Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • entries
    891
  • comments
    3,675
  • views
    1,591,230

Trevor Plouffe Has A Home With Minnesota


Ted Schwerzler

2,194 views

 Share

Twins Video

Coming into the season, arguably one of the most head-scratching decisions the Minnesota Twins made was to load up on first basemen and designated hitter types. There was Miguel Sano, Joe Mauer, Trevor Plouffe, and then the acquisition of Byung Ho Park. Given the scarcity of at bats to go around, more questions than answers were present in regards to how it would all work. Now nearing the end of the 2016 campaign, it seems the most likely to be moved of the bunch, may have a future role.

 

Trevor Plouffe has not had the 2016 season that Minnesota hoped for after a solid 2015 campaign. Owning a .244/.307/.435 line a season ago, bolstered by 22 homers and 86 runs batted in, this season has been nothing short of a disappointment. Slashing just .259/.295/.399 his .694 OPS is the worst mark he's put up as a pro. Plouffe has just seven long balls, and he's played in just 65 of the Twins 120 games this season.

 

Therein is the greatest issue for Plouffe during the second year under Paul Molitor however, he just hasn't been able to stay healthy. Having taken multiple trips to the disabled list, it's hard to imagine Plouffe finding any ability to get into a consistent rhythm.

 

With the idea that a mulligan can be placed on his 2016 season, it's going to be decision time as to whether or not the Twins bring Plouffe back a year from now. Making $7.25 million this season, and entering his final year of arbitration, I'd be more than ok with that happening. I was a big supporter of the idea that Minnesota should've extended Plouffe last season, buying out his final two years of arbitration and one year of free agency, likely saving themselves money in the long run. Having not done that, the Twins will end up spending a bit more through the arbitration process, but that shouldn't deter them from Plouffe being at Target Field to open 2017.

 

Considering the log jam that was created, we've been given some clarity as to how the Twins can manage the group due to what's taken place this season. Joe Mauer is having his most productive season in years, and the reality is that it's come with him getting more rest. Byung Ho Park has struggled with a wrist injury most of the year, and hasn't yet proven he's capable of catching up to Triple-A pitching let alone the big league level. On the Miguel Sano front, his position is third base when playing the field, but elbow concerns have that looking like something that may not be an every day scenario.

 

Where does that leave Plouffe and the rest of the Twins infield cast? Likely in a constant shuffle, but one that can be tweaked on a game-by-game basis. Despite having a better approach this season, I still don't see Kennys Vargas as much more than a bench bat. He'll be out of options, and likely not clear waivers, but Minnesota could try and move him in a package deal this winter. Jorge Polanco can be given the starting shortstop job allowing Eduardo Escobar to rotate in. Polanco has the ability to play third as well, and can find time there, or in spelling Brian Dozier at second when necessary.

 

To summarize what Plouffe's position boils down to is to suggest that he remain flexible. Knowing that 2016 isn't a reflection of the production that should be projected for him, keeping his bat on your 25 man roster is a good idea. Plouffe can rotate in at third, designated hitter, first, and even play some corner outfield if need be. Right now though, there's not an internal option for the Twins that is substantially more reliable than what Trevor Plouffe brings to the table.

 

I don't expect Minnesota to realistically compete in 2017. That means Plouffe could potentially be flipped over the summer if that's what ends up needing to take place. Going into the year though, he should be seen more as a solution, than a part of the once perceived log jam.

 

For more from Off The Baggy, click here. Follow @tlschwerz

 Share

10 Comments


Recommended Comments

I've thought about this a lot lately as well. Been thinking how there is room for Mauer, Vargas and Park to all fit as 1B/DH and bench bat. It would mean 1 utility infielder and 4 total OF, which means...barring someone out with injury...either Santana or Grossman doesn't fit.

 

Now what if we throw Plouffe in the mix? Now someone else in the 1B/DH mix has no room. I don't know for sure if that's good or bad. You shorten the flexibility of your bench, but produce a more dangerous offense potentially.

 

I thought Ploughed was done in Minnesota. But now I'm beginning to think he may be back as insurance for Sano and his elbow. Of course, this could change if Sano proves healthy the next month and a half.

 

But isn't it almost comical how Polanco doesn't play any SS in the minors this year at all, but now he's playing there for the Twins? And so far, not looking bad there at all.

Link to comment

Among current internal options, Plouffe is the team's best option as an everyday 3B and I don't think it's really even close. I'm not happy about that fact, but it's true.

 

Personally, I'm ready to see Miguel Sano's glove taken away permanently. Sure, that will cause issues for Vargas/Park, but who cares? If Polanco's arm is questionable for short, how is he an option for third? I suppose you could scoot Escobar over there, but he's been terrible and even when things were going well wasn't putting up numbers that would look good for a corner guy.

 

I'm not opposed to a full on youth movement, but if this team wants to complete in '17 Plouffe is the guy for 3B. Sure, you could sign a free agent, but that would likely take a multi-year commitment. Addressing the position via a trade would be an option too, but I'd think there are bigger problems to fix.

