March 15, 201610 yr I guess this would be my crack at it: Pitchers (12)Nick BurdiTyler DuffeyCasey FienKyle GibsonPhil HughesKevin JepsenTommy MiloneRicky NolascoRyan O'RourkeGlen PerkinsRyan PresslyErvin Santana Catchers (2)John Ryan MurphyKurt Suzuki Infield (6)Brian DozierEduardo EscobarJoe MauerEduardo NunezByung Ho ParkTrevor Plouffe Outfield (5)Byron Buxton (will be interesting to see if he even makes it)Carlos QuentinMax Kepler (praying he comes north)Eddie RosarioMiguel Sano Lost to Waivers:Danny SantanaOswaldo ArciaJ.R. Graham (unsure of options, but Burdi has him beat as of now, IMHO) Minors:Alex MeyerJorge Polanco (he's MLB-ready now)Kennys Vargas DUDE, no offense, but you're insane for forgetting Trevor May Trevor May is on, NIck Burdi is in AA And Plz Twins Take Santana, over Sweeney/ Quentin or even Buxton YOu have to have a guy to play SS...... BECAUSE if Dozier or Plouffe Go Down for any leght of time Escobar is the fill-in
March 15, 201610 yr I keep seeing people say they want Nolasco off the roster... Well, who do promote to replace him? Pat Dean? Does that matter? A bullpen isn't a group of seven guys who throw innings based on a hat draw. Guys have specified roles and the role slotted for Nolasco is not a role you'd give to Meyer, Burdi, or one of the other talented young arms. He's a three inning mop-up guy who might spot start in a pinch. I get that people dislike Nolasco but, come on... Booting him off the roster just for the sake of booting him off the roster is bad asset management.
March 15, 201610 yr DUDE, no offense, but you're insane for forgetting Trevor May Trevor May is on, NIck Burdi is in AA And Plz Twins Take Santana, over Sweeney/ Quentin or even Buxton YOu have to have a guy to play SS...... BECAUSE if Dozier or Plouffe Go Down for any leght of time Escobar is the fill-inThe team still has Nunez to play Short. I don't think they'll carry Danny Santana if they have a roster crunch. He's just not hitting or fielding well in ST.
March 15, 201610 yr Author DUDE, no offense, but you're insane for forgetting Trevor May Trevor May is on, NIck Burdi is in AA Oh yeah... duh. Pitchers (12)Trevor MayTyler DuffeyCasey FienKyle GibsonPhil HughesKevin JepsenTommy MiloneRicky NolascoRyan O'RourkeGlen PerkinsRyan PresslyErvin SantanaCatchers (2)John Ryan MurphyKurt SuzukiInfield (6)Brian DozierEduardo EscobarJoe MauerEduardo NunezByung Ho ParkTrevor PlouffeOutfield (5)Byron Buxton (will be interesting to see if he even makes it)Carlos QuentinMax Kepler (praying he comes north)Eddie RosarioMiguel Sano Nunez is backup SS.
March 15, 201610 yr See, I would say the plan along being option him to AAA this year makes it even WORSE. He's going to be 27 next season. Meyer, Burdi, Reed, Melotakis, Chargois, etc. I mean at what point is he even going to be a viable option in the bullpen? At least the plan was all along for Santana to start eventually. He's not going to become a pumpkin at 27. Depth and competition is a good thing. Our scouts found Pressly and Graham for $50,000 a piece. I don't see a downside.
March 16, 201610 yr It's not a huge deal. Just the same thing they do every year being too conservative with the younger guys that annoys me at the beginning of every season. I'd take Kepler off the bench over Arcia or Santana certainly, and I don't even know what business Nunez has on the roster at all. I think they could have made reasonable improvements to the bullpen by experimenting a bit instead of say, going with the devils they do know in Fien, Pressly, or of course Nolasco like you mentioned. They may well be delaying the clock on Berrios but I think we can agree he'd have a good chance at being the class of that rotation right now if given the chance and I hope we all get to see him up as soon as possible. Other than that, it's fine and that offense even looks a little bit competitive to me!I would rather see Orourke, Burdi, Chargois round out our pen instead of rule 5ers, reclamation projects or guys we are afraid to DFA(see the past 4-5 years for examples). Arcia will make the team. He is not the most ready guy to help the team from opening day. Kepler is way more mature with his at bats. Plouffe will play 3b while our MVP will relocate to right field and play lesser defense than Kepler could. Add Nolasco to the list somewhere. If your a guy fighting to get to the majors I doubt you care about poor Ricky or asset management. If your a starting lineup guy, I doubt you care as much about asset management as you do surrounding yourself with the best possible guys from opening day. Biggest problem facing the Twins is Ryan's aversion to either fishing or cutting bait on any level. Rather, he delays everything as long as possible while avoiding making decisive decisions. Edited March 16, 201610 yr by Spikecurveball
March 16, 201610 yr Chargois has looked really polished and clearly has back end reliever type stuff. Imagine him coming in when Casey Fien blows his next 3 run lead. Burdi should have a spot based on pure entertainment value alone (does anybody still feel like they get entertained by the twins or are we all just self flagellating ourselves with this team??) They have the pieces for an exciting bullpen at the very least, let alone the sorry state of the bench they're going to break camp with I'm sure.
