World Series Winners Typically Add Midstream; Can Twins Buck Recent Trend?

[Derek Wetmore]

Can the Twins buck the recent trend of World Series winners' path to a championship? Not since the 2009 Yankees has a team won it all without the help of a significant addition at the Trade Deadline. The Twins, rounding into better health with the return of three key players, will try to accomplish that feat this October.With Byron Buxton and Michael Pineda back in action – and now that Josh Donaldson is the proud owner of two healthy calves and back in the fold – the Twins must feel like they picked up some nice late-season additions for the low, low price of some mid-summer discomfort. Patience, not prospects, turned out to be the reasonable asking price to add a couple of stars to their clubhouse at the MLB Trade Deadline.

 

Hey, it sure beats giving up Royce Lewis.

 

And while the Twins’ claims that health should help point the bow of this ship back in the right direction, I couldn’t help but compare them to teams in recent years with similar aspirations. How many recent World Series winners – Minnesota’s stated and obvious goal – have won it all without making a significant in-season addition by way of a trade?

 

It depends on the definition of ‘significant addition’ and also that of ‘recent,’ but the truth of it is that no team did that trick in the last decade. We’ll have to go back to the 2009 super Yankees team that won the World Series without an important addition at the trade deadline. (In fairness, they did purchase Chad Gaudin from the Padres that summer, and he was useful in the regular season, with a 3.43 ERA in 42 innings for the Yankees, split between starting and relief; he wasn’t much of a factor in October.)

 

So, that’s the stage the Twins have set. They’ll be bucking the recent trend if they can get to and win the World Series, with only a minor trade (Ildemaro Vargas) and subsequent release.

 

2019, Nationals

 

Traded for Daniel Hudson, Roenis Elias and Hunter Strickland. The most noteworthy addition, Hudson, didn’t have a great World Series overall but he did close out Game 7 and how many people on this planet can say that?

 

They also signed Asdrubal Cabrera as a free agent on August 6. He had six hits as the starting second baseman in the World Series, pushing Brian Dozier to the bench.

 

(World Series losers Houston Astros went for it by adding Zack Greinke at the trade deadline.)

 

2018, Red Sox

 

Traded for Steve Pearce, who was great (you’ll remember the June trade that yielded a future World Series MVP); Nathan Eovaldi (who pitched so well in three games that he got paid a large sum of money); and Ian Kinsler.

 

The Dodgers that year traded for Brian Dozier and only slightly more notably, Manny Machado, who famously did not hustle.

 

2017, Astros*

 

Their pre-deadline acquisitions included lefty reliever Francisco Liriano and Codebreaker. August trades brought Tyler Clippard and, oh yeah, Justin Verlander.

 

The Dodgers, who technically lost the World Series, traded for Yu Darvish (two World Series starts, which now only serve to make us sad – he got rocked for nine runs in just 3 1/3 combined innings to the very-possibly-cheating Astros). L.A. also traded for Tony Cingrani (three WS games) and Tony Watson (two WS games), plus an August trade for Curtis Granderson.

 

2016, Cubs

 

Chicago, you’ll remember, traded Gleyber Torres for Aroldis Chapman. They also added Mike Montgomery (five World Series games) and Joe Smith, who pitched well to help get them there but then didn’t pitch in the postseason.

 

Derek Falvey’s Indians traded for Andrew Miller, and made an August trade for Coco Crisp.

 

2015, Royals

 

Traded for Johnny Cueto and Ben Zobrist.

 

The Mets traded for, among others, Tyler Clippard (A’s), Yoenis Céspedes (Tigers), and a waiver trade for Addison Reed who appeared in five World Series games before he pitched with the Twins.

 

2014, Giants

 

Traded for Jake Peavy, who pitched well down the stretch (2.17 ERA in 12 starts with SF) but then got lit up in his two starts in the World Series (four runs in five innings in his first start, Game 2; and chased in the second inning of an eventual 10-0 loss in Game 6).

 

2013, Red Sox

 

Added Jake Peavy in a three-team trade (with the Tigers and the White Sox). You might not remember the ‘13 Red Sox as “Jake Peavy’s Red Sox,” but he did start Game 3 of the World Series for them.

 

2012, Giants

 

Giants swept the Tigers and Sergio Romo saved three of the four games. San Francisco traded for Marco Scutaro and Hunter Pence, and the pair combined for eight hits and six runs between them in the Fall Classic.

 

2011, Cardinals

 

The Cards swung an eight-player deal – which famously included ex-Twin P.J. Walters – that netted Octavio Dotel, Edwin Jackson, Corey Patterson and Marc Rzepcynski. Dotel and Rzepcynski appeared in nine games between the two of them, and Jackson started Game 4.

 

2010, Giants

 

This is the first one where you’d argue with the term “significant trade” acquisition. Midstream they picked up Chris Ray, Javier Lopez, Ramon Ramirez, and, in August, Mike Fontenot and Jose Guillen. And they picked up future NLCS MVP Cody Ross on waivers in late August.

 

Of the pitchers, Lopez and Ramirez combined for 1 2/3 innings in the World Series, and the others didn’t appear. However – and I know this doesn’t technically count here because of when he was added - Ross was on base eight times and scored five runs in the World Series for the Giants. He played all three outfield spots down the stretch and hit .288/.354/.466 after joining San Francisco from the Florida Marlins.

