Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Leaderboard

  1. SwainZag

    Community Moderator
    Points
    3,123
    Posts
  2. Thrylos

    Old-Timey Member
    Points
    11,094
    Posts
  3. Seth Stohs

    Administrator
    Points
    24,042
    Posts
  4. Brock Beauchamp

    Administrator
    Points
    29,627
    Posts

Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation on 10/18/2015 in all areas

  1. Could Maloney be a Find?

    gbg and 5 others reacted to SwainZag for a post in a topic

    6 points
    I see nothing wrong with this kind of signing, it's exactly zero risk.
  2. Twins outlook - mlbtraderumors

    sane and 2 others reacted to nytwinsfan for a post in a topic

    3 points
    I agree that it is highly speculative that Escobar is likely to hit better long-term by just being a SS, rather than utility man. I also think there is a decent chance he regresses a bit next year. However, all that being said, while Desmond might be an upgrade, I just don't think his cost is worth it, given that we (1) have Escobar, who has a very good chance to be at least league average, and (2) we have so much bigger needs at catcher and relief pitcher.
  3. Could Maloney be a Find?

    darin617 and one other reacted to Thrylos for a post in a topic

    2 points
    No, by any means: Mauer/Plouffe at the MLB level Vargas/Kepler at the AAA level DJ Hicks/Bryan Haar at the AA level Trey Vavra at the A+ level Chris Paul, Pat Kelly somewhere in the equation as well Plus Amaurys Minier and Lewin Diaz are Twins top prospects that will end up at 1B likely as well. And I am not talking about Sano/Walker who people slate as first basemen for some reason The Twins are loaded at first base.
  4. From my perspective, the situation is worse than the list implies because it does not consider players who were released. RA Dickey (signed by the Mets and after a Cy Young year traded for Syndergard and Travis d'Arnaud). You will find threads on TD trying to address acquiring front line starters and what to do about the catching position. Pat Neshek pitched well for the Astros this year. Chris Colabella would have been great at DH (before Sano). I realize the situation with Colabella is slightly complicated because of his injury last April and his high BABIP, however keeping Doug Bernier on the 40 man roster and releasing Colabella made little sense for a last place team. Also, Sean Gilmartin pitched very well for the Mets after being selected in Rule 5 draft. The Mets, who have one of the best pitching staffs in baseball were picking from an organization with one of the worst MLB pitching staffs. The implication here is the Twins are doing a poor job of evaluating talent. Do the Twins have any commitment to sabermetric analysis? I think we have alot to learn from the Cardinals and Houston in that category. David
  5. Nope. The Twins have too many pitchers. Find a way to offload Santana and Nolasco. Then I'd love to see Greinke on the team.
  6. I think paying for a guy coming off of a career year and who is going to be 32 is probably not a good idea.
  7. 1 point
    Twins fans you want a stud as your number 1 pitcher that will command 25 to 35 million over 5 years even though he is 32 years old this is your guy. After opting out of his current contract I say why not. I am really interested in opinions on this one. We don't have to trade anyone and coming off a season with a 1.66 ERA give me a better option.
  8. I think it's time to go ahead and tackle this topic. It's no secret that one of the prime reasons the Twins improved from a 90+ loss team to an 80+ Wildcard contender is they put together the best overall starting rotation they have had in years. It was downright respectable! And there were very few of the 3rd inning blowout sogoaheadandturnthestationorgettoyourhoneydolistsinceyouhadnothingbettertodo games. Despite a down-ish year from Hughes, half a season from Santana, brief contributions from Nolasco, May being removed from the rotation, having to actually depend on Mike Pelfrey every 5th day, and assorted injuries late in the season, the Twins were very close to shaving a run off their ERA from the year before. Imagine what better health, Santana for a full season and just a little better luck here and there could have meant?! But while we know how important pitching is to the game, while we are all a bit giddy that our beloved Twins actually had some and may have more coming, there is still a thought of "more" floating out there. As in more=better. What can we do to take that next step? So the questions for 2016 and the Twins starting rotation are: Should we try to get better? Can we really get better? How much better can we be and how do we get there? First, let's look at what is in house: 1) Phil Hughes. He was an outstanding FA acquisition for 2014 and had probably the best year of his career. His "pedigree" is outstanding, probably as strong as feelings of frustration over inconsistency in his career. But he has won 15 games 3 times, an OK AL ERA, a solid Whip, and excellent SO/BB ratio. After a bit of a slow start in '14 he was excellent. In '15 his slow start lingered a bit longer, and while he never quite hit his '14 stride, he actually pitched very well for about half a season before injuries slowed and shelved him. Talented, strapping and happy in Minnesota, I think a return to his 2014 numbers, or close, is not to be unexpected if healthy. 