Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • entries
    891
  • comments
    3,675
  • views
    1,591,233

The Curious Case Of Michael Tonkin


Ted Schwerzler

2,863 views

 Share

Twins Video

The 2015 Minnesota Twins returned to relevance for the first time since the 2010 Major League Baseball season. After a rocky first few games, a spring run put Paul Molitor's club in a great position down the stretch. Not being eliminated from playoff contention until the final weekend hampered Minnesota from exploring some less entrenched options, but no one was a by-product of that reality more than Michael Tonkin.

 

Last season, the Twins jumped down a rabbit hole that has now begun to come full circle. Employing the worst bullpen in the big leagues by multiple statistical measures, they left a lot of things unanswered. One of the biggest misses of those "things" was whether or not Michael Tonkin can be effective at the big league level.

A season ago, Tonkin was a 25 year old pitching at Triple-A Rochester. On the season, he posted a 1.10 ERA along with a 10.1 K/9 and walked just 1.1 batters per nine innings. After a 2.80 ERA in 2014 at Triple-A, it appeared pretty apparent that Tonkin was ready for a new challenge.

 

In "understanding" that, the Twins called upon him. In fact, they did so five different times. During the 2015 season, Tonkin was promoted to Minnesota on five different occasions (meaning he was demoted as well). Of those five promotions, two of them lasted just one game, while a third was played out over the course of four appearances. In total, Tonkin gave the Twins 23.1 IP to the tune of a 3.47 ERA and a 7.3 K/9. Those numbers were all compiled while the Twins learned little to nothing about what they had, and in turn, Tonkin about himself.

 

Sure, Minnesota was in the midst of a competitive season that saw them narrowly miss the playoffs, but does that really excuse things? Remember, the Twins owned one of the big leagues worst bullpens a season ago. A.J. Achter, Tim Stauffer, and Aaron Thompson were given a combined total of 60.2 IP despite none of them owning better than a 5.00 ERA. Brian Duensing, owner of a 4.25 ERA and a 4.4 K/9 threw 48.2 IP for the 2015 Twins, and Casey Fien pumped a 5.83 K/9 rate during his 63.1 IP. To summarize, Minnesota chose to give struggling and low ceiling options more run than instead to figure out what they may be sitting on.

 

That leads us to where we are now. Over the course of spring training, Tonkin did everything he could to not make the club. Despite being what seemed to be a roster lock thanks to being out of options, the 26 year old generated a 7.88 ERA across 8.0 IP. The small sample size makes numerical conclusions difficult, but he gave up earned runs in four of his seven appearances, and had as many games result in multi-hit appearances. A team looking to improve upon a bad bullpen wouldn't have carried Tonkin, but the Twins saw their hands tied as they still don't know what they have.

 

At the break of spring training, ESPN 1500's Derek Wetmore asked me if I believed Tonkin would be claimed on waivers, and if so, I would be ok with it. I answered that I thought there was better than a 50% chance he would be, and that it wouldn't necessarily bother me. From a roster standpoint, the Twins relief options on the farm are some of the best in all of baseball. There's reason to believe that the pen is overhauled and turned into an area of strength. From the notion of how Tonkin was handled however, it would be troubling.

 

In selecting Ricky Nolasco for the rotation, Minnesota spared Tonkin a roster spot. It absolutely should be Tyler Duffey pitching among the five, and Nolasco in the pen, but in handling things the way they did, the Twins once again put Tonkin in an odd spot. Now on the roster as a carryover, Tonkin is being asked to pitch in a long relief role.

Thus far in his career (60 MLB games) Tonkin has thrown more than 25 pitches just 10 times. Minnesota elected to stretch him out on the Saturday before Opening Day, he threw 53 pitches. In doing so, Tonkin was not available for the rain delayed (per Derek Wetmore and relayed by Curse Of Punto), and didn't make his debut in his new role.

 

What things have boiled down to with Michael Tonkin is a really unfortunate narrative. A guy that excelled at the highest level of the farm system the past two years was never given an opportunity to produce, is now being included out of necessity, and is being utilized in a less than favorable role. Sure, things could all work out wonderfully, but could there have been a more backwards way of going about it?

I definitely don't think so.

 

For more from Off The Baggy, click here. Follow @tlschwerz

 Share

10 Comments


Recommended Comments

 

I hope he gets off to a good start. He may get a chance in Fien's role with a good start.

 

I'd much rather have went with Tonkin and someone else than Fien from the get go.

Link to comment

"Those numbers were all compiled while the Twins learned little to nothing about what they had"

 

I think the Twins base their decisions on the past 10 years in the minors and scouting rather than a few games. 2015 performance was relevant, but not a determining factor.

Link to comment

 

"Those numbers were all compiled while the Twins learned little to nothing about what they had"

 

I think the Twins base their decisions on the past 10 years in the minors and scouting rather than a few games. 2015 performance was relevant, but not a determining factor.

 

You're missing the point. The evaluation process unfolds over the entirety of a career, of course. Against major league competition however, moving a guy ten times throughout a season and compiling 23 meaningful innings doesn't indicate much of anything.

Link to comment

I know we have a plethora of quality young arms getting so very, very close to making their debut. But they weren't ready last season. They aren't ready yet this season. And nobody without a well functioning crystal ball knows exactly when they will be ready.

 

Which is why it is so frustrating the Twins didn't use the $2+Mil being paid to Fien, throw another 3 with it, and signing someone like Bastardo for 2 years. Now, pour out another $5M or so, roughly, and something the team could afford, and you have another option for May.

 

Now how much better does the rotation look with Santana, Gibson, Hughex, May and Milone in it while we wait for Berrios and/or Duffey?

 

And unless they completely implode, the Twins have a veteran RP or two to trade come the second half of the season when some,of the prospects, probably/hopefully arrive.

Link to comment

But this in a nutshell is the Twins. Endless roster decisions driven by contracts, options, and injuries. Oft times talent is fourth on the list of reasons. I personally like Tonkin, but have no idea if he will succeed. But whenever you leave a player with no idea where he stands, or what his role is, you don't do yourself any favors. Asking a short guy to pitch long innings might not work. And it just might not be the players fault.

Link to comment

 

But this in a nutshell is the Twins. Endless roster decisions driven by contracts, options, and injuries. Oft times talent is fourth on the list of reasons. I personally like Tonkin, but have no idea if he will succeed. But whenever you leave a player with no idea where he stands, or what his role is, you don't do yourself any favors. Asking a short guy to pitch long innings might not work. And it just might not be the players fault.

 

Completely in agreement with you in that we have no idea what Tonkin in, and he likely has no idea what the Twins see either. It was an incredibly poor way to go about using him.

Link to comment

From what I have heard, Tonkin has a straight fastball, if you look at the sucessful relievers, all of their pitches have movement, most of it late.  Not worried, case closed.

Link to comment

From watching Tonkin pitch with the Twins I think its pretty easy to see why they haven't stuck with him or given him more opportunities at the major league level. Very straight fastball and and an OK breaking ball that he has trouble locating. Relievers can often succeed in the minors with one good pitch and less than reliable secondary stuff but struggle at the major league level. 

Link to comment
Guest
Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...