Link to comment

Twins not auditioning Polanco at SS when Escobar went down was silly, him not playing there at all in AAA was even worse. He's not an ideal fit, but if that's where you can get him starts, you do it.

 

Plouffe becomes less of a clog if he can move between 3B, 1B, and DH while having Sano DH more and Polanco primarily play SS. There's also the very real realization that Park has been struggling significantly at AAA as well, wrist injury or not.

Link to comment

 

Among current internal options, Plouffe is the team's best option as an everyday 3B and I don't think it's really even close. I'm not happy about that fact, but it's true.

 

Personally, I'm ready to see Miguel Sano's glove taken away permanently. Sure, that will cause issues for Vargas/Park, but who cares? If Polanco's arm is questionable for short, how is he an option for third? I suppose you could scoot Escobar over there, but he's been terrible and even when things were going well wasn't putting up numbers that would look good for a corner guy.

 

I'm not opposed to a full on youth movement, but if this team wants to complete in '17 Plouffe is the guy for 3B. Sure, you could sign a free agent, but that would likely take a multi-year commitment. Addressing the position via a trade would be an option too, but I'd think there are bigger problems to fix.

 

I guess I'm not even so much on Plouffe as an answer to them competing, as I am still of the belief that he gives you more being on your team than anything you'll get in return.

 

Sure, it's not ideal to take away Sano in the field this young, but he looks like a bat (a very good one) and nothing more. Let that be the case. Park hasn't pushed for any real playing time, and when he does, it can come at 1B to spell Joe. I think Vargas is a bench bat at best, and if the Twins believe that as well, shipping him out this winter could be a good move.

Link to comment

I'm not willing to give up on Sano at 3B yet. Yeah, there have been some plays that make you shake your head, but he's also made some nice plays, charges the ball surprisingly well, and has a cannon for an arm. It will take time to iron out some things, but keep him there. Doesn't preclude, however, from him DH or even playing 1B also. And Plouffe can move around, as stated. It worked well the second half of last season

Link to comment

Sorry, but I am less and less impressed with Plouffe as a piece moving forward. He's just not that good and he doesn't appear to be getting better with age.  

 

Keeping Plouffe at third base pushes Sano to DH, but the plan is to get Mauer more of that DH time. This extra DH time might be what is accounting for Mauer's mini-offensive resurgence. 

 

Defensive stats are not perfect, and in a few years StatCast data will make Fangraphs data look primitive, but Fangraphs shows Sano to have really good range. Sano is 6.8 runs above average as measured by RngR, which is second best in the majors. Plouffe is 6.6 runs below average in this stat, which is near the bottom. Plouffe was also in the bottom quartile of third basemen in this stat last year. Plouffe has better hands than Sano, but won't get to nearly the number of balls Sano gets to. Is that a trade off you would accept? 

 

http://www.fangraphs.com/leaders.aspx?pos=3b&stats=fld&lg=all&qual=200&type=1&season=2016&month=0&season1=2016&ind=0&team=0&rost=0&age=0&filter=&players=0&sort=21,d&page=1_30

 

If we attribute Plouffe's poor fielding this season to injury, then why can't we attribute everybody's poor fielding to injury?

 

Also, what about the other infielders? 

 

Just some thoughts.

Link to comment

I'm not arguing that Plouffe IS a valuable player and will play...somewhere...in baseball. I just don't see the Twins to make him one their five highest paid players and not really have a fulltime position for him to play.

 

He becomes an expensive utilityman, who will be a free agent in 2018.

 

And supposedly he didn't attract much worthwhile attention in 2015, and no one is breaking down the door to grab him in 2016 (not that someone won't sign him for 2017). It is just his value.

 

If the Twins were to keep him, they should've signed him to that contract taking him thru year one of free agency. They should've not bid on Park. At worst, we would still have Arcia looking for time in the outfield and Vargas may be on the farm, still, wishing he did go to Asia.

 

Okay, I CAN stomach Plouffe for a longer time with the Twins IF Sano is the fulltime DH. But that means you have to deal with the issues of Park, Vargas, possibly Walker. In some ways, I would rather allow Sano to get big as a DH and play there for the next 15 years than have him hold down third for at least two more years, which at this point is what the Twins will comfortably need before they can plug someone of equal offensive value (to Plouffe) into the position.

 

He is just soooooo darn expensive. Worth $25 million? Worth $30 million. Send him walking and hope you can bring him abck for $6 million next year (as he builds his worth) or even $12-15 million for two years (that is if you don't have him on your arbitration roster which, again, releasing him right now). And, if handled such, does he really want to come back then.

Link to comment

Sanos range might cancel his glove, and his bat also does its part. And this is one of the positions where you make those trade offs. Not behind the plate, at SS, or in CF. while the Twins won't contend for anything except draft choices until they get some decent SP, that doesn't mean they can't start balancing their lineup with hitters on the corners, and some defense in the middle. I will repeat a past observation: If Trevor Plouffe is your cleanup hitter (and an intregal part of your lineup), you got big problems!! It does not take advanced metrics to figure that out, just common sense!

Link to comment
Guest
Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...