2) Ervin Santana. There is no question only half season from Santana was greatly disappointing. Despite the surprise first half contributions from Pelfrey, you almost have to believe having Santana for the full season would have been worth at least a couple more wins. An examination of Santana's career shows him to be very, very consistent. You can almost guarantee 32 GS, 195-ish IP, 165 SO and at least 13 wins with a shot at 14-17 if on a quality team. There are no guarantees, of course, but he seems healthy and fit for 2016 after his half season with the Twins. Looking beyond a couple weeks in August when he was very much off, he sandwiched some outstanding pitching to begin and end his inaugural Twins season. 3) Kyle Gibson. I get frustrated when people jump on Gibson. He is not exactly old, lost a season to TJ surgery, made a hell of a quick recovery back to the mound and competence, and has only pitched 2 seasons in the ML. And all he has done is pitch solid one year, pitch even better the second year, and at various times has been the Twins best starter. In his 2 ML seasons, Gibson has had moments of brilliance where he looks like a possible #1, and no worse than a quality #2 SP. Now, he's not really going to be a #1 pitcher, more than likely, but the point is how good he can be at times...that he is still improving...and really just needs a little more consistency. Only 2 years in the league, I think we can count on some additional improvement. 4) May. He might look great in the bullpen, but you just don't take a young arm talent like him out of the rotation until or unless you don't have a choice. The control issues that we heard would hold him back from being a top of the rotation starter have been curtailed. He showed real sign of improvement when still in the rotation, and lead the Twins in several categories. 5) Duffey. Converted from relief, the curveball specialist...along with Sano...almost single-handedly preserved the Twins second half last season. He was darn near "Ace-like" during his couple months of performances. I don't think anyone expects him to be a top rotation SP, but is what he showed all sustainable? Even close? We sure need to find out and he deserves the chance to prove it. 6) Milone. He is nothing special. But he is a pitcher. And he showed, when healthy, why he has won previously despite pedestrian stuff. Simply, he appears to be a very solid be counted back of the rotation contributor that can win. But he also has the least upside of any candidate here. And with a few breakdowns here and there, I wonder if he might be best as a swing man. 7) Berrios. I believe he has a very solid chance to break with the club. What could hold him back is not service time, but rather, a logjam of options in the rotation and bullpen and the Twins letting him get a month in AAA while they sort through various options. 8) Nolasco. A big wild card. He is not a bad pitcher. The majority of his career has been unspectacular, but very solid and consistent. But he must have signed his Twins contract with a cursed pen. He could help. He could surprise. He could be needed if an injury bug suddenly hits the Twins in ST. But otherwise...this is the one guy the Twins should be trying to move in any manner they can. If you accept the numbers provided by MLTraderumors, the Twins would enter 2016 about $10M under the top payroll the team has ever had. Could and would the Twins be willing to top that mark? I believe they would. While not earth shattering, the Twins have added payroll before when the addition(s) in question meant winning. Also, said highest payroll ever will have been 5 years removed. Inflation and all don't ya know! But how much higher than $10M might they go? Another $10M? That gives you $20M for a top of the rotation starter, but with needs still in the bullpen, and probably a bench bat, maybe help at catcher in the form of a FA as well. If you can move Nolasco, and say it only costs you half his salary each of the next 2 years to do so, you save another $6M. Based on projections, if you trade Plouffe as part of a deal somewhere, you save another $7M. That's another $13M or so, and you could add a couple more if they let Fien go. But you still have to address the pen, catcher, and maybe the bench as well, at some point. And if Plouffe is traded, do we then need to consider a DH signing? The whole point is the Twins have needs, assets, and also money to spend. But it's also a business. The Pohlads will not break out their American Express card for $20M per for 6 years on a player. Nor would anyone. The Twins have 3 choices here: 1) Trade 3-5 prospects/players for a young-ish top of the rotation SP to push their rotation and the team over the top. This allows your relative "choice" of said player, and possibly more cost control for the next 2-5 years. But you are going to lose 1 of Berrios, May, Gibson or Duffey for sure, probably Kepler, another milb pitcher or two, etc. Does this acquisition improve the team enough to warrant the cost in dollars and prospects? 2) Keep the prospects for yourself or additional moves, and fork out $18-23M for 5-6 years for a 30-32 yo FA SP. You've got, in theory, $10M to work with though, and another $13-15M if you can swing some moves. Could you possibly move Hughes or Santana as well as Nolasco? Because we still have finances to consider as well as additional additions. 3) Stay your hand. You move Nolasco. You may move Plouffe for additional help. But you believe in and trust a rebound for Hughes, Santana to keep on keeping on, Gibson, May, Duffey to continue to improve and make way for young stud Berrios. You re-in force the pen, add to catcher, possibly add a bench player or DH, and feel secure that you have a talent, deep, and mostly young rotation that would only be improved somewhat by another veteran starter. As long as what you have is healthy. Those are the rotation candidates. The team really has 3 options to consider in all of this. Should the team make a big move? Which option? How much does it improve the team? It's all your call.
  9. 2015 MLB Over/Under Contest! Win BIG!

