Mine would look like this:

 

AL

 

Starters

 

C Stephen Vogt

1B Miguel Cabrera

2B Jason Kipnis

SS Xander Bogaerts

3B Josh Donaldson

OF Mike Trout

OF Josh Reddick

OF Adam Jones

DH Nelson Cruz

 

Reserves

 

C Russell Martin

C Salvador Perez

1B Albert Pujols

1B Prince Fielder

2B Brian Dozier

2B Dustin Pedroia

SS Jose Iglesias

3B Manny Machado

OF Yoenis Cespedes

OF Michael Brantley

OF George Springer

DH Alex Rodriguez

 

Pitchers

 

Chris Sale

Chris Archer

Corey Kluber

Sonny Gray

Felix Hernandez

Dallas Keuchel

Michael Pineda

David Price

Dellin Betances

Andrew Miller

Glen Perkins

Wade Davis

Zach Britton

 

NL

 

Starters

 

C Buster Posey

1B Paul Goldschmidt

2B Dee Gordon

SS Jhonny Peralta

3B Todd Frazier

OF Bryce Harper

OF Giancarlo Stanton

OF Joc Pederson

 

Reserves

 

C Yadier Molina

C Derrick Norris

1B Joey Votto

1B Anthony Rizzo

1B Freddie Freeman

2B Kolton Wong

SS Troy Tulowitzki

3B Matt Carpenter

3B Nolan Arenado

OF AJ Pollock

OF Starlin Marte

OF Ryan Braun

OF Andrew McCutchen

 

Pitchers

 

Max Scherzer

Gerrit Cole

Clayton Kershaw

Jacob DeGrom

Michael Wacha

Madison Bumgarner

Cole Hamels

Zack Greinke

Aroldis Chapman

Kevin Siegrist

Mark Melancon

Trevor Rosenthal

 

My AL roster:

 

Starters

C Salvador Perez

1B Eric Hosmer

2B Omar Infante

SS Alcides Escobar

3B Mike Moustakas

OF Alex Gordon

OF Lorenzo Cain

OF Alex Rios

DH Kendrys Morales

 

Reserves

C Drew Butera

2B Christian Colon

OF Jarrod Dyson

 

Pitchers

Edinson Volquez

Jeremy Guthrie

Chris Young

Joe Blanton

Yohan Pino

Greg Holland

Wade Davis

Ryan Madson

Franklin Morales

Kelvin Herrera

Jason Frasor

Brandon Finnegan

Luke Hochevar

 

I know what you're thinking -- "how can an all-star team only have a 3 man bench"?  I just think this starting 9 is that good.  

I would fully get on board with a Drew Butera write in campaign.