Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • entries
    5
  • comments
    24
  • views
    8,150

What would the ideal 25-man roster be to end the year?


ttreadway

1,881 views

 Share

Twins Video

I've posted it several times in different blogs or comments over the last couple of weeks, but as much as I'd love to think the twins can compete this year, I don't think they are going to. However, I do think that the Twins can win 80-82 games, and at least be fun to watch, and the recent surge of minor league talent flooding the big league team has kept me very interested in the big league team despite a losing month of June. I've watched the major league debut's of Eddie Rosario, Byron Buxton, Alex Meyer and look forward to watching Miguel Sano hit a 430 foot bomb tonight against the Royals. My opinion is that the twins FO is doing things right, and I hope and pray that they don't trade away any valuable future prospects this month in an attempt to win 4 or 5 more games. I strongly believe that we have the talent to be a .500 team within our organization, and I hope that the front office believes that as well, and sees that trying to please the fan base by making the playoffs is not worth sacrificing any of our potential future stars. I think I speak for most of the twins fan base in saying that what would make me more happy than getting to the playoffs and then losing in 3 games...or maybe even 1, would be to finish around .500 and continue to see glimpses of who we will be next year, and for years to come.

 

With this in mind, what would you like the 25-man roster to look like by years end? Below I have put the current roster on top and my ideal roster underneath. Below that I have put down what I would like our lineup and starting rotation as well as our bullpen to look like down the stretch in August and September.

 

Catchers

Kurt Suzuki

Chris Hermann

Infielders

Brian Dozier

Joe Mauer

Trevor Plouffe

Eduardo Escobar

Eduardo Nunez

Danny Santana

Miguel Sano

Outfielders

Torii hunter

Eddie Rosario

Shane Robinson

Pitchers

Phil Hughes

Kyle Gibson

Mike Pelfrey

Tommy Milone

Trevor May

Blaine Boyer

Aaron Thompson

Ryan Pressley

Glen Perkins

Alex Meyer

JR Graham

Casey Fien

Brian Duensing

 

Catchers

Kurt Suzuki

Chris Hermann

Infielders

Brian Dozier

Joe Mauer

Jorge Polanco

Trevor Plouffe

Miguel Sano

Eduardo Escobar

Eduardo Nunez

Outfielders

Byron Buxton

Eddie Rosario

Torii Hunter

Oswaldo Arcia or Max Kepler...(whoever the twins see as ready, and part of their future)

Pitchers

Phil Hughes

Ervin Santana

Kyle Gibson

Trevor May

JO Berrios

Alex Meyer

J R Graham

Taylor Rogers

Blaine Boyer

Casey Fien

Logan Darnell (if the twins want a 3rd lefty in their bullpen) otherwise AJ Achter or Tyler Duffey

Glen Perkins

 

Ideal Starting rotation: Hughes, Santana, Gibson, May and Berrios. We'd have Alex Meyer for a spot start if needed and trusted, or Milone in AAA.

 

Long relievers: Meyer and Graham. Either of these guys could be used in higher leverage situations if they prove capable over the next few weeks/months.

 

Mid relievers: Meyer, Graham, Rogers, Boyer and either Darnell/Achter/Duffey

 

Setup relievers: Fien and possibly Boyer and Darnell/Achter/Duffey

And we all know who the closer is.

 

Ideal starting lineup

Buxton CF

Dozier 2B

Mauer 1B (if Mauer continues to progress. If not, swap him with Rosario, but you need a lefty here)

Sano DH

Plouffe 3B

Rosario LF

Hunter RF (Arcia every 3rd or 4th day)

Polanco SS

Suzuki C

 

That would be an exciting lineup and pitching staff...one that would keep me watching through September.

 Share

7 Comments


Recommended Comments

Ideal for me after we make trades and or DFA players and some may stay on DL

SP Hughes

SP Gibson

SP May

SP Santana

SP Berrios

RP Perkins

RP Pressly

RP Fien

RP Graham

RP Meyer

RP Rogers

RP Achter

C Suzuki

C Herrmann

1st Sano

2nd Dozier

3rd Plouffe

SS Polanco

LF Rosario

CF Buxton

RF Hicks

DH Hunter/Mauer

UTL Escobar

UTL Santana

Link to comment

The key thought from ttreadway, "My opinion is that the twins FO is doing things right, and I hope and pray that they don't trade away any valuable future prospects this month in an attempt to win 4 or 5 more games."

 

I agree. My lineup would resemble the one put together by blairpaul715, except I would have a 25-man roster (not 24 - am I counting ok?). I would add Arcia, so we have a left-handed power hitter. 12 pitchers are enough.

 

Since this is an ideal roster, I would have Berrios in the rotation as well. Realistically, I would keep Milone until Berrios is ready.

 

 

Link to comment

The ideal roster to end this year is the roster that will win them the most games this year.

 

The roster that ends this year does not necessarily have to be the roster that starts next season. They can make changes in the offseason. Almost every team does.

 

Polanco, Berrios, Rogers, Darnell, and Buxton (based on his few at bats) could all be on next season's roster not this season's.

Link to comment

My point was that by playing these guys this year, it will prepare them better for next year. Why not get the rookie jitters out the=is year, so they can all be a more polished and experienced bunch next year. After all, it seems most of those guys are MLB ready, or close to it.

Link to comment

After September first the roster expands, so it really doesn't matter which 25 when they could have all 40 of them up here. Sorry to be a nit pick  pr*** but there isn't a 25 man limit then so you can't artificially place one.   Secondly, the Twins still have the fourth best record in the AL as the hallway point of the season draws near, you play what you have that is your best option to win this year. On a 40 man roster that really does not have a lot of age on it there are going to be a couple of younger players.

Link to comment

 

The key thought from ttreadway, "My opinion is that the twins FO is doing things right, and I hope and pray that they don't trade away any valuable future prospects this month in an attempt to win 4 or 5 more games."

 

I agree. My lineup would resemble the one put together by blairpaul715, except I would have a 25-man roster (not 24 - am I counting ok?). I would add Arcia, so we have a left-handed power hitter. 12 pitchers are enough.

 

Since this is an ideal roster, I would have Berrios in the rotation as well. Realistically, I would keep Milone until Berrios is ready.

There is 25 :) have Mauer and Hunter on same DH line

Link to comment
Guest
Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...