March 16, 201610 yr He's not going to become a pumpkin at 27. Depth and competition is a good thing. Our scouts found Pressly and Graham for $50,000 a piece. I don't see a downside. The downside is that his roster spot in 2015 could have been used by someone who actually contributed to the team, allowed for a 12 man pitching staff instead of 13, etc. They were in the playoff hunt until the last weekend of the season... Guys like him are a dime a dozen, and regularly available
March 16, 201610 yr Checking B-Ref this morning, it looks like my Opposition Quality ("OppQual") ranking theory produces a pretty likely roster now, with the exception of Park (who of course is playing under special circumstances this spring). Relief PitchersMayJepsenGraham*KintzlerFienPerkinsAbad * I'd still guess Pressly takes Graham's spot here, but Graham does still lead in the early "OppQual" rankings, and maybe the team would want Pressly to start at AAA as a sort of rehab after his injury shortened 2015? CatchersSuzukiMurphy InfieldersSantanaEscobarDozierPlouffeNunez OutfieldersRosarioArciaSanoBuxton 1B/DHMauerPark** ** Like I said, Park actually trails a couple guys in OppQual but that's more a function of his extra early usage And of course OppQual doesn't really matter for judging starting pitcher "opportunity" so I'll just pick a likely 5, bumping Duffey. Starting PitchersSantanaHughesGibsonNolascoMilone Quentin and Sweeney are close behind too, I could see one of them taking Arcia's spot. Santana's positional versatility probably preserves his spot, although they have given Rosario a few looks in CF lately, and Sweeney has some reps there too. And "second backup infielder" probably isn't as vital given the starting group we have.
March 16, 201610 yr Maybe addressed elsewhere, but why did Duffey start a minor league game on Sunday? Nolasco had a 60 pitch limit in the MLB game, and we spent 4 IP on relievers who were immediately sent to minor league camp after the game. To me, that implies Duffey is probably the odd starter out right now.
March 16, 201610 yr Also, here is the current order of starters: Santana / BerriosGibsonHughes / MayNolasco / DuffeyMilone That looks like their preferred season-opening rotation, barring injury or trade. The backup starters even seem arranged by preference and potential opportunity (ranking Duffey, May, and finally Berrios, with the top two likely needing replacement being Nolasco and Hughes). Santana would be in line to start opening day on regular rest, and Gibson would start the home opener too, which seems like the kind of opportunity/reward the Twins would plan for those two. Edited March 16, 201610 yr by spycake
March 16, 201610 yr Maybe addressed elsewhere, but why did Duffey start a minor league game on Sunday? Nolasco had a 60 pitch limit in the MLB game, and we spent 4 IP on relievers who were immediately sent to minor league camp after the game. To me, that implies Duffey is probably the odd starter out right now.If Duffey is the odd man out, that brings up an interesting dilemma. Does he immediately become the first call-up for ineffective play or injury? Or is Berrios still first in line when there is an opening?
March 16, 201610 yr If Duffey is the odd man out, that brings up an interesting dilemma. Does he immediately become the first call-up for ineffective play or injury? Or is Berrios still first in line when there is an opening?Unless Duffey scuffles in AAA, I'd guess he would be first in line. I don't think the Twins are in that big of a rush to get Berrios up here.
March 16, 201610 yr Even with Duffey's rough start, I'm still predicting he gets the 5th spot. Hopefully he shows something better in his next couple outings to make this an easy decision, because Nolasco has been just as bad so far. Also, the scenario being discussed above where Berrios is the second guy in line to be called up from AAA if Duffey starts down there is just simply not fun to think about.
March 16, 201610 yr Author I like to sort by "OppQual" at B-Ref to determine the likely roster. That's showing you who's getting the first crack at playing time this spring against other team's A-listers, and thus who is probably on track to make the opening day roster. Thanks for sharing that; very useful.
March 19, 201610 yr No early opt-out for Quentin. I think they send him to Rochester. Sweeney has an opt-out and Santana hasn't hit at all. I think Danny''s injury might get worse if he doesn't start hitting.
March 19, 201610 yr Quentin is coming north. I think it would be crazy to release Arcia to hold on to Quentin out of Spring Training. The Twins have until June 1 to make a decision on Quentin.
March 19, 201610 yr I think it would be crazy to release Arcia to hold on to Quentin out of Spring Training. The Twins have until June 1 to make a decision on Quentin. Yeah, I doubt he comes north but damn, he has looked good this spring. Yeah, yeah, I know... Spring Training SSS and all that but the guy has done everything he can do to force himself onto the roster.
March 19, 201610 yr Yeah, I doubt he comes north but damn, he has looked good this spring. Yeah, yeah, I know... Spring Training SSS and all that but the guy has done everything he can do to force himself onto the roster.I hear the White Sox are looking for a 1B/DH type. Maybe we can trade them Quentin for Sale?
March 19, 201610 yr Yeah, I doubt he comes north but damn, he has looked good this spring. Yeah, yeah, I know... Spring Training SSS and all that but the guy has done everything he can do to force himself onto the roster.I agree and it wasn't that long ago that Carlos was a baseball force with the Sox. It's not unreasonable to think he can't be a force again. It would be nice if baseball actually worked... You know... Best player makes the club... But it doesn't. Rules say that we can't keep Arcia in Rochester until he's 40. That is probably fair to Arcia but someone has to pay the price for that rule and it will be Carlos... For a couple of months at least.
March 19, 201610 yr I hear the White Sox are looking for a 1B/DH type. Maybe we can trade them Quentin for Sale?I bet Kahn took a couple of phone calls from other GM's to see if Sale needed to removed from the situation.
Create an account or sign in to comment