bullpen and the Twins letting him get a month in AAA while they sort through various options. 8) Nolasco. A big wild card. He is not a bad pitcher. The majority of his career has been unspectacular, but very solid and consistent. But he must have signed his Twins contract with a cursed pen. He could help. He could surprise. He could be needed if an injury bug suddenly hits the Twins in ST. But otherwise...this is the one guy the Twins should be trying to move in any manner they can. If you accept the numbers provided by MLTraderumors, the Twins would enter 2016 about $10M under the top payroll the team has ever had. Could and would the Twins be willing to top that mark? I believe they would. While not earth shattering, the Twins have added payroll before when the addition(s) in question meant winning. Also, said highest payroll ever will have been 5 years removed. Inflation and all don't ya know! But how much higher than $10M might they go? Another $10M? That gives you $20M for a top of the rotation starter, but with needs still in the bullpen, and probably a bench bat, maybe help at catcher in the form of a FA as well. If you can move Nolasco, and say it only costs you half his salary each of the next 2 years to do so, you save another $6M. Based on projections, if you trade Plouffe as part of a deal somewhere, you save another $7M. That's another $13M or so, and you could add a couple more if they let Fien go. But you still have to address the pen, catcher, and maybe the bench as well, at some point. And if Plouffe is traded, do we then need to consider a DH signing? The whole point is the Twins have needs, assets, and also money to spend. But it's also a business. The Pohlads will not break out their American Express card for $20M per for 6 years on a player. Nor would anyone. The Twins have 3 choices here: 1) Trade 3-5 prospects/players for a young-ish top of the rotation SP to push their rotation and the team over the top. This allows your relative "choice" of said player, and possibly more cost control for the next 2-5 years. But you are going to lose 1 of Berrios, May, Gibson or Duffey for sure, probably Kepler, another milb pitcher or two, etc. Does this acquisition improve the team enough to warrant the cost in dollars and prospects? 2) Keep the prospects for yourself or additional moves, and fork out $18-23M for 5-6 years for a 30-32 yo FA SP. You've got, in theory, $10M to work with though, and another $13-15M if you can swing some moves. Could you possibly move Hughes or Santana as well as Nolasco? Because we still have finances to consider as well as additional additions. 3) Stay your hand. You move Nolasco. You may move Plouffe for additional help. But you believe in and trust a rebound for Hughes, Santana to keep on keeping on, Gibson, May, Duffey to continue to improve and make way for young stud Berrios. You re-in force the pen, add to catcher, possibly add a bench player or DH, and feel secure that you have a talent, deep, and mostly young rotation that would only be improved somewhat by another veteran starter. As long as what you have is healthy. Those are the rotation candidates. The team really has 3 options to consider in all of this. Should the team make a big move? Which option? How much does it improve the team? It's all your call.