    ashbury reacted to spinowner for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Shouldn't that be WINNAH! ?
  10. Why so much love for Plouffe?

    gil4 reacted to mazeville for a post in a topic

    1 point
    There's plenty of speculation, here and elsewhere, that Trevor Plouffe will be traded in the offseason to make way for Miguel Sano. Not surprisingly, this has led to something of a backlash among some who insist Trevor Plouffe shouldn't be traded. He's a productive third baseman and an "above average defender." Ugh. I'll agree Plouffe is reasonably productive and an above average defender. In no way does this make him an untradeable. But Plouffe is hardly a world-beater with the bat. He was 14th among league third basemen in OPS at .742. That's decidedly average. And he's 29, so it's not like his prime years are ahead of him. Granted, he led the Twins at 2.5 WAR, but that was more a fault of the Twins' lack of real top-flight players outside of Sano. The Twins have a logjam of corner infielders and designated hitters. Joe Mauer is more or less stuck at first for three more years, regardless of what Souhan wants. Some platoon option does nobody any favors. It certainly doesn't help a player like Sano get better at fielding grounders at third or first. You're not going to put Sano in the outfield, not when we have like 57 of them. The Twins would have to trade multiple outfielders to make room for him there. Maybe they could do that, and maybe they should. But you're still much better off in Target Field with an outfield of Rosario-Buxton-Hicks-Kepler. That leaves Plouffe the best option for a potential trade to break this logjam. And, because he is an apparent competent third baseman, and under team control for two more seasons, he should be able to get something in the trade market. Maybe it's a young pitcher. Maybe it's a catcher. This is how trades work. You trade from an area of plenty -- in this case third -- to shore up an area of need. And to get quality, you have to give up quality. Yet it drives me nuts when people insist that anybody good cannot be traded. Of course he can be traded! And once you trade Plouffe, you open things up. Sano can fit at third. If you're that scared of his defense, make Mauer play there and put Sano at first. (Mauer should have been the third baseman years ago). And then you open up DH for one of your can't-field bats, like Arcia or Josmil Pinto or Kennys Vargas. One of those guys has to be able to break through. And remember that Arcia hit 20-plus homers just one season ago. I like Trevor Plouffe. I don't like him enough that he has to be chained to his Twins uniform for life.
  11. 1 point
    There are better odds that one of us TD members will win the lottery than the Twins signing Grienke. He's probably hoping the Yankees or Red Sox create a bidding war but why leave LA? They can pay any price to resign him.
  12. Honestly as good as he is I just can't believe everyone thinks giving a 5-6 year deal to a 32 year old coming off a career best season would be a good idea. Nope.
  13. 1 point
    Grienke has professed respect for the Twins multiple times over the years. Still, I don't see it happening. I won't complain if it does, but I think signing pitchers to long term deals is basically throwing money away in the end. It's a long term commitment where only the few 1-3 years tends to actually pay off. (But I don't write the checks. Why should I complain if they're throwing money away.)
  14. Whew, Hughes, Milone and Nolasco in the bullpen is one stinky bullpen.
  15. 1 point
    Win Profit.
  16. At least three of the bullet items he listed are negatively impacted if you have a losing team. The other three are part of building a winning team. Nobody is forgetting about winning games. There is disagreement on the marginal cost of improving the odds of winning a World Series, given that 29 other teams to varying degrees are also trying and no amount of investment can insure a ring.
  17. The Twins 30 yr old + SP reminds me of buying something on CL that you thought would work perfectly for a task at hand. So you paid the asking price. You get it home and find out it worked, but not as well as you thought it would. When you try to get rid of it, you find that you cannot recoup your cost. And you either sell it for a loss, or are stuck with a "tool" that does work, but not at the level needed to get the project finished. Sooner or later a shop with too many underperforming "tools" has to get cleaned out.
  18. I don't think this can be fixed for 2016, just too many ugly contracts in the rotation. The goal should be to have no more than one pitcher over 30 on a multi-year deal come 2017. Don't worry about recouping list salary in the form of players, just move at minimum two of Nolasco, Hughes or Santana whenever they flash enough to tempt a team to take a chance on them, regardless of compensation.
  19. I could throw out fantasy scenarios, but long-time Twins fans know that the plan to improve the rotation is to pray that Hughes is better, that Nolasco is almost adequate, and that Berrios can provide a boost once his service clock has been delayed.
  20. The article was interesting and made a ton of good points, but still seemed pretty subjective. The list of acquired pitchers was pretty fantastic, even if it had just been Santana, Liriano and Nathan. That's a really impressive group. What's not impressive is those moves happened long, long ago. The article would have been more effective if the samples were shortened in years and the article instead discussed the suggested (though inflammatorily unexplored and thus unsupported) angle of the Twins not getting any SABR friendly players in the last decade or so since these kind of measurements have been easily accessible. It basically boiled down to saying "The Twins are bad at trades and free agency, except sometimes when they weren't last decade." Great try to explain why and propose a solution.
  21. Could Maloney be a Find?

