Aggregate Twins and MLB Top Prospect List

[kvothe]

Hey all,

I put together an aggregate of all of the major national top prospect lists (and TD's list). Thought I'd post here in case anyone else was interested.

 

http://i.imgur.com/UHmQUSC.png

 

Some notes:

• In a few cases, the rankings changed a bit between the time when the Twins list was published vs. the MLB list. In cases like these (Kiley for example), I edited the Twins rankings to match up with the order that prospects appeared on the MLB list.
• List is sorted based on the number of Twins prospects lists they appear on, with the average ranking as the tie breaker. I didn't do any editorializing to bump prospects I (dis)like up or down.
• Sean Gilmartin appeared on one list that was made before the Rule 5 draft.
• Only Mayo's list was done after the Rule 5 draft, so it's possible that JR Graham would be on more lists if they were updated today.
• Avg = Average ranking
• # = Number of lists a prospect appears on
• Hi = Highest ranking
• Lo = Lowest ranking
• Δ = Difference between Hi and Lo ranking
• HM = Honorable Mention. This could be anywhere from 101 to 200+, depending on the list
• There is a lot of guesswork on my part with regard to the Level, but it is meant to be the level where they will start 2015. If you find some information that contradicts my list, let me know and I will update

[diehardtwinsfan]

I like it.  Good work.

[Thrylos]

Good effort, but I think that you got way few data points there, because I know at least 2 lists that Buxton was not rated the Twins' number 1 prospect this season...   The "nationals" all agree on that, but...

[gunnarthor]

Nice work.