 

If you liked this piece and want to read more from Derek Wetmore ...

— Subscribe to the 5 Thoughts newsletter

— Or listen to the 5 Thoughts podcast

 

MORE FROM TWINS DAILY

— Latest Twins coverage from our writers

— Recent Twins discussion in our forums

— Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook or email

 

Click here to view the article

[DocBauer]

Yeah, adding Verlander was a small and surprising addition, huh?

 

I don't know. There are a lot of guys listed here who helped. But for every Verlander, there is a Hudson or Pearce, etc, who does something special. Baseball history is filled with guys who stepped forward in a 7 game series to make a difference. Some were acquired, some were already on their respective teams.

 

But even if some of those acquired players shined in their moments, the team still wouldn't have been there without the nucleus of the team already intact. But other than Clevinger and the Diamonbacks closer...forgetting his name at the moment...where was a difference maker moved?

 

How could ANYONE predict any of the players moved over the last 2 days could suddenly rise up and be a hero? You just can't.

 

But you CAN, IMO, speculate that a really good team...despite a recent, AWEFULL, 6 game losing streak...can get much better by just getting back Donaldson, Buxton, Hill and Pineda. Hopefully Odorizzi and Stashak soon as well. Get all that back and the hitters, hopefully, make a few more adjustments over the next few weeks, and where and how would any trades have made a difference?

 

Just my opinion.

[DocBauer]

Yeah, adding Verlander was a small and surprising addition, huh?

 

I don't know. There are a lot of guys listed here who helped. But for every Verlander, there is a Hudson or Pearce, etc, who does something special. Baseball history is filled with guys who stepped forward in a 7 game series to make a difference. Some were acquired, some were already on their respective teams.

 

But even if some of those acquired players shined in their moments, the team still wouldn't have been there without the nucleus of the team already intact. But other than Clevinger and the Diamonbacks closer...forgetting his name at the moment...where was a difference maker moved?

 

How could ANYONE predict any of the players moved over the last 2 days could suddenly rise up and be a hero? You just can't.

 

But you CAN, IMO, speculate that a really good team...despite a recent, AWEFULL, 6 game losing streak...can get much better by just getting back Donaldson, Buxton, Hill and Pineda. Hopefully Odorizzi and Stashak soon as well. Get all that back and the hitters, hopefully, make a few more adjustments over the next few weeks, and where and how would any trades have made a difference?

 

Just my opinion.

[Otwins]

Nothing in 2020 has been normal so why not win it with no additions. Good to see you writing again.

[Trov]

I would not say a middle of road player that made big plays a big trade.  Yes, some teams made huge trades that paid off well, but many of the names you listed would not move the dial all too often.  So they added some players, but we would never know how it would play out if they did not, would the replacement have played the same, or worse.  We do not know.  Lets play this year out and see.  Dodger made no trades and everyone still thinks they should win the whole thing.

[dex8425]

The Yankees also did nothing. This was definitely a different trade deadline, with only a couple teams making significant moves. It's 2020. This year is different. 

[Brock Beauchamp]

On top of this being a bizarre year, tbe Twins are a team that can improve but has no glaring weakness if the roster is healthy.

 

And, until last night, it looked like the roster was on its way to health.

 

While there’s no predicting injury, I still feel they missed a bit by not acquiring a RH corner outfielder, even moreso now that Kepler is down.

 

Then again, they could just call up Rooker.

 

Please call up Rooker.

[bighat]

Why any team would trade valuable prospects this year is beyond me.

 

I think most teams are looking at 2020 as an exhibition season, and so are about 75% of the fans. Play the hand you're dealt and if you get lucky on the river card you might just win the whole thing. Nothing more nothing less.

 

I'm frankly kinda baffled to see that any trades were made at the deadline.

[Brock Beauchamp]

 

Why any team would trade valuable prospects this year is beyond me.

 

I think most teams are looking at 2020 as an exhibition season, and so are about 75% of the fans. Play the hand you're dealt and if you get lucky on the river card you might just win the whole thing. Nothing more nothing less.

 

I'm frankly kinda baffled to see that any trades were made at the deadline.

Clevenger made a ton of sense, as he's controlled beyond this season.

 

Which is reportedly what the Twins were also pursuing, which makes sense... it just didn't work out for the Twins and I'm pretty okay with that, really.

 

I think this offseason is going to be primed to pick up whatever your team needs on the relative cheap. There are going to be some financially-strapped teams that simply won't be playing in the market as they normally do. I hope the Twins aren't one of those teams and given their (lack of) financial commitments, I suspect they'll be players this offseason.

[Shaitan]

I see no correlation here.

 

How many teams have made big trades and not won the World Series? Way more.

[bighat]

 

Clevenger made a ton of sense, as he's controlled beyond this season.

 

Which is reportedly what the Twins were also pursuing, which makes sense... it just didn't work out for the Twins and I'm pretty okay with that, really.

Yeah, I guess pursuing controlled guys does make sense - for some reason my mind was just focused on the "rentals" when I made that post. But you're right when it comes to the guys with years of control.

 

[woolywoolhouse]

The last time the Twins won the World Series - or even made an appearance - was 1991; that year, they didn't make any significant trades at the deadline either. 

 

Am I grasping for straws? You're damn right I am.