    bird reacted to freshinthehouse for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Sounds like the Twins found their 1st basemen for AAA next year. Here's hoping he can rip it up in the Int'l league.
  22. Could Maloney be a Find?

    HitInAPinch reacted to Physics Guy for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Nothing wrong with this kind of signing, but most likely will just be minor league filler.
  23. Why so much love for Plouffe?

    Major League Ready reacted to SwainZag for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Trading Plouffe does not make them "sellers." It makes them a team who is trading off a surplus to make the team better in other areas. Whether or not those other areas are on the ML team right now, or pieces for a later time, or for a later trade is to be seen. If money wasn't a thing and the Twins could just have Plouffe for the next 5-6 years, then yeah.....hang on to him, but with him starting to get paid rather well this off season and needing a multi year deal after that......they need to decide what's right to do.
  24. Could Maloney be a Find?

    HitInAPinch reacted to Kwak for a post in a topic

    1 point
    So desperate.
  25. Twins outlook - mlbtraderumors

    nytwinsfan reacted to SwainZag for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Is there any stats or evidence to back this up?
  26. 1 point
    He won't even be pursued. Pohlad already stated "$120MM... after pay raises.." plus "...[i don't like] long-term contracts...". That interview excludes the addition of a Grienke, not to mention Grienke's personal preferences (maybe he fancies LA?). The thread makes grist for the posting mill, but little else.
  27. Whaddya think-- Gardy to the Nats?

    Willihammer reacted to Thrylos for a post in a topic

    1 point
    A couple things: Kids. Vavra has 2 sons in the system: 25 year old Tanner Vavra hitting .258/.346/.300 (.646 OPS) in A+, as 2.4 years older than the league and 23 year old Trey Vavra hitting .346/.406/.538 in A, as 1.6 years older that the league. Tanner looks like his dad, but Trey is a bit taller and more athletic. Tanner is not doing that well, Trey is indeed doing unexpectedly well, but got to see what he can do in AAA Vavra replaced Al Newman in the Twins' coaching stuff after the 2005 season. Ullger moved to Newman's position (third base) and Vavra to Ullger's (hitting.) Not outside of the organization. Vavra was the Twins' minor league fielding coordinator from 2002-2005... Not one of the original Gardy 5, but Gardy's guy for seven seasons, from 2006-2014
  28. I like it... And, I do believe Turner and Garver will catch in the big leagues.
  29. Mets win!

    whosafraidofluigirussolo reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic

    1 point
    I was surprised there wasn't discussion by the broadcast team (though I was in and out, and maybe missed it). As the play was developing I was mostly expecting him to let it drop. Early inning or not, with a stud on the mound I thought it would be the percentage play.
  30. Several other guys are getting raises. The real difference is maybe $5-7m, can't remember the exact numbers.
  31. 1 point
    Sure. It isn't my money. Let me see...... Greinke ...... or any of the pitchers the Twins have..... yup.... I'll take Greinke.
  32. 1 point
    Hunter 10.5mm and Pelfrey 5.5mm off the books?
  33. 1 point
    No. Zimmerman is a much better choice (and even then, the Twins need to find a home for one of Hughes, Santana and Nolasco)
  34. I would concur the Twins, as an organization, are not primarily focused on winning the WS. But I view that as a weakness, not a strength. And not a weakness shared by all 30 MLB teams.
  35. You say this with such conviction. The Minnesota Twins organization is a business. I could come up with a half dozen things would without question be more important to judging a GM than World Series Appearances. 1. Leadership 2. Financial Performance 3. Managing / Elevating the Twins Brand 4. Risk Mitigation 5. Asset Management – Primarily related to minor league development given the Twins revenue relative to the top markets. 6. Developing methodologies that provide competitive advantage (Saber Metrics / Scouting, etc)T The exact six measures are debatable but this is a business and the people who run them measure success differently than fans.
  36. Judging a GM only on trades or only on free agent signing or only on draft picks, does not make any sense. If there were a singular thing a GM chould be judged on is World Championships and World Series appearances. Ryan is oh for 17 in those metrics. But there is isn't. Ryan did make a couple of good trades, did botch a couple of others, did sign a couple of decent free agents and did sign a bunch of bad ones and let a future hall of famer go. The thing with Ryan is risk adversity. And it shows in many ways: Will not make a blockbuster, will not trade players and prospects at the peak of their value and will not sign top of the line free agents. Instead he will make small, corrective type of moves of medium risk, medium reward. That's ok if you have a team like the Yankees had a decade ago. Not ok for the 2010s Twins... Got to risk something to get a high reward. Too bad that this piece does not get this and does not look at the big picture here... Cannot look at trades in a vacuum
  37. That's why they're in the 40s. Some good potential on this list, but injuries or inconsistent play or scouting reports or whatever have them here. If these guys were top 20 guys, it'd be worrisome. That this group is 41-50 should be pretty encouraging for what's left on the list. Even after some really good prospects 'graduated' from prospect rankings.
  38. What's weird is that they had Turner skip the Midwest League. He's advanced defensively, but if they wanted the bat to catch up, it would have been nice to put him at Cedar Rapids. Then instead of keeping him at Ft. Myers to start this year, he jumped up to AA right away. I'm not saying that's right or wrong... but if it was me, I'd have Garver and Turner both start the year at AA next year. I think an extra half-season there for Turner would be beneficial. In fact, it wouldn't hurt for him to spend the full season there in the hopes that his bat will catch up a little. He doesn't need to be a great hitter to be a valuable MLB catcher, but he has to be OK.
  39. Yeah, I read it but it's dubious. We'll be fine.
  40. Well, nice to see a critique that says the Twins are good at drafting and developing talent. I thought that was the reason the Twins were bad. We'll be fine. Besides the AJ trade, Ryan collected Milton, Silva, Punto, Ortiz, Bartlett, Lohse, Guerrier, Stewart, Guzman, Ford, Liriano, Castillo and Casilla.
  41. He had a really solid second half. I think Garver is still a legit future big leaguer. The power dropped, but that's not unusual in the FSL. He takes a lot of walks, has a very professional approach. And, as I've mentioned before, pitchers love throwing to him and working with him. His defense has improved. And, it's far from now-or-never for Garver or Turner.
  42. 1 point
    Please write that book! I'll buy a copy. And regarding that "welcoming party"; I was there. It was one of the most intense emotional Twins-related experiences in my life. I get misty just thinking about it.
  43. Why so much love for Plouffe?

    glunn reacted to David HK for a post in a topic

    1 point
    He is a Cali boy- might welcome a return home.
  44. Why so much love for Plouffe?

    glunn reacted to David HK for a post in a topic

    1 point
    In that alternate universe, where Spock wears the goatee, we could trade 2nd-half Dozier, and keep 1st-half Dozier. That would be swell. And logical.
  45. Why so much love for Plouffe?

    gil4 reacted to RedBull34 for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Have you seen his hair? It's gorgeous.
This leaderboard is set to Chicago/GMT-